Homeopathic Cough Medicine

Actually, homoeopathy doesn't claim that particular remedies will cure particular conditions; it claims that the remedy needs to be "individualised" to the particular patient.
Yes, and once individualized it becomes one of thousands of claimed remedies.

In practice this means that after the initial consultation the homoeopath will prescribe a remedy. If the patient doesn't get better they will say they haven't found the right remedy and prescribe another. This will continue until the patient gets better (or doesn't return for further consultations), at which point the homoeopath will claim a cure.
And if something unfortunate occurs, such as death, the client did not consult the homeopath early-enough.

The stuff about individualisation is the basis for their claim that homoeopathy cannot be tested by DBPC trials. This isn't true, of course; it is quite possible to design a DBPC trial of individualised homoeopathy, and at least one has been carried out and (guess what) shown results no better than placebo.
And that begets the question of what constitutes a "placebo" for homeopathy:
http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/2006/11/homeopaths_doubleblind_studies_of_homeop.php#more
 
Are you referring to the 2005 Lancet study? A good review of that is given by Peter Fisher:

"The meta-analysis at the centre of the controversy is based on 110 placebo-controlled clinical trials of homeopathy and 110 clinical trials of allopathy (conventional medicine), which are said to be matched. These were reduced to 21 trials of homeopathy and 9 of conventional medicine of ‘higher quality’ and further reduced to 8 and 6 trials, respectively, which were ‘larger, higher quality’. The final analysis which concluded that ‘the clinical effects of homoeopathy are placebo effects’ was based on just the eight ‘larger, higher quality’ clinical trials of homeopathy. The Lancet's press release did not mention this, instead giving the impression that the conclusions were based on all 110 trials.

That is a mischaracterization of the metanalysis. The trials were analyzed on several points and most analyses included all 110 trials in each group. Only one of the analyses was done on 8 and 6 trials. The conclusions in the published study were based on analyses of all the trials (e.g. heterogeneity), not just the analysis done on a small number. Plus the authors make it very clear which analyses involve which studies.

"The criteria for the matching of the homeopathic and conventional trials were not clearly stated, and it is evident from the numbers above that the clinical trials of homeopathy and conventional medicine were not, as claimed, well matched—the homeopathic trials were generally of better quality. And this is a crucial parameter [as Shang et al. acknowledge]; it is well established that high quality trials are less likely to be positive than those of lower quality.

That is another mischaracterization. The criteria for the matching were clearly stated in the published study. That last statement serves (bizarrely) as an admission that the "positive" results depend upon bias.

The evidence is inadequate to conclude that homeopathy is effective in any condition. In the absence of evidence, the null hypothesis is assumed, since it is almost always the one that turns out to be true. Also, the accumulation of the absence of evidence eventually begins to serve as evidence of absence.

I don't say that anyone has to give up their particular beliefs. I'm just saying that it has not shown that it deserves the attention of limited resources (e.g. public funds) or that it serves as a substitute for demonstrably effective care.

Linda
 
I don't say that anyone has to give up their particular beliefs.

But I will. I won't say 'has', but 'should' give up their belief. The evidence is sufficient to relegate belief in homeopathy to the mentally feeble.

The only way that one can maintain belief in homeo today, is to be unable to 'understand' the body of evidence.
 
But I will. I won't say 'has', but 'should' give up their belief. The evidence is sufficient to relegate belief in homeopathy to the mentally feeble.

The only way that one can maintain belief in homeo today, is to be unable to 'understand' the body of evidence.

Hear, hear! :)

M.
 
Hmm. You may be right. I wouldn't call the decision to leave a saucer of milk out arbitrary. After all, they wouldn't be leaving a saucer of rocks out for the IPU :)

Perhaps their actions aren't entirely arbitrary within the framework of homeopathy, but the entire framework of homeopathy IS arbitrary. Like the concept of the IPU, it is something someone just pulled out of their :Dss one day and decided to run with. If the concept/basic premise is faulty, everything that follows from it, no matter how logical or obvious it may appear, is likely just as faulty.

In other words, whether you're leaving a saucer of milk, rocks, sugar or marinated pork outside at night, expecting it to cure your illness is just silly, even if you have a mental twist going on making it completely logical to do so.
And since nobody knows what IPUs really eat or drink, who's to say rocks won't work better than milk? So it's still pretty darn arbitrary anyway.
 
"The meta-analysis at the centre of the controversy is based on 110 placebo-controlled clinical trials of homeopathy and 110 clinical trials of allopathy (conventional medicine), which are said to be matched. These were reduced to 21 trials of homeopathy and 9 of conventional medicine of ‘higher quality’ and further reduced to 8 and 6 trials, respectively, which were ‘larger, higher quality’. The final analysis which concluded that ‘the clinical effects of homoeopathy are placebo effects’ was based on just the eight ‘larger, higher quality’ clinical trials of homeopathy. The Lancet's press release did not mention this, instead giving the impression that the conclusions were based on all 110 trials.

Translation: They had to cut all the low quality studies and were left with only 21 good trials to compare. This comparison then resulted in the well known conclusion that homeopathy doesn't appear to do anything.

The fact that 89 homeopathy trials had to be ditched because they just weren't any good doesn't mean that they weren't taken into account. They simply weren't of sufficient quality to make for a decent analysis.
Same thing with the further 13 who were dumped in the next stage.

To then claim that only 8 trials were really being used in the comparison is just dishonest. All 110 were considered, only 8 were deemed good enough to yield proper results.

The fact that homeopaths don't like the idea that of the 110 studies, all those showing the best results were thrown out is not surprising. But there's a reason those studies showed good results in the first place, and it's that same reason that got them rejected from the comparison: untrustworthy results due to improper controls or bad test design.
 
Rodney,

Do you realize that "equivalent to, or indistinguishable from, a placebo" is a failure for the test preparation?
Yes. Do you realize that (non-homeopathic) cough medicines have generally failed to meet that burden?

LIES Rodney!!

LIES!!
 
"There is no clinical evidence that over-the-counter cough expectorants or suppressants actually relieve cough," said Dr Richard Irwin, panel chair of the American College of Chest Physicians which drew up the latest US guidelines.
See http://www.dailymail.co.uk/pages/li...ain.html?in_article_id=373758&in_page_id=1774

Yes, Rodney. We already know that journalists write articles that contain incorrect statements. To their credit, the cause generally seems to be ignorance, rather than malice.

Linda
 
Yes, Rodney. We already know that journalists write articles that contain incorrect statements. To their credit, the cause generally seems to be ignorance, rather than malice.
Linda

You keep saying that and the evidence keeps piling up against your position. Was Dr Irwin misquoted, or do you just think you know more about the subject than he does? If the latter, how many studies have supported the efficacy of OTC cough medicines? And are you familiar with the 2002 Schroeder study, which concluded: "OTC cough medicines do not appear more effective than placebo in relieving symptoms of acute cough. Even if statistically significant, effect sizes were small and of doubtful clinical relevance. The number of trials in each category was small, and the results of this systematic review have to be interpreted with caution. Based on the available evidence from a small number of studies, we cannot recommend OTC cough medicines as a first line treatment for children with acute cough."

See http://adc.bmj.com/cgi/content/abstract/86/3/170
 
You keep saying that and the evidence keeps piling up against your position.

You have never provided evidence against my position. I have provided you with numerous explanations, links to research articles, and summaries of all available information. You have provided links to quotes taken out of context, inaccurate summaries written by people without knowledge or expertise, and study abstracts that are irrelevant or refer to articles that (if actually read) confirm my position.

Was Dr Irwin misquoted, or do you just think you know more about the subject than he does? If the latter, how many studies have supported the efficacy of OTC cough medicines?

You have already been provided with those details and it is dishonest of you to pretend otherwise.

I do not dispute that you can selectively find somebody, somewhere that has said something that you think supports your position (even when it doesn't). What I dispute is the conclusion that that serves as "proof" of anything. The pursuit of science is a sincere consideration of all the information, not a game.

Linda
 
Rodney, please..... something does not have to be true simply because you wish it.

I am reduced to cheering because Linda has this so covered.
 
Next: Rodney states that steamrollers never have traffic accidents. Therefore all clown cars painted pink with green spots are safe for anyone to drive.
 
"There is no clinical evidence that over-the-counter cough expectorants or suppressants actually relieve cough," said Dr Richard Irwin

[SIZE=-1]The needle returns to the start of the song, and we all sing along like before..... :rolleyes:
(Del Amitri)
[/SIZE]
 
steamrollerAPEX170806_600x386.jpg
 
You keep saying that and the evidence keeps piling up against your position.

I think you have that backwards Rodney. YOU are the one who keeps asserting that homeopathy might work, while evidence keeps piling up that it's nothing more than placebo, and so far, no evidence has been found for its effectiveness, only promising looking stuff that never materializes because follow-up research that's asked for is either not performed, or its not published because it fails to live up to expectations.

On the other hand, what you call evidence against OTC cough medicine, and why it's not evidence at all, has been clearly and properly explained to you over and over again. Your willful ignorance and selective blindness/deafness to our counterarguments is speaking volumes about your true position on the subject. Even if you claim you're not here defending the virtues of sCAM.

You may have started out in this thread and a few others pretending to be "the skeptic's skeptic", but you've been beaten back time and again. And your insistence on re-using old arguments that we've already debunked won't work either. If you keep this up then this can only devolve into a circular discussion where you keep rehashing old statements and we keep rehashing old counterarguments.

This has now been going on for 17 pages, and you're not one bit closer to either proving that homeopathy works, or that OTC cough medicine doesn't. Unless you come up with something new, this could go on for another couple of pages, where we just start cutting and pasting our old posts, because it seems you are doing exactly the same ...

Unless you are willing to change your mind about any of this, your continued participation in this thread is only going to be like bashing your head against the wall, and we'll keep making sure you don't ignore the wall on the other side, when you suddenly turn around again and try running in that direction.
 
Last edited:
On the other hand, what you call evidence against OTC cough medicine, and why it's not evidence at all, has been clearly and properly explained to you over and over again. Your willful ignorance and selective blindness/deafness to our counterarguments is speaking volumes about your true position on the subject.

I'll leave you with one more link to ponder -- http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/cough-medicines/DI00052

Under the title " Cough medicines not helpful", the article begins:

"What happened? Guidelines on the diagnosis and management of cough recommend avoiding the use of over-the-counter cough medicines for coughs related to upper respiratory infections, such as colds and flu. The newly released guidelines, developed by the American College of Chest Physicians (ACCP), say that over-the-counter cough expectorants and suppressants don't treat the underlying cause of the cough, and often don't help relieve symptoms. Having reviewed the available evidence, the ACCP advises that cough medicines appear to be of limited use. Guidelines strongly recommend against using over-the-counter cough or cold medicines in any child under 14 years of age, citing safety concerns for this age group."

But this is probably just one more case of the public being misled. After all, who knows more about this subject -- the Mayo Clinic or Randi Forum participants? ;)
 
I'll leave you with one more link to ponder -- http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/cough-medicines/DI00052

Under the title " Cough medicines not helpful", the article begins:

"What happened? Guidelines on the diagnosis and management of cough recommend avoiding the use of over-the-counter cough medicines for coughs related to upper respiratory infections, such as colds and flu. The newly released guidelines, developed by the American College of Chest Physicians (ACCP), say that over-the-counter cough expectorants and suppressants don't treat the underlying cause of the cough...
Which for colds and flu is a virus. I don't think anyone has claimed that OTC cough medicines treat viral infections.
...and often don't help relieve symptoms.
They don't say that they don't relieve symptoms, or even that they usually don’t relieve symptoms; just that they don't always do so. And a medicine that works some of the time will show results better than placebo in properly conducted trials.
Having reviewed the available evidence, the ACCP advises that cough medicines appear to be of limited use.
"Of limited use"; not no use at all.
Guidelines strongly recommend against using over-the-counter cough or cold medicines in any child under 14 years of age, citing safety concerns for this age group."
If the risks outweigh the likely benefits for this group, then they shouldn't be used for this group. This is not the same as saying they don't work.

But this is probably just one more case of the public being misled.
It might have been, Rodney, but you've been foiled again.
 
Rodney, do you read your own articles?

And from further down.

What does it mean to you? Cough medicines remain safe, if used as directed, and are still readily available over-the-counter. However, if your cough is related to an upper respiratory tract infection you may get more relief from an antihistamine with a decongestant.

This isn't much of a condemnation.

So, for certain TYPEs of coughs, there MAY be more effective alternatives. wow.

This does not support your position (that OTC cough syrups have NO effectiveness or that hemeo preparations do anything at all).

If you came and stated that your position is that OTC cough syrups are not as effective as many people think they are, or that certain types of cough aren't very amenable to treatment with cough syrup, I'd say you quoted a fine source. But, those are not your positions. Your never ending well of self delusion is facinating.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom