Gold will go $1,500/oz

Beats me - but because gold is global and if the right sort of panic happens it could be even higher. Now throw in speculators from all different countries - mix in a dash of various Central Banks - toss in a hedge fund or two and who knows?

Then how do you justify your exuberance?

Anyway I picked up some more equities today including BZ and CAT.
 
It really comes down to this:
drkitten has faith in Bernanke. So drkitten doesn't feel like the Federal Reserve Notes are at risk. drkitten is confident drkitten's investment strategy will more then compensate for the intentional devaluation of the Federal Reserve Notes.

I don't have faith in Bernanke nor the other Central Planners.

Not in the slightest. Whether you expect inflation or not, gold is simply a lousy investment. If you don't expect inflation, there are better investments out there. If you do expect inflation, there are still better investments out there.

By analogy, it really comes down to this:

ACS has faith in airplane pilots, so he's willing to get on a plane to go somewhere. I don't have faith in airplane pilots, so instead, I'm going to go from Washington, DC to Chicago next week by strapping a thousand seagulls to my body.

Really? That's the best I can do? You wouldn't think I was an idiot and suggest that there's a perfectly functional train? Or a bus? Or even renting a car? No, the only alternative if I don't like planes must be a flock of seagulls.

If you think that Bernanke is going to manage to produce hyperinflation, buy JNJ. Regardless of the dollar price of toothpaste and toilet paper, people will still need to buy them, and so JNJ will still make money for you. Or buy TIPS bonds. Or buy euro-denominated investments.
 
If you think that Bernanke is going to manage to produce hyperinflation, buy JNJ. Regardless of the dollar price of toothpaste and toilet paper, people will still need to buy them, and so JNJ will still make money for you. Or buy TIPS bonds. Or buy euro-denominated investments.

I agree. And I'll buy gold too. :) And a chicken.
 
Originally Posted by A Christian Sceptic
It really comes down to this:
drkitten has faith in Bernanke. So drkitten doesn't feel like the Federal Reserve Notes are at risk. drkitten is confident drkitten's investment strategy will more then compensate for the intentional devaluation of the Federal Reserve Notes.

I don't have faith in Bernanke nor the other Central Planners.
Not in the slightest. Whether you expect inflation or not, gold is simply a lousy investment. If you don't expect inflation, there are better investments out there. If you do expect inflation, there are still better investments out there.

Do you think Bernanke will succeed in creation inflation as he intends? Do you think he'll be able to get that inflation under control? Do you think your current investment strategy is protecting your wealth (or will protect your wealth) from Bernanke? Because my impression is that your answer is yes to all that. I would seriously like for you to elaborate if any of those are no. And if any is no then I apologize for misunderstanding.
 
Why not wait till it goes to $800 buy it then and wait for it to hit $1300 again? Instead of buying at what might be a peak?

:)

When the gold goes back to that price, it more likely will go lower and stay low for a long time. So there is still chance to make some money on gold for that gold rushing. ($1,500 to $2,000)
 
When the gold goes back to that price, it more likely will go lower and stay low for a long time.

Over my years of watching financial markets, I've pretty much accepted the "random walk" school of thought.

You can Google it or find it on Wikipedia if you're not familiar. But, in short, the theory is that prices of freely traded things move randomly. Barring inside information, everything that you may know or think you know about what the price of something "should be" or "will be" is also known to everyone else and is already factored into the price of that item.

Gold closed at $1,355.99 yesterday. Whether you look at formulae, fundamentals or past performance, I hold that it is impossible, in principle, to know whether the price tomorrow will be up or down. The same goes for a week from now, a month from now, a year from now or a decade from now.

Some here seem to think they know where the price of gold is going. If anyone really does, there are literal fortunes to be made. You can sell gold short. IOW, sell gold you don't have with the promise to replace it after the price goes down. Or buy or sell options on gold. Commodities markets are set up to make these things relatively easy. Think back to what Hillary Clinton did with cattle futures.

Some here have likened the buying or holding of gold, or even of real estate, as gambling. Having had a compulsive gambling problem in my family, there can be a compulsive element to trading anything. Historically, its been extremely difficult to amass a fortune by short-term trading. Day trading comes to mind as an activity where some thought they could "game" the system, but found out that in spite of computers it was extremely difficult (impossible?) to predict future prices from past performance. Long-term trading (buy and hold) does not appeal to the compulsive personality.

Again, to try to burn one particular straw man, I am not advocating the purchase of gold in the hopes of "buying low and selling high". If I play my cards right, I may never sell, and my heirs will have a nice little stash of metal to do with as they please. Would I buy at these levels? Though I'm not adding to my precious metals store right now, its not because of the price - its because I'm changing the allocation of asset types in my portfolio as I age. If I was still adding to my metals holdings, I would continue to do so at these prices - since a random walker knows with certainty that the price of gold can only go up...

...or down...

...or stay the same.
 
Last edited:
Do you think Bernanke will succeed in creation inflation as he intends?

No, I think that bringing the economy back on track will require legislative as well as monetary policy, and I think we're in for a repeat of 1937, where the newly elected conservatives derail the ongoing recovery.

Do you think he'll be able to get that inflation under control?

I believe that if he manages to get inflation up to reasonable levels, it will remain there and not go to hyperinflationary levels. No sensible person expects hyperinflation.

Do you think your current investment strategy is protecting your wealth (or will protect your wealth) from Bernanke?

Of course, or I wouldn't be using it. But even if I had different expectations, I wouldn't be in gold. If I did expect hyperinflation, I'd be in TIPS bonds instead of speculative equities.

Because gold is a lousy hedge against inflation.

That's the real problem that you're not understanding. The fact that I don't like venison is not the reason I'm telling you that going deer hunting with a fishing rod is a silly idea. If your goal is to hedge your portfolio against a lost of purchasing power due to inflation, investing in gold is not a sensible way to do it.
 
When the gold goes back to that price, it more likely will go lower and stay low for a long time. So there is still chance to make some money on gold for that gold rushing. ($1,500 to $2,000)

Well, that's not what you said in the opening post.

I think Gold will be pushed up to $2,000/oz, $1,500 at least, before it falls back to $800. Now it's a chance to buy some at the level of $1,300. Of course, before the crazy booming, there will be a blitze short period of falling to below $1,000, that's a technique to kill the small speculator follower.

Why should I buy gold at $1300 when I could sell gold now, buy back in at $1000, and then get even more profit from the "crazy booming"?
 
No, I think that bringing the economy back on track will require legislative as well as monetary policy, and I think we're in for a repeat of 1937, where the newly elected conservatives derail the ongoing recovery.

OK - I see. I think Bernanke is hell-bent on creating inflation and won't stop until he succeeds. And I think he'll succeed.

I believe that if he manages to get inflation up to reasonable levels, it will remain there and not go to hyperinflationary levels. No sensible person expects hyperinflation.

Inflation does not have to be at hyper-inflationary levels (whatever that level may be) to be painful. I wouldn't even be thinking about high-inflation except all the "experts" are so sure they'll be able to contain and control the inflation they are attempting to create.

Of course, or I wouldn't be using it. But even if I had different expectations, I wouldn't be in gold. If I did expect hyperinflation, I'd be in TIPS bonds instead of speculative equities.

Because gold is a lousy hedge against inflation.

That's the real problem that you're not understanding. The fact that I don't like venison is not the reason I'm telling you that going deer hunting with a fishing rod is a silly idea. If your goal is to hedge your portfolio against a lost of purchasing power due to inflation, investing in gold is not a sensible way to do it.

I don't agree with you about gold. That's all. After doing a risk analysis on my personal situation and researching various strategies I'm implementing a variety of approaches and strategies to do my best to protect myself and family. Gold's a small part. TIPS are too. And yes, even though you may think it's stupid, chickens are part of my plan too. (And a pig - except we're not raising it - we purchase half of a pig with a few others from a family friend and get far better pig at half the price of the stores). I don't view gold as an investment and I hope to never sell it. I'm spreading out my risk in as broad a way as possible in the best way I can with what little resources I have. I suppose in ten years or so we'll know if it was really "stupid". All I know is so far it's working great and we're hurting far less than those around us. In fact, because of this we are in a position to help friends and neighbors who are struggling - even if all we're doing is giving them extra zuchinni or free eggs.
 
OK - I see. I think Bernanke is hell-bent on creating inflation and won't stop until he succeeds. And I think he'll succeed.

Well, given that we've had "inflation" for something like 99 of the past 100 years,... and that when countries don't have "inflation" they have "deflation" instead, which is an utter disaster as evidenced by Japan's Lost Decade, I hope he will succeed.

I wonder why you think inflation is bad.


Inflation does not have to be at hyper-inflationary levels (whatever that level may be) to be painful. I wouldn't even be thinking about high-inflation except all the "experts" are so sure they'll be able to contain and control the inflation they are attempting to create.

I see. So when the surgeon says "this is a routine procedure and I'm confident of the results," you take that as evidence that you're going to die on the table?

Why is it that the first thing that stupid wingnuts latch on to is the idea that they know better than the experts precisely because the experts know their subject?
 
Well, given that we've had "inflation" for something like 99 of the past 100 years,... and that when countries don't have "inflation" they have "deflation" instead, which is an utter disaster as evidenced by Japan's Lost Decade, I hope he will succeed.

I wonder why you think inflation is bad.

I'm sure you do.

I see. So when the surgeon says "this is a routine procedure and I'm confident of the results," you take that as evidence that you're going to die on the table?

Why is it that the first thing that stupid wingnuts latch on to is the idea that they know better than the experts precisely because the experts know their subject?

see - I was right about you after all.

The negative reaction you have to someone different from you is revealing, but not surprising.

I guess if all that's left in this thread is tossing insults around we don't have much more to discuss, because I don't really care enough about what you are or are not doing as an investment strategy to feel a need to insult you.

See you on the flip side.
 
Last edited:
see - I was right about you after all.

Not at all.

The negative reaction you have to someone different from you is revealing, but not surprising.

Hardly. I'm a professional academic and researcher; I thrive on differences and controversy. But there are a few ground rules, most notably that difference for the sake of difference is not to be valued. If you're going to suggest that everyone in the world is doing something wrong, you better be prepared to back that up with hard evidence.


I guess if all that's left in this thread is tossing insults around we don't have much more to discuss,

We never had anything to "discuss"; you don't know enough to "discuss" this issue. On the other hand, this is an educational forum, and I'm happy to educate you in anything you're willing to learn. Failing that -- because you're demonstrably unwilling to learn even the fundamentals of investments -- I'm happy to use you as an object lesson for the benefit of the rest of the readership of the forum.

I call you out on your advocacy of gold not because your opinion differs from mine but because your opinion is objectively wrong. Anyone who wants can go look at the charts of gold's return and how it correlates to inflation; I think the actual number is 0.08 or thereabouts, effectively zero -- no inflation hedge at all. If you want an inflation hedge, buy TIPS bonds, buy commodities, or buy foreign currencies, any of which actually work as inflation hedges.
 
I call you out on your advocacy of gold not because your opinion differs from mine but because your opinion is objectively wrong. Anyone who wants can go look at the charts of gold's return and how it correlates to inflation; I think the actual number is 0.08 or thereabouts, effectively zero -- no inflation hedge at all. If you want an inflation hedge, buy TIPS bonds, buy commodities, or buy foreign currencies, any of which actually work as inflation hedges.

What did the WISE men give Jesus? TIPS bonds? Foreign currencies? Of course not.

Frankincense, myrrh, and GOLD. They were obviously concerned with inflation, and wanted to make sure Jesus had a solid portfolio.

Shows what you know.
 
The negative reaction you have to someone different from you is revealing, but not surprising..

People are entitled to their own opinions not their own facts. You are getting a negative reaction because you are asking for your own facts. Specifically you continue to insist that a) inflation is a problem and b) gold is a good hedge against inflation. Both of these “facts” fail to represent reality.

As far as investment strategies, the following may help if there really is inflation.

Hint 1: If the Price of “stuff” is going up invest in companies that sell “stuff”, preferably ones that have lower marginal/higher fixed costs and have already spent the money for their fixed costs.

Hint 2: Inflation is bad for lenders but good for borrowers so lending or investing in companies that lend may not be a good idea. Companies that borrow up front to build/acquire a profitable asset may see the value of their debt decrease relative to the value of their earnings.

Hint 3: if the USD is falling, then investments in companies outside the US goes up, as does the profits of US companies with significant earnings outside the US.
 
People are entitled to their own opinions not their own facts. You are getting a negative reaction because you are asking for your own facts. Specifically you continue to insist that a) inflation is a problem and b) gold is a good hedge against inflation. Both of these “facts” fail to represent reality.

To be fair, the opinion that inflation is likely to be a problem in the future is an opinion, albeit a misguided one. It's certainly true that Bernanke is (correctly) trying to address the problem of too-low inflation, a problem that if addressed will by definition result in more inflation. If he misses and overshoots, the result could be something akin to hyperinflation.

And, of course, the moon could suddenly turn into a giant fruitbat and fly away. "Difficult to see. Always in motion is the future."

But the statement that gold is a good inflation hedge is a factual claim, and simply a wrong one.
 
I remember years ago hearing about a stock-market scan called "pump and dump" where various talking heads on TV would hype a stock they own, causing a small but noticeable price increase, then they would sell their holdings and profit from it.

The gold business right now smells like a pump and dump operation to me.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom