Gold will go $1,500/oz

Hardly. I'm a professional academic and researcher;

You are? Do you call your students stupid wingnuts to their face or behind their back as you attempt to teach them? Or do you just do research and not teach?


If you're going to suggest that everyone in the world is doing something wrong, you better be prepared to back that up with hard evidence.

What specifically are you referring to here - central planners and Bernanke's actions or investment strategies of others?

We never had anything to "discuss"; you don't know enough to "discuss" this issue.

Ah ... I see. ...

On the other hand, this is an educational forum, and I'm happy to educate you in anything you're willing to learn. Failing that -- because you're demonstrably unwilling to learn even the fundamentals of investments -- I'm happy to use you as an object lesson for the benefit of the rest of the readership of the forum.

Yes - you've definitely impressed me with your academic wisdom - especially with your profoundly advanced vocabulary.

I call you out on your advocacy of gold not because your opinion differs from mine but because your opinion is objectively wrong. Anyone who wants can go look at the charts of gold's return and how it correlates to inflation; I think the actual number is 0.08 or thereabouts, effectively zero -- no inflation hedge at all. If you want an inflation hedge, buy TIPS bonds, buy commodities, or buy foreign currencies, any of which actually work as inflation hedges.

You must not be a mathematics professor I take it.
 
To be fair, the opinion that inflation is likely to be a problem in the future is an opinion, albeit a misguided one. It's certainly true that Bernanke is (correctly) trying to address the problem of too-low inflation, a problem that if addressed will by definition result in more inflation. If he misses and overshoots, the result could be something akin to hyperinflation.

And, of course, the moon could suddenly turn into a giant fruitbat and fly away. "Difficult to see. Always in motion is the future."

But the statement that gold is a good inflation hedge is a factual claim, and simply a wrong one.

$600 billion is A LOT of money...unless you happen to live in a $14 trillion economy.

It just baffles me that anyone could even remotely consider hyper-inflation right now.
 
As far as investment strategies, the following may help if there really is inflation.

Hint 1: If the Price of “stuff” is going up invest in companies that sell “stuff”, preferably ones that have lower marginal/higher fixed costs and have already spent the money for their fixed costs.

Hint 2: Inflation is bad for lenders but good for borrowers so lending or investing in companies that lend may not be a good idea. Companies that borrow up front to build/acquire a profitable asset may see the value of their debt decrease relative to the value of their earnings.

Hint 3: if the USD is falling, then investments in companies outside the US goes up, as does the profits of US companies with significant earnings outside the US.

No arguments from me that those are all good areas to consider.
 
$600 billion is A LOT of money...unless you happen to live in a $14 trillion economy.

It just baffles me that anyone could even remotely consider hyper-inflation right now.

Do you think QE2 is the last attempt by Bernanke? Or will Bernanke do QE3, QE4, and on and on until he succeeds?
 
I remember years ago hearing about a stock-market scan called "pump and dump" where various talking heads on TV would hype a stock they own, causing a small but noticeable price increase, then they would sell their holdings and profit from it.

The gold business right now smells like a pump and dump operation to me.

Agreed. Boiler Room is a decent movie about this phenomenon.
 
Do you think QE2 is the last attempt by Bernanke? Or will Bernanke do QE3, QE4, and on and on until he succeeds?

I hope he does more, but I doubt he will.

The stimulus was a decent response to the facts as we knew them at the time. When we learned more, we should have done stimulus B, and C, and D, if necessary, but absurd know-nothings shut down the process.

Bernanke's QE will make little difference and chances are he'll never do another one.

Although, one caveat is that the Fed can operate with more impunity as they're not as directly affected by political pressure.

The point, however, is that no matter how many QE's we get, we won't approach hyper-inflation.

It's interesting to me that not a single "fire-in-Noah's-Flood" inflation fear-mongerer has remotely attempted to justify their position based on the historical challenges I presented. Here's one of them again, I'm curious to hear your answer:

The United States of America is currently one of the safest investments in the world, which is why 10-year rates are so low. Find a single nation that has entered hyper-inflation immediately after being the safest investment in the world without an intervening war or similarly destructive disaster.
 
To be fair, the opinion that inflation is likely to be a problem in the future is an opinion, albeit a misguided one. It's certainly true that Bernanke is (correctly) trying to address the problem of too-low inflation, a problem that if addressed will by definition result in more inflation. If he misses and overshoots, the result could be something akin to hyperinflation.

ACS didn’t seem to be discussing the possibility of the Fed overshooting, rather he seemed to be making the straightforward claim that the Fed was trying to create inflation and this is bad. Another problem is that ACS hasn’t really differentiated between inflation and hyperinflation so it seems he is trying to say the Fed is trying to create high/hyper inflation which would make the “inflation is bad” claim more reasonable but the Fed trying to create hyper-inflation doesn’t really fall into the realm of something we can reasonably call opinion.
 
Do you think QE2 is the last attempt by Bernanke? Or will Bernanke do QE3, QE4, and on and on until he succeeds?

You may see QE3 if there is still danger of deflation after QE2, likewise you may see QE4 if there is still danger of deflation after QE3. Either would indicate that QE not only didn’t produce hyperinflation they didn’t even produce normal inflation.

More likely, however, would be the conclusion that the fed is pushing on a string and other alternative may need to be explored to fight deflation. Ideally this would involve fiscal policy, but with Republicans controlling the house this may not be an option and the Fed may need to look at something else. The other day I heard the suggestion they bypass the banks and buy corporate bonds directly, but this seems to be fraught with complaints of market intervention and favouritism. It may even open up scamming possibilities if someone finds out which bonds the Fed is buying.
 
I call you out on your advocacy of gold not because your opinion differs from mine but because your opinion is objectively wrong. Anyone who wants can go look at the charts of gold's return and how it correlates to inflation; I think the actual number is 0.08 or thereabouts, effectively zero -- no inflation hedge at all.

....

But the statement that gold is a good inflation hedge is a factual claim, and simply a wrong one.

Just did some quick and dirty numbers (and rounded up at that). A person buying a single 1 troy oz. gold bullion round every January from 1975 until this year would have spent around $14700 total. Adjusted for inflation (using the governments calculator) those gold coins would need to be worth $24126.56 to have kept pace with inflation. At a market value of $1355 those coins would actually be $48780.

But since everyone seems to like to pick 1980 as the data point (Gold's height at that time). If a person buys a single coin every January starting in 1980 they would have spent $13855. The coins would need to be worth $21136.43 to have kept pace with inflation. At a market value of $1355 those coins would be worth $42005.

So explain to me how that's not a hedge against inflation again?
 
You may see QE3 if there is still danger of deflation after QE2, likewise you may see QE4 if there is still danger of deflation after QE3. Either would indicate that QE not only didn’t produce hyperinflation they didn’t even produce normal inflation.

More likely, however, would be the conclusion that the fed is pushing on a string and other alternative may need to be explored to fight deflation. Ideally this would involve fiscal policy, but with Republicans controlling the house this may not be an option and the Fed may need to look at something else. The other day I heard the suggestion they bypass the banks and buy corporate bonds directly, but this seems to be fraught with complaints of market intervention and favouritism. It may even open up scamming possibilities if someone finds out which bonds the Fed is buying.

They should just give me $1 million free and clear. I'd be productive with it and stimulate the economy! :)
 
ACS didn’t seem to be discussing the possibility of the Fed overshooting, rather he seemed to be making the straightforward claim that the Fed was trying to create inflation and this is bad. Another problem is that ACS hasn’t really differentiated between inflation and hyperinflation so it seems he is trying to say the Fed is trying to create high/hyper inflation which would make the “inflation is bad” claim more reasonable but the Fed trying to create hyper-inflation doesn’t really fall into the realm of something we can reasonably call opinion.

I think their intentions are to create low inflation in the 3-4% area. I don't think they'll contain it at that level once they succeed. I don't have a guess at the level - just that it won't be what they're aiming for. One way or another ...

So - what's everyone's investment strategy if they faily miserably and we have 20 years of deflation?
 
So - what's everyone's investment strategy if they faily miserably and we have 20 years of deflation?

Do you want my honest opinion on this?

If the US goes into a cycle like Japan I would either refocus my business on the new markets that are doing well and/or possibly move to another country to do business.

Keep in mind my company does business globally anyway so the dollar dropping means that we get more dollars per unit shipped overseas anyway. We are already trying to exploit the new markets opening in China/Korea etc. A weaker dollar just makes my local employees cheaper which is a good thing for our economy.
 
That is assuming someone made a single purchase at the gold last height in 1980. If they also bought at lower amounts dollar cost averaging would make the return alot higher.

Buying a single 1 oz. coin at $800 plus four 1 oz. coins at $250 = $1800 / 5 = $360 / coin.

It's neat people here like to pick single data points to make some sort of hypothetical situation point, but I've yet to come across (in my little neck of the world and cyber space) people buying gold the way it's being described here in order to argue against it.

Are there people out there who do as described - of course - usually in a panic - not when they've got some sort of plan.

I won't be mean to you like drkitten is but I have to ask you something. Aren't you telling people they ought to buy gold right now? You aren't giggling to yourself about how your auctioned off your property in 2000 and just got a 13% to 14% annual return last week by selling your shiny treasure trove.

That means you have to use today's price and not the one you just found out gave a pretty good ten-year return.

If you don't like a 1980 data point then pick one that you do like. For almost any long term, an index as uncomplicated as the DJIA offers a better return and lower volatility than gold does. You might be asking why I used such an easy target as the DJIA because most equities investors are diversified into non-USA securities that have had much better returns in the past ten years.
 
I won't be mean to you like drkitten is but I have to ask you something. Aren't you telling people they ought to buy gold right now?

No.

You aren't giggling to yourself about how your auctioned off your property in 2000 and just got a 13% to 14% annual return last week by selling your shiny treasure trove.

I think you might confusing me with someone else.

That means you have to use today's price and not the one you just found out gave a pretty good ten-year return.

Today's closing price was $1357.

If you don't like a 1980 data point then pick one that you do like. For almost any long term, an index as uncomplicated as the DJIA offers a better return and lower volatility than gold does.

The argument drkitten put forth is that gold is not good at all as a hedge against inflation - that it's virtually zero. The numbers (whether you start in 1975 or at it's last height in 1980) show differently.

You might be asking why I used such an easy target as the DJIA because most equities investors are diversified into non-USA securities that have had much better returns in the past ten years.

OK - let's take the last ten years. Buying a 1 oz. gold coin every January for the past 10 years would have cost you about $6035. For it to keep pace with inflation those 10 coins would need to be now worht $6537.87. Those 10 coins at the current price are worth $14905. You've more than doubled your money and by far outpaced inflation.

So - how is gold not being a hedge against inflation?
 
OK - let's take the last ten years. Buying a 1 oz. gold coin every January for the past 10 years would have cost you about $6035. For it to keep pace with inflation those 10 coins would need to be now worht $6537.87. Those 10 coins at the current price are worth $14905. You've more than doubled your money and by far outpaced inflation.

So - how is gold not being a hedge against inflation?

Because something being in a bubble is not the same as it being an inflation hedge. Especially when the bubble is correlated with a lack of inflation.

What you want from an inflation hedge is something that rises in price when inflation rises and drops in price when inflation drops; that's exactly what gold hasn't been doing (which is why the correlation between gold price and inflation is so low).

You're also cherry-picking your exit date. Yes, we all acknowledge that gold prices are high right now, which means any investment strategy that involved buying gold some time ago and selling it today would have been a good strategy. I could make the same statement, of course, about any investment that's reaching a multi-year high, but that doesn't mean that that investment is a good inflation hedge in general or a good investment going forward. By your criteria, tulip bulbs would have been a great inflation hedge in 1636.
 
Nice link here. Despite all the teeth gnashing actual market indicators say that inflation risk is the lowest in decades and that this risk will remain low for many years to come.

http://finance.yahoo.com/banking-bu...-budgeting&sec=topStories&pos=9&asset=&ccode=

Here's a nice chart with a comparison to the CPI-U.

http://investing.mattters.com/2010/10/26/chart-of-the-week-inflation-in-the-real-world

the-real-cost-of-living-27-october-2010.JPG
 
And once again, ACS discovers that if you ignore all the prices that have gone down, prices have risen.

A link to a chart of all those necessities of life which have gone down would have been better than a purile comment. Got a chart like that?
 
Because something being in a bubble is not the same as it being an inflation hedge. Especially when the bubble is correlated with a lack of inflation.

What you want from an inflation hedge is something that rises in price when inflation rises and drops in price when inflation drops; that's exactly what gold hasn't been doing (which is why the correlation between gold price and inflation is so low).

You're also cherry-picking your exit date. Yes, we all acknowledge that gold prices are high right now, which means any investment strategy that involved buying gold some time ago and selling it today would have been a good strategy. I could make the same statement, of course, about any investment that's reaching a multi-year high, but that doesn't mean that that investment is a good inflation hedge in general or a good investment going forward. By your criteria, tulip bulbs would have been a great inflation hedge in 1636.

Very observant of you - If you buy high and sell low - that's a sure way to lose money. I'd advise against doing that.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom