Has Edgar Cayce made any gross errors in prophecy?

What you're missing is that even the best doctors sometimes make errors. Cayce's sons did a randomized survey of their father's accuracy on medical readings and it worked out to be 85%, based on responses from clients. Randi attempted to discredit this percentage in Flim Flam, but did not succeed, in my opinion. If Cayce's remedies were generally ineffective, why not more complaints -- even lawsuits -- regarding them?

I might have more confidence if Cayce did it himself.:rolleyes:
 
You guys do know that Rodney is a card carrying member of Cayces organisation the A.R.E. right
You're not at any point going to get him to accept the facts, not while hes still paying the A.R.E. for membership
:p

and again, this thread is not about his medical claims unless he was using his status as a fraudulent doctor to make predictions for the future
theres already a thread for his medical fraudulence here
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=162342&highlight=edgar+cayce&page=2

you can see the responses you will get to any medical question about Cayce from Rodney there already
;)

now Rodney, was Cayces claim that the Giza pyramids were built around 10,000bce by Atlanteans accurate ?

or if thats too difficult perhaps you could enlighten us to how accurate Cayces claim was that
the missing link didn’t exist. Instead, God’s will had become imbued in an ape that greatly resembled man, and this ape was thus instantly gifted with creativity and the ability to plan and communicate. From then on, man was driven to evolve; but virtually instantaneously, not over millions of years.
when confronted with evidence that didn't exist at the time like this ?
fossil-hominid-skulls.jpg


was that claim accurate ?

no ?
how about his claims for the building of stonehenge
Answer Cayce: In the Holy Land when there were those breakings-up in the period when the land was being sacked by the Chaldeans and Persians, among those groups who escaped in ships and settled in portions of the English land near what is now Salisbury; and there built those altars that were to represent the dedication of individuals to the service of a living God.
was that accurate too ?
 
Last edited:
Considering all of the threads on the Randi Forums that argue that spinal manipulations are extremely dangerous, it's interesting that you come to that conclusion.


You would need to do an apples to apples comparison, which would not be easy. Again, many of Cayce's clients sought him out only after conventional medicine had failed them.

That's not really an argument in his favor.
 
Hi Rodney,
back to my original question.
I'm just curious. Why does anyone give a damn about this long dead crackpot?

Why should anyone care about this long dead crackpot that left absolutely nothing to medicine and has failed so miserably in his so called prophecies?
 
Hi Rodney,
back to my original question.


Why should anyone care about this long dead crackpot that left absolutely nothing to medicine and has failed so miserably in his so called prophecies?



I can answer that one
because the long dead crackpot left behind a multi billion dollar business (of which Rodney is a fully paid up member) that relies on peoples susceptibility to pseudo science and pseudo history and woo to make its money
That it continues to promote pseudo science and pseudo history and woo is unquestionable, (just look at anything they have ever done or produced)
they recently were promoting Sylvia Brown too
;)
 
Last edited:
I can answer that one
because the long dead crackpot left behind a multi billion dollar business (of which Rodney is a fully paid up member) that relies on peoples susceptibility to pseudo science and pseudo history and woo to make its money
That it continues to promote pseudo science and pseudo history and woo is unquestionable, (just look at anything they have ever done or produced)
they recently were promoting Sylvia Brown too
;)
Ahhhh...so this crackpot is the founder of an organization promoting woo. So this crackpot is way more harmful than I first thought.
 
We hear the same ole snake oil remedies,cept they are in a New Age package. Suggestion has a strong effect on some folks. May work for awhile, but they usually become ill again.
Homeopathy reminds me of these old timey medicine shows. Smoke and mirrors.
I want traditional medicine and nothing else. My cancer surgery is tuesday....same time as last year. Do I want some esoteric natural herb or healing blue waters when I come awake? Hell no,bring on the percs!
I do not trust any so called medicines that are named after colors.....pretty colors....pretty lies.
 
Last edited:
I want traditional medicine and nothing else. My cancer surgery is tuesday....same time as last year. Do I want some esoteric natural herb or healing blue waters when I come awake? Hell no,bring on the percs!
Be well.
I do not trust any so called medicine that are named after colors.....pretty colors....pretty lies.
We do use Methylene Blue and a few medicines have colors in their names ;)
 
Last edited:
well if you consider advising people with cancer to treat it by eating wood and shining a UV lamp on their bodies for 1 1/2 minutes then yes, I expect its very harmful
http://www.edgarcayce.org/health/database/health_resources/ultraviolet_light_therapy.asp

What the hell is "animated" ash? Does it have anything to do with Yggdrasil, the world tree? Also, oh holy crap, I can't believe they're still suggesting this for cancer patients. I mean, nice disclaimer at the bottom, but that's some seriously dangerous stupidity there.
 
We hear the same ole snake oil remedies,cept they are in a New Age package. Suggestion has a strong effect on some folks. May work for awhile, but they usually become ill again.
Homeopathy reminds me of these old timey medicine shows. Smoke and mirrors.
I want traditional medicine and nothing else. My cancer surgery is tuesday....same time as last year. Do I want some esoteric natural herb or healing blue waters when I come awake? Hell no,bring on the percs!
I do not trust any so called medicines that are named after colors.....pretty colors....pretty lies.

All the best on your surgery.

On a less serious note, does "healing blue waters" make anyone else think of Ty-D-Bol toilet cleaner?
 
What the hell is "animated" ash? Does it have anything to do with Yggdrasil, the world tree? Also, oh holy crap, I can't believe they're still suggesting this for cancer patients. I mean, nice disclaimer at the bottom, but that's some seriously dangerous stupidity there.

apparently its Ash that is still alive
:D
 
I was also thinking banana bags and bubblegum enemas sound pretty woo-ish, not to mention people going for "cabbage surgery" (CABG) LOL :)

Edgar Cayce recommends regular enemas as a cure for arthritis
:D
whos gonna tell Grandpa ?
 
Why should anyone care about this long dead crackpot that left absolutely nothing to medicine and has failed so miserably in his so called prophecies?

Are you kidding!? No contribution to modern medicine?! Cayce frequently recommended eating gelatin for any number of ailments.

And today, I'm pretty sure it's impossible to get a hospital dinner that doesn't include a rectangular chunk of green Jello.

;)
 
Last edited:
You would need to do an apples to apples comparison, which would not be easy. Again, many of Cayce's clients sought him out only after conventional medicine had failed them.

I agree. When looking specifically at cases where the diagnosis has been uncertain, the patient satisfaction drops to 90 percent.

Linda

P.S. Sorry Marduk.
 
Cayce frequently recommended eating gelatin for any number of ailments.
.

;)

Edgar Cayce said:
It isn't the vitamin content but it is ability to work with the activities of the glands, causing the glands to take from that absorbed or digested the vitamins that would not be active if there is not sufficient gelatin in the body. See, there may be mixed with any chemical that which makes the rest of the system susceptible or able to call from the system that needed. It becomes then, as it were, "sensitive to conditions."

there you have it, Gelatin is a catalyst for the absorbtion of vitamins by "the glands", so the following for which gelatin is recommended
arthritis, anemia, kidney problems, "incoordination between assimilations and eliminations," problems with lymph, poor circulation, Parkinsonism, general debilitation and multiple sclerosis
must all be conditions caused by vitamin/glandular deficiency. That must be why they give you green Jello in hospital
:D
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom