Has Edgar Cayce made any gross errors in prophecy?

I didn't know that he ever did work with a doctor. However, scope of practice generally defines what a person may or may not do within their licensed training. However, they can sometimes go outside of their scope if practicing under a medical director who accepts responsibility for it. I don't know what the laws were like in Cayce's day, but perhaps as long as the physician took responsibility for negligence or error, then Cayce could have theoretically "practiced" without being licensed at all or the physician being present or having to run everything by him ... perhaps. It would have depended on the laws at the time I think, which I'm ignorant of.

YOu preface your speculation with the word "perhaps." So, yes, I will agree that perhaps it was that way. On the other hand, why would legislatures pass a law saying that people with no medical degree and absolutely no training at all could diagnose and treat patients if a doctor assumes responsibility? No one would agree to a law where an unlicensed pilot with no training at all could fly a commercial airliner if a licensed pilot took responsibility.
 
Does anyone out there know of any astronomical (as in obvious) errors in Edgar Cayce's psychic predictions and/or prophecy?


How about his prediction that Hitler would rise to power in Germany? This would have been quite a good prediction if it hadn't been made in January 1934, a year after Hitler had become Chancellor and 10 months after the Enabling Act of 1933 had effectively made Hitler's government into a dictatorship. This makes it rather like the diagnostic readings he gave for patients who were already dead.
 
And also, as in the case of the bogus readings on subjects who were already dead, what damages could any even sue for?
There were only two such cases, and neither would likely be known to the public if it were not for The Outer Limits of Edgar Cayce's Power. As detailed in that book, Cayce gave five readings for subjects who were dying or had already died. In three of those cases, he correctly assessed the situation. In the other two cases, his readings seemed to fit the situation that had existed a few days earlier, but that was no longer relevant. Embarrassing errors? Absolutely, but again, why did Cayce's sons bring them to public attention?
 
You would instigate a lawsuit if your expectations were high enough that they could actually be let down, so it may be that people were generally unsurprised when his suggestions didn't help.
What about the many osteopathic adjustment that Cayce recommended? I would think that if those had gone seriously awry, the patient would have sued both the osteopath and Cayce. Cayce usually recommended a particular osteopath, and so -- while he could have argued that it was the osteopath who incorrectly followed his prescribed treatment -- I'm quite sure Cayce would have been mentioned in the lawsuit. I'm not aware of any such lawsuits.

And, of course, his sons did not work out that he had an 85% accuracy. They took a sample of his readings and then looked for any follow-up. A sizeable portion (over half?) of the readings did not have any sort of follow-up. Of those that did, it was recorded whether or not the respondant found Cayce's reading helpful or not. This would have very little to do with whether or not the reading was accurate (in some ways, the readings are not specific enough to be inaccurate or are presented in such a way as to be impossible to confirm or deny anyway). And a substantial portion of his clients should have been willing to report that he was helpful, based on the select population he would have been dealing with. One wonders if 85% of less than half of his clients is actually lower than should be expected.
I agree that we have no baseline here, and that's my point about Randi's critique. He never presented any evidence that the average doctor would fare better than Cayce using the type of analysis that Cayce's sons did.
 
YOu preface your speculation with the word "perhaps." So, yes, I will agree that perhaps it was that way. On the other hand, why would legislatures pass a law saying that people with no medical degree and absolutely no training at all could diagnose and treat patients if a doctor assumes responsibility? No one would agree to a law where an unlicensed pilot with no training at all could fly a commercial airliner if a licensed pilot took responsibility.
That's what I mean about the "laws of the day." Without researching what they were like back then, I don't know if that kind of thing was looked past or "winked at" or not (i.e. snake oil salesman). I mean, back then we had segregated water fountains didn't we? The laws didn't have to "make sense". But I do understand what you're saying.

And there are certain types of "practice" a person can go into without having any legitimate training whatsoever (obviously LOL). I have a family member who sent off for a DIY home course on Xtian counseling. When she completed it on her own time, she got a certificate in the mail. She started advertising herself as a certified therapist in the phonebook, rented an office space, and had clients --- some of which were suicidal! I suppose it's really not that much different than faith healers still, in some ways. Except that Cayce was actually diagnosing, correct? THAT right there is something that is very limited to specific scopes of practice today. But back then? I have no idea :)
 
Last edited:
And, again, I raise the question that I've raised in other Cayce threads: Did anyone's health ever decline after following Cayce-prescribed treatments?


We should contact all of them and ask!

What, we can't do that because a large majority of them are deceased? Then the answer is definitely yes!

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
No, the A.R.E. began in 1931, and Cayce was not convicted of practicing medicine without a license until 1935.(That came about when a doctor filed a complaint with the Detroit police because he did not think Cayce's diagnosis of a case was accurate.) Cayce generally worked with a doctor, and so there was usually no issue of practicing medicine without a license. And, as far as I know, you did not have to join the A.R.E to obtain a reading.

ah I knew I had it a little screwy
so Cayce didn't exclusively read just for A.R.E. members until after he was convicted

thanks
;)
 
ah I knew I had it a little screwy
so Cayce didn't exclusively read just for A.R.E. members until after he was convicted

thanks
;)
In reviewing my source material, it appears that, once the A.R.E was founded in 1931, Cayce required that an applicant for a reading be a member of the A.R.E. However, the A.R.E application form could be filed simultaneous with the application for a reading, and so there was no waiting period for a reading. But it is incorrect to state: "Cayce didn't exclusively read just for A.R.E. members until after he was convicted." Rather, Cayce began to do readings exclusively for A.R.E members in 1931, but he wasn't convicted of practicing medicine without a license until 1935.
 
What about the many osteopathic adjustment that Cayce recommended? I would think that if those had gone seriously awry, the patient would have sued both the osteopath and Cayce. Cayce usually recommended a particular osteopath, and so -- while he could have argued that it was the osteopath who incorrectly followed his prescribed treatment --
Ah, osteopathy, the outdated form of medicine that has since been shown to be no better than a nice massage? Not a good example.
I'm quite sure Cayce would have been mentioned in the lawsuit. I'm not aware of any such lawsuits.
So?
I agree that we have no baseline here, and that's my point about Randi's critique. He never presented any evidence that the average doctor would fare better than Cayce using the type of analysis that Cayce's sons did.
What "analysis" was that?
 
There were only two such cases, and neither would likely be known to the public if it were not for The Outer Limits of Edgar Cayce's Power. As detailed in that book, Cayce gave five readings for subjects who were dying or had already died. In three of those cases, he correctly assessed the situation. In the other two cases, his readings seemed to fit the situation that had existed a few days earlier, but that was no longer relevant. Embarrassing errors? Absolutely, but again, why did Cayce's sons bring them to public attention?
Yes, Rodney. Why would they do so?

Are you suggesting that it somehow makes his magic more plausible?
 
Ah, osteopathy, the outdated form of medicine that has since been shown to be no better than a nice massage? Not a good example.
According to Wikipedia:

"In a 2005 meta-analysis and systematic review of six randomized controlled trials of osteopathic manipulative treatment (OMT) that involved blinded assessments of lower back pain in ambulatory settings, it was concluded that OMT significantly reduces lower back pain, and that the level of pain reduction is greater than expected from placebo effects alone and persists for at least three months . . . Safety concerns have been raised in relation to manipulative techniques used by some osteopaths. 'Neck cracking', i.e. cervical high-velocity low-amplitude thrusting, has received particular attention in the popular media owing to a possible risk of arterial occlusion and consequently of stroke. Although the existing data cannot provide a conclusive estimate of the cervical artery dissection risk researchers have stated that a stroke risk of about 1.3 per 100 000 chiropractic visits for individuals aged under 45 years, with a 95% confidence interval of 0.5–16.7 per 100 000 is a theoretically unbiased estimate. Although these data primarily concern chiropractic visits, both osteopaths and chiropractors may practise cervical manipulations." See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Osteopathy

So, there seems to be doubt whether osteopathy is "no better than a nice massage." But, from your perspective, the issue is the risk of osteopathic adjustments. If it's risky, why haven't we heard of some of Cayce's clients suffering adverse consequences?

So where are the lawsuits? Were all of Cayce's clients afraid to sue, even if their health deteriorated after Cayce's treatments? And bear in mind that not all of Cayce's clients were true believers. Many turned to him only after the conventional medical wisdom of the day had failed.


What "analysis" was that?
Computing the percentage of Cayce's clients that had a positive opinion on the efficacy of Cayce-recommended treatments relative to the percentage that had a negative opinion regarding those treatments.

P.S. I'm still waiting for you to produce any evidence that Cayce was either a fraud or a "dangerous nutjob."
 
CAYCE FLIM-FLAM!
by James Randi

When all else fails to convince the skeptic, promoters of the paranormal fall back on the Sleeping Prophet, Edgar Cayce, who is credited with having made accurate diagnoses and having prescribed cures for distant patients who sent him letters - and this despite having little or no information about them. Cayce is also famous for his "life readings" - descriptions of former and present lives of people derived from their names alone. He claimed it was all done while he slept, and that he never remembered a word of what he said while entranced. The Association for Research and Enlightenment is the result of all this, and its library of thirty thousand case histories is great material with which to regale the credulous. Moreover, the rationalizations that Cayce and his supporters used to explain his numerous and notable failures are prime examples of the art of evasion.
...

Full: http://psychicinvestigator.com/demo/ReinSkp4.htm
 
Last edited:
So, there seems to be doubt whether osteopathy is "no better than a nice massage." But, from your perspective, the issue is the risk of osteopathic adjustments.
So you did not read your link did you?
If it's risky, why haven't we heard of some of Cayce's clients suffering adverse consequences?
Risky? Did I say that? I prefer to state USELESS and often imaginary.
So where are the lawsuits? Were all of Cayce's clients afraid to sue, even if their health deteriorated after Cayce's treatments? And bear in mind that not all of Cayce's clients were true believers. Many turned to him only after the conventional medical wisdom of the day had failed.
Yes, Rodney. Why would they not do so?

Are you suggesting that it somehow makes his magic more plausible?
Computing the percentage of Cayce's clients that had a positive opinion on the efficacy of Cayce-recommended treatments relative to the percentage that had a negative opinion regarding those treatments.
Really? What was their control set? What was their measure of success? Please do tell about this "analysis".
P.S. I'm still waiting for you to produce any evidence that Cayce was either a fraud or a "dangerous nutjob."
His record as a useless piece of garbage who practiced medicine without any training leading to endangering the lives of those who listened to him and who left no lasting benefit to humanity is enough evidence to call him a nutjob.

Do you have any evidence any of his nonsense worked? I'll I've ever seen you try to produce as anecdotes written after the fact and...well basically nothing or are you going to keep trying to insinuate that because no one sued him that his magic powers are real by default?
 
well thats the claims that he was a gifted doctor put to bed, shall we move on to some of his claims for History now,

1. the pyramids were built around 10,000 by survivors of Atlantis
2. Stone henge was built by a fleeing tribe of Israel fresh from the exodus of 1500bce
3. etc
:p
 
What about the many osteopathic adjustment that Cayce recommended? I would think that if those had gone seriously awry, the patient would have sued both the osteopath and Cayce. Cayce usually recommended a particular osteopath, and so -- while he could have argued that it was the osteopath who incorrectly followed his prescribed treatment -- I'm quite sure Cayce would have been mentioned in the lawsuit. I'm not aware of any such lawsuits.

Again, we wouldn't expect this to happen regardless of the extent of any harm.

First of all, there is little correlation between the filing of a malpractice lawsuit and the presence of harm from negligence. Only about 20 percent of malpractice claims involve negligence, and only 1 to 3 percent of cases of harm from negligence result in a suit being filed. Second, since he wasn't a medical professional, there wasn't any reasonable expectation that his advice would be without error. Third, any harm would not come from his own actions, but from others following his advice.

Add to that the failure to recognize or attribute harm to the treatment (or to the delay in seeking proper treatment), not wanting to look foolish for following the advice of an obvious crank, the tendency for failure to reinforce belief, etc., it would be extremely unlikely for anyone to file suit, regardless of the extent of any harm. However, from readings that I have read, it looks more like his advice would be generally useless, rather than harmful.

I agree that we have no baseline here, and that's my point about Randi's critique. He never presented any evidence that the average doctor would fare better than Cayce using the type of analysis that Cayce's sons did.

I agree that no information is presented which allows us to consider Cayce's patient satisfaction rate remarkable. If you consider that the average doctor fares much better than Cayce (patient satisfaction surveys tend to return rates of satisfaction rates in excess of 90 percent - often 99 percent), Cayce's rate starts to look remarkably poor.

Linda
 
However, from readings that I have read, it looks more like his advice would be generally useless, rather than harmful.
Considering all of the threads on the Randi Forums that argue that spinal manipulations are extremely dangerous, it's interesting that you come to that conclusion.

I agree that no information is presented which allows us to consider Cayce's patient satisfaction rate remarkable. If you consider that the average doctor fares much better than Cayce (patient satisfaction surveys tend to return rates of satisfaction rates in excess of 90 percent - often 99 percent), Cayce's rate starts to look remarkably poor.
You would need to do an apples to apples comparison, which would not be easy. Again, many of Cayce's clients sought him out only after conventional medicine had failed them.
 
There were only two such cases, and neither would likely be known to the public if it were not for The Outer Limits of Edgar Cayce's Power. As detailed in that book, Cayce gave five readings for subjects who were dying or had already died. In three of those cases, he correctly assessed the situation. In the other two cases, his readings seemed to fit the situation that had existed a few days earlier, but that was no longer relevant. Embarrassing errors? Absolutely, but again, why did Cayce's sons bring them to public attention?

Why does that matter? The motivations of his sons does not argue one way or the other about the validity of Edgar Cayce's claims. (Ditto lawsuits. The motivations of a damaged party to file suit and his ability to win a suit are also irrelevant to the question of whether Cayce's claims were true.)

He claimed in his trance state to be able to see the subject's body and every little nuance in health. These gross "errors" (especially giving readings on dead people where he thought they were still alive and could still be cured) prove beyond any doubt that he simply couldn't do what he claimed.

His percentage of hits and misses is also irrelevant to the point I'm making.
 
His number one son didn't value Edgars historical predictions
Hugh Lynn and I talked after the work for him was over and I remember he felt quite satisfied with our work, and of the opinion that his father's best work was in healing people and not in archaeological predictions. I had the distinct feeling Hugh Lynn was quite satisfied there was no Hall of Records anywhere under the Sphinx."
http://www.touregypt.net/featurestories/secretchambers3.htm

just want to point out here that discussing wether or not Edgar was a good fraudulent doctor is off topic
;)
 
I'll check that when I get a chance. I think it's safe to say that, after the A.R.E. was established, the overwhelming majority of the readings were for members. However, I'm not sure that no readings were given after that for non-members. Also, I can't see how a members only requirement for readings would protect Cayce from a legal charge that he was practicing medicine without a license. If, in fact, he was doing that and a patient's health was adversely affected, a defense that the A.R.E. member had waived all legal rights against Cayce by signing the membership agreement would not be likely to work. And, again, I raise the question that I've raised in other Cayce threads: Did anyone's health ever decline after following Cayce-prescribed treatments?


You are asking if Cayce was worse than a placebo.
 
And, again, I raise the question that I've raised in other Cayce threads: Did anyone's health ever decline after following Cayce-prescribed treatments?

Definitely. Most (if not all) of the subjects Casey diagnosed are now dead.

I know that's not what you're after, but maybe it will help you refine your question. Are you suggesting that there is no evidence that Casey did harm?

Even if it's true (and I doubt it), it doesn't argue that his claims were valid. He could have done no harm by not practicing medicine without any training.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom