A Christian Sceptic
Master Poster
- Joined
- Dec 7, 2007
- Messages
- 2,288
Which would you rather have, 3000 tins of beans or an ounce of gold?
Both - plus some chickens.
Which would you rather have, 3000 tins of beans or an ounce of gold?
Beats me - but because gold is global and if the right sort of panic happens it could be even higher. Now throw in speculators from all different countries - mix in a dash of various Central Banks - toss in a hedge fund or two and who knows?
Then how do you justify your exuberance?
Anyway I picked up some more equities today including BZ and CAT.
It really comes down to this:
drkitten has faith in Bernanke. So drkitten doesn't feel like the Federal Reserve Notes are at risk. drkitten is confident drkitten's investment strategy will more then compensate for the intentional devaluation of the Federal Reserve Notes.
I don't have faith in Bernanke nor the other Central Planners.
Well, thanks for the vote of confidence....
Then how do you justify your exuberance?
Anyway I picked up some more equities today including BZ and CAT.
If you think that Bernanke is going to manage to produce hyperinflation, buy JNJ. Regardless of the dollar price of toothpaste and toilet paper, people will still need to buy them, and so JNJ will still make money for you. Or buy TIPS bonds. Or buy euro-denominated investments.
Not in the slightest. Whether you expect inflation or not, gold is simply a lousy investment. If you don't expect inflation, there are better investments out there. If you do expect inflation, there are still better investments out there.Originally Posted by A Christian Sceptic
It really comes down to this:
drkitten has faith in Bernanke. So drkitten doesn't feel like the Federal Reserve Notes are at risk. drkitten is confident drkitten's investment strategy will more then compensate for the intentional devaluation of the Federal Reserve Notes.
I don't have faith in Bernanke nor the other Central Planners.
Why not wait till it goes to $800 buy it then and wait for it to hit $1300 again? Instead of buying at what might be a peak?
![]()
When the gold goes back to that price, it more likely will go lower and stay low for a long time.
Do you think Bernanke will succeed in creation inflation as he intends?
Do you think he'll be able to get that inflation under control?
Do you think your current investment strategy is protecting your wealth (or will protect your wealth) from Bernanke?
When the gold goes back to that price, it more likely will go lower and stay low for a long time. So there is still chance to make some money on gold for that gold rushing. ($1,500 to $2,000)
I think Gold will be pushed up to $2,000/oz, $1,500 at least, before it falls back to $800. Now it's a chance to buy some at the level of $1,300. Of course, before the crazy booming, there will be a blitze short period of falling to below $1,000, that's a technique to kill the small speculator follower.
No, I think that bringing the economy back on track will require legislative as well as monetary policy, and I think we're in for a repeat of 1937, where the newly elected conservatives derail the ongoing recovery.
I believe that if he manages to get inflation up to reasonable levels, it will remain there and not go to hyperinflationary levels. No sensible person expects hyperinflation.
Of course, or I wouldn't be using it. But even if I had different expectations, I wouldn't be in gold. If I did expect hyperinflation, I'd be in TIPS bonds instead of speculative equities.
Because gold is a lousy hedge against inflation.
That's the real problem that you're not understanding. The fact that I don't like venison is not the reason I'm telling you that going deer hunting with a fishing rod is a silly idea. If your goal is to hedge your portfolio against a lost of purchasing power due to inflation, investing in gold is not a sensible way to do it.
OK - I see. I think Bernanke is hell-bent on creating inflation and won't stop until he succeeds. And I think he'll succeed.
Inflation does not have to be at hyper-inflationary levels (whatever that level may be) to be painful. I wouldn't even be thinking about high-inflation except all the "experts" are so sure they'll be able to contain and control the inflation they are attempting to create.
Well, given that we've had "inflation" for something like 99 of the past 100 years,... and that when countries don't have "inflation" they have "deflation" instead, which is an utter disaster as evidenced by Japan's Lost Decade, I hope he will succeed.
I wonder why you think inflation is bad.
I see. So when the surgeon says "this is a routine procedure and I'm confident of the results," you take that as evidence that you're going to die on the table?
Why is it that the first thing that stupid wingnuts latch on to is the idea that they know better than the experts precisely because the experts know their subject?
see - I was right about you after all.
The negative reaction you have to someone different from you is revealing, but not surprising.
I guess if all that's left in this thread is tossing insults around we don't have much more to discuss,
I call you out on your advocacy of gold not because your opinion differs from mine but because your opinion is objectively wrong. Anyone who wants can go look at the charts of gold's return and how it correlates to inflation; I think the actual number is 0.08 or thereabouts, effectively zero -- no inflation hedge at all. If you want an inflation hedge, buy TIPS bonds, buy commodities, or buy foreign currencies, any of which actually work as inflation hedges.
The negative reaction you have to someone different from you is revealing, but not surprising..
People are entitled to their own opinions not their own facts. You are getting a negative reaction because you are asking for your own facts. Specifically you continue to insist that a) inflation is a problem and b) gold is a good hedge against inflation. Both of these “facts” fail to represent reality.