Homeopathic Cough Medicine

You do realize that characterizing me as biased is based only on your desire for my information to be wrong, right?

Of course you are biased, you did not come the the correct decision, that homeopathy works, the techniques you used must be biased. It is like how they are giving up on well executed double blind studies because they do not show the right result so they must not be very good studies.
 
You do realize that characterizing me as biased is based only on your desire for my information to be wrong, right?

Linda

I'll lay bets that Rodney will never, ever be convinced, Linda. Why that might be is anyone's guess.

M.
 
I think people often misunderstand the hierarchy of woo. Homeopathy is not a single claim, it is thousands of different ones.

No homeopathy is a set of well defined claims.

1. If a substance causes a problem then if you dilute it by say 10x it will cause the body to remove that symptom from itself.
2.The more you dilute it the more effective it is.

As this has never been shown to be true the fundamental processes that it is supposed to work by has nothing backing it up.
 
That is correct. Either it is Over-the-Counter (OTC) or it is prescription.

Pharmacists are a (underused) repository of information, but they have no prescription authority.

There is starting to be an intermediate category with needing ID for Emergency contraception and the limits being placed on pseudo ephedrine
 
Do you have a degree in statistics, Linda?

You need a degree to understand statistics? I did two semesters of stats for the social sciences thirty years ago, yet I needed only a little brushing up to comprehend Linda's data.

I wasn't characterizing you -- I'm simply suggesting that we could benefit from the wisdom of a statistician who doesn't care one way or another whether there is any validity in homeopathy.

Rodney, isn't it apparent to you that most, if not all, posters here are extremely neutral as regards the "validity" of homeopathy, and that they are people who require extraordinary proof for extraordinary claims, such as those claims made by the proponents of homeopathy?

Sorry, mate, but you just put your own biased foot in it.

M.
 
It is like how they are giving up on well executed double blind studies because they do not show the right result so they must not be very good studies.

Exactly!

Science: you'll believe it when you see it.

Homeopathy: you'll see it when you believe it.
 
Yeah - I used to get sent the books by my Uncle in NZ when I was a kid

And should have said it sooner (my bad) - Thanks fls\Linda :)

hey a big ditto as well from me on the Kudos to Linda !! Great Job Linda - sometimes I just love these forums when I get a chance to learn something.

Loved Footrot Flats one of the great unsung comic strips! Great choice as an avatar
 
Do you have a degree in statistics, Linda?

No. I have taken several graduate courses in statistics, and it is a large part of my research interests.

Yes, extremely so. In fact, I think there is a Nobel prize in this for someone -- IF it's truly a new cutting-edge model, as opposed to malarkey. ;)

It is not Nobel prize material, in that these ideas are well-established. What the author accomplished was to provide a more rigorous formulation. Sorry, I'm not treading on thin ice, here. This stuff is the core of evidence-based medicine.

I wasn't characterizing you -- I'm simply suggesting that we could benefit from the wisdom of a statistician who doesn't care one way or another whether there is any validity in homeopathy.

I don't care one way or the other whether there is any validity in homeopathy - I'm happy to recommend any treatment that works. If anything, I'd prefer that homeopathy worked. The more ways we have of helping people, the better. I came to the conclusion that homeopathy wasn't valid after I looked at the evidence.

Linda
 
I should have been more exact. By "reliable" I meant a phase III clinical study. I doubt we will ever see one for any homeopathic claim.

Ah, I see. Yeah, a Phase III clinical study would necessarily have been preceded by positive, good-quality Phase I and Phase II clinical studies. I agree that level of evidence would be taken more seriously.

Linda
 
Sorry, mate, but you just put your own biased foot in it.
He has not been as smug as some on this thread.;)

Look, I have a grudging respect for the guy. He is here on his own against an avalanche of posts. He has never at any time become abusive. He has shown signs of wanting to understand. Yeah, he is not giving in easily on the central issue but that is as it should be. Time to mull it over and think it through and all that.

And, hey, we all have our biases.
You and me as well. :(

BJ
 
He has not been as smug as some on this thread.;)

Look, I have a grudging respect for the guy. He is here on his own against an avalanche of posts. He has never at any time become abusive. He has shown signs of wanting to understand. Yeah, he is not giving in easily on the central issue but that is as it should be. Time to mull it over and think it through and all that.

And, hey, we all have our biases.
You and me as well. :(

BJ

I don't have any sort of bias whatsoever - except for mild, very mild, savage hatred of all conspiracy theorists, quacks, mlmers, fundy religionists and Knights who say Ni!
 
No. I have taken several graduate courses in statistics, and it is a large part of my research interests.
I have taken undergraduate and graduate level courses in statistics, but I have never come across an analysis similar to the one you are attempting to apply to homeopathy trials.

It is not Nobel prize material, in that these ideas are well-established. What the author accomplished was to provide a more rigorous formulation. Sorry, I'm not treading on thin ice, here. This stuff is the core of evidence-based medicine.
I don't have any problem with the article, but I do have a major problem with this statement of yours: "The negative studies don't matter; there don't even have to be any. Weird, huh?" This is what I believe would indeed be Nobel prize material if it could be proven. You seem to be saying that, if there are 84 trials showing that homeopathy is effective, it makes no difference if those are the only 84 trials that have ever been done, or if -- on the other hand -- there are many other trials showing that homeopathy is ineffective. To put it mildly, this contradicts what I learned in my statistics courses.

I don't care one way or the other whether there is any validity in homeopathy - I'm happy to recommend any treatment that works. If anything, I'd prefer that homeopathy worked. The more ways we have of helping people, the better. I came to the conclusion that homeopathy wasn't valid after I looked at the evidence. Linda
And you may be right, but I don't think your analysis proves it.
 
He has not been as smug as some on this thread.;)

Look, I have a grudging respect for the guy. He is here on his own against an avalanche of posts. He has never at any time become abusive. He has shown signs of wanting to understand.

I'd have to disagree. Have you seen him answer a pertinent question, for example? He either ignores them or gives evasive answers. He certainly won't commit himself to holding a view on anything.;)

He's playing games. He's attempting to look like he's never quite convinced by skeptics' arguments (even Linda's excellent, insightful explanations) so that any neutral reader, who's not knowledgeable on the subject, will think he actually has a valid stance on this issue.

He's using the argument to ignorance; basically thus: OK, there are doubters of homeopathy but it hasn't been conclusively proven not to work; or, your methods seem valid but I'm not sure you're using them correctly in this context: as if displaying his own personal ignorance has some importance on the issue.

Claims can only be decided by evidence; and in the case of homeopathy, every link in the chain used to support it is both highly implausible and lacking in robust evidence.

Don't let his selective humility confuse us as to the game he's playing.
 
I have taken undergraduate and graduate level courses in statistics, but I have never come across an analysis similar to the one you are attempting to apply to homeopathy trials.

Are you serious? You've never come across 2x2 table analysis in the statistics courses you've taken? Not even when studying dependent probabilities?

My undergraduate statistics courses were before medicine, so weren't as heavily weighted towards biostatistics. But it still seems like this stuff should be covered in regular statistics courses. I use it for all kinds of areas other than medicine, so I find it hard to believe it isn't really used outside of medicine or the biological/social sciences. Maybe my memory is faulty, but I really thought I remembered first learning about likelihood ratios in an undergraduate classes. I took a lot of math classes though - maybe it wasn't a statistics class.

It really seems a shame.

I don't have any problem with the article, but I do have a major problem with this statement of yours: "The negative studies don't matter; there don't even have to be any. Weird, huh?" This is what I believe would indeed be Nobel prize material if it could be proven. You seem to be saying that, if there are 84 trials showing that homeopathy is effective, it makes no difference if those are the only 84 trials that have ever been done, or if -- on the other hand -- there are many other trials showing that homeopathy is ineffective. To put it mildly, this contradicts what I learned in my statistics courses.

Well, I gave a detailed example of how the process works (using real numbers and everything <g>). Point out exactly where I am wrong.

And you may be right, but I don't think your analysis proves it.

I was giving you a free-ride because I thought you knew very little about statistics. But from now on, I'm going to ask you to back up your vague claims of "I don't think that's right". Tell me specifically what you think is wrong with my analysis.

Linda
 
Are you serious? You've never come across 2x2 table analysis in the statistics courses you've taken? Not even when studying dependent probabilities?

My undergraduate statistics courses were before medicine, so weren't as heavily weighted towards biostatistics. But it still seems like this stuff should be covered in regular statistics courses. I use it for all kinds of areas other than medicine, so I find it hard to believe it isn't really used outside of medicine or the biological/social sciences. Maybe my memory is faulty, but I really thought I remembered first learning about likelihood ratios in an undergraduate classes. I took a lot of math classes though - maybe it wasn't a statistics class.

It really seems a shame.
I've seen many 2 X 2 table analyses. That's not the problem. :)

Well, I gave a detailed example of how the process works (using real numbers and everything <g>). Point out exactly where I am wrong.

I was giving you a free-ride because I thought you knew very little about statistics. But from now on, I'm going to ask you to back up your vague claims of "I don't think that's right". Tell me specifically what you think is wrong with my analysis.
Linda
Okay, first the number of chemicals, whether it's 100,000 or a zillion, has no relevance to the analysis. The only thing that is of interest with respect to the testing of homeopathic medicines in controlled trials is the same thing that is of interest with respect to testing non-homeopathic medicines in similar trials: Do they work better than placebos?

Second, to assume that for every homeopathic trial that is a true positive, there will be 10,000 trials that are false positives has no basis in reality. I believe what you're thinking of are medical tests, such as mammograms, that have a high ratio of false positives to true positives. However, false positives are no more likely in the testing of a specific homeopathic medicine (such as cough medicine) than they are in the testing of a specific non-homeopathic medicine.

Third, the notion that negative test results don't matter flies in the face of all statistical theory. Again, the same thing is true of the testing of homeopathic medicines as it is of non-homeopathic medicines: All things being equal (test quality, number of test participants, etc.), the more often a medicine outperforms a placebo in a controlled trial, the more probable it is that it is an effective medicine.
 
Okay, first the number of chemicals, whether it's 100,000 or a zillion, has no relevance to the analysis.

Did you read the paper that I referenced? It explains why the number of potential candidates for a homeopathic treatment is very important. If I want to test whether or not water that has come in contact with a specific chemical can help my cough, there are thousands of chemicals to be tested, and so I would be performing thousands of tests to try each one.

The only thing that is of interest with respect to the testing of homeopathic medicines in controlled trials is the same thing that is of interest with respect to testing non-homeopathic medicines in similar trials: Do they work better than placebos?

Exactly. And how do we know if they work better than placebo (because there are always going to be differences between the treated and the untreated groups, especially if there's bias)? We look for a difference that is so large that we'd only expect to see it one time in twenty due to chance, in the absence of bias. We don't know for sure that it works, but there's only a 5% chance that it doesn't. Except that when we do a thousand tests, 50 of them are going to be labelled as "positive" due to chance.

Second, to assume that for every homeopathic trial that is a true positive, there will be 10,000 trials that are false positives has no basis in reality.

You have mixed up what are assumptions and what are conclusions. My assumptions were that any chemical is a potential candidate for effect (and there are at least 100,000 chemicals present on earth), and that any medical condition is a potential candidate for relief (and there are at least 100 different medical conditions in humans). What is unrealistc about those assumptions?

I simply applied a straightforward 2x2 analysis to those assumptions and reported the result. If you think the result is unrealistic, then what numbers would you use?

I believe what you're thinking of are medical tests, such as mammograms, that have a high ratio of false positives to true positives.

No, I wasn't trying to find a comparable medical test and estimating the result from that.

However, false positives are no more likely in the testing of a specific homeopathic medicine (such as cough medicine) than they are in the testing of a specific non-homeopathic medicine.

That was the whole point of the exercise!!! How do we figure out how likely it is to have a false-positive? We calculate it using a 2x2 table. We don't just assume it's some arbitrary number.

Third, the notion that negative test results don't matter flies in the face of all statistical theory.

No it doesn't. Whether or not my mammogram represents a true-positive or a false-positive has nothing to do with whether or not the woman ahead of me in the line has a negative mammogram.

Again, the same thing is true of the testing of homeopathic medicines as it is of non-homeopathic medicines: All things being equal (test quality, number of test participants, etc.), the more often a medicine outperforms a placebo in a controlled trial, the more probable it is that it is an effective medicine.

NO!!! The probability that it is an effective medicine depends upon the pre-test probability (in the form of odds) and the likelihood ratio. When you talk about the results of a clinical trial, all that it determines for you is the likelihood ratio. You cannot assume that the post-test probability is the same as the likelihood ratio!!! That is a meaningless assumption!! You are essentially saying that "a*b=b" no matter what the value of "a" is.

The whole point of this post was that if you apply the results of the trial to the pre-test probability like you are supposed to do in order to make a valid conclusion, the post-test probability is dramatically different when you are looking at studies of homeopathic treatments. The reason that this isn't usually mentioned specifically in conventional medicine trials is because the pre-test probabilities are usually close to 1 - i.e. they represent a special case.

Linda
 
Last edited:
Linda, don't let him get to you. He knows full well you have explained this thoroughly convincingly a number of different ways, and now is just stirring the pot, as far as I can tell.
 
I'd have to disagree. Have you seen him answer a pertinent question, for example? He either ignores them or gives evasive answers. He certainly won't commit himself to holding a view on anything.;)

He's playing games. He's attempting to look like he's never quite convinced by skeptics' arguments (even Linda's excellent, insightful explanations) so that any neutral reader, who's not knowledgeable on the subject, will think he actually has a valid stance on this issue.

He's using the argument to ignorance; basically thus: OK, there are doubters of homeopathy but it hasn't been conclusively proven not to work; or, your methods seem valid but I'm not sure you're using them correctly in this context: as if displaying his own personal ignorance has some importance on the issue.

Claims can only be decided by evidence; and in the case of homeopathy, every link in the chain used to support it is both highly implausible and lacking in robust evidence.

Don't let his selective humility confuse us as to the game he's playing.


Well put, John. I think it takes a fairly perceptive mind to see through the facade.

M.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom