Have you ever taken a statistics course, Garette?
No.
Rodney said:
--snip--
Does that make sense to you?
Two part answer:
1. Only vaguely, as I am not a statistician. As such, I am forced to determine levels of credibility of the presenters, one side being you, the other being fls, exarch, and others. fls' credentials alone would have me leaning her way. Add my experience with you indicating quite clearly how you avoid answering questions, shift goalposts, and pretend arguments that refute your assertions never happened, and it's a slam dunk.
2. You'll recall in a much earlier post how fls talked about context, meaning the robust history of conventional medicine research and the paucity of vigorous homeopathic research. That makes sense to me.
Rodney said:
And if it does, why isn't that same probability applied to non-homeopathic medicines?
See my point number 2 above.
Rodney said:
(You inquired: "If homeopathy wants to be treated as conventional medicine, then it must accept conventional analysis." But Linda's analysis is completely unconventional!)
You are mixing two different meanings of "conventional." I don't know if you're doing it intentionally.
"Conventional" as I used it meaning mainstream medicine which does not accept complementary medicines because of their lack of evidentiary foundation.
"Conventional" as you used it meaning "standard usage, regardless of discipline."
I don't know if her analysis is conventional in the sense of not being usual, standard, or common statistical method. But I do know that she has said it is. While I admit I could be wrong, she has far more credibility than you right now.
Rodney said:
Try actually following the logic of the arguments,
I do. And when the technical aspects get beyond my understanding (as they have here), I choose my experts carefully.
Rodney said:
rather than assuming that Linda is the "skeptic" and I am the "woo" with regard to statistical analysis of homeopathy studies.
I don't assume Linda is a skeptic in regard to this. I assume I'm not being lied to regarding her qualifications, and based on the clarity of her (non-technical) posts, I assume she is not only open minded but has the best interests of her patients at heart and that she would adopt any validated method for treating them.
Likewise, I don't assume you are the woo. I have reached the reasoned conclusion that you will not change your position, regardless of evidence. I have reached the conclusion that you will espouse claims regarding homeopathy and Edgar Cayce and the like regardless of the lack of valid evidence supporting them. Whether you do this because of a legitimate belief on your part, I do not know.