Has Edgar Cayce made any gross errors in prophecy?

I'm just curious. Why does anyone give a damn about this long dead crackpot?
 
Well, as others said before, since there were no major changes in Earth's geography (Atlantis has not risen from deeps, for example), the answer is YES.

Next?
 
No, the A.R.E. began in 1931, and Cayce was not convicted of practicing medicine without a license until 1935.(That came about when a doctor filed a complaint with the Detroit police because he did not think Cayce's diagnosis of a case was accurate.) Cayce generally worked with a doctor, and so there was usually no issue of practicing medicine without a license. And, as far as I know, you did not have to join the A.R.E to obtain a reading.

That's my understanding of the time line too.

Once the membership agreements were established, I do think you needed to be a member after that to obtain a reading. Remember the case where Cayce was arrested on fortune telling charges? According to Gertrude Cayce, she had explained to the undercover cop that signing was required, that Edgar gave trance readings under a Virginia-based charter that stipulated that only members could have readings" (Kirkpatrick p. 444). She later stated she'd paid $70 to have her fortune read, but the Cayces were able to argue that she'd paid $70 as her membership fee. That was in 1931.
 
I'm just curious. Why does anyone give a damn about this long dead crackpot?

Coincidentally, I was having a few beers with friends last week at a bar where they have a "psychic" come in once a week and set up shop at a table where he entertains willing patrons with Tarot readings and engaging conversation.

We usually snicker at the guy but it brought up conversation which turned to Cayce, and to my chagrin one of my friends waxed poetic about his accomplishments. Not having ready knowledge of the man's history I had to bite my tongue and keep my lips pressed tightly together to avoid blasting him without having facts at my disposal.

Now I will have some ammunition. These threads can come in handy as a central knowledge base fed by the experience of a wide range of posters.
 
Once the membership agreements were established, I do think you needed to be a member after that to obtain a reading. Remember the case where Cayce was arrested on fortune telling charges? According to Gertrude Cayce, she had explained to the undercover cop that signing was required, that Edgar gave trance readings under a Virginia-based charter that stipulated that only members could have readings" (Kirkpatrick p. 444). She later stated she'd paid $70 to have her fortune read, but the Cayces were able to argue that she'd paid $70 as her membership fee. That was in 1931.
I'll check that when I get a chance. I think it's safe to say that, after the A.R.E. was established, the overwhelming majority of the readings were for members. However, I'm not sure that no readings were given after that for non-members. Also, I can't see how a members only requirement for readings would protect Cayce from a legal charge that he was practicing medicine without a license. If, in fact, he was doing that and a patient's health was adversely affected, a defense that the A.R.E. member had waived all legal rights against Cayce by signing the membership agreement would not be likely to work. And, again, I raise the question that I've raised in other Cayce threads: Did anyone's health ever decline after following Cayce-prescribed treatments?
 
He got several things wrong :)

If I remember, though, didn't he supposedly work off donations only and he never asked for payment or money? Is that "fact" or a myth?

I think he was one who actually believed what he was doing was real. Some of his stuff was vague, but some of it was much more specific --- albeit some of the specifics could not be proven either, so some were a "safe bet" if you will ...

Don't know about the donations part, but when I read a book of his some years ago I must say he came off as genuinely believing what he was doing was real. Even upon reflection, I think he really believed and, unlike, Sylvia Browne, really thought he could help people.

Edit - in light of a following post since I read him as many years ago as I read Sylvia Browne, I was probably young and dumb! Okay, maybe he didn't really believe his claims.
 
Last edited:
I'm just curious. Why does anyone give a damn about this long dead crackpot?

Probably because he is still talked about, mentioned on tv, and others keep trying to "follow in his footsteps." At least that's my guess.
 
By the way, Cayce's two sons wrote a book about their father's errors, which seems a bit odd, if he was a fraud.

OK--I'll bite. He claims to be able to give readings on people not present, to be able to assess their health and give accurate diagnoses, advice for remedies and prognoses.

How exactly are instances where he is proven wrong (including giving readings to subjects that were already dead) not evidence that his claim is fraudulent?

He obviously couldn't do what he was claiming to do. He had reason to know he couldn't do what he was claiming he could do.

Sorry, Rodney, but there's no way you can spin evidence that he couldn't do what he claimed into evidence that he could.

At best you're arguing that he was a pious fraud--that he believed his claims (despite evidence to the contrary).
 
No, the A.R.E. began in 1931, and Cayce was not convicted of practicing medicine without a license until 1935.(That came about when a doctor filed a complaint with the Detroit police because he did not think Cayce's diagnosis of a case was accurate.) Cayce generally worked with a doctor, and so there was usually no issue of practicing medicine without a license. And, as far as I know, you did not have to join the A.R.E to obtain a reading.

Does that mean he sometimes worked without a doctor? Do you consider telling people what illness they suffer from and what steps they should take to cure the illness to be practicing medicine without a license? Was Cayce's conviction just or unjust?
 
He got several things wrong :)

If I remember, though, didn't he supposedly work off donations only and he never asked for payment or money? Is that "fact" or a myth?

I think he was one who actually believed what he was doing was real. Some of his stuff was vague, but some of it was much more specific --- albeit some of the specifics could not be proven either, so some were a "safe bet" if you will ...

To some extent that's a myth because at different times Cayce did accept payment for his readings. In the early years, he worked with a homeopath named Ketchum and a few others who had agreed to charge a fee of $25. This is again according to the biography by Sindey Kirckpatrick. Also, in the early 1930s, they seem to have established a process where they would charge people for a membership to the A.R.E. before providing a reading. Kirkpatrick's book states that by the late '30s, early '40s the Cayces were making a decent living off the membership fees. The information I have makes it sound like Cayce may have worked on donations during the intervening few years.

I'll check that when I get a chance. I think it's safe to say that, after the A.R.E. was established, the overwhelming majority of the readings were for members. However, I'm not sure that no readings were given after that for non-members. Also, I can't see how a members only requirement for readings would protect Cayce from a legal charge that he was practicing medicine without a license. If, in fact, he was doing that and a patient's health was adversely affected, a defense that the A.R.E. member had waived all legal rights against Cayce by signing the membership agreement would not be likely to work. And, again, I raise the question that I've raised in other Cayce threads: Did anyone's health ever decline after following Cayce-prescribed treatments?

It would be interesting to see a copy of the actual membership agreement. I suppose it would have protected them from fortune-telling charges (charging for a membership versus for a reading). I don't know if it would have been of any use against the charge of practicing medicine without a license or harming a patient's health. I guess some of that would depend on exactly what the agreement said.

I haven't heard of any instances when a person's health declined after they followed a Cayce prescribed treatment. Then again, it's impossible to determine that with any accuracy since not everyone who contacted Cayce for a reading and then followed his advice would have written back with an update.
 
While browsing through the A.R.E. site, I came across this article:

http://www.edgarcayce.org/are/ancient_mysteries.aspx?id=2667

Now, is there any truth to this prediction or not? Personally, I think that most scholars would agree that men and women lived together in most societies, including the Essenes' society, and so I find the claims of the A.R.E. to be weak.
 
Last edited:
OK--I'll bite. He claims to be able to give readings on people not present, to be able to assess their health and give accurate diagnoses, advice for remedies and prognoses.

How exactly are instances where he is proven wrong (including giving readings to subjects that were already dead) not evidence that his claim is fraudulent?

He obviously couldn't do what he was claiming to do. He had reason to know he couldn't do what he was claiming he could do.

Sorry, Rodney, but there's no way you can spin evidence that he couldn't do what he claimed into evidence that he could.

At best you're arguing that he was a pious fraud--that he believed his claims (despite evidence to the contrary).
What you're missing is that even the best doctors sometimes make errors. Cayce's sons did a randomized survey of their father's accuracy on medical readings and it worked out to be 85%, based on responses from clients. Randi attempted to discredit this percentage in Flim Flam, but did not succeed, in my opinion. If Cayce's remedies were generally ineffective, why not more complaints -- even lawsuits -- regarding them?
 
While browsing through the A.R.E. site, I came across this article:

http://www.edgarcayce.org/are/ancient_mysteries.aspx?id=2667

Now, is there any truth to this prediction or not? Personally, I think that most scholars would agree that men and women lived together in most societies, including the Essenes' society, and so I find the claims of the A.R.E. to be weak.
According to Wikipedia: "Pliny clearly wrote that the Essenes that lived near the Dead Sea 'had not one woman, had renounced all pleasure ... and no one was born in their race.'" See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Essenes
 
What you're missing is that even the best doctors sometimes make errors. Cayce's sons did a randomized survey of their father's accuracy on medical readings and it worked out to be 85%, based on responses from clients.


Of course they wouldn't have been biased for any reason.

Randi attempted to discredit this percentage in Flim Flam, but did not succeed, in my opinion. If Cayce's remedies were generally ineffective, why not more complaints -- even lawsuits -- regarding them?


Uh, maybe because they were generally ineffective?
 
What you're missing is that even the best doctors sometimes make errors.

But not errors that disprove their claimed abilities. Cayce's errors prove that he was not able to do what he claimed to be able to do.

If Cayce's remedies were generally ineffective, why not more complaints -- even lawsuits -- regarding them?
What kind of argument is that? Paucity of lawsuits doesn't change the fact that Cayce's egregious errors prove beyond any doubt that he was not doing what he claimed to be doing.

If anything, the paucity of lawsuits only supports the idea that his believers will believe no matter what. And also, as in the case of the bogus readings on subjects who were already dead, what damages could any even sue for?
 
I'm just curious. Why does anyone give a damn about this long dead crackpot?
Because my father had a couple of his books hanging around my house when I was ten years old, right next to his copy of the Happy Hooker. I became interested in both, one more than the other :)

Does that mean he sometimes worked without a doctor? Do you consider telling people what illness they suffer from and what steps they should take to cure the illness to be practicing medicine without a license? Was Cayce's conviction just or unjust?
I didn't know that he ever did work with a doctor. However, scope of practice generally defines what a person may or may not do within their licensed training. However, they can sometimes go outside of their scope if practicing under a medical director who accepts responsibility for it. I don't know what the laws were like in Cayce's day, but perhaps as long as the physician took responsibility for negligence or error, then Cayce could have theoretically "practiced" without being licensed at all or the physician being present or having to run everything by him ... perhaps. It would have depended on the laws at the time I think, which I'm ignorant of.

What you're missing is that even the best doctors sometimes make errors. Cayce's sons did a randomized survey of their father's accuracy on medical readings and it worked out to be 85%, based on responses from clients. Randi attempted to discredit this percentage in Flim Flam, but did not succeed, in my opinion. If Cayce's remedies were generally ineffective, why not more complaints -- even lawsuits -- regarding them?
Hmmm .... did Cayce ever claim 100% accuracy I wonder?

This is always something that's been interesting to me. When psychics and the like claim they are not always accurate. On the one hand, we would expect them to be 100% accurate, or at least be able to explain in a detailed, objective manner why they were unable to be accurate. Something that could be verified. And the thinking would also be that if they were claiming to not always be accurate, then what good are they from someone making random guesses or logical deductions (cold reading)?

So could a "psychic" still be considered useful if they claim, "I'm not always accurate," ... and are even unable to provide a clear range of accuracy? Perhaps it would depend on the situation and circumstance. Hmmm ......
 
Last edited:
What you're missing is that even the best doctors sometimes make errors. Cayce's sons did a randomized survey of their father's accuracy on medical readings and it worked out to be 85%, based on responses from clients. Randi attempted to discredit this percentage in Flim Flam, but did not succeed, in my opinion. If Cayce's remedies were generally ineffective, why not more complaints -- even lawsuits -- regarding them?

I suspect that this goes back to Paximperium's question. It's hard to tell why anyone gave a damn about what he had to say, so I wonder if that was the prevailing attitude among his clients. We've all tried stuff without any real expectation that it will work (as a sort of last ditch effort), so when it doesn't, we just shrug it off and move on to try something new. You would instigate a lawsuit if your expectations were high enough that they could actually be let down, so it may be that people were generally unsurprised when his suggestions didn't help.

And, of course, his sons did not work out that he had an 85% accuracy. They took a sample of his readings and then looked for any follow-up. A sizeable portion (over half?) of the readings did not have any sort of follow-up. Of those that did, it was recorded whether or not the respondant found Cayce's reading helpful or not. This would have very little to do with whether or not the reading was accurate (in some ways, the readings are not specific enough to be inaccurate or are presented in such a way as to be impossible to confirm or deny anyway). And a substantial portion of his clients should have been willing to report that he was helpful, based on the select population he would have been dealing with. One wonders if 85% of less than half of his clients is actually lower than should be expected.

Linda
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom