Has Edgar Cayce made any gross errors in prophecy?

That was kind of the point I was trying to make, too.

I guess we will all have to agree to disagree on this.

Nope, until you actually answer the extremely simple question I asked you earlier, we'll have to assume that youre still brainwashed like Rodney

ok ?
:D
 
That was kind of the point I was trying to make, too.

I guess we will all have to agree to disagree on this.

Agree to disagree on what?

It has been stipulated by a few posters on this thread that, of all of the myriad unsubstantiated, undocumented, "folk" cures for cancer, Cayce's unsubstantiated, undocumented, "folk" cure is somehow exempt from the usual burden of proof. Because a book Rodney read say's so. Although this book has an obvious bias, we are nonetheless instructed to simply accept all of it's assertions concerning said mystic.

If we dare to suggest that neither Rodney or the book he quotes from has any corraborating evidence that events transpired as stated, we are being unreasonable.
 
What I said was that it is not unreasonable to ask whether this particular treatment has been discredited. I was curious about this, too.

Never did I say that the fact that it has NOT been discredited is reason to believe in the efficacy of the treatment.

What I did say was that it seems unreasonable to me to state with certainty that said treatment does not work without evidence. Does that mean I have said that the burden of proof doesn't lie with the A.R.E.? NO. I most definitely did not say that either.

To me, it seems a reasonable skeptical response would be, "We don't have any evidence either way. The burden of proof is on the A.R.E. and they haven't bothered to do the necessary studies, so far as we know."

That's all. It seems I am in the minority with this viewpoint.
 
What I said was that it is not unreasonable to ask whether this particular treatment has been discredited. I was curious about this, too.

Never did I say that the fact that it has NOT been discredited is reason to believe in the efficacy of the treatment.

What I did say was that it seems unreasonable to me to state with certainty that said treatment does not work without evidence. Does that mean I have said that the burden of proof doesn't lie with the A.R.E.? NO. I most definitely did not say that either.

To me, it seems a reasonable skeptical response would be, "We don't have any evidence either way. The burden of proof is on the A.R.E. and they haven't bothered to do the necessary studies, so far as we know."

That's all. It seems I am in the minority with this viewpoint.

no clearly youre thinking processes are retarded for some reason, the A.R.E have already posted a disclaimer on the animated ash cure, so they don't believe it either

so the burden of proof is on anyone who claims it works,
and the only person claiming that is Rodney

funny that the person who the burden of proof rests on has done nothing to prove it isn't it
;)

btw EM ignoring my posts makes you look dumb
:p
 
Have any of Cayce's cancer remedies ever been subjected to a controlled test? If not, your numbers have no relevance to the issue at hand.

That's the point, isn't it? Without any information (like a controlled test) which lets us alter the prior probability, we don't have any way to say that it is different from the information we already have of 3 in 10,000.

Linda
 
no clearly youre thinking processes are retarded for some reason, the A.R.E have already posted a disclaimer on the animated ash cure, so they don't believe it either

so the burden of proof is on anyone who claims it works,
and the only person claiming that is Rodney

funny that the person who the burden of proof rests on has done nothing to prove it isn't it
;)

btw EM ignoring my posts makes you look dumb
:p

Marduk, that is an offensive thing to say.

In what way have I ignored your posts?
 
I have asked you the same perfectly reasonable question three times and three times you have ignored it, that made it look as if you either didn't want to or couldn't answer it.
 
I have asked you the same perfectly reasonable question three times and three times you have ignored it, that made it look as if you either didn't want to or couldn't answer it.

Please show me where you have asked me the same question 3 times (?).

I have gone back and I see only one question directed at me, one time. That was: Who is the burden of proof on?

You later make a comment that I am brain-washed by the A.R.E., which is too silly and ridiculous to respond to, so I am going to presume you aren't referring to that.

I'm happy to answer your question and in fact have attempted to answer that one question you asked me in different ways in the past several posts. My impression has been that you are ignoring what I have been trying to say, which is why I have said maybe it's best to agree to disagree on this. But maybe we're just not understanding each other.
 
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=5764830&postcount=361
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=5763747&postcount=353
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=5763529&postcount=350

three times asked, three times ignored, so its not a case of us not understanding each other, its a case of you ignoring whats right in front of you isnt it
:p

and you still havent answered the question, which led me to answer it myself, the burden of proof is on the person claiming that animated ash can cure cancer, thats not the A.R.E because they posted a disclaimer. That just leaves Rodney.
and to be fair to him, he doesnt have the critical thinking skills to run such a test nor the medical expertise to pull it off. So its a non question and not worth anyones time to answer.

Now if you really can't see why its a ridiculous question it tells me two things
1. you don't know a lot about cancer
2. you havent bothered to find out about cancer
this does not paint you in glory.
thats all
 
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=5764830&postcount=361
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=5763747&postcount=353
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=5763529&postcount=350

three times asked, three times ignored, so its not a case of us not understanding each other, its a case of you ignoring whats right in front of you isnt it
:p

and you still havent answered the question, which led me to answer it myself, the burden of proof is on the person claiming that animated ash can cure cancer, thats not the A.R.E because they posted a disclaimer. That just leaves Rodney.
and to be fair to him, he doesnt have the critical thinking skills to run such a test nor the medical expertise to pull it off. So its a non question and not worth anyones time to answer.

Now if you really can't see why its a ridiculous question it tells me two things
1. you don't know a lot about cancer
2. you havent bothered to find out about cancer
this does not paint you in glory.
thats all


I answered post #350 and #353. Post #363 was irrelevant to me since I considered your questions answered. Not once did I consider ignoring your question about burden of proof, though I decided to ignore some of your more condescending/insulting posts.

Edgar Cayce made the claim. The A.R.E. represents Cayce, disclaimer or no disclaimer. It's silly to argue otherwise.

I was not aware that Rodney had made a claim, only that he had asked a question. If Rodney made such a claim, I stand corrected.

No, I don't know much more about cancer than the average person. Working in the medical field, I know some. I know next to nothing about animated ash. I don't even know what the heck animated ash is supposed to mean, nor do I care. Whether or not you think that paints me in glory doesn't really concern me.
 
No, I don't know much more about cancer than the average person. Working in the medical field, I know some. I know next to nothing about animated ash. I don't even know what the heck animated ash is supposed to mean, nor do I care. Whether or not you think that paints me in glory doesn't really concern me.

If you haven't bothered to do a little research yourself then you have no right to tell anyone else what questions a critical thinker should be asking. Because you are not a critical thinker

You know that the A.R.E. lies to the public, I already proved that, so whats the point of asking for their burden of proof, its just going to be another lie, we already know that Rodney has turned self delusion into a personal art form, so theres no point asking him for evidence of anything either, it would just be another demonstration of his confirmation bias.

Who does that leave to provide burden of proof ?
How about cancer doctors all over the world trying their hardest to cure cancer, surely the fact that none of them are using animated ash or anything like it answers the question as to its validity. Its a ridiculous question that doesn't require an answer anymore than my dog faeces claim, if you can't see that then you have some serious issues you need to address, remember now, you are taking the word of a man who was convicted of a fraudulent crime as if its worth something
It isn't

:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
That's the point, isn't it? Without any information (like a controlled test) which lets us alter the prior probability, we don't have any way to say that it is different from the information we already have of 3 in 10,000.

Linda
We know that many individuals who turned to Cayce after the conventional medicine of his time had failed them or their child got better, and some of the improvements were dramatic. Now, your take on that seems to be that those cases were spontaneous recoveries. But can you document anything similar with the failed 9,997 out of 10,000 cancer treatments?
 
And you are? :rolleyes:

Yes Rodney I am, thats why I'm not stupid enough to pay woo groups for membership and why if I ever get cancer I'll be going to my doctor rather than my lumbermill
:p

We know that many individuals who turned to Cayce after the conventional medicine of his time had failed them or their child got better, and some of the improvements were dramatic.
No we don't, thats what the A.R.E. says and they are liars
Now, your take on that seems to be that those cases were spontaneous recoveries. But can you document anything similar with the failed 9,997 out of 10,000 cancer treatments?
confirmation bias, go look it up Rodney, then come back and tell us the difference between psoriasis and cancer
:D
 
Last edited:
If you haven't bothered to do a little research yourself then you have no right to tell anyone else what questions a critical thinker should be asking. Because you are not a critical thinker

You know that the A.R.E. lies to the public, I already proved that, so whats the point of asking for their burden of proof, its just going to be another lie, we already know that Rodney has turned self delusion into a personal art form, so theres no point asking him for evidence of anything either, it would just be another demonstration of his confirmation bias.

Who does that leave to provide burden of proof ?
How about cancer doctors all over the world trying their hardest to cure cancer, surely the fact that none of them are using animated ash or anything like it answers the question as to its validity. Its a ridiculous question that doesn't require an answer anymore than my dog faeces claim, if you can't see that then you have some serious issues you need to address, remember now, you are taking the word of a man who was convicted of a fraudulent crime as if its worth something
It isn't

:rolleyes:

Thank you for your opinion, though I will respectfully disagree with just about everything you've said here.

I repeat for the last time, my honest question had nothing whatsoever to do with burden of proof, and I am tired of you failing miserably to understand my posts and completely missing the point so I will not respond to this same ridiculous accusation again.

I am not a Cayce believer, as I have made clear elsewhere and even earlier in this thread. A former believer, yes, but not now, so again you have written another rambling, overly emotional post, accusing me of taking the word of Cayce, which again is inaccurate, ridiculous and completely not the point anyway.

Just for the record and even though it's none of your business, I like Rodney. I may not often agree with him but there is something about him that I respect, and I enjoy his debates with Linda especially. So insult him as much as you want; I am not going to agree with you.

In a thread about Cayce, it is nice to have people with some background on Cayce to contribute, which is what we've had here. Perhaps some Cayce believers will find this thread and find it helpful - ignoring these last few posts, of course.

You are free to disagree with me obviously, but I am entitled to my opinion and your personal tirades against me are getting old and have added nothing of value to this thread.

I have done plenty of research on Cayce. I can critical think as well as the next person these days. I am not impressed by your attempts at drama by referring to Cayce as an ex-convict. Please stick to the facts and stop make wild assumptions and even wilder accusations.

Not once have I stooped to insulting you ("you must have some serious issues," etc.) as you have inappropriately done to me in quite a few posts here recently. And this is the last time I will respond to those types of personal insults.
 
Last edited:
Thank you for your opinion, though I will respectfully disagree with just about everything you've said here.

so you no longer believe that the A.R.E. lies to the public despite the evidence being in black and white earlier in the thread. And you don't think Rodney is self deluded and wilfuly ignorant. And you don't believe that Cayce was convicted of a fraudulent criminal offence. All that has already been proven true, so what is this now. lies from you, willfull ignorance, idiocy ???

that sir proves you are still brainwashed, its a pity that you think youre a critical thinker when you clearly aren't that just shows that you never will be.

Its people like you who enable organisations like the A.R.E. to continue to con people out of their health and their money, you have the intelligence to know better, yet for some reason you are incapable of making that final step into reality
shame on you
:mad:

I am tired of you failing miserably to understand my posts and completely missing the point so I will not respond to this same ridiculous accusation again.
And this is the last time I will respond to those types of personal insults.

bet you do, youve already proven how unreliable your conviction is, I don't see that claim of yours being any different. Go on prove yourself a liar
 
Last edited:
so you no longer believe that the A.R.E. lies to the public despite the evidence being in black and white earlier in the thread. And you don't think Rodney is self deluded and wilfuly ignorant. And you don't believe that Cayce was convicted of a fraudulent criminal offence. All that has already been proven true, so what is this now. lies from you, willfull ignorance, idiocy ???

that sir proves you are still brainwashed, its a pity that you think youre a critical thinker when you clearly aren't that just shows that you never will be.

Its people like you who enable organisations like the A.R.E. to continue to con people out of their health and their money
shame on you
:mad:

No, I would not say the A.R.E. lies to the public. Now, before you get all worked up and accuse me of being a rabid Cayce supporter as a result of not agreeing with your choice of wording, and even though I know you will not slow down long enough to read and understand this: My opinion is that the A.R.E. obviously stands to gain by finding/producing research to back up Cayce's claims and they will tend to be interested in publishing such research. As the A.R.E. is not a scientific organization and because they are biased and stand to gain from supporting Cayce, I would expect to have to verify any scientific data provided by the A.R.E. independently before I would take it too seriously.

No I do not think Rodney is self-deluded or willfully ignorant.

Yes, I know Cayce was convicted of a criminal offence. Sheesh, Marduk, this has in fact been discussed earlier in the thread. Now, who is being willfully ignorant?

I am not a sir, sir.

I do not support the A.R.E.

Thank you for at least refraining from the personal insults. Calm down, Marduk. You might want to read a little more slowly and think before you post.
 
Last edited:
Didn't waste any time did you
:rolleyes:

Except that I said, "This is the last time I will respond to those types of personal insults."

I did not say I would not respond to any more of your posts.

Nice try, though, Marduk.

ETA: Based on the immature and hostile nature of your posts to me at this point in this thread, on second thought, I will not respond to any more of your posts either. So consider any and all future insults ignored.
 
Last edited:
you did it twice now, or are you so used to people calling you a liar that you no longer see it as an insult
:p
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom