gold bull/bear survey

Where do you think the gold price is going?


  • Total voters
    138
Make sure you also pick your currency properly to ensure that your position is enhanced.

sarcasm aside, it would appear to make quite a difference where you are from, between say these two? how interested do we think the Japanese are in the USD "price"? also this chart appears to disagree with "gold doesn't like deflation" too, doesn't it?

nikkei-gold.png


and note the current convergence in USD performance with equities here.

dow-gold.png


interesting huh? the goldbugs clearly couldn't be allowed to be continually correct and heckle the CBs with gold breaking out to new all time highs as they start to go all-in desperation tactics.
 
Last edited:
I think I was educated on this site that collectibles may be taxed at a higher rate than other investments, and that gold and silver bullion and coins are considered collectibles.

Short term traders (less than a year) are not affected, paying their marginal rate regardless on short term capital gains. Long term traders are penalized, paying the 28% capital gains rate on collectibles, compared to 15% for other asset classes.
I'm pretty sure I am the one who posted that.

So why was what was originally money outlawed through executive order 6102 by FDR, what followed as money sharply devalued subsequent to that, and then all promises to redeem in the metal to foreign countries broken by Nixon in 1971?

On top of that, the government has the gall to tax what was originally its money at a usurious "collectible" rate and thus heavily discourage its ownership versus competing paper and electronic investments.

So the government, Wall Street, and most of the forum denizens here obviously hate and mock gold, a barbarously inert yellow metal on the periodic table of elements. The question is why?

The answer, is that the profits of fiat money are virtually limitless, and those who benefit from those profits (or, sometimes incorrectly think they benefit), will stop at nothing to preserve them.
 
It's now $1328.81, down almost 3% in one day!

Edit: dropping so fast I can't keep up. Now down to $1320.14, -3.42%!!!
 

Attachments

  • 1328 6-20-13.jpg
    1328 6-20-13.jpg
    125.2 KB · Views: 3
Last edited:
yes indeed, looks like today is going to be a big day one way or the other for Gold.

it's a good job the world is all fixed now though, and it's not like Bernanke losing control of interest rates at the same time as the fraudulent Chinese statistics become clear and their shadow banking system is imploding, is any cause for concern or anything..

gold is going down, therefore all is well in the world..
 
Last edited:
yes indeed, looks like today is going to be a big day one way or the other for Gold.

it's a good job the world is all fixed now though, and it's not like Bernanke losing control of interest rates at the same time as the fraudulent Chinese statistics become clear and their shadow banking system is imploding, is any cause for concern or anything..

gold is going down, therefore all is well in the world..

You planning on spinning any of that straw man into gold there Rumplestiltskin?
 
You planning on spinning any of that straw man into gold there Rumplestiltskin?

do you mean that you disagree with the statements, or that you don't understand them and the underlying market forces therefore implied, and you'd like me to elaborate?
 
And we have a new 52-week low: $1304.

http://www.bloomberg.com/quote/XAUUSD:CUR

Currently at $1309.

Kev, I hope I don't come off as if I'm gloating about this or something. I'm just following it with interest. I don't claim to know which way the price will go although I admit to being skeptical of the bullish case. I'm not invested either short or long in gold so whichever way it goes doesn't affect me. (Actually I do have a small investment in some mining interests, so I guess the price of gold does probably affect a part of my investment portfolio, but I don't directly invest in the commodity itself.)
 
Last edited:
do you mean that you disagree with the statements, or that you don't understand them and the underlying market forces therefore implied, and you'd like me to elaborate?

Are you unfamiliar with the concept of a straw man? No one enjoying a little schadenfreude at the expense of gold bugs thinks, and I quote:

it's a good job the world is all fixed now though, and it's not like Bernanke losing control of interest rates at the same time as the fraudulent Chinese statistics become clear and their shadow banking system is imploding, is any cause for concern or anything..

gold is going down, therefore all is well in the world..​

Capice?
 
Just curious...

...is anyone here profiting from the decline?

Lots of post hoc "explanations" of moves, but very little sound prediction that I can see.
 
And we have a new 52-week low: $1304.

http://www.bloomberg.com/quote/XAUUSD:CUR

Currently at $1309.

Kev, I hope I don't come off as if I'm gloating about this or something. I'm just following it with interest. I don't claim to know which way the price will go although I admit to being skeptical of the bullish case. I'm not invested either short or long in gold so whichever way it goes doesn't affect me. (Actually I do have a small investment in some mining interests, so I guess the price of gold does probably affect a part of my investment portfolio, but I don't directly invest in the commodity itself.)

your figures are a bit delayed, currently 1290's

s7z5n.png


the 2 orange ovals mark triangle resolutions, last weeks one broke downwards eventually and tracked the previous downtrendline, before again compressing into the triangle formed by the lower trendline, and then when that one failed broke down convincingly.

- $90 more and you could have taken one of my silver coins off me ;) and of course this now confirms that the previous rallies were also DCBs (new lower lows)

and don't worry, I don't take it like that. I was looking at this again yesterday, another 30ish % drop and I will be back to my zero point (in GBP) from 2009, but I've done very well using it to buy discounted things along the way, if I sold back at breakeven (£600GBP) I'm over 25% up on things bought (effectively free) along the way, I could live happily with just that, if I had to.
 
Are you unfamiliar with the concept of a straw man? No one enjoying a little schadenfreude at the expense of gold bugs thinks, and I quote:

it's a good job the world is all fixed now though, and it's not like Bernanke losing control of interest rates at the same time as the fraudulent Chinese statistics become clear and their shadow banking system is imploding, is any cause for concern or anything..

gold is going down, therefore all is well in the world..

Capice?

no not really, you still need to tell me more precisely what "no one" thinks:

does no-one think that Bernanke has lost control of interest rates?
does no one think there is fraudulent reporting of "growth" from China, (and just now clearly reflected in overnight figures?)
does no one think that the Chinese banking and shadow banking system is in a liquidity crisis, that the PBOC doesn't want to help with, due to inflation?
does no one think that liquidity crises cause major across the board selloffs?
does no one think that gold is the standard go-to, to raise liquidity when things are blowing up?
does no one think that because gold is going down, all is well in the world? (ie. its all fixed and recovering)

I know what I think, I think its not over by a long way and day to day noise is just that, but I struggle to know what everyone else thinks, unfortunately.

http://www.businessinsider.com/global-financial-markets-are-selling-off-2013-6
 
no not really, you still need to tell me more precisely what "no one" thinks:

If you find continuing this exchange prodcutive, enjoy it. I posted what I posted. You can take it however you want. You can think whatever you want.

I - and others - will just sit back and enjoy a little shadenfreude at the expense of gold bugs. It will be all the better as they lash out at straw men.
 
If you find continuing this exchange prodcutive, enjoy it. I posted what I posted. You can take it however you want. You can think whatever you want.

I - and others - will just sit back and enjoy a little shadenfreude at the expense of gold bugs. It will be all the better as they lash out at straw men.

ah, so basically just trolling then, ok no worries. I do find it interesting such activities please you, as you may be aware I basically consider gold my currency, much like you consider the USD, yours.

So maybe I should start ShadyFraudening the USA politics forum once in a while trolling you guys about the US Dollar index while you lose 3-5% of your purchasing power that day. would you care?

Mr Ramjets lost 4% of his worth denominated in AUD yesterday too, when priced in USD. (do you care Ramjets?) possibly he is a little more interested in the China angle than you anyway.

I dont consider my original paragraph that you quoted "lashing out" really, more sarcastic commentary on the idiocy of centrally planned markets and confidence in their eventual come-uppence arriving one way or the other.

hence I don't think gold's longterm bull market is over over quite yet.

..was what you were really supposed to infer from that.
 
I know what I think, I think its not over by a long way and day to day noise is just that, but I struggle to know what everyone else thinks, unfortunately.

http://www.businessinsider.com/global-financial-markets-are-selling-off-2013-6

Well here's what I think, fwiw. It's true certainly true that it's not just gold, there's a selloff today in all the major asset classes: stocks, bonds and commodities. However the amount of change seems to be larger for precious metals than for the other assets. The others are down around 2-3% whereas gold and silver are down 5-7%. You often hear gold described as a "safe haven". And probably sometimes it is. But not right now, clearly. Right now the US dollar seems to be the "safe haven" of choice.

The question is though, why is everyone selling right now? Is it because of what Bernanke said? If so, it seems like an overreaction to me. There is no tightening yet, and tightening will only come if things continue to improve. Is it because of the latest disappointing economic report from China? If so, that also seems like an overreaction, because the response is worldwide. I realize that globalization means that China's economy affects everyone else's but it still seems like a bit of an overreaction to suddenly sell everything from bonds to gold on this one report. So I think that markets will stop freaking out and get over it. It' just panic feeding on itself.

One interesting thing is that Friday is a quadruple witching day, if that means anything. Supposedly it means that trading volume will be heavier than usual on Friday. I don't know if that's a good thing or a bad thing for the markets.
 
Last edited:
ah, so basically just trolling then, ok no worries. I do find it interesting such activities please you, as you may be aware I basically consider gold my currency, much like you consider the USD, yours.

:goat

So maybe I should start ShadyFraudening the USA politics forum...

Given your posting history, I'm not sure you could find it.

(In case I'm being too subtle, do a "find all posts" search on yourself and you'll get the joke.)

hence I don't think gold's longterm bull market is over over quite yet.

Well good luck with bud.
 
The question is though, why is everyone selling right now?

in my opinion yesterday was primarily driven by the liquidity crunch in the Chinese banking system, with overtones of eventual tapering setting the mood, but not really being the prime drivers yesterday.

we are in short term agreement here that "tapering" isn't imminent, he couldn't have made more effort to stress that even the *possibility* of slowing the easing is data dependent, but this is how addicted to stimulus the equity markets are now.

my opinion is that the Fed will increase next, not decrease, and this will be a total game-changer with almost the whole world facing the wrong way in their trades.

when people say "markets are forward looking" there is some truth to that. a better way of putting it is that markets always attempt to frontrun the next big move.

so they've been frontrunning the Fed (and BOJ etc) all the way up, but if they feel the Fed might start backing away, or worse still lose control, then the frontrunning will work even more effectively on the way back down again.

the trading mindset strongly flipped from bad=good (moar printing) to good=bad (less printing) as evidenced by the carnage in homebuilder stocks, even as positive data came in. this sums up yesterdays mood IMO

Since we lost the deer yesterday as it was run over by bond sellers, it appears everyone else came to the realization that QE cannot be infinite, that EU event risk never went away, and that China does have a credit bubble

Where-ever we look today there is carnage. The superlatives are all extreme but are the biggest since Europe collapsed in October/November 2011 (preceding the coordinated global central bank bailout) - 1-day and 2-day drops in stocks the biggest in 19 months, Gold and Silver's second largest 1-day drop in 20 months, investment-grade and high-yield credit's worst 1-day and 2-day widening in 19 months, EM currencies (e.g. MXN) worst day in 19 months, Copper's worst day in 19 months, and the heaviest volume day in S&P futures in 20 months
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom