Gold will go $1,500/oz

No one has ever explained to me why gold would be a good thing to have in case of a total societal meltdown (zombies, nuclear war, etc). People seem to think that gold will still be valuable if something happened to render paper money useless. Seems to me you'd be better off with a trunk full of whiskey, a good rifle and a brick of ammunition. In some post-Apocalyptic wasteland, who would be dumb enough to sell the raccoon they just shot for a handful of Kruggerands? You can cook a Kruggerand all day and it still won't taste good.

I don't really know about investing or anything like that, but I have heard the "gold as a hedge against societal breakdown" for years. Anyone have some rationale for this idea?
 
No one has ever explained to me why gold would be a good thing to have in case of a total societal meltdown (zombies, nuclear war, etc). People seem to think that gold will still be valuable if something happened to render paper money useless. Seems to me you'd be better off with a trunk full of whiskey, a good rifle and a brick of ammunition. In some post-Apocalyptic wasteland, who would be dumb enough to sell the raccoon they just shot for a handful of Kruggerands? You can cook a Kruggerand all day and it still won't taste good.

I don't really know about investing or anything like that, but I have heard the "gold as a hedge against societal breakdown" for years. Anyone have some rationale for this idea?

The basic idea is that it's a hedge against partial societal breakdown. The Weimar Republic (and more recently Zimbabwe) are examples of this; if you had gold, you had access to a wider economy that you didn't have with local currency. (I could slip across the border into France, for example, and trade my gold watch for what I wanted. And because I could do that, I would be willing to sell bread in exchange for gold watches from other people where I might not be willing to accept semi-worthless currency.)

So what they're really hedging against is the idea that the United States will descend into hyperinflation, anarchy, and civil disorder that will magically stop at the Canadian border. Because, of course, the Canadian economy is not in any way dependent upon exports to the United States....

And we all know that since Obama has taken office, inflation has been running at close to 10%, with correspondingly negative unemployment rates. Oh, wait, did I get those reversed?
 
I don't really know about investing or anything like that, but I have heard the "gold as a hedge against societal breakdown" for years. Anyone have some rationale for this idea?

You simply don't understand. Gold is shiny and pretty and rare, and just like every swan is white, shiny and pretty and rare things will always be valuable and people will always be willing to give you food, tools, fuel, etc. for it.
 
Thanks, drkitten. Makes sense, but it doesn't really explain the survivalist with the box of gold coins buried in the back forty. I know some of these oddballs, and many of them feel like we'll all be living in the woods in a few years. How is gold going to help them? I've asked them before, but never really got a good answer.

I haven't ruled out the possibility that they're just crazy as hell.

ETA: Thanks to timhau, as well. Because of you, I still haven't ruled out the possibility that they're just crazy as hell. :)
 
Last edited:
Seems to me you'd be better off with a trunk full of whiskey, a good rifle and a brick of ammunition.

Not really an either/or. Lots of people have gold AND ammunition AND weapons. I'm not sure how the whiskey fits in, exactly.

I don't really know about investing or anything like that, but I have heard the "gold as a hedge against societal breakdown" for years. Anyone have some rationale for this idea?

It doesn't appear you've read this thread - the rationale has been given repeatedly. If you wish not to agree with it, or not give it the weight others do, that's another story.
 
Not really an either/or. Lots of people have gold AND ammunition AND weapons. I'm not sure how the whiskey fits in, exactly.



It doesn't appear you've read this thread - the rationale has been given repeatedly. If you wish not to agree with it, or not give it the weight others do, that's another story.

Whiskey would be a more welcome commodity than gold if everything went in the crapper.

Imagine this: You're sitting around the campfire after a busy day of fighting Hunter/Killers and T-1000's. The pot of possum boulliabaise is just about done simmering when some bedraggled survivor staggers into camp, moaning that he hasn't eaten in days. There's only enough possum for you and your companions, and you're about to chase the interloper away at gunpoint , when suddenly he hauls a full bottle of Wild Turkey out of his pocket and offers to trade it for some soup. Now, a little snort would be pretty welcome right now, so you let him stay and you eat a little less possum, but you get a slug of whiskey.

If he had gold instead of Wild Turkey, would you make the trade? Why carry heavy gold around with you when you're better served by ammo or food?

This example is extreme, I know, but I'm not talking about the situation that drkitten gave, where gold might get you out of the country because it's still perceived as valuable. I'm talking about the total breakdown of everything. The rationale given so far in this thread seems to assert that gold will help in times of economic uncertainty or rampant inflation. How's it going to help in a full-on Mad Max type situation? I'm not trying to start a big poop storm, I'm just wondering where this idea came from?
 
Thanks, drkitten. Makes sense, but it doesn't really explain the survivalist with the box of gold coins buried in the back forty. I know some of these oddballs, and many of them feel like we'll all be living in the woods in a few years. How is gold going to help them? I've asked them before, but never really got a good answer.

I haven't ruled out the possibility that they're just crazy as hell.

Don't confuse "crazy as hell" with "pig-ignorant" and/or "dumber than a sack of hammers."

Although a lot of goldbugs seem to be all three, any one of the three is a sufficient condition.
 
Not really an either/or. Lots of people have gold AND ammunition AND weapons. I'm not sure how the whiskey fits in, exactly.
Unlike gold the whisky would go up in value under these conditions. I’m a big fan of freeze dried food. Under really desperate conditions it will increase in value even more then the whisky and in the worst case you can use it all yourself.
The basic idea is that it's a hedge against partial societal breakdown. The Weimar Republic (and more recently Zimbabwe) are examples of this; if you had gold, you had access to a wider economy that you didn't have with local currency. (I could slip across the border into France, for example, and trade my gold watch for what I wanted. And because I could do that, I would be willing to sell bread in exchange for gold watches from other people where I might not be willing to accept semi-worthless currency.)

So what they're really hedging against is the idea that the United States will descend into hyperinflation, anarchy, and civil disorder that will magically stop at the Canadian border. Because, of course, the Canadian economy is not in any way dependent upon exports to the United States....
Even then it would depend on there being some culture of accepting gold as an exchange medium, which doesn’t really exist anymore. You can’t “spend” gold these days, so if the collapse really happens you still need find someone who will buy your gold and give you bottle caps or whatever the new popular exchange medium is.

My guess is that whisky would be a much better exchange medium then gold because people can use it themselves if it turns out they can’t trade it. With gold, I’d be waiting to see if people are willing to give me anything for it before taking it in exchange for anything.
 
Even then it would depend on there being some culture of accepting gold as an exchange medium, which doesn’t really exist anymore.

Not really. In any reasonably prosperous society, you will find people who want shiny metals because they're shiny -- in the same way that you could use gems to hedge against Weimar Republic hyperinflation even though no society in history has ever been on the "ruby standard." But shiny rocks are shiny, and shiny gold is shiny, and if you give your sweetie a gold-and-ruby necklace you might get some, so you will be willing to trade your unneeded bread for gold and rubies.

Of course, the key word there is unneeded. In today's prosperous economy, I have more bread than I can eat and no reasonable expectation of ever going hungry. So I'm willing to trade my bread for shiny rocks from the people across the border who are trying to figure out how long you need to boil rubies to make them tender. If I were one of those people, I'd probably be trading my rubies for someone else's bread, because rubies al dente don't taste good and therefore would be all but valueless to me.


You can’t “spend” gold these days, so if the collapse really happens you still need find someone who will buy your gold and give you bottle caps or whatever the new popular exchange medium is.

My guess is that whisky would be a much better exchange medium then gold because people can use it themselves if it turns out they can’t trade it. With gold, I’d be waiting to see if people are willing to give me anything for it before taking it in exchange for anything.

And in the absence of people with more whisky than they can drink, you'd be looking at the thirst-quenching properties of gold and wondering why you had bothered.....
 
We all have fertile imaginations. How would US markets and the US dollar react to:

1) an H1N6 virus that killed 90% of the US and world population?

2) a WWIII started by Iran and N Korea which pivoted on the survival of Israel?

3) a Cyber-attack that crippled the internet for months?

I imagine the US stock market would go down. I would go shopping.

I have no idea how the US dollar would react. I don't participate in currency markets because I don't understand them.
 
I don't think you answered my question, unless you're implying that you believe the chances of economic/societal meltdown are 1 in 5 or greater.

Some people have defending holding gold as a rational hedge against a remote, "Black Swan" event. I'm just pointing out that physically possessing gold exposes you to a not-so-remote risk of robbery.

Plus storage fees. So not only does it offer historically poor returns (compared to securities and real estate), and it doesn't pay any dividends, you also have to pay storage fees (assuming your gold holdings are more than a Krugerand or two).
 
Thanks, drkitten. Makes sense, but it doesn't really explain the survivalist with the box of gold coins buried in the back forty. I know some of these oddballs, and many of them feel like we'll all be living in the woods in a few years. How is gold going to help them? I've asked them before, but never really got a good answer.

It's not. Which is why most of them are living in the woods already (or at best a single wide), and I live in a very nice 8th floor condo with a couple of cars parked in the basement.
 
It's not. Which is why most of them are living in the woods already (or at best a single wide), and I live in a very nice 8th floor condo with a couple of cars parked in the basement.

So, I'm back to the "crazy as hell" theory.

That was the theory I suspected was right all along, you and drkitten have mostly confirmed it.

Thanks.
 
So, I'm back to the "crazy as hell" theory.

That was the theory I suspected was right all along, you and drkitten have mostly confirmed it.

Thanks.

Like I said earlier - the ones pushing gold are almost always conspiracy nuts or late night TV hucksters. Their trailer has a closet full of weapons with more buried out back, and they want the rest of us to emulate them? No thanks, I'll enjoy my 8th floor air conditioned condo.
 
I did one time about a year ago visit a shop in McCaysville, GA - near my house.

The fellow had various silver half-dollars for sale - at what appeared to be less than their bullion value. I thought about it and went back in and said - I'll take them all - I got 20 of them for just over $75. That's about $7.50/oz.

The fellow said he might have some more at home and I said I'd take them, too. When I went back in a couple of days later, he had them priced at about their fair value. He recognized me and said, "You know, I think I sold those other coins too cheap!". I agreed.

Once in a while opportunities like that do come up, but I find they're pretty rare.
 
Unlike gold the whisky would go up in value under these conditions. I’m a big fan of freeze dried food. Under really desperate conditions it will increase in value even more then the whisky and in the worst case you can use it all yourself.

Even then it would depend on there being some culture of accepting gold as an exchange medium, which doesn’t really exist anymore. You can’t “spend” gold these days, so if the collapse really happens you still need find someone who will buy your gold and give you bottle caps or whatever the new popular exchange medium is.

My guess is that whisky would be a much better exchange medium then gold because people can use it themselves if it turns out they can’t trade it. With gold, I’d be waiting to see if people are willing to give me anything for it before taking it in exchange for anything.

In Zimbabwe many spend all day panning for gold in order to buy some bread. Apparently they've created a market that accepts gold for food.
I wonder if any of them wishes they were able to pre-buy some gold (before hyper-inflation hit) to avoid having to pan for it?

I'm sure whiskey would be worth some value too (not sure how good Zimbabwe's access to that is) - probably everything other than their worthless currency has trading value.
 
Last edited:
In Zimbabwe many spend all day panning for gold in order to buy some bread. Apparently they've created a market that accepts gold for food.
I wonder if any of them wishes they were able to pre-buy some gold (before hyper-inflation hit) to avoid having to pan for it?

I'm sure people in Zimbabwe wish for a lot of things.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom