Has Edgar Cayce made any gross errors in prophecy?

Hi all, I just popped in to check if anyone has given us an unambiguous example of Edgar Cayce ever being correct in any of his prophecies...

Anyone?

Could we maybe summarise for those of us who don't want to wade through the whole thread?

By prophecy I mean things other than the "medical treatments" he recommended. All that stuff about Oceans engulfing the USA or Atlantis rising from the deep, did he get anything right at all? Even just a lucky guess would be something...
Behold Atlantis risen:
2.jpg
 
Well, technically, any cancer trial involving a group given sugar pills would be a trial of homeopathy. I don't know of any controlled trials of homeopathic cancer remedies, but the effect of homeopathy in the treatment of cancer is no different from its effect in any other condition.

Linda
What I'm asking is, for alleged cancer treatments that were found not to work in controlled tests, what were the bases for the claims that they worked? I'm sure that there must have been a variety of bases, but I'm trying to understand why certain treatments are tested while others are not.
 
Supplements are treated differently from pharmaceuticals when it comes to safety. It is much more difficult to remove unsafe supplements from the market than it is to remove unsafe pharmaceuticals. Most of the time, the information used to remove or place black box warnings on pharmaceuticals would be inadequate to lead to any action against a supplement.
Considering that Cayce died more than 65 years ago and products that he recommended have been used by many people for more than 100 years, I would think that any unsafe products would have been identified by the FDA long ago.
 
What I'm asking is, for alleged cancer treatments that were found not to work in controlled tests, what were the bases for the claims that they worked? I'm sure that there must have been a variety of bases, but I'm trying to understand why certain treatments are tested while others are not.

I linked to the NCI fact sheet earlier, which describes the testing process starting with screening large numbers of substances with in vitro arrays.

The choice of substances to test includes those coming from ethnobotany and pharmaceutical companies as well as other collections. The process of ethnobotany looks like it identifies a group of plants which are more likely to have some pharmaceutical activity than an unselected group. It is estimated that the yield for anti-cancer agents may be as high as twice the yield from an otherwise unselected collection. However, if you look only at those plants which include any traditional use against any sort of cancer, you will lower the number found, as many important anti-cancer drugs did not have a traditional anti-cancer use.

If you try to turn it around and start with controlled trials of substances with a traditional use as an anti-cancer drug (and remember, some of that means that it was used to treat warts), the yield may be as high as 1 in 100, but it is likely to be much less (since you have many types of cancers to choose from).

So even if there was some history of use to fall back on for animated ash, the chance that it would work in any particular cancer is unlikely to even be as good as 1 in 100.

Linda
 
Considering that Cayce died more than 65 years ago and products that he recommended have been used by many people for more than 100 years, I would think that any unsafe products would have been identified by the FDA long ago.

Nope. Without an active reporting system and without investigation, many cases of harm will go undetected. People don't associate their kidney failure with the 'safe and natural' product they took for weight loss 6 months ago. Nor can the 'safe and natural' tea they drink daily be resonsible for their liver failure when they have be using it, without problem, for years. And even when that harm is detected, the FDA does not have the authority to remove the product or require warnings about the product that it has over pharmaceuticals.

Linda
 
Marduk, I know almost nothing about Cayce or the A.R.E., but even assuming they are as bad as you say, here are two questions:

1) Where exactly is ExMinister "supporting" them? I have not read this entire thread, so perhaps I missed it.

No, I would not say the A.R.E. lies to the public.
This after she has been given solid evidence of the A.R.E. lying to the public in order to enrich themselves

Now lets put that in terms you'll easily understand Robert
If someone made a public statement saying that Sylvia Browne does not lie to the public, would you say that was support or not ?

2) Even if she was supporting them, how does it promote skepticism to tell her not to post in the forum any more? I would think you'd welcome the opportunity to reason with an A.R.E. supporter, in hopes of either changing their mind or those of lurking fence-sitters. i would certainly love to have Browne supporters posting here in support of her, as the resulting conversations would educate them, or those lurkers.

Robert, Exminister stated she would not be responding to my insulting posts any more, when the posts she was referring to were not insulting in any way, at the same time she was saying my posts were
offensive
failing miserably
ridiculous
overly emotional
immature and hostile

Seems to me that she thinks the A.R.E. are an ok organisation, despite the fact that they are in effect an organisation that lies to protect the memory of a convicted criminal in order to make a profit and shes quite happy to insult me to keep that view and to publicise it on this forum.

I don't think when people are being willfully ignorant that they should be allowed to remain that way
do you
;)
 
Last edited:
Just for the record, I will list the personal insults Marduk claims not to have made:

clearly youre thinking processes are retarded for some reason
btw EM ignoring my posts makes you look dumb
:p

if you can't see that then you have some serious issues you need to address,
:rolleyes:

you did it twice now, or are you so used to people calling you a liar that you no longer see it as an insult
:p

My hostile posts, you mean the ones where I pointed out that you were lying again
yes terrible reaction that isn't it, perhaps in future you should be more honest about the evidence you've been shown and it won't happen

lol, I'm really not missing anything without your input, I would suggest you do everyone a favour and not post anywhere else either
:p

Also for the record, I do not consider Marduk to have proven the A.R.E. to be "lying." I explained my position on that to him. As I have repeatedly said, just because I find Marduk's evidence lacking does not mean I support the A.R.E. It means I find Marduk's evidence lacking.

Here is my position, as related in an above post to Marduk, on whether the A.R.E. is "lying:"

No, I would not say the A.R.E. lies to the public. Now, before you get all worked up and accuse me of being a rabid Cayce supporter as a result of not agreeing with your choice of wording, and even though I know you will not slow down long enough to read and understand this: My opinion is that the A.R.E. obviously stands to gain by finding/producing research to back up Cayce's claims and they will tend to be interested in publishing such research. As the A.R.E. is not a scientific organization and because they are biased and stand to gain from supporting Cayce, I would expect to have to verify any scientific data provided by the A.R.E. independently before I would take it too seriously.

I think that is a reasonable stance. Now, for the last time: I am not an A.R.E. supporter.
 
Also for the record, I do not consider Marduk to have proven the A.R.E. to be "lying." I explained my position on that to him. As I have repeatedly said, just because I find Marduk's evidence lacking does not mean I support the A.R.E. It means I find Marduk's evidence lacking.

How can you possibly say that
heres a few examples
http://www.bibliotecapleyades.net/ciencia/ciencia_adn05.htm
Written by Greg Little the head of the A.R.E.'s search for Atlantis in the Bahamas project, which is their highest profile project
The Atlantean Haplogroup may be X

Perhaps the most astonishing confirmation of Cayce’s story of ancient America is the presence of haplogroup X. What is known is that the X haplogroup first showed up in America perhaps 34,000 years ago, but its main entry occurred in 10,000 B.C.
From wiki
The Solutrean Hypothesis postulates that haplogroup X reached North America with a wave of European migration about 20,000 BP by the Solutreans
This is the currently accepted paradigm for Haplogroup X entering America. that it did so around 20,000bce, not 34,000 years ago as Little claims. Shall we guess why hes claiming that, he goes on
These dates match Cayce’s timeframe for Atlantean migrations as well as the occurrence of X in the specific tribes predicted by his statements. The X group also appears to have shown up in ancient Iberia and in the Basques about the same time as well as in the Gobi.
from wiki
Sub-group X2 appears to have undergone extensive population expansion and dispersal around or soon after the last glacial maximum, about 21,000 years ago. It is more strongly present in the Near East, the Caucasus, and Mediterranean Europe
So It arrives in Europe around 21,000 years ago, not 34,000 as Little claims. Can you guess why Little is saying that yet. He states

These dates match Cayce’s story of the final two destructions of Atlantis and the resulting migrations to these areas.

So what hes done there is lied about the dates of Haplogroup X global expansion in order to make it fit Cayces claims for the sinking of Atlantis
Now correct me if I am wrong EM, but Greg Little is a member of the A.R.E.
He makes public statements on behalf of the A.R.E.
so the A.R.E. publically lies to enrich themselves don't they
They frequently lie about genetic evidence for two reasons
1. because its totally destroys all of Cayces claims for Atlantis and would damage his credibility and their profits
2. because they know that most people don't know enough about genetics to tell when theyre being lied to, in essence they milk the gullible and the uneducated.

I could show you text after text filled with lies told by the A.R.E. it seems to be endemic with their brand of woo

is this really surprising when really this is an organisation based on the claims of a convicted fraudulent criminal (accurate description of Edgar Cayce which you objected to)
I'm not surprised, what surprises me is that you have gone on record to claim that they don't lie to the public, which in light of this evidence makes what you said at best wrong and at worst another lie doesn't it,

so are you going to deny that the A.R.E. lies to the public now like you did earlier ?
because that would be just another lie wouldn't it
why don't you just admit it, you were wrong to join this organisation and fund their lies to the public, having to admit that they were lying the whole time would show very clearly that you were one of the gullible people taken in, so your claim that they werent lying was told for the sole reason of a face saving exercise on your part
and quite frankly thats disgusting. its just the same as giving your full support to Sylvia Browne when you found out she was lying, and you did that too for a while didnt you
:(

now in light of this you should go back and read my posts which you said were insulting, you'll find that theyre not insults, theyre accurate descriptions of your behaviour
 
Last edited:
I linked to the NCI fact sheet earlier, which describes the testing process starting with screening large numbers of substances with in vitro arrays.

The choice of substances to test includes those coming from ethnobotany and pharmaceutical companies as well as other collections. The process of ethnobotany looks like it identifies a group of plants which are more likely to have some pharmaceutical activity than an unselected group. It is estimated that the yield for anti-cancer agents may be as high as twice the yield from an otherwise unselected collection. However, if you look only at those plants which include any traditional use against any sort of cancer, you will lower the number found, as many important anti-cancer drugs did not have a traditional anti-cancer use.

If you try to turn it around and start with controlled trials of substances with a traditional use as an anti-cancer drug (and remember, some of that means that it was used to treat warts), the yield may be as high as 1 in 100, but it is likely to be much less (since you have many types of cancers to choose from).

So even if there was some history of use to fall back on for animated ash, the chance that it would work in any particular cancer is unlikely to even be as good as 1 in 100.

Linda
Thanks very much for the information, but I disagree that the chance that animated ash would work for at least lung cancer (the reading quoted on the A.R.E. website pertained to lung cancer) is as remote as your statistics would dictate. Why? Because (a) Cayce operated in a unique manner and many reputable individuals -- including medical doctors -- attested to his success rate; and (b) None of his treatments have been subject to controlled tests, and so you have no basis to assign a probability with respect to those treatments.

Now, if there were many individuals who operated in the same manner as Cayce (including similar testimonials to their success rates) and dozens of their treatments had been tested without success, I would agree with you. But there is no such baseline. So, perhaps none of Cayce's treatments will prove efficacious, but perhaps all of them will. We just don't know.
 
Nope. Without an active reporting system and without investigation, many cases of harm will go undetected. People don't associate their kidney failure with the 'safe and natural' product they took for weight loss 6 months ago. Nor can the 'safe and natural' tea they drink daily be resonsible for their liver failure when they have be using it, without problem, for years. And even when that harm is detected, the FDA does not have the authority to remove the product or require warnings about the product that it has over pharmaceuticals.

Linda
What I think you're missing is that skeptics have been casting a wary eye at Cayce's treatments for more than 100 years. Skeptics of his era, not to mention folks like Martin Gardner, Robert Carroll, Joe Nickell, and Randi, would give their right arm to show that even one of Cayce's treatments has caused harm. Instead, all they can say is: "What a weird treatment, any fool knows that wouldn't work."
 
What I think you're missing is that skeptics have been casting a wary eye at Cayce's treatments for more than 100 years.
What I think you're missing, deliberately or otherwise is that Edgar Cayce was a convicted criminal, his organisation the A.R.E was organised to enable him to manipulate a loophole in the law and that since then the A.R.E. has lied about pretty much everything that they then spoonfeed to their followers who are on the whole gullible and uneducated sheep.

Raw wood does not cure cancer, neither does a UV sun lamp, however if someone were to think it did convinced by the dishonest practices of the A.R.E. then their neglect of a proper treatment would kill them.

You by not realising that youve been conned are enabling this dishonest organisation to continue lying to people as you are in effect funding them

Your subscription money is being used to spread lies, I hope that makes you feel really proud of yourself Rodney, because everyone else whos posted in this thread but you knows that the A.R.E. and what they preach is utter bs, youre not the one voice crying out in the wilderness here, but the lone nut desperate to prove his erroneous beliefs are valid amongst a sea of critical thinkers who do actually know better.
:p

EM decided not to comment did you, theres a surprise
:rolleyes:
 

That's it? Out of all of the hundreds (thousands?) of readings this modern day prophet made in the decades that he was active, that was the best example you could find? OK let's look at it:
Try this reading on for size. It was given for the same stockbroker on March 5, 1929. The stockbroker stated that he had a dream about a bull following his wife, and he "got the impression regarding the market that we ought to sell everything, including the box stock."
Who had the prophetic dream? Was it Cayce? No, it was a Stockbroker. The Stockbroker also gave his own interpretation. "SELL, SELL, SELL!!!" OK. Not looking too good for your mate Edgar...
Cayce's interpretation: " . . . a warning as respecting an individual account - which would mean not only this special individual but many others - and that their accounts during this turmoil as will come by these many changes, as will be seen in a downward movement of a long duration, gradually sliding off, with fitful conditions of sudden rises and drops - that the body must be mindful of how individuals' accounts are taken care of from day to day. Not allowing, then, those that apparently even are VERY safe, too much latitude. As to the activities of self, as is indicated in the impression that the body should dispose of all those held - even those in box - would signify the great amount of change as would come." (Reading 137-115)

Then Cayce agrees with the stockbroker that he should sell everything including the box stock.

How in the name of the seven green pygmies of justice can you see this kind of thing as special, paranormal or prophetic? Did he warn anybody else about the approaching stock market crash and global depression? Just this one guy? This one guy who actually already saw the writing on the wall and was thinking of selling up anyway?

That's pathetic, not prophetic.
 
Has Edgar Cayce made any gross errors in prophecy?

:D

"As a prophet, Cayce was a catastrophic failure. For instance, he prophesied that during the early portion of a forty-year span (1958-98) a tilting of the Earth’s axis would produce drastic physical alterations of our planet. “The earth will be broken up in the western portion of America. The greater portion of Japan must go into the sea,” etc. (Stern, 1967, p. 37). Cayce’s apologists claim that he predicted World War II. And yet, Jess Stern, who did more to popularize Cayce than any other writer, wrote: “Edgar Cayce was as stunned as anybody else when the bombs dropped on Pearl Harbor” (1967, p. 16)."
http://www.apologeticspress.org/articles/279


"Outside his private "psychic" practice, Edgar Cayce was notorious for many tabloid press predictions such as California falling into the Pacific, New York City being destroyed by some sort of disaster, and the secret of Atlantis and its great energy crystal being unveiled by the U.S. government. His followers maintain that he had prophecy successes too, including the Great Depression and the Lindbergh kidnapping, but those are suspect at best."
http://www.allaboutcults.org/edgar-cayce.htm


"Many doubt Cayce's claims, noting times when his predictions proved inaccurate. He predicted that 1933 would be a good year, when in fact it was the very year that the Great Depression got under way in earnest, and that China convert to Christianity by 1968. He and a dowser once went searching buried treasure on the seashore, finding nothing. Psychic believers defended him, saying treasure had been buried there before and dug up, or it would be buried there in the future.

Cayce's monumental failure to help locate the kidnapped son of aviator Charles Lindbergh was never publicised by the metaphysical or New Age communities, but it was well known to police investigators.
[...]

He failed to heal his own wife and infant son; both died.

Another failed prophecy of Cayce was his catastrophic readings regarding massive earthquakes, flood-ins and other calamitious natural phenomena which were to affect eastern US and Japan in particular. By the year 2000, Cayce predicted, the ocean would invade North America as far as Idaho and Kansas, leaving a trail of islands to the west. He also said US scientists would discover a death ray from Atlantis in 1958."

http://www.indopedia.org/Edgar_Cayce.html
 
What I think you're missing is that skeptics have been casting a wary eye at Cayce's treatments for more than 100 years.


How much research into Cayce's treatments has the "Association for Research and Enlightenment" conducted in the 79 years since its foundation? Has it published any results showing that they work?
 
How much research into Cayce's treatments has the "Association for Research and Enlightenment" conducted in the 79 years since its foundation? Has it published any results showing that they work?

Obviously you have that backwards, A.R.E. haven't published anything that shows that the treatments don't work; Therefore they do.

Step right up folks, everyone's a winner!
 
Thanks very much for the information, but I disagree that the chance that animated ash would work for at least lung cancer (the reading quoted on the A.R.E. website pertained to lung cancer) is as remote as your statistics would dictate. Why? Because (a) Cayce operated in a unique manner and many reputable individuals -- including medical doctors -- attested to his success rate; and (b) None of his treatments have been subject to controlled tests, and so you have no basis to assign a probability with respect to those treatments.

Now, if there were many individuals who operated in the same manner as Cayce (including similar testimonials to their success rates) and dozens of their treatments had been tested without success, I would agree with you. But there is no such baseline. So, perhaps none of Cayce's treatments will prove efficacious, but perhaps all of them will. We just don't know.

That was why I spoke of traditional use. Of course, your claim that medical doctors attested to his success is unsupported, but let's pretend for a moment that it's true. This is the same basis for the claims made for traditional uses - reputable individuals including medical doctors attesting to success in the absence of controlled tests. And as I said, the success rate under those conditions may be as high as 1 in 100. But if you're talking about a specific cancer, then it is likely to be much lower, since the 1 in 100 in many cases will be referring to the successful treatment of warts or other skin growths.

As you have pointed out many times, we have no additional information which would allow us to alter that probability.

Linda
 
What I think you're missing is that skeptics have been casting a wary eye at Cayce's treatments for more than 100 years. Skeptics of his era, not to mention folks like Martin Gardner, Robert Carroll, Joe Nickell, and Randi, would give their right arm to show that even one of Cayce's treatments has caused harm. Instead, all they can say is: "What a weird treatment, any fool knows that wouldn't work."

So what? None of the relevant information was collected or made available. In most cases of harm (other than fairly obvious poisonings), discovery requires the careful collection of information and access to that information, neither of which was the case for Cayce's cases.

Linda
 
So what? None of the relevant information was collected or made available. In most cases of harm (other than fairly obvious poisonings), discovery requires the careful collection of information and access to that information, neither of which was the case for Cayce's cases.

Linda
Case in point is dastardly Vioxx. Using Rodney's backward "logic" the harm of Vioxx would've been indistiguishable from the background rate of heart attacks and its users would've been very happy with the pain relief while taking the medicine.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom