Almo
Masterblazer
UWdude said:
Are you saying lottery tickets are a good investment? I hope not...
UWdude said:
Are you saying lottery tickets are a good investment? I hope not...
As I said, an intelligently diversified portfolio will have exactly twice as much in lottery tickets as in gold.
Yes, and that was "not to [sic] long ago," not now. Now it's simply stupid.
Seriously? You're advocating diversifying into chickens and a pig?
I think it was TCS who pointed out that as a result of his successful investments, he's got a lovely 8th floor condominium. Where's he supposed to keep this pig?
You're not taking into account opportunity costs. Farmland costs money, and in order to make it worthwhile, you need to put some serious labor into it. Which mean you'll either need to quit your day job and start subsistence farming, or you'll need to hire someone to farm your land for you. Pigs and chickens need food, shelter, vet care,.... which turns farming into a very expensive investment unless you're willing to do it full-time. Even if you do it full-time, it's generally not a good investment, which is why family farms are disappearing all over the United States.
What you're not considering is opportunity costs. Yes, I could spend $100,000 on a small farm in East Dakota,.... but I don't live in East Dakota and really don't want that kind of a commute, thanks. I can spend the same $100,000 on BMO and make nearly $5000 a year in income, and still be able to do my normal job and earn money the way I usually do.
The idea of investing in everything is, frankly, stupid. You should invest in things that are actually good investments. Land can be a good investment, but not simply for sitting there. Chickens are a pretty bad investment unless you're willing to go all-in and try to become the next Frank Perdue. But if you're a dentist in the Bronx, farmland and chickens are just a very expensive hobby.
I didn't invent the term, alas.
Wikipedia:
Almost all investments in precious metals are "greater fool" investments, precisely because there's no "worth" in a piece of shiny metal.
Originally Posted by Fast Eddie B:
If someone says Apple is "overpriced" at $300, they're wrong - .
You are the one who is wrong. As a company Apple has earnings, which can be used to calculate it's value.
Yes, and that was "not to [sic] long ago," not now. Now it's simply stupid.
Seriously? You're advocating diversifying into chickens and a pig? I think it was TCS who pointed out that as a result of his successful investments, he's got a lovely 8th floor condominium. Where's he supposed to keep this pig?
I and others have attempted to make the case that having some part of one's worth in precious metals can be worthwhile. We've used logic and analogy and history to make our points.
Care to repeat, in condensed form, the parts where logic and analogy came into play?
According to your quote it's only a "greater fool" investment when you knowingly buy something you don't think is a good investment (or worth it's price) hoping to sell it to someone else. I'm not doing that - Is there anyone here doing that?
Gold is only something you invest in to resell to the next guy. So, strictly speaking it's not a Greater Fool investment if you actually think it's a good investment.
DrK's point I think is that it's obviously not a good investment (since it pays no dividends, and even carries a cost of ownership), it must be a GF investment.
DrK's point I think is that it's obviously not a good investment (since it pays no dividends, and even carries a cost of ownership), it must be a GF investment.
So... now that the price of gold is $1,368 per ounce, what's its value?
Yup.
I can make money buying CAT even if I never sell it. It pays me a dividend every quarter. I can even do that with AAPL; I can at least expect that AAPL will eventually start paying a dividend when it runs out of growth opportunities. The intrinsic value of a stock is the (net present value of) the income stream it generates.
I can't make money with gold if I never sell it. The only way I can make money on gold is by selling it to a greater fool than I am at a higher price than I paid.
I'll have to reread the posts here, but it seems most (if not all) the people here are using gold as a form of insurance....
Okay, I'll take a quick shot at that. The value of a commodity is based on the amount of work that goes into it's production. That can change as the method of production changes. Part of the reason gold is so valuable is that it is rare and takes a lot of work to find and produce.
The price of a commodity fluctuates around its value, sometimes more, sometimes less. Market forces cause these fluctuations, e.g. supply and demand. Unless someone figures out a way to make lead into gold, or a radical new method of finding and processing gold, the value of gold is pretty much stable.
And no you can't eat it or wear it, but throughout history, and across cultures, and with few exceptions that i can find, a little piece of yellow metal has been able to buy you something to eat or wear.
I'll have to reread the posts here, but it seems most (if not all) the people here are using gold as a form of insurance not investment, and have diversified their other investments to spread out risks - and stocks appear to be part of their diversified assets as well as gold. (and some even include chickens in their diversification.) I haven't seen anyone share the view that they really don't like gold (or think it's not worthwhile to own) but are buying it just in the hope to sell it to another "greater fool" - except maybe the guy who claimed to be selling gold below market value - I've yet to be contacted on how I can buy his below market value gold.
Has gold ever been worth ZERO?
And no you can't eat it or wear it, but throughout history, and across cultures, and with few exceptions that i can find, a little piece of yellow metal has been able to buy you something to eat or wear.
Has Coca-Cola? IBM? Microsoft? Land?