Gold will go $1,500/oz

To be fair, it hardly takes paranoia and/or stupidity to recognize that if you live in Tornado Alley, you will lose power at some point to a tornado, or that if you live in the snow belt, at some point you will get snowed in and have to live off whatever food you have in the house.

I was referring specifically to 1999 for a reason. :)
 
Here's why I buy gold. I am not a speculator, just looking for the safest way to set something aside for the future. Gold has value based on its rarity and its desirability. This has been true and constant throughout human history. Value and price are not the same thing. The price of gold fluctuates wildly, but the value remains constant. If the price goes down, it will be because the economy recovers and the dollar stabilizes. I doubt that will happen, but if it does, I will be glad to see the price of my gold go down. But whatever happens, I have a valuable asset that I can pass to my children.
 
Except in times when it hasn’t, right? Like the collapse of gold in Spain during the 17th (?) century?

No, the price of gold collapsed, but the value remained, and still remains.

An asset worth much, much less than had you spent your money more wisely.

And how, oh great wise one, should I have spent it. I'm sure you must have some stocks or bridges you would like me to buy. I await your advice.
 
Last edited:
No, the price of gold collapsed, but the value remained, and still remains.

You can't eat it drink it or live in it. At most it's a luxury item that only has value when your other needs are accounted for, so it wasn't just the price that collapsed it was the value.

If you want to leave your kids something that won't lose it's value buy land. If you want to leave them the most you can without to much risk buy some good index funds.
 
If you want to leave your kids something that won't lose it's value buy land. If you want to leave them the most you can without to much risk buy some good index funds.

Great idea! I've got some land in Camden, NJ, and Detroit, MI that I'd like to sell. Interested?

Real estate is pure speculation. I'm not a gambler.

Believe me when I say that I've checked the alternatives (I'm quite sure you won't believe me, but that's okay). i'm convinced for the reasons I stated earlier - gold has had value thorughout history. However, nothing is for sure, and we will all probably get wiped out by the asteroid in 2036 or whenever anyway.

It's very hard for people to get their heads around the difference between value and price. And I won't even go into use value and exchange value. Thanks for the input. I'm really trying to avoid the vitriol which is so common in these discussions. Talking is so much more fun than arguing.
 
And how, oh great wise one, should I have spent it. I'm sure you must have some stocks or bridges you would like me to buy. I await your advice.

You should spend your money on something that generates a return while you hold it. This return can be used for further investment to generate even more return which can be used for further investment...You get the idea.
 
I was referring specifically to 1999 for a reason.

Yes - totally missed that.

Let it be said that in spite of what did or didn't happen at the end of that particular year, owning a generator is still not a bad idea.

An asset worth much, much less than had you spent your money more wisely.

Aye, there's the rub.

Money spent elsewhere is subject to the same vagaries as gold, if not more so. Had one recently invested in real estate, one might have lost 50% of the value, and real estate is far less liquid than gold. Had one invested in Enron or GM, one might have lost more.

Again, I think gold "opponents" are painting a straw man. I am not saying to invest everything you have in gold. Or to invest in gold if you don't like it.

I'm saying its wise to diversify across a range of asset types, and it is not a mistake to include some gold among those assets. One can always look back in time and find assets that would have been superior (I still wish my broker had not talked me out of buying some Microsoft when it went public). But a diversified portfolio has the best chance of weathering financial ups and downs over time.
 
Last edited:
Why invest in assets that don't provide any return, ever? I'm not having a go, it's a serious question.
 
So... now that the price of gold is $1,368 per ounce, what's its value?

OOOH. OOOOH!

horshack.jpg


I know this one...

$1,368!

I think the question is naive - in a free market something is always "valued" or "worth" what two consenting adults can agree to buy or sell it for at a given time. If someone says Apple is "overpriced" at $300, they're wrong - unless they're operating on inside information. If a single tulip sells for $1,000, then that what its worth at that given time.

And same for gold. Trying to predict what it will do next is, frankly, impossible. As is the market. As is a particular stock. As is real estate. If it was that obvious what assets classes would do over time, people would not continue to get burned, and everyone would be a winner!

Its been about 45 years since my "formative years" and I've watched prices on various things go up about 10x. Look forward 45 years and think of a new Toyota for $200,000, a new house for $2,000,000, a single Fireball™ for $1, or a $10 can of Coke. And that would be if inflation remains at about the same overall rate. And gold? About $14,000 if history is any indication. And some "hedge" against that insidious inflation.

But I think we have some here really emotionally and fundamentally invested in the position that "gold is stupid" and any arguments are falling on deaf ears.

So it goes...
 
Last edited:
Why invest in assets that don't provide any return, ever?

Gold, just like any other asset, provides return if someone is willing to buy it from you for more than you paid for it. The problem is that this is the only kind of return it can provide and it doesn't have a calculable 'inherent value', so it's purely a speculative investment.
 
Why invest in assets that don't provide any return, ever? I'm not having a go, it's a serious question.

Many stocks do not pay dividends, yet people hold them and hope to benefit from earnings being reinvested rather than distributed via dividends. If you invest in blue chip stocks and/or utilities that pay dividends, you're sure to have at least some income stream. But you usually give up the hope of huge winners: the Microsofts, Apples, Netflix's, that sort of stock.

One hopes to benefit from appreciation. Same with gold.

But diversify, diversify, diversify!
 
Gold, just like any other asset, provides return if someone is willing to buy it from you for more than you paid for it. The problem is that this is the only kind of return it can provide and it doesn't have a calculable 'inherent value', so it's purely a speculative investment.

Well that's my point; you are relying solely on capital growth, whereas other investments provide yield (as well as capital growth) which can be used to offset the cost of the investment or be re-invested to increase future returns. Gold sounds like a really slow way to grow your money, unless you get lucky in a volatile market.
 
I know this one...

$1,368!

That's what I would have said. However, the question was addressed to minus, who disagreed:

Value and price are not the same thing. The price of gold fluctuates wildly, but the value remains constant.

The only constant 'value' I can see gold having is that your gold stash is constantly pretty much the same portion of existing gold. I find that a fairly silly concept of 'value'.


I think the question is naive - in a free market something is always "valued" or "worth" what two consenting adults can agree to buy or sell it for at a given time. I someone says Apple is "overpriced" at $300, they're wrong - unless they're operating on inside information. If a single tulip sells for $1,000, then that what its worth at that given time.

And same for gold. Trying to predict what it will do next is, frankly, impossible. As is the market. As is a particular stock.

Trying to predict what happens in the short term is impossible. However, I find it somewhat odd to look at companies like they were black boxes -- that their share price always accurately reflects their value, and that there's nothing more to the story. Companies have assets and debt, they manage to get more-or-less consistent returns on assets and employed capital, they have products that they sell for a price that may be rising, falling or stagnating, to a customer base that may be shrinking, growing, or staying put. You can make more or less educated guesses on the future free cash flows of companies and base your valuations of company shares on these calculations; they may prove to be occasionally wildly off the mark, but at least you have something other than the prices people were willing to pay for them last week, last year, or 6 years ago.

Gold has none of that.
 
Many stocks do not pay dividends, yet people hold them and hope to benefit from earnings being reinvested rather than distributed via dividends.

And that's the key difference between stocks, even non-dividend-paying stocks, and gold.

Some stocks don't generate dividends. But gold doesn't even generate earnings. It literally just sits there until you can find a Greater Fool to take the lump of shiny metal off your hands.

But diversify, diversify, diversify!

I hope not. I hope you diversify wisely and to improve your overall risk/return profile, rather than just for the sake of diversification. There's no place in a portfolio for lottery tickets.

And gold? Well, let me just say that in a properly diversified portfolio, you should have exactly half as much in gold as you have in lottery tickets.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom