Has Edgar Cayce made any gross errors in prophecy?

We know that many individuals who turned to Cayce after the conventional medicine of his time had failed them or their child got better, and some of the improvements were dramatic. Now, your take on that seems to be that those cases were spontaneous recoveries. But can you document anything similar with the failed 9,997 out of 10,000 cancer treatments?

Yes. Surveys of individuals who have received treatments which are ineffective show satisfaction/improvement at rates which are similar to those reported for Cayce (we are hampered by not knowing the real satisfaction rate for Cayce, only that in half of his cases it was 85%).

http://nationalcenterforhomeopathy....atisfaction-and-improvement-with-homeopathy-0

Linda
 
Last edited:
ETA: Based on the immature and hostile nature of your posts to me at this point in this thread, on second thought, I will not respond to any more of your posts either. So consider any and all future insults ignored.

My hostile posts, you mean the ones where I pointed out that you were lying again
yes terrible reaction that isn't it, perhaps in future you should be more honest about the evidence you've been shown and it won't happen

so tell me again
Cayce wasn't convicted of a fraudulent criminal offence
The A.R.E. don't lie to the public
Rodney is not a total woo
and oh yes, eating wood needs to be peer reviewed as a cure for cancer before you realise its baloney

lol, I'm really not missing anything without your input, I would suggest you do everyone a favour and not post anywhere else either
:p
 
Last edited:
We know that many individuals who turned to Cayce after the conventional medicine of his time had failed them or their child got better, and some of the improvements were dramatic.
Yes. That's YOUR and other Cayce follower love to claim.

They make great stories. So?
Now, your take on that seems to be that those cases were spontaneous recoveries.
If they supposedly even happened as claimed and I have zero reason to take a miraculous claim by his followers seriously.
But can you document anything similar with the failed 9,997 out of 10,000 cancer treatments?
fls already provided a citation.
What cancers would you like to compare since each cancer has very different regression rates?

Oh wait...you have no idea what type of cancers these "cures" supposedly are directed at are you? Or did you not realize that "cancer" is not one disease.
 
lol, I'm really not missing anything without your input, I would suggest you do everyone a favour and not post anywhere else either
:p
Marduk, I would suggest that you... oh, never mind. it's not worth upsetting the mods.

Just because ExMinister's posts have not been helpful to you does not make her contributions here useless to others. Her communication with me, both here on the forum and elsewhere, have been very helpful to me in my StopSylvia.com efforts.

She has been trying in the past few years to really examine her beliefs, and has come a long way in doing so. Your insulting her and making her feel unwelcome here do nothing to help her, nor do they help further skepticism.
 
I had finished my comments Robert, would you really like me to continue ?

anyone supporting organisations like the A.R.E. or the ideals they represent or their supporters is as guilty of promoting fraud as someone promoting Sylvia
the A.R.E. makes Sylvia look like a saint
you should know better, .
:rolleyes:
 
I had finished my comments Robert, would you really like me to continue ?

anyone supporting organisations like the A.R.E. or the ideals they represent or their supporters is as guilty of promoting fraud as someone promoting Sylvia
the A.R.E. makes Sylvia look like a saint
you should know better, .
:rolleyes:
Marduk, I know almost nothing about Cayce or the A.R.E., but even assuming they are as bad as you say, here are two questions:

1) Where exactly is ExMinister "supporting" them? I have not read this entire thread, so perhaps I missed it.

2) Even if she was supporting them, how does it promote skepticism to tell her not to post in the forum any more? I would think you'd welcome the opportunity to reason with an A.R.E. supporter, in hopes of either changing their mind or those of lurking fence-sitters. i would certainly love to have Browne supporters posting here in support of her, as the resulting conversations would educate them, or those lurkers.
 
Marduk, I know almost nothing about Cayce or the A.R.E., but even assuming they are as bad as you say . . .
One of the reasons Marduk believes that the A.R.E. is a bad organization is that he claims that they distorted an October 9, 1910 New York Times article about Cayce. See http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=5704959&postcount=226

I invite everyone here to carefully examine the original NY Times article and the Cayce.com* reproduction of that article that are available in the above link, and tell me what was distorted. If you can, you will have done something Marduk has not been able to do.

* By the way, Cayce.com is not actually the A.R.E., but an organization that provides information about Cayce and products and remedies that are based on the Cayce readings.
 
* By the way, Cayce.com is not actually the A.R.E., but an organization that provides information about Cayce and products and remedies that are based on the Cayce readings.
In my eye that makes them irresponsible and unethical scum.
 
Yes. Surveys of individuals who have received treatments which are ineffective show satisfaction/improvement at rates which are similar to those reported for Cayce (we are hampered by not knowing the real satisfaction rate for Cayce, only that in half of his cases it was 85%).

http://nationalcenterforhomeopathy....atisfaction-and-improvement-with-homeopathy-0

Linda
Are you saying that homeopathic cancer remedies have been evaluated in controlled studies? Do you have any links?
 
For selling products that may or may not be effective?
Tsk tsk Rodney. Not only is it not tested to see if it is ineffective; it has not tested to be considered safe either.
How does that differ from drugstores selling cough medicine?
Cough medicines are safe and a few of them actually work. It all depends on the source of the cough. We actually pulled baby cough medicines because they don't work and can instead be harmful. But this of course is based on clinical studies. You know, the ethical and responsible thing to do.

And of course you'd like to equate the quackery of pushing Cayce cancer remedies with ineffective cough medicines; don't you?
 
Last edited:
Tsk tsk Rodney. Not only is it not tested to see if it is ineffective; it has not tested to be considered safe either.
If Cayce.com is selling an unsafe product, why doesn't the FDA order them to withdraw it from the marketplace?

Cough medicines are safe and a few of them actually work.
That's what I would call damning with faint praise. ;)

It all depends on the source of the cough. We actually pulled baby cough medicines because they don't work and can instead be harmful.
After many years on the market.

But this of course is based on clinical studies. You know, the ethical and responsible thing to do.
There's still a lot of doubt about the efficacy of cough medicine: "We want to believe these remedies will work because we’re so desperately uncomfortable when we’re sick,” says John E. Heffner, MD, a pulmonologist and immediate past president of the American Thoracic Society. “But clinical trials have not found that cough medicines are any better than a placebo.” See http://www.webmd.com/cold-and-flu/features/cough-medicine-should-you-shouldnt-you

And of course you'd like to equate the quackery of pushing Cayce cancer remedies with ineffective cough medicines; don't you?
I don't think the A.R.E. is pushing Cayce's cancer remedies -- they're simply providing information that an individual can use in consultation with his/her doctor.
 
If Cayce.com is selling an unsafe product, why doesn't the FDA order them to withdraw it from the marketplace?
Ah, the whole stupid "Lack of evidence" nonsense again?
It's not the responsibility of others to prove YOU wrong, it is YOUR responsibility to prove your claim to be right.

Selling untested garbage because you are too irresponsible to test it is the epitome of unethical and irresponsible scum.
That's what I would call damning with faint praise. ;)
Safe is a praise that some more responsible people actually care about.

I think most homeopathy garbage is safe but it is harmful in its own way and useless.
After many years on the market.
Yup. Science and evidence works that way. What about it?
There's still a lot of doubt about the efficacy of cough medicine: "We want to believe these remedies will work because we’re so desperately uncomfortable when we’re sick,” says John E. Heffner, MD, a pulmonologist and immediate past president of the American Thoracic Society. “But clinical trials have not found that cough medicines are any better than a placebo.” See http://www.webmd.com/cold-and-flu/features/cough-medicine-should-you-shouldnt-you
Yup. So?
Are you trying to say that Cayce's garbage is no better than placebo?
That's what I would call damning with faint praise.
I don't think the A.R.E. is pushing Cayce's cancer remedies -- they're simply providing information that an individual can use in consultation with his/her doctor.
And this is the most disgusting part about your mindset. The complete and utter contempt at taking responsibility for your actions. You sell something to the gullible that could harm them and like the other Cayce vermin, you refuse to take responsibility for the harm that you wreck. That is disgusting.
 
For selling products that may or may not be effective? How does that differ from drugstores selling cough medicine?
Rodney this is one of the most irresponsible things I've heard. Would you pick up something out of your yard and give it to a child to eat, unsure of what might happen?

What if a person claimed to be a prophet and told you as such?

I think this post of yours boils down the thread .... believing in Cayce's remedies/recommendations is based on FAITH, not FACT or even well collected evidence. Therefore it's a RISK.

Why are people's lives worth the risk to YOU? I'm not talking about the FDA or the practice of modern western medicine, etc and so forth. I'm asking why the risk is worth it to you in particular, and how far would you be willing to risk your own health based on a Cayce claim? And why?

The point is, if you're willing to place another person or even yourself at risk based on little evidence, you're operating on faith. So if you don't confuse the two concepts (faith and fact), it will probably save you a lot of time. You should push why people should have faith in Cayce, which is subjective, instead of trying to lean on disputable evidence and make it objective. It is no different than someone claiming God but relying on the bible as "proof". Do you see my point?
 
Last edited:
Hi all, I just popped in to check if anyone has given us an unambiguous example of Edgar Cayce ever being correct in any of his prophecies...

Anyone?

Could we maybe summarise for those of us who don't want to wade through the whole thread?

By prophecy I mean things other than the "medical treatments" he recommended. All that stuff about Oceans engulfing the USA or Atlantis rising from the deep, did he get anything right at all? Even just a lucky guess would be something...
 
Are you saying that homeopathic cancer remedies have been evaluated in controlled studies? Do you have any links?

Well, technically, any cancer trial involving a group given sugar pills would be a trial of homeopathy. I don't know of any controlled trials of homeopathic cancer remedies, but the effect of homeopathy in the treatment of cancer is no different from its effect in any other condition.

Linda
 
For selling products that may or may not be effective? How does that differ from drugstores selling cough medicine?

Cough medicines have demonstrated efficacy. Many have demonstrable effectiveness as well. A few have demonstrable effectiveness for the condition and in the population for which they are usually used, but under conditions where safety starts to be a concern.

Linda
 
If Cayce.com is selling an unsafe product, why doesn't the FDA order them to withdraw it from the marketplace?

Supplements are treated differently from pharmaceuticals when it comes to safety. It is much more difficult to remove unsafe supplements from the market than it is to remove unsafe pharmaceuticals. Most of the time, the information used to remove or place black box warnings on pharmaceuticals would be inadequate to lead to any action against a supplement.

There's still a lot of doubt about the efficacy of cough medicine: "We want to believe these remedies will work because we’re so desperately uncomfortable when we’re sick,” says John E. Heffner, MD, a pulmonologist and immediate past president of the American Thoracic Society. “But clinical trials have not found that cough medicines are any better than a placebo.” See http://www.webmd.com/cold-and-flu/features/cough-medicine-should-you-shouldnt-you

<shrug> It is always possible to find people who say something that isn't true. However, systematic reviews of the effectiveness of cough medicines have found that some are or may be better than placebo in the conditions for which they are used.

http://www2.cochrane.org/reviews/en/ab001831.html

Linda
 
Hi all, I just popped in to check if anyone has given us an unambiguous example of Edgar Cayce ever being correct in any of his prophecies...

Anyone?

Could we maybe summarise for those of us who don't want to wade through the whole thread?

By prophecy I mean things other than the "medical treatments" he recommended. All that stuff about Oceans engulfing the USA or Atlantis rising from the deep, did he get anything right at all? Even just a lucky guess would be something...
See summary of Cayce Reading 137-115 at http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=5693973&postcount=97
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom