Heiwa Challenge to be Explained at NMSR

Did the FBI write back to him after the presentation at NMSR expressing interest ? If they did they must have had agents there I guess.

If you write to them and tell them that there are aliens in your closet, with Scud missles, and are holding you hostage in exchnge for 12 dozen Donken Donuts and a U2 record, they will write back to you in the exact same manner.
 
Please explain in detail.
Again, the crushing happens simultaneously in the real world in accordance with Newton's third law. Please note the lack of any real world example or simulation demonstrate Bazant's claims of crush-down before crush-up.

Your statement is at odds with itself.
No, it's your suggestion of the cores having needed stabilization from the floors which is at odds with the design of the towers.
 
Would that be enough if they were performing verinage with a high-rise of say 25 stories ( about 25% as tall as the Twin Towers)



That's actually a very good question, and the answer is, they're really quite vague on that detail in that patent. Earlier in the document, they discuss the safety zone needed in an explosive demolition of a 16-story building, and they cite the required zone as being 300 meters. They also mention that the Verinage technique can be applied to a building of any height, but they don't really go into detail on what considerations might be needed for taller buildings.

What one must remember when reading a patent is that it's not addressed to any Joe Public who might be reading it, it is addressed to one skilled in the art, who is reading the patent with a mind willing to understand it. One skilled in the art of building demolition would be expected to know that the safety zone would likely scale with the size of the building being demolished, and would probably realize that the 3m zone was intended as a comparison to the 300m zone discussed earlier - for a 16 story building. So 3m is probably a lower bound on the safety zone.

Of course, we could always try to contact the inventor, and ask him.
 
That's actually a very good question, and the answer is, they're really quite vague on that detail in that patent. Earlier in the document, they discuss the safety zone needed in an explosive demolition of a 16-story building, and they cite the required zone as being 300 meters. They also mention that the Verinage technique can be applied to a building of any height, but they don't really go into detail on what considerations might be needed for taller buildings.

What one must remember when reading a patent is that it's not addressed to any Joe Public who might be reading it, it is addressed to one skilled in the art, who is reading the patent with a mind willing to understand it. One skilled in the art of building demolition would be expected to know that the safety zone would likely scale with the size of the building being demolished, and would probably realize that the 3m zone was intended as a comparison to the 300m zone discussed earlier - for a 16 story building. So 3m is probably a lower bound on the safety zone.

Of course, we could always try to contact the inventor, and ask him.

What is the tallest building that you know of to have been successfully demolished by verinage ?
 
Can you not even acknowledge what I've pointed out is different?

I fail to see why its different, no.

With verinage they purposefully, in a controlled manor allow the top block to fall asymmetrically off the load bearing connections onto the floor systems. The floor system is obviously not designed to be load bearing and so it crushes through the building. With the WTC this also happened, but it wasnt controlled.

I see absolutely no reason why you are claiming it was suddenly so different.

Your claim about how verinage works btw is against how Heiwa believes it works. He believes they destroy the bottom supports, because according to him the smaller part of a building can never destroy the larger part. So he is even more exaggeratedly wrong than you are.

Bazant's claim of crush-down before crush-up breaks Newton's third law, while all Verinage demolitions demonstrate how the crushing happens simultaneously in the real world.

Except for a start the top and bottom block were not solid objects so your understanding of Newtons law cannot be used in this situation in the way you seem to interpret it to.

This is something they teach in schools, so why is it 99.9% of scientists engineers can't understand something so simple but you and bunch of fringe nobody's can along with a guy that believes all footage of the planes were CGI and that the plane should have bounced off? Doesn't that concern you a little bit, that maybe you might be wrong and there's a reason they dont accept it other than mass incompetence/stupidity/delusion/conspiracy?

The Verinage demolitions are considerably slower considering the scale, don't eject massive chunks of the structures out their sides, and don't produce nearly the amount of dust even when considering the difference in scale.

Yes they do eject massive chunks out of the sides, but the WTC had perimeter columns and these buildings do not. So, on 911, the upper block sheared off the sides of the building. The trajectory is the same. If it is clear this happens with verinage, why not with the towers? Otherwise you have to believe they used quiet explosives to do that and let me tell you that really is breaking the laws of physics.

The dust generated by the verinage collapses is also extremely large, its just the WTC was 110 stories rather than 20 or so. What Gage doesn't realise is the dust produced in a explosive demolition is also created by the collapsing building and not by explosives. Thats because explosive demolition isnt trying to be powerful enough to pulverise the entire building into dust or propel heavy steel, just enough to cut critical supports. The WTC also had tons of dry wall which these buildings wouldnt have had.

Face it, these Gage's "indicators" of explosive demolition are directly disproved by verinage as they show you get those same effects without explosives.

I like how you guys are so unbelievably picky about why verinage doesnt look like the WTC collapses yet dont care that your "experts" like Gage and Jones like to compare the WTC to concrete steel buildings like the Windsor tower that had a concrete core or demolitions that were extraordinarily loud and even then werent anywhere near the intensity Gage claims the explosives in the WTC towers were. Do you ever try and correct errors like that by people like Gage? Or do you not care about truthers promoting stupid lies that that?
 
Last edited:
That's actually a very good question, and the answer is, they're really quite vague on that detail in that patent. Earlier in the document, they discuss the safety zone needed in an explosive demolition of a 16-story building, and they cite the required zone as being 300 meters. They also mention that the Verinage technique can be applied to a building of any height, but they don't really go into detail on what considerations might be needed for taller buildings.

What one must remember when reading a patent is that it's not addressed to any Joe Public who might be reading it, it is addressed to one skilled in the art, who is reading the patent with a mind willing to understand it. One skilled in the art of building demolition would be expected to know that the safety zone would likely scale with the size of the building being demolished, and would probably realize that the 3m zone was intended as a comparison to the 300m zone discussed earlier - for a 16 story building. So 3m is probably a lower bound on the safety zone.

They mention a 3m zone without any reference to the height of the building being demolished. Yes, they also claim that verinage will work on any height of building, and that more cables can be used to disable other levels, as needed.

We have yet to see verinage used on a steel-framed structure. I think the engineers "skilled in the art", as Horatius mentions, would be able to determine that it probably wouldn't work.
 
They mention a 3m zone without any reference to the height of the building being demolished. Yes, they also claim that verinage will work on any height of building, and that more cables can be used to disable other levels, as needed.

We have yet to see verinage used on a steel-framed structure. I think the engineers "skilled in the art", as Horatius mentions, would be able to determine that it probably wouldn't work.

If they are talking three meters they do not really mean a building of any height. Obviously the Twin towers would not conform to three meters.
 
Again, the crushing happens simultaneously in the real world in accordance with Newton's third law. Please note the lack of any real world example or simulation demonstrate Bazant's claims of crush-down before crush-up.


No, it's your suggestion of the cores having needed stabilization from the floors which is at odds with the design of the towers.
You failed to prove Bazant's work violates Newton's third law, you need math and physics not failed talk. Your saying it mean you have delusions and you can't prove due to it being a moronic lie and you can't do the math and physics.

Heiwa's claim is stupid, do you support it? Heiwa was proved wrong by WTC 1, and WTC 2. You are proved wrong by failing to support your lies. You don't understand Bazant's model, why? What engineering school failed you?
 
Last edited:
Why does Heiwa believe the FBI's courtesy automatic response is actually them seriously investigating his claims?

Heiwa mocks you and you can't even see it. He had to be banned from here because everybody could see he had you wrapped around his little finger.
 
Why would they not ? They already were full of admiration- in writing- for Richard Gage's work on the subject. Are you saying they should ignore all that despite having gushed over the quality of the work ?

Ah okay so you're also as delusional as Heiwa I see. :rolleyes:
 
If they are talking three meters they do not really mean a building of any height. Obviously the Twin towers would not conform to three meters.

I agree. However, purely gravitational collapses also wouldn't be ejecting material laterally for hundreds of feet, as the Towers did. I think the inventors also recognize this.
 
Heiwa mocks you and you can't even see it. He had to be banned from here because everybody could see he had you wrapped around his little finger.

And we mock a guy that thinks steel buildings are indestructible and that even most of the truth movement thinks his no plane theories are absolutely certifiably insane. Considering how Gage kicked out a no planer Judy Wood space beamer supporter from his cult I have to wonder why he hasnt thrown Heiwa out for also being an embarrassment.
 
Heiwa mocks you and you can't even see it. He had to be banned from here because everybody could see he had you wrapped around his little finger.
Does this mean you can't prove Heiwa's insane claims are wrong? No math, no physics? Why can't you prove Heiwa is right? Because he is wrong. Simple stuff. If you can prove Heiwa is right, then you are a famous engineer. Are you an engineer? Got some skills to back up your lies? Wait, they are lie, you can't back up lies. Like Heiwa, you have delusions on 911, which you can't defend with evidence, math, engineering, or physics. This is why you will have 10 years of failure, solid nonsense, this time September 11, 2011. A decade of delusions based on fantasy, hearsay and idiotic lies.

Roll out the differential equations and give it a try to defend the insane claims of Heiwa, it would be entertaining to see 911 truth try reality after 9 years of fantasy.
 
Last edited:
You don't have the technical chops to answer, do you?

That's ok, no twoofer does.

The nearest I've seen to a technical answer to the question of how the cores could have been brought down by the falling rubble was Mackey's "funny forces" explanation.
 
No, it's your suggestion of the cores having needed stabilization from the floors which is at odds with the design of the towers.

1- I asked you if the columns would fail without the floors and you replied that it's "obvious" that they would. A correct answer.

2- but you also say that they would stand on their own, due to being designed that way.

3- you have nothing to substantiate statement #2.

4- you are a liar
 
The nearest I've seen to a technical answer to the question of how the cores could have been brought down by the falling rubble was Mackey's "funny forces" explanation.
This is not evidence, it your excuse so you don't have to do the math to see Heiwa's claim is nonsense.

Obsessed with Mackey? That is funny, and the funny forces, that seals the deal you and physics don't have a reality based relationship.

The topic is Heiwa's nut case Challenge which was won on 911, twice with full size models. Heiwa was wrong on 911, and he will not pay, he is the judge and he has delusions on 911, like you he is not using reality, math, physics or engineering to make up his delusional claims.
 
They mention a 3m zone without any reference to the height of the building being demolished. Yes, they also claim that verinage will work on any height of building, and that more cables can be used to disable other levels, as needed.

We have yet to see verinage used on a steel-framed structure. I think the engineers "skilled in the art", as Horatius mentions, would be able to determine that it probably wouldn't work.



Well, it would depend on your definition of "work", wouldn't it? I'd expect the profession of knocking down tall buildings surrounded by other buildings to be an inherently conservative one. We know we can do demolitions of large buildings with explosives without excessive danger to surrounding buildings, but it's not clear that we can do that with Verinage, is it? I'd expect that a few more decades of experience with Verinage, on progressively larger buildings, and on buildings with different structures, to take place before anyone would seriously suggest applying it to a skyscraper.

After all, the explosive demolition guys didn't run out and blow up the biggest building they could find the very first time, did they?
 
The nearest I've seen to a technical answer to the question of how the cores could have been brought down by the falling rubble was Mackey's "funny forces" explanation.

1- I'm unfamiliar with Mackey's response. But experience with twoofs indicate that what appears to you personally as "funny forces" is easily understood by just about anyone else.

2- it boils down to - a column that was designed to be braced.... needs to be braced. Otherwise it fails from self weight alone. The falling debris would have removed the floors in the core area, as well as the truss supported flooring outside the core. This results in unbraced columns.

This is not "funny forces". Your inability to form a technical rebuttal will be very telling to all that read it.
 
We know we can do demolitions of large buildings with explosives without excessive danger to surrounding buildings, but it's not clear that we can do that with Verinage, is it?

The patent owners expressly state that a 3m safety zone is sufficient. So, yes, they are suggesting that it is safe, as far as collateral damage is concerned. That's also mentioned in the preamble.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom