gold bull/bear survey

Where do you think the gold price is going?


  • Total voters
    138
Given your posting history, I'm not sure you could find it.

(In case I'm being too subtle, do a "find all posts" search on yourself and you'll get the joke.)

lulz, I get you alright ;) I avoid the place because I have zero interest in Rep / Dem debates, its all the same 2 headed snake IMO and I'd just get banned if I spoke my mind freely in there.

Well good luck with bud.

gracias, and you.
 
the trading mindset strongly flipped from bad=good (moar printing) to good=bad (less printing) as evidenced by the carnage in homebuilder stocks, even as positive data came in.

This is what is driving me nuts. I think you are right. Bad news is good, and good news is bad. wtf.

I guess that makes me a "contrarian" because I actually think that good news is good.
 
This is what is driving me nuts. I think you are right. Bad news is good, and good news is bad. wtf.

there's no doubt, this is what I meant when I said the markets are broken.


In the "new normal" as per chart 1, it is plain to see the relationship between ZIRP, stimulus (or threat/hint) of and the stock market.

ZIRP distorts price and valuation across all asset classes, and encourages speculation (carry) in areas that would not otherwise be viable.

in the new normal, this fine "recovery" we find ourselves in, investors are forced to basically choose between the prospect of continual money printing (risk on) and impending deflationary collapse episodes (risk off)

this is driven almost entirely by what central banks say, do, or say they are going to do, the market lunges up and down like a crack addict being offered and then denied their next hit continually.

of course market forces are present at all times, however there is no doubt that the primary driver of direction is what the Bernank and his European counterparts say or do on a daily basis.

have another chart from the WSJ

the relationship between price and CB expansion has not exactly gotten better since 2009 (chart 1)

what they have been focused on for quite some time is frontrunning the next CB moves, fundamentals dont matter while we're in this mode. until all of a sudden one day they do again.

I guess that makes me a "contrarian" because I actually think that good news is good.

:D ..if you were a trader, then yes, you very much would be.
 
Incidentally, did anyone define over what timescale our "bull" and "bear" are judged here?
 
Incidentally, did anyone define over what timescale our "bull" and "bear" are judged here?

here as in this thread? everybody has their own ideas I think lol.

this is the accepted understanding.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_trend

A market trend is a tendency of a financial market to move in a particular direction over time.[1] These trends are classified as secular for long time frames, primary for medium time frames, and secondary for short time frames.[2]
 
Kevsta: I have a question. Given the events of yesterday, do you see gold as a safe haven when markets get panicky? It still seems to me that when investors get nervous, it's greenbacks they want, not the yellow stuff.
 
Kevsta: I have a question. Given the events of yesterday, do you see gold as a safe haven when markets get panicky? It still seems to me that when investors get nervous, it's greenbacks they want, not the yellow stuff.

I don't really subscribe to the whole safe haven thing. and I also think there's a lot more going on than nervous investors wanting dollars.

needing.. maybe... remember, unintended consequences lurk everywhere from rapid 50% yield moves in bond markets in a few weeks. (US10YR 1.5-2.3)

http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/82d66636-d9ec-11e2-98fa-00144feab7de.html

A wave of selling caused many exchange traded funds to tumble below the value of their underlying assets as a bond market sell-off caused stress in the $2tn ETF industry.

ETFs track baskets of underlying assets, such as emerging-market stocks or municipal bonds, but discounts widened sharply on Thursday as dealers struggled to keep up with the sell orders.

“The losses for ETFs today were far beyond what the most sophisticated financial risk models could have predicated for worst-case scenarios,”
said Bryce James, president of Smart Portfolio, which provides ETF asset allocation models.

He added: “The falls violated risk tolerance levels for many investors and if they were leveraged at all they are likely facing capital calls.”
[Note, they are, hence needing dollars]

ETFs have been a boom product in recent years. They are bought
and sold as an equity but can hold a variety of assets that are less liquid than exchange traded stocks.

The heavy selling across global markets triggered the disruption in products that track less liquid assets such as municipals or securities in markets that are closed during parts of the US trading day.

More on ETFs

http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/7a21a69c-ceb4-11e2-ae25-00144feab7de.html#axzz2WkBYl6tb

http://sovereign-investor.com/2011/03/23/etfs-will-be-the-next-bubble-that-bursts/
 
Just curious...

...is anyone here profiting from the decline?

Lots of post hoc "explanations" of moves, but very little sound prediction that I can see.

I'm looking at taking physical delivery of some of my paper gold derivatives, since the fabrication costs are determined by the spot price. I'm not exactly "profiting" from the decline, but I am using it as an opportunity to trade in paper for the real thing.
 
Kevsta: I have a question. Given the events of yesterday, do you see gold as a safe haven when markets get panicky? It still seems to me that when investors get nervous, it's greenbacks they want, not the yellow stuff.

Puppycow, I have found the safe haven issue much more true when looking at other weaker currencies, especially the ZAR, not really in US$.

My gold holdings are up 27% over the last two years in my currency (ZAR) but is down 16% on the two year chart in US$.
 
this seeming relationship continues to intrigue me.

gold-aapl.png


on the one hand we have inert useless yield-less metal that one cannot eat.

on the other hand we have part ownership of (the?) financially most successful tech company ever thus far, values allegedly based on P/E, growth prospects and a whole career's worth of different business analysis topics with which to value it.

these 2 assets could not be more different in nature, yet there is clear correlation here.

does anybody have any theories about why this might be?
 
Is there a term "pattern fitting" or did I just make it up?

Otherwise, it looks like just pain "cherry picking", unless it holds equally well for different time frames.

Can we see the same chart going back to 1990?
 
Is there a term "pattern fitting" or did I just make it up?

Otherwise, it looks like just pain "cherry picking", unless it holds equally well for different time frames.

Can we see the same chart going back to 1990?

unfortunately not, as far back as it will zoom on the charts is 1995, done again for you here
 
could you explain this in layman's terms please? dont think I get it.
There is a trade off between the demand for cash and the demand for things you can buy with it. When people are spending money, prices rise and vice versa.

The fact that the price of both gold and the tech company in your chart have fallen this year suggests that the demand for cash is rising faster than Bernanke can print it. This is further evidenced by the record low yields for bonds. People are buying bonds (which have a fixed cash value) in preference to stocks and commodities.

You can also take into account the fact that the Feds money printing is not leading to the usual deposit expansion. People aren't borrowing money (which is what you do if you want to spend it). They are holding onto their cash instead.

I don't understand this confidence in the USD - I'm just interpreting the data.
 
Last edited:
There is a trade off between the demand for cash and the demand for things you can buy with it. When people are spending money, prices rise and vice versa.

The fact that the price of both gold and the tech company in your chart have fallen this year suggests..

technically it's not (as) in sync from the top downwards as for the previous 9 years, although on the big picture it looks close here, but gold peaked and topped in 2011 and AAPL a year later, one seems to lead the other by a 6 months / 1 year-ish period.

what strikes me more than the topping though is the whole drift and then acceleration into parabola from 2000's onwards.

it certainly looks to me as though there is a greater overall market trend force at work across entirely different asset classes?

that the demand for cash is rising faster than Bernanke can print it. This is further evidenced by the record low yields for bonds. People are buying bonds (which have a fixed cash value) in preference to stocks and commodities.

and so the reverse applied 2000 onwards? Bernank (Greenspan)was printing more than people wanted, so they spent it on anything and everything in different asset classes?

You can also take into account the fact that the Feds money printing is not leading to the usual deposit expansion. People aren't borrowing money (which is what you do if you want to spend it). They are holding onto their cash instead.

this is because the Fed's printing has always been with attempted reflation of the Shadow Bank system in mind and nothing to do with price stability or unemployment. They'll actually stop printing when the Shadow banking system isn't threatening continued implosion should they stop.

I don't understand this confidence in the USD - I'm just interpreting the data.

hmm. not sure confidence is the right word.
 
Some potentially bad news for gold:
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-...ear-record-low-as-fed-risk-slows-inflows.html

Gold Demand

The All India Gems & Jewellery Trade Federation, a group that represents about 300,000 gold jewelers, manufacturers, wholesalers, retailers and distributors, will send notices to members asking them to halt sales of coins and bars to retail investors until the current-account gap stabilizes, Chairman Haresh Soni said by phone from New Delhi yesterday. The curbs may reduce demand by about 20 percent in the world’s largest bullion consumer, he said.

http://www.moneycontrol.com/news/commodities/five-reasonsgold-will-plunge-further_905101.html

Five reasons why gold will plunge further

Might be a good time to sell some gold to reduce your exposure to further losses.

ETA: not to say I told you so, but I did post about this before the recent plunge:
Regarding the price of gold, this might be bad news for gold bulls:

Gold Imports by India Tumbling as Curbs Boost Titan’s Costs
I think that gold is down about $100 since I posted that. India is the biggest buyer of gold in the world. China's CB could put a crimp in it too. I really think now is not the time to be too exposed to gold (or silver).
 
Last edited:
Some potentially bad news for gold:
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-...ear-record-low-as-fed-risk-slows-inflows.html

http://www.moneycontrol.com/news/commodities/five-reasonsgold-will-plunge-further_905101.html

Might be a good time to sell some gold to reduce your exposure to further losses.

ETA: not to say I told you so, but I did post about this before the recent plunge:

I think that gold is down about $100 since I posted that. India is the biggest buyer of gold in the world. China's CB could put a crimp in it too. I really think now is not the time to be too exposed to gold (or silver).

thanks for your concern, genuinely, but I would point you to one of my favourite books (Page 47 onwards)

Old Turkey would cock his head to one side, contemplate his fellow customer with a fatherly smile, and finally he would say very impressively,

"You know, it's a bull market!"

Time and again I heard him say,

"Well, this is a bull market, you know!"

as though he were giving to you a priceless talisman wrapped up in a million-dollar accident-insurance policy. And of course I did not get his meaning.

however having been so wrong from $1500 so far, I do think it would be prudent for me to maybe hedge my holdings in the Futures for a while on the next bounce.

and this is actually a tiny trade in real life, ie the amount of real ounces I own is relatively miniscule compared to what you can trade on leverage with a $5000 account.

and I think the plan will just be to take $profits from shorts and recycle into metals at ever lower prices anyway because the mining industry is in virtual meltdown at the moment due to prices, and it will reverse, *somewhere*
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom