gold bull/bear survey

Where do you think the gold price is going?


  • Total voters
    138
yes of course, this was only just to illustrate these points that:

a) there is no one answer to that

Gold is priced in dollars so a discussion about the price of gold should really relate to its price in gold. Discussing its price in any other currency then makes it a conversation about both the price of gold and currency fluctuations.

b) nobody EVER once comes on these threads asking how much they would have made during the times they were up, do they? :rolleyes:

People who are making money from their investments are usually pretty good at advertising this as a way to validate their ideas and methods without being asked about it. OTOH they tend to clam up when their investments start to fall.
 
Gold is priced in dollars so a discussion about the price of gold should really relate to its price in gold. Discussing its price in any other currency then makes it a conversation about both the price of gold and currency fluctuations.

actually I agree with your typo here, so (didn't) FTFY :D but you meant dollars didnt you, not priced in gold?

gold is only priced in USD to buy if you are American or trading it (paper, not real) through the Western exchanges.

when the vast majority of actual physical gold demand is from rest of (not western) world nations, I suspect the whole USD thing is less important than you think to much of the world's physical gold investment community.
 
actually I agree with your typo here, so (didn't) FTFY :D but you meant dollars didnt you, not priced in gold?

Yes, hurp-durp. :o

But if we're talking about the price of gold in isolation then I think it's only fair to talk about its price in dollars.

Someone converting yen to dollars a couple of years ago and invested in gold will have had their currency gains wiped out by their commodity losses (or their commodity losses offset by their currency gains). Either way, in retrospect they'd have been better off doing the currency conversion and either put the money in a US bank or just keep it under their mattress.

Unless we remove currency from the equation I'm sure we could find some currency in which even the worst investment looks good. It's like claiming that the Nikkei isn't tanking as badly as it is if you used dollars to invest in it.
 
Last edited:
Regarding the price of gold, this might be bad news for gold bulls:

Gold Imports by India Tumbling as Curbs Boost Titan’s Costs

it could be, or on the other hand, markets might just be markets like usual.

they're not that bothered what colour they are, and they dont generally give a [naughty word] about government's wishes :)

http://goldnews.bullionvault.com/gold-bullion-061120136

INDIA'S increased duty on gold imports from 6% to 8% has seen a rising amount of smuggling, custom officials have reported.

Two men were found smuggling 2.6 kilograms of gold worth $110,000 at the IGI airport in Delhi. A man from Uttar Pradesh was also arrested, carrying gold worth $35,000 hidden as silver coloured pins on the box of a TV he was legally importing from Dubai.

The pins were checked and found to be gold. In another event, a resident of Karnataka was found trying to smuggle 1.9 kg of gold jewellery wrapped around his legs.

India is the world's biggest gold bullion consumer. In the past 18 months, the tax on gold imports has gone from 2% to 8% in the hope of reducing inflows, blamed as the main reason for India's current account deficit.

The rise in import duty has had little impact, however. According to Reserve Bank of India data, in May 2013 India imported 162 tonne of gold versus 142 tonne in April.

if the people want it enough, they'll get it anyway.
 
Yes, hurp-durp. :o

But if we're talking about the price of gold in isolation then I think it's only fair to talk about its price in dollars.

Someone converting yen to dollars a couple of years ago and invested in gold will have had their currency gains wiped out by their commodity losses (or their commodity losses offset by their currency gains). Either way, in retrospect they'd have been better off doing the currency conversion and either put the money in a US bank or just keep it under their mattress.

I disagree, gold was around millions of years before dollars, and will be around millions of years after them. (Non-American) people buying gold in other currencies own gold, and don't care about what it's dollar price is, they care about what their currency price is.

for example there were longish periods of months a while back where we were seeing daily GBP and EUR new highs, while USD was languishing a bit, before the big USD spike happened. how much did Europeans and British care about the USD price? personally, not at all. :D

and while I understand your argument that it is currently the "standard" mechanism, I think measuring history's traditional, and currently unofficial global reserve currency (and it would be again if everything blew up tomorrow, would it not?) with just one "jelly ruler" leads to a flawed perception.
 
On 4 August as 2011 far as I can see it was $1,670/oz

It rose to $1,880/oz or thereabouts later that month

Current spot is around $1,380/oz

Remember to factor in any charges when calculating your profit ;)

I think I'll factor in lost dividends and/or interest as well. :D
 
Remember to factor in any charges when calculating your profit ;)

I recall when Planet Money bought a gold coin and then sold it 6 months later, they lost money even though the price of gold was higher when they sold it than when they bought it. This is because the dealer had a profit margin when he sold it to them and another profit margin when they sold it back to him. The price has go up by a lot to make a profit. If it stays the same or only goes up a little, you actually lose money on the dealer's margin.
 
I recall when Planet Money bought a gold coin and then sold it 6 months later, they lost money even though the price of gold was higher when they sold it than when they bought it. This is because the dealer had a profit margin when he sold it to them and another profit margin when they sold it back to him. The price has go up by a lot to make a profit. If it stays the same or only goes up a little, you actually lose money on the dealer's margin.

with actual lumps of it from shops yes. there are other options for allocated physical though, it costs me 1.0% round trip total (to buy in and sell out again) and 0.12% per annum storage.

pretty meaningless in the grand scheme of a secular bull run.
 
I think I was educated on this site that collectibles may be taxed at a higher rate than other investments, and that gold and silver bullion and coins are considered collectibles.

Short term traders (less than a year) are not affected, paying their marginal rate regardless on short term capital gains. Long term traders are penalized, paying the 28% capital gains rate on collectibles, compared to 15% for other asset classes.

http://beginnersinvest.about.com/od/capitalgainstax/ss/capital-gains-tax-rates_4.htm

Of course, one can simply "not mention" the gains on their taxes. Depending on how you bought and sold your gold or silver, the government may not have a way to track your gains. But you do become an instant felon if you go down that road, and "don't do the crime if you can't do the time" may apply.

Finally, you could use my strategy to avoid taxes on collectibles - just never sell them! Let you heirs worry about it down he road, and they may skate, inheriting the gold or silver at the stepped-up (hopefully) basis as of your date of death.

But long term strategies do not stoke a trader's need for action, so I suppose none of this makes much difference to a trader/speculator.
 
Last edited:
I think I was educated on this site that collectibles may be taxed at a higher rate than other investments, and that gold and silver billion and coins are considered collectibles.

Short term traders (less than a year) are not affected, paying their marginal rate regardless on short term capital gains. Long term traders are penalized, paying the 28% capital gains rate on collectibles, compared to 15% for other asset classes.

http://beginnersinvest.about.com/od/capitalgainstax/ss/capital-gains-tax-rates_4.htm

Of course, one can simply "not mention" the gains on their taxes. Depending on how you bought and sold your gold or silver, the government may not have a way to track your gains. But you do become an instant felon if you go down that road, and "don't do the crime if you can't do the time" may apply.

Finally, you could use my strategy to avoid taxes on collectibles - just never sell them! Let you heirs worry about it down he road, and they may skate, inheriting the gold or silver at the stepped-up (hopefully) basis as of your date of death.

But long term strategies do not stoke a trader's need for action, so I suppose none of this makes much difference to a trader/speculator.

yea, they've already got some pretty oppressive special treatment for PMs in place in the US, don't they. they also banned USA citizens from trading gold & silver futures on leverage in 2011 didn't they. you lot obviously can't be trusted :D

for UK citizens it's standard rate cap gains rate payable on any profits withdrawn over the annual 10k GBP threshold, in any one year.
 
haha no, I'm a UK citizen, but have emigrated to a better place. so no, thankfully, your laws are not mine.

If you're in the EU somewhere (I'm not asking where - I don't want to know) I presume that there is some kind of tax on capital gains.
 
If you're in the EU somewhere (I'm not asking where - I don't want to know) I presume that there is some kind of tax on capital gains.

you don't want to know? yes I'm in the EU, a sunny bit. :)

but actually my finances are (just) re registering through the UK again now, as opposed to my host countries oppressive tax regime for the last few years, primarily because the UK will let me trade "spread bet" entirely capital gains tax free moving forwards.

http://www.alpari.co.uk/products/financial-spread-betting

my current host country dont have any spreadbetting loopholes, but worse still require tax to be paid on profits in the trading account whether you withdraw any or not!!!! they are completely insane, nobody is going to do that when you might (in theory) lose it all again the next week.
 
Parasite :p

I, on the other hand, would be pleased to pay tax on my capital gains if only I was liable *



* - most of our investments that could get capital gains are in tax efficient vehicles like PEPs and ISAs **
** - apart from property but it's unlikely that we'd be selling our investment properties any time soon and we have a stupid amount of cash
 
Last edited:
Parasite :p

I, on the other hand, would be pleased to pay tax on my capital gains if only I was liable *

well this is the point, given that I have to throw tax money into somebody's black hole of debt, I'd rather contribute to the country who regard dangerous gambling with your hard earned money as "not-liable" should you ever happen to win.

the counter is that you cant offset losses either.
 
I recall when Planet Money bought a gold coin and then sold it 6 months later, they lost money even though the price of gold was higher when they sold it than when they bought it. This is because the dealer had a profit margin when he sold it to them and another profit margin when they sold it back to him. The price has go up by a lot to make a profit. If it stays the same or only goes up a little, you actually lose money on the dealer's margin.

Dallas Gold and Silver Exchange has a couple of locations on D-FW. One that used to be near where I lived would sell uncirculated silver American Eagles a little over spot. I wish I'd purchased more from them and then sold them to coin dealers/collectors willing to pay the numismatic price.
 
Dallas Gold and Silver Exchange has a couple of locations on D-FW. One that used to be near where I lived would sell uncirculated silver American Eagles a little over spot. I wish I'd purchased more from them and then sold them to coin dealers/collectors willing to pay the numismatic price.

looks like some of these guys might be interested in buying from you too?

http://usa.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2013-06/12/content_16611576.htm

The promotion attracted nearly 10,000 people who rushed to the store despite restricting each customer's shopping time to 15 minutes. While gold markets in the US and Europe saw panic selling, China has just seen a surge in gold sales in the past few months

and the TFMetals thoughts on it. http://www.tfmetalsreport.com/blog/4779/considering-chinese-demand

We also know that officially reported Chinese imports are soaring. In just the first four months of this year, China has imported through Hong Kong nearly 500 metric tonnes of gold. This adds to the 834 metric tonnes that they imported in calendar year 2012. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-...om-hong-kong-gain-to-all-time-high-in-12.html

...

Me: "Andy, where the heck is all this gold going?"

Andy: "It's not going anywhere."

Me: "What do you mean?"

Andy: "I mean exactly that. Shanghai settles all that bullion each day to domestic wholesalers. That metal is then shipped off to Chinese dealers and refiners for domestic consumption."

Me: "So wait a minute. You're telling me that public demand in China is currently soaking up 250 metric tonnes per month or nearly ALL of the publicly-reported global mine supply?"

Andy: "Exactly."

And then I started thinking...Well how hard would that be to do?

250 metric tonnes is about 8,000,000 troy ounces. The current population of China is 1.344 billion. If only 25% of the population is taking their government up on the idea of gold ownership, that's 336,000,000 people or, roughly, an amount equivalent to the entire population of the United States!

So now let's say that these 336,000,000 people buy, on average, 1/40th of an ounce every month. That works out to be about 3/4 of a gram or about $35 worth at $1400/ounce. Working the math backward we get: 336,000,000 people buying .75 grams = 252,000,000 grams and 252,000,000 grams = 252 metric tonnes.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom