Gold will go $1,500/oz

Here's another website for you - in case you need help getting started on becoming prepared:

http://www.ready.gov

Well,.... actually, that site kind of proves the anti-gold point.

What are we supposed to stockpile against a disaster?

Well,...

  • Water, one gallon of water per person per day for at least three days, for drinking and sanitation
  • Food, at least a three-day supply of non-perishable food
  • Battery-powered or hand crank radio and a NOAA Weather Radio with tone alert and extra batteries for both
  • Flashlight and extra batteries
  • First aid kit
  • Whistle to signal for help
  • Dust mask, to help filter contaminated air and plastic sheeting and duct tape to shelter-in-place
  • Moist towelettes, garbage bags and plastic ties for personal sanitation
  • Wrench or pliers to turn off utilities
  • Can opener for food (if kit contains canned food)
  • Local maps
  • Cell phone with chargers, inverter or solar charger

So, no gold. But, wait. There's a secondary list:


  • Additional Items To Consider Adding To An Emergency Supply Kit:
  • Prescription medications and glasses
  • Infant formula and diapers
  • Pet food and extra water for your pet
  • Important family documents such as copies of insurance policies, identification and bank account records in a waterproof, portable container
  • Cash or traveler's checks and change
  • Important family documents such as copies of insurance policies, identification and bank account records in a waterproof, portable container.

    Et cetera,....

So, no gold. In fact, they even recommend "Cash or traveler's checks and change," because they recognize that in a real disaster, gold is Not Worth The Trouble. If the disaster is so bad that you can't spend cash, you're not going to be spending gold, either.
 
Well,.... actually, that site kind of proves the anti-gold point.

What are we supposed to stockpile against a disaster?



So, no gold. In fact, they even recommend "Cash or traveler's checks and change," because they recognize that in a real disaster, gold is Not Worth The Trouble. If the disaster is so bad that you can't spend cash, you're not going to be spending gold, either.

These strawman arguments are getting old. Gold is a hedge against inflation, not nuclear war or earthquake.
 
Great. The stupid have spread to the suburbs. Probably the same idiots who were buying generators in 1999.

To be fair, it hardly takes paranoia and/or stupidity to recognize that if you live in Tornado Alley, you will lose power at some point to a tornado, or that if you live in the snow belt, at some point you will get snowed in and have to live off whatever food you have in the house.

I don't really see any harm in having extra blankets, candles, and a case of Beefaroni in the basement for when that happens. If you want to go whole hog and throw a $50 propane stove in there as well,... well, then you don't have to eat cold Beefaroni.

But I'm still not sure how much good a case of Kruggerands will do you when the Snowtorious B.I.G. hits again....
 
These strawman arguments are getting old. Gold is a hedge against inflation,

This excuse is getting old. Run the numbers; gold is a terrible inflation hedge in general. The long-term return from gold is about 5% per year; the long-term return from equities is closer to 10%.

If you're hedging for inflation by buying gold, you're doing it wrong. Buy TIPS bonds instead, or, hell, buy classic cars. At least no one's likely to steal your Shelby Cobra when your house gets burglarized, and it won't generate any less income than gold.
 
These strawman arguments are getting old.

Oh, and by the way, it's not a straw man when it's a criticism of a site that one of your fellow goldbugs cited in defense of gold.

A straw man (note spelling) is when I respond to an argument that no one made. When I respond to an argument that you made, it's called "proving you wrong."
 
Oh, and by the way, it's not a straw man when it's a criticism of a site that one of your fellow goldbugs cited in defense of gold.

A straw man (note spelling) is when I respond to an argument that no one made. When I respond to an argument that you made, it's called "proving you wrong."

You are just piling on to a weak case. Gold as a hedge against complete societal collapse or disaster may be something somebody said on some website, and maybe even here on this thread, (although I don't recall reading that) but the entire argument presented both in the OP and by most other goldbugs here is about inflation.
 
Last edited:
The entire argument presented both in the OP and by most other goldbugs here is about inflation.

And when you point out how bad gold is as an inflation hedge, they start talking about how only gold will hold its value when society collapses.

It's not my fault that you chose to defend an investment theory that only an idiot would choose to defend....
 
And when you point out how bad gold is as an inflation hedge, they start talking about how only gold will hold its value when society collapses.

It's not my fault that you chose to defend an investment theory that only an idiot would choose to defend....

Why would somebody get so worked up over personal investment strategies? I'll invest my way, you invest your way, and may the wiser man come out ahead. The exchange of ideas on these strategies is not idiotic, nor is long term PM investing idiotic.
 
Why would somebody get so worked up over personal investment strategies?

Because this is an educational forum, and people, at least in theory, come here to learn things.

If they learn that "buy gold as an inflation hedge" is snake oil, then I've done my job as an educator.
 
Because this is an educational forum, and people, at least in theory, come here to learn things.

If they learn that "buy gold as an inflation hedge" is snake oil, then I've done my job as an educator.

Do you have to be so acerbic in your replies? It's just investing, and you are assuming a normal economic progression, whilst those advocating PM investment are assuming a more dramatic economic progression. Since neither can see into the future, it is based upon your perspective and assumptions about the future.

So you are arguing vehemently against something because of your particular view of what the future may hold. You may be wrong, and you should know you may be wrong, after all, this is a skeptic forum, and everyone knows the future is unpredictable.

So your reasoning for being so worked up over the issue, resorting to name calling over such nonsense is really unwarranted.
 
I don't really see any harm in having extra blankets, candles, and a case of Beefaroni in the basement for when that happens. If you want to go whole hog and throw a $50 propane stove in there as well,... well, then you don't have to eat cold Beefaroni.

When I was younger I used to eat beefaroni cold out of a can. That thought makes me feel ill but I'm sure a day of hunger would make it taste wonderful.
 
So here's another question. If you are worred about US hyperinflation why not invest in other currencies instead of gold? You could buy Euros or remnimibi or something.
 
Do you have to be so acerbic in your replies?

No. I choose to be so acerbic.

It's just investing,

That's right. It's real money, that you and your loved ones are probably going to need one day. 90% of your return comes not from picking the right instruments, but from picking the right investment strategy. And any investment strategy that involves the word "gold" is almost certainly going to be the wrong one and end up costing you real money.

and you are assuming a normal economic progression, whilst those advocating PM investment are assuming a more dramatic economic progression. Since neither can see into the future, it is based upon your perspective and assumptions about the future.


You may be wrong, and you should know you may be wrong, after all, this is a skeptic forum, and everyone knows the future is unpredictable.

It's not that unpredictable. And telling us "oh, you can't predict the future, so you have no way of knowing that my 100% in lottery tickets investment strategy that I advertise on late-night television won't work." And, yes, gold is every bit as wrong an investment as lottery tickets; even in a properly diversified portfolio, gold is simply dead weight that lowers your returns over the long or even the medium term.

And I see no reason to refrain from calling a dupe a dupe, or a snake oil salesman a snake oil salesman.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom