Gold will go $1,500/oz

I'm sure you don't.

Gold bugs also ignore the fact that gold mining indices normally outperform the price of the metal.

@A X'n Sceptic:

re: I did however offer to sell some silver coins...

Yeah, that's pretty much what I've been saying. There is money to be made selling metals. Just not sure why people would be buying when they should be selling.

But, point is taken, as long as you're not recommending buying right now.
 
I'm well aware of Tulip Mania. Gold will get into a bubble - especially when the average person panics into it.

So far - no one around me is talking about gold investing - but it wasn't too long ago that darn near everyone around me was talking about how the housing prices will never go down. If I hear any of those same people talk the same way about gold then maybe a bubble's about to burst ....

Hold on, so you're claiming that gold is not currently in a bubble because the bubble hasn't started yet? How freakin high do you expect gold to go? What's the highest price your foresee in the next decade in US$?
 
Hell, BZ has more than quadrupled over the past 18 months or so. Two years ago it was at 0.50, now it's at 7 and change. And it's still got a P/E ratio less than 10, with the analysts expecting a more than 200% near-term growth. CAT isn't quite there yet; it's only up threefold over the past two years,... but it's also paying out 2% in dividends.

And, unlike gold, people actually have a use for tractors and paper.

And how much would you have now if you'd bought some Lehman Brothers back in 2000? We can pick individual winners and losers all day. Doesn't change the fact that gold (and silver, platinum, etc.) has vastly outperformed the market as a whole. Perhaps it will have another phenomenal ten year run. No one knows. But people who diversified in precious metals over the last ten years have seen that part of their portfolio do remarkably well.
 
You both have it right. Heck, I wish I'd put all my "investments" into gold in 1999 or when it was around $280 USD an ounce. Then use my uncanny foreknowledge to reap that 13 or 14 per cent annualised return.

The point is that, today, the people making money from gold are those selling it and not those buying it. I tabled the exceptions in the previous pages.

What a strange point to make...
 
But dramitically lagged the return on the Dow. Like I've been saying - gold is a hedge against great returns.

Except recently. From 20 years out, it's kept up with the DJIA. From ten years out, it's outperformed it many times over. I had some- very little- money in it and sold it when it hit $1,000 an ounce. Not a bad return at all.
 
Except recently. From 20 years out, it's kept up with the DJIA. From ten years out, it's outperformed it many times over. I had some- very little- money in it and sold it when it hit $1,000 an ounce. Not a bad return at all.

Talk to me again in 10 years.
 
Except recently. From 20 years out, it's kept up with the DJIA. From ten years out, it's outperformed it many times over. I had some- very little- money in it and sold it when it hit $1,000 an ounce. Not a bad return at all.

Assuming one purchased it during the 1990s or early in the 2000s. If one has purchased it in the last three years, especially from hucksters like Goldline that sell you a numismatic quality coin with a massive premium over the bullion price, then one might get a decent turn around (bought at, say, $1300, sold at $1500), or you could take a massive bath when the price drops again.
 
Great. So what is the "value" of gold today? In US dollars, please.

(Prediction: this question will go unanswered)

OOOh, what a scary question. Answer is "I don't know."

A more specific answer is that c + L = W, where c is the amount of constant capital (i.e. raw materials etc.) put into the production and L is the quantity of labor time (average skill and productivity) performed to produce the unit and W is value (German, you know. Makes it sound so much more profound.). I don't know what those quantities are at this period of time so I can't answer the question. Not being an economist, I will not pull those values out of thin air. However, I don't see what difference it makes to the question at hand (wtf is the question at hand anyway, I forgot.)

So, you see, your prediction is both right and wrong. I hope that helps you feel good today, because that is my goal in life. Cheers.
 
Originally Posted by stilicho
The point is that, today, the people making money from gold are those selling it and not those buying it.
What a strange point to make...


Please elaborate.

Listen, if you'd purchased gold in 1980 and sold it in 2000 (ostensibly to buy some real estate or something that appeared to be appreciating at a better rate) you'd have gotten about 1% to 2% annually. That's worse than if you'd bought GICs or money market mutual funds.

If, by chance, you'd sold your equities in 2000 and purchased gold, then you'd have earned about a 13% to 14% annual return if you were selling it now. Not buying it. Selling it now.

Does that explain it better? What I see is a lot of people urging folks to buy gold right now. As I explained, we do at my company because we buy what's essentially scrap that you couldn't sell at its market value because it's stuck in useless form such as jewelry. But you're a small investor, I take it, and you have nowhere to go now unless you expect gold to be selling at $6,300 USD or thereabouts by 2020.
 
Talk to me again in 10 years.

He doesn't have to. He already sold it.

That's the sign of a smart investor. When the price is high you sell the commodity.

I'm more curious about the anecdotes from those who sold the house, the car, cashed in the mutual funds, let their kids' tuition cheques bounce, and dumped it all into gold bars last week.

I want them to come back here in ten years and let us know how all that worked out.
 
OOOh, what a scary question. Answer is "I don't know."

A more specific answer is that c + L = W, where c is the amount of constant capital (i.e. raw materials etc.) put into the production and L is the quantity of labor time (average skill and productivity) performed to produce the unit and W is value (German, you know. Makes it sound so much more profound.). I don't know what those quantities are at this period of time so I can't answer the question. Not being an economist, I will not pull those values out of thin air. However, I don't see what difference it makes to the question at hand (wtf is the question at hand anyway, I forgot.)

So, you see, your prediction is both right and wrong. I hope that helps you feel good today, because that is my goal in life. Cheers.

So you're buying stuff and your don't even know its value? How do you know you're not overpaying? :eek:
 
So you're buying stuff and your don't even know its value? How do you know you're not overpaying? :eek:

Worse. He is saying the value of something is dependent on the amount of work you put into creating it. Were that the case I have EQ2 characters that have a "value" of $150 000.
 
So you're buying stuff and your don't even know its value? How do you know you're not overpaying?

I think this has degenerated into a debate over semantics, esp. "value".

If we get into a Platonic view of "value", we can end up with disparate answers. IOW, my I "value" my wedding band more than the value of the metals contained therein.

And I guess one can also come up with formulae, as some here have.

But its all rather pointless for a commodity that traded freely on an exchange. For gold, the value right now is $1,342.79/oz., and I got that with one click on a widget.

About 10 year forecasts - I hold out that no one can predict the future. Gold could be at $20,000/oz or $200/oz. And some "guessers" will have been right and some will have been wrong.

So what?
 
Please elaborate.

Listen, if you'd purchased gold in 1980 and sold it in 2000 (ostensibly to buy some real estate or something that appeared to be appreciating at a better rate) you'd have gotten about 1% to 2% annually. That's worse than if you'd bought GICs or money market mutual funds.

That is assuming someone made a single purchase at the gold last height in 1980. If they also bought at lower amounts dollar cost averaging would make the return alot higher.

Buying a single 1 oz. coin at $800 plus four 1 oz. coins at $250 = $1800 / 5 = $360 / coin.

It's neat people here like to pick single data points to make some sort of hypothetical situation point, but I've yet to come across (in my little neck of the world and cyber space) people buying gold the way it's being described here in order to argue against it.

Are there people out there who do as described - of course - usually in a panic - not when they've got some sort of plan.
 
Assuming one purchased it during the 1990s or early in the 2000s. If one has purchased it in the last three years, especially from hucksters like Goldline that sell you a numismatic quality coin with a massive premium over the bullion price, then one might get a decent turn around (bought at, say, $1300, sold at $1500), or you could take a massive bath when the price drops again.

Or you could just buy that much more at the lower prices.
 
Hold on, so you're claiming that gold is not currently in a bubble because the bubble hasn't started yet? How freakin high do you expect gold to go? What's the highest price your foresee in the next decade in US$?

Beats me - but because gold is global and if the right sort of panic happens it could be even higher. Now throw in speculators from all different countries - mix in a dash of various Central Banks - toss in a hedge fund or two and who knows?
 
As a short term investment, buy low sell high (you hope), gold is as good or bad as any other. As a long term investment (especially in a non-dollar area) its poor. As a hedge against a possible catastrophe it sucks. Which would you rather have, 3000 tins of beans or an ounce of gold? Which is the more tradeable comodity?

Steve
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom