Gold will go $1,500/oz

And once again, ACS discovers that if you ignore all the prices that have gone down, prices have risen.

Great point! :rolleyes: - apparently tobacco, designer jeans, and ipods have all gone down in value. Maybe if you boil all that your saying with some chicken broth it will be easier for people to swallow.
 
Great point! :rolleyes: - apparently tobacco, designer jeans, and ipods have all gone down in value. Maybe if you boil all that your saying with some chicken broth it will be easier for people to swallow.

As opposed to the household staples included in your chart like gold, silver, and copper....
 
OK - let's take the last ten years. Buying a 1 oz. gold coin every January for the past 10 years would have cost you about $6035. For it to keep pace with inflation those 10 coins would need to be now worht $6537.87. Those 10 coins at the current price are worth $14905. You've more than doubled your money and by far outpaced inflation.

So - how is gold not being a hedge against inflation?

Is that what you actually did? If you did then bully for you and you deserve a little giggle at the expense of the people who just bought your shiny treasure trove.

But your last line isn't talking about doubling your money in ten years. You're talking about hedging against inflation. This suggests an investment strategy that involves low volatility and probably a compounding yet steady return. Am I misunderstanding your use of the term "hedge against inflation"?

Inflation is a fairly predictable rate of compounding return (or compounding negative return). Gold prices are not the inverse of this fairly predictable economic phenomenon. They are usually the product of intense speculation and there's no reason to believe that's stopped in the last ten years.
 
As opposed to the household staples included in your chart like gold, silver, and copper....

Why are you focusing on the shiny metals alone? Wheat, corn, oats, canola, heating oil, gasoline, natural gas, beef, pork, coffee, sugar and cotton, even the copper, are very major factors in most of the things in my budget. The shiny metals are dwarfed by the increases in wheat, oats, pork and cotton with cotton prices actually being low in that chart. They are up more like 80% since July

These increases are being absorbed by producers and retailers who have been reluctant to pass them along to consumers (hence the lag in the CPI) but how long can this go on?
 
Why are you focusing on the shiny metals alone?

Because I was responding to a poster (ACS) who was dismissive of any reference to consumer goods that can't be eaten. I was just asking for a little consistency.

These increases are being absorbed by producers and retailers who have been reluctant to pass them along to consumers (hence the lag in the CPI)

Right, because traditionally businesses like to protect their customers from price increases, what with them being not-for-profit and all that.

but how long can this go on?

Well, you tell me: how long is this "lag" in the CPI that you're theorizing?

And incidentally, why is it that QE1 still left us with inflation under 2%, but QE2 is the harbinger of doom? At what point does the sky fall? Let's have some specific predictions from you Chicken Littles.
 
This suggests an investment strategy that involves low volatility and probably a compounding yet steady return.

No, it really doesn't. Gold does not provide that at all, and yet can serve as a hedge against inflation (examples already given of how that's worked both in the past and theoretically).

Inflation is a fairly predictable rate of compounding return...

Until its not. Like other Black Swans, it can strike unpredictably. Nothing predictable about it.

Wheat, corn, oats, canola, heating oil, gasoline, natural gas, beef, pork, coffee, sugar and cotton, even the copper, are very major factors in most of the things in my budget.

Fine. What sets gold apart is its high value in relation to its size and weight. Its also durable. If you had $100,000 of your portfolio you wished to invest in hard assets, any of those things might do, but obviously the amounts involved would dwarf gold in terms of space/weight/convenience.
 
...and you deserve a little giggle at the expense of the people who just bought your shiny treasure trove.

This seems to be an almost deliberate misunderstanding of what's being proposed here.

None of those advocating for gold as a consideration have talked about buying low with the intent of selling high - trying to time the gold market for short term profits. At least not that I can remember.

Since I've been buying somewhat steadily since the late '70's, I do have a large paper profit and could sell. But that was not the point of the investment.

I have to remind everyone that there are two sides to every trade. Today, there are exactly as many people selling gold at $1,354 because they think it might be a good time to get out as there are buying it for the same price thinking its time to get in. Imbalances Monday will move the market in one direction or the other - and I still hold that no one has the smarts or computer program to tell them what it will do Monday or in any particular time frame in the future.

If you somehow KNOW gold is "overpriced", sell it short. You can giggle at the expense of others, if that's your modus operandi. There will be buyers out there to take it and you'll just have to cover the short later. But you better be right, and know something that the free market in gold is somehow blind to.

Good luck with that!
 
Last edited:
Because I was responding to a poster (ACS) who was dismissive of any reference to consumer goods that can't be eaten. I was just asking for a little consistency.

I think you are having some trouble tracking the thread. That poster was making the point that inflation was a little more complicated than just following the CPI. I could be wrong about what ACS was trying to say but he will have to fill in the blanks if I am.

Right, because traditionally businesses like to protect their customers from price increases, what with them being not-for-profit and all that.

This sarcasm seems to make the assumption that businesses are of one mind on making a fast buck. Most are a little more sophisticated than that. They are currently in a bind where they are getting squeezed on both ends. Consumers have less to spend so they need to keep their prices as low as possible to keep market share.

Well, you tell me: how long is this "lag" in the CPI that you're theorizing?

My theory? Thanks for the compliment but I don't deserve it. Do a little research. Here is a prediction on food prices from CNBC Food Prices Expected to Rise Sharply

.... you Chicken Littles.

If you have no argument then resort to name calling. DrKitten teach you that?
 
I think you are having some trouble tracking the thread. That poster was making the point that inflation was a little more complicated than just following the CPI. I could be wrong about what ACS was trying to say but he will have to fill in the blanks if I am.

I think the history there is pretty clear. ACS posts a chart of cherry-picked data, Drkitten points out that it's cherry-picked, and ACS dismisses any items for which prices have decreased as not mattering because you can't boil and eat them.

My theory? Thanks for the compliment but I don't deserve it. Do a little research. Here is a prediction on food prices from CNBC Food Prices Expected to Rise Sharply

You mean the article that predicts that "For all food, prices are expected to rise two to three percent." Wow. Break out the wheelbarrows, it's the new Weimar Republic!

If you have no argument then resort to name calling. DrKitten teach you that?

"Chicken Little" seems a pretty accurate name for those who claim that the economic sky is falling.

But to answer your question, no: I've been refusing to suffer fools gladly long before I encountered the estimable DrKitten.
 
"Chicken Little" seems a pretty accurate name for those who claim that the economic sky is falling.

I think there's a difference between saying the economic sky is falling and saying the economic sky could fall.

I think the latter point of view has been the predominant one expressed by the gold advocates here.
 
You mean the article that predicts that "For all food, prices are expected to rise two to three percent." Wow. Break out the wheelbarrows, it's the new Weimar Republic!

Missed the part where the article said "...we could see these projections revised upward in the ensuing months." ?

That gets to the crux of what I've seen being argued here by those who think that inflation is a possibility. There is a reasonable possibility of inflation going beyond what is being expected. Reasonable enough to take precautions.

"Chicken Little" seems a pretty accurate name for those who claim that the economic sky is falling.

Name calling is name calling. It's childish and does nothing to promote you as a serious intellect.
 
Missed the part where the article said "...we could see these projections revised upward in the ensuing months." ?

Didn't miss it at all; I just gave it all the weight it deserves. We "could" see a lot of things. Aliens could land tomorrow and share with us their technology for turning dirt into gold, rendering gold nearly worthless.

That gets to the crux of what I've seen being argued here by those who think that inflation is a possibility. There is a reasonable possibility of inflation going beyond what is being expected. Reasonable enough to take precautions.

Great, precautions such as... oh, wait, you mean buying gold, which is not a hedge against inflation.

Name calling is name calling. It's childish and does nothing to promote you as a serious intellect.

Your concern is noted.
 
I think you are having some trouble tracking the thread. That poster was making the point that inflation was a little more complicated than just following the CPI. I could be wrong about what ACS was trying to say but he will have to fill in the blanks if I am.

You're correct.
 
Last edited:
OK - let's take the last ten years. Buying a 1 oz. gold coin every January for the past 10 years would have cost you about $6035. For it to keep pace with inflation those 10 coins would need to be now worht $6537.87. Those 10 coins at the current price are worth $14905. You've more than doubled your money and by far outpaced inflation.

So - how is gold not being a hedge against inflation?



That's worth stealing!

Thanks!
 
That poster was making the point that inflation was a little more complicated than just following the CPI.

Personally I've never been swayed by people saying "it's all incomprehensible so I won't bother trying to understand it and just believe whatever I want".
 
Since I've been buying somewhat steadily since the late '70's, I do have a large paper profit and could sell. But that was not the point of the investment.
Apologies if I seem dense here, but if you're not going to sell, in what way have you made an investment? Surely what you have is a collection?
 
Apologies if I seem dense here, but if you're not going to sell, in what way have you made an investment?

Sledge,

I know this has been a long thread, but if you look back I think I've tried to answer this.

Definitions help:

Investment: the investing of money or capital in order to gain profitable returns, as interest, income, or appreciation in value.

I don't see my buying and holding of gold as some part of my portfolio "investing" per se', though I don't doubt I've used that word and that its not totally inappropriate.

I think of it more as a form of insurance. Neither term life insurance nor auto insurance nor health insurance can be considered investments but they can still be rational choices. You purchase something to insure against future possibilities - death, car accident, illness.

That's how I see gold. Others disagree, and that's fine, but history has shown repeatedly that in tumultuous economic times gold has helped some people maintain some portion of their net worth, while other portions vanished.

There may be a generational element at work here. My parents were children of the depression, and I remember stories of fortunes lost and shoes being made to last one more year with the cardboard from matzoh boxes being used as insoles. I'm just speculating, but there may be some younger people here that have never been through or been regaled by stories of hard times, that consider themselves at this time and in this place to be immune from catastrophe.

Like those other forms of insurance, one who is buying gold for this purpose is NOT buying it with the expectation of future profits - as others have pointed out there are other things that can more rightly be called investments that serve that function better, and should be the lion's share of a balanced portfolio.

Like life insurance, I hold gold in the hope that I will never see the time (in this case economic times) where I will need it. Downside? Limited - I've lost some potential gains if I had invested the same funds elsewhere, and I have to store it somewhere. Upside? In the unlikely event the dollar crashes and takes a portion of US equity markets with it, I'll have an asset that may carry me through lean times.

BTW, we're focusing on gold here, but a case can be made for silver as well. Though it takes a lot more room to store, the smaller denominations can make it easier to "parcel out" for small items in the future. Plus, bags of "junk silver" are fun to look through and think about the history of some of the coins.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom