Gold will go $1,500/oz

Really? That's the best I can do? You wouldn't think I was an idiot and suggest that there's a perfectly functional train? Or a bus? Or even renting a car? No, the only alternative if I don't like planes must be a flock of seagulls.

I think I'd prefer four Beatles
 
I hope he does more, but I doubt he will.

The stimulus was a decent response to the facts as we knew them at the time. When we learned more, we should have done stimulus B, and C, and D, if necessary, but absurd know-nothings shut down the process.

How much QE (inflation tax), in your expert opinion, will fix everything? And who gets to spend the money?

Bernanke's QE will make little difference and chances are he'll never do another one.

Really? Open market operations where the Fed buys government debt is synonymous with quantitative easing. It's been going on for a long time, and will continue for a long time to come as long as the Fed exists. The only thing that is likely to increase in the future, is the scope, as our tax base shrinks and our foreign credit dries up. On what basis do you think it won't happen again?

Although, one caveat is that the Fed can operate with more impunity as they're not as directly affected by political pressure.

The point, however, is that no matter how many QE's we get, we won't approach hyper-inflation.

So, the Fed gets to manufacture as many hundreds of billions as it wants to reward it's cronies at Goldman and other government/bank insiders, they aren't subject to political pressure or any real accountability, but according to you they're unlikely to do it again. Wanna bet?

The issue isn't really about whether we will or won't have hyperinflation, it's about the unfairness and regressive nature of any monetary inflation at all.

It's interesting to me that not a single "fire-in-Noah's-Flood" inflation fear-mongerer has remotely attempted to justify their position based on the historical challenges I presented. Here's one of them again, I'm curious to hear your answer:

The United States of America is currently one of the safest investments in the world, which is why 10-year rates are so low. Find a single nation that has entered hyper-inflation immediately after being the safest investment in the world without an intervening war or similarly destructive disaster.

If you hadn't noticed, the central bank is creating boat-loads of money so as to subsidize bond investors and manipulate the interest rate lower. So the US is either one of the safest investments in the world, or US Treasuries are in a bubble of unimaginable scale. I'd bet on the latter.

Incidentally, war is not an unlikely outcome for defaulting or inflating our way out of debt.
 
Not in the slightest. Whether you expect inflation or not, gold is simply a lousy investment. If you don't expect inflation, there are better investments out there. If you do expect inflation, there are still better investments out there.

By analogy, it really comes down to this:

ACS has faith in airplane pilots, so he's willing to get on a plane to go somewhere. I don't have faith in airplane pilots, so instead, I'm going to go from Washington, DC to Chicago next week by strapping a thousand seagulls to my body.

Really? That's the best I can do? You wouldn't think I was an idiot and suggest that there's a perfectly functional train? Or a bus? Or even renting a car? No, the only alternative if I don't like planes must be a flock of seagulls.

If you think that Bernanke is going to manage to produce hyperinflation, buy JNJ. Regardless of the dollar price of toothpaste and toilet paper, people will still need to buy them, and so JNJ will still make money for you. Or buy TIPS bonds. Or buy euro-denominated investments.

Any investment that- legally- gives a 400% return over ten years is not a lousy investment.
 
Any investment that- legally- gives a 400% return over ten years is not a lousy investment.

Provided that you buy it and sell it at exactly the right times, sure.

I suppose you could also say that buying a lottery ticket is a good investment, provided that you pick the right numbers.
 
This guy doesn't seem to think it's a hedge against inflation, either.

That's because it isn't. Gold is a hedge against negative real interest rates, and it is a stable money that forms the bottom of Exeter's pyramid.
 
Provided that you buy it and sell it at exactly the right times, sure.

I suppose you could also say that buying a lottery ticket is a good investment, provided that you pick the right numbers.

People that bought lottery tickets over the past decade did not fare any better than people who did not, with a few notable exceptions. People who bought PM's during the last decade have fared much better than people who invested in the stock market.
 
That's because it isn't. Gold is a hedge against negative real interest rates,..........

I can't quibble with your definitions, but is this a distinction without a difference as far as the layman is concerned?
 
I can't quibble with your definitions, but is this a distinction without a difference as far as the layman is concerned?

No, because monetary inflation and negative real interest rates are two distinctly different things. The latter is usually a consequence of the former, when it results in asset bubbles. Neither has their been much of a correlation between gold prices and government inflation indices historically:

The "Real" Reason It's Still Too Early to Bet Against Gold
 
I can't quibble with your definitions, but is this a distinction without a difference as far as the layman is concerned?

Tippet has his own personal definition for inflation that make it pretty much impossible to hold a discussion with him on the topic. Essentially he considered inflation to be something different then rising prices...
 
My dad likes to buy lots of gold so that he has lots of money when the dollar collapses or something. What should I do? :confused:
 
You know, Krugman's blog is one of the first ones I check every morning. It's amazing how often he's dealing with the same nonsensical claims we find ourselves arguing against here:
what you often see among hard-money types is a sort of Lives of the Saints approach to history: they’ve got their iconic examples (Weimar Germany! Zimbabwe!) which they pull out on every occasion, while remaining utterly ignorant of all the examples that go the other way.

And no, it’s not symmetric: people like me have heard about hyperinflation, while people like Ryan apparently have never heard about post-crisis Korea or Argentina.
http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/11/24/devaluing-history/

QEII PANIC, PANIC!!! PILE UP THE GOLD.

But wait:

The truth is that every recovery from financial crisis I know of since World War II was driven by currency depreciation.

This is why early in the thread I challenged people to come up with better examples than Weimar Germany! Zimbabwe! Of course, no one remotely tried to take the historical challenge, for obvious reasons.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom