Gold will go $1,500/oz

Some stocks don't generate dividends. But gold doesn't even generate earnings. It literally just sits there until you can find a Greater Fool to take the lump of shiny metal off your hands.

Even worse, it generates negative earnings. You have to pay for storage.
 
Sounds like sour grapes from some posters. Gold has quadrupled in value over the last ten years. I think a few of you are upset you missed the boat ;)
 
Sounds like sour grapes from some posters. Gold has quadrupled in value over the last ten years. I think a few of you are upset you missed the boat ;)

What has it done over the last 30 years? :)

Also, I have stocks that have more than quadrupled over the last 10 years. I don't start threads about them.
 
What has it done over the last 30 years?

Also, I have stocks that have more than quadrupled over the last 10 years. I don't start threads about them.

Hell, BZ has more than quadrupled over the past 18 months or so. Two years ago it was at 0.50, now it's at 7 and change. And it's still got a P/E ratio less than 10, with the analysts expecting a more than 200% near-term growth. CAT isn't quite there yet; it's only up threefold over the past two years,... but it's also paying out 2% in dividends.

And, unlike gold, people actually have a use for tractors and paper.
 
Great idea! I've got some land in Camden, NJ, and Detroit, MI that I'd like to sell. Interested?

Real estate is pure speculation. I'm not a gambler.

Believe me when I say that I've checked the alternatives (I'm quite sure you won't believe me, but that's okay). i'm convinced for the reasons I stated earlier - gold has had value thorughout history. However, nothing is for sure, and we will all probably get wiped out by the asteroid in 2036 or whenever anyway.

It's very hard for people to get their heads around the difference between value and price. And I won't even go into use value and exchange value. Thanks for the input. I'm really trying to avoid the vitriol which is so common in these discussions. Talking is so much more fun than arguing.

Funny that you consider owning land “speculation” while owning gold, a commodity with very little intrinsic value is “setting something aside for the future”. Land can be farmed and you can build a house to live on it. It has real use and therefore real value that will not go away, this is what you said you wanted.

Personally, I’m an engineer. I like things I can quantify. If you know it’s earning and growth you can quantify the value of a company in a way you cannot with gold or land. The latter are only worth what someone else is willing to pay unless you plan to use them yourself. Between land and gold, only land has any real utility, using gold yourself isn’t really much of an option.
 
Oh, and by the way, it's not a straw man when it's a criticism of a site that one of your fellow goldbugs cited in defense of gold.

A straw man (note spelling) is when I respond to an argument that no one made. When I respond to an argument that you made, it's called "proving you wrong."

That link was not posted in defense of gold - so according to you above it would be a strawman - except I think you didn't read the context the link was posted in - so I'll give you the benefit of the doubt.
 
Also, I have stocks that have more than quadrupled over the last 10 years. I don't start threads about them.

That just proves your short-sightedness.

When the 4 Horsemen come rumbling through and have the board of directors of your precious company pinned to the ground as a thousand blood-thirsty succubi take advantage of their vulnerability and preform unspeakable acts, that stock price is going to tumble pretty quickly.

You'll be like, "Damn, should have bought gold," as you huddle with a few dozen survivors with foresight. They listened to Beck. They sit terrified on the very edge of a nightmare, tattered, desperate, but secure against inflation.
 
And that's the key difference between stocks, even non-dividend-paying stocks, and gold.

Some stocks don't generate dividends. But gold doesn't even generate earnings. It literally just sits there until you can find a Greater Fool to take the lump of shiny metal off your hands.



I hope not. I hope you diversify wisely and to improve your overall risk/return profile, rather than just for the sake of diversification. There's no place in a portfolio for lottery tickets.

And gold? Well, let me just say that in a properly diversified portfolio, you should have exactly half as much in gold as you have in lottery tickets.

I think you should also diversify into - farmable land, canned food, dehydrated food, next years clothes, emergency cash, cash hidden at home and your car, a generator, bottled water, education, guns (and training), hands on skills (gardening, sewing, canning, carpentry, etc), chickens, maybe a pig, etc. And yes - some gold and silver - but diversify in that too (i.e. bullion, old coins, collectible coins, jewelry, etc.)

I was raised on farms and my grandparents were homesteaders - so all that above not to long ago was just simply called "self-reliance" and not, as it's been called here, "stupid".

So far I haven't read a single "goldbug" here who simply says throw everything at gold, but I have heard many anti-gold people here telling us we should do that for some reason - as if, since we are not, we're being hypocrites or something. This really is just odd.

I mean, I don't have the hostility (or even the emotional reaction) towards anti-gold people's investment strategies that I see many of them direct towards people here who think you should also have some gold.
 
I mean, I don't have the hostility (or even the emotional reaction) towards anti-gold people's investment strategies that I see many of them direct towards people here who think you should also have some gold.

Because the "anti-gold" people don't start threads telling the world how high their Coca-Cola stock is going to go and how smart they are for buying it and oh, by the way, everyone should put 10% of their money into Coca-Cola stock.
 
Because the "anti-gold" people don't start threads telling the world how high their Coca-Cola stock is going to go and how smart they are for buying it and oh, by the way, everyone should put 10% of their money into Coca-Cola stock.

The OP didn't strike me that way.

But, you do know, there is advice often given on what percentages of investment money should go into which types of stocks. I don't get the connection, though, to people posting or telling you how much they think should be invested and where and a reader/listener having a negative emotional reaction to that or towards people who follow it.

I also don't get the connection on why it's bad if someones excited that their investment and strategy is working.
 
Last edited:
I think the question is naive - in a free market something is always "valued" or "worth" what two consenting adults can agree to buy or sell it for at a given time.

That’s true of a commodity, but not a company or asset that has defined earnings.

If someone says Apple is "overpriced" at $300, they're wrong - .

You are the one who is wrong. As a company Apple has earnings, which can be used to calculate it's value. (To justify it's present value apple needs phenomenal earnings, likely impossible earnings growth)
 
Hell, BZ has more than quadrupled over the past 18 months or so. Two years ago it was at 0.50, now it's at 7 and change. And it's still got a P/E ratio less than 10, with the analysts expecting a more than 200% near-term growth. CAT isn't quite there yet; it's only up threefold over the past two years,... but it's also paying out 2% in dividends.

BMO has tripled since 2009 and it’s still paying 4.7% dividend. If you really liked gold back in 2000 GG has gone up 10X since then.
 
I think you should also diversify into - farmable land, canned food, dehydrated food, next years clothes, emergency cash, cash hidden at home and your car, a generator, bottled water, education, guns (and training), hands on skills (gardening, sewing, canning, carpentry, etc), chickens, maybe a pig, etc. And yes - some gold and silver - but diversify in that too (i.e. bullion, old coins, collectible coins, jewelry, etc.)

I was raised on farms and my grandparents were homesteaders - so all that above not to long ago was just simply called "self-reliance" and not, as it's been called here, "stupid".

Yes, and that was "not to [sic] long ago," not now. Now it's simply stupid.

Seriously? You're advocating diversifying into chickens and a pig? I think it was TCS who pointed out that as a result of his successful investments, he's got a lovely 8th floor condominium. Where's he supposed to keep this pig?

You're not taking into account opportunity costs. Farmland costs money, and in order to make it worthwhile, you need to put some serious labor into it. Which mean you'll either need to quit your day job and start subsistence farming, or you'll need to hire someone to farm your land for you. Pigs and chickens need food, shelter, vet care,.... which turns farming into a very expensive investment unless you're willing to do it full-time. Even if you do it full-time, it's generally not a good investment, which is why family farms are disappearing all over the United States.

What you're not considering is opportunity costs. Yes, I could spend $100,000 on a small farm in East Dakota,.... but I don't live in East Dakota and really don't want that kind of a commute, thanks. I can spend the same $100,000 on BMO and make nearly $5000 a year in income, and still be able to do my normal job and earn money the way I usually do.

The idea of investing in everything is, frankly, stupid. You should invest in things that are actually good investments. Land can be a good investment, but not simply for sitting there. Chickens are a pretty bad investment unless you're willing to go all-in and try to become the next Frank Perdue. But if you're a dentist in the Bronx, farmland and chickens are just a very expensive hobby.
 
So interesting ....

I didn't invent the term, alas.

Wikipedia:

The greater fool theory (also called survivor investing) is the belief held by one who makes a questionable investment, with the assumption that they will be able to sell it later to "a greater fool"; in other words, buying something not because you believe that it is worth the price, but rather because you believe that you will be able to sell it to someone else at an even higher price.

Almost all investments in precious metals are "greater fool" investments, precisely because there's no "worth" in a piece of shiny metal.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom