gold bull/bear survey

Where do you think the gold price is going?


  • Total voters
    138
This is completely absurd. The gold I own is in the form of British sovereigns and half sovereigns. These are legal tender in the UK. That is why no VAT is payable on them, and why no capital gains tax is charged on them. They have been coins of the realm, exactly the same as they are today, since Queen Victoria was on the throne. You are seriously trying to convince the people reading this thread that I am stuck in a buyback arrangement? As for "scrapes", the coins I bought are mixed year bullion coins in good to fair condition - they are of no interest to coin collectors, and nobody is recording how scraped the coins are. Nobody is going to refuse to accept them because they are scraped and deliberately defacing them is illegal in the UK.

Right now, I expect that just about any bullion dealer in the country would buy those coins off me at near to spot price. I'd be bonkers to sell them if I don't have to, and the dealer would be well aware of this.

Last week it was still possible to buy gold by post for next day delivery in the UK. This week it is not, because the dealers are both running out of bullion and quite happy to sit on any remaining stock because they know where the price is going....

I didn't even look at the premiums they're charging you on the coins since I assumed you were buying bars. You should be able to resell your coins at a moderate discount because there's very little risk associated with them. Those aren't what the deep discounters are buying, though, and I think you knew that already.

At what price are you going to sell your bullion coins?
 
Originally Posted by kevsta
also, could a couple of the 45 odd Gold bears express opinions on this question from page 3 please?


I didn't vote in the poll -- didn't even view the results -- mostly because none of the options quite capture my outlook (ie; 1-2 year weakness, but 3-5 year still bull market).


I think I gave a meager scenario in this post, but I really don't even care what the after-the-fact explanations may look like.

If it happens, armchair explanations will abound.

I know you're probably looking for more detailed causal reasons, but I'm just trying to make money. (I would like to think that this is everyone's goal, but I'm know better).

.

Bears never comment on gold threads apart from a hit and run. There is still money to be made in gold but it's largely from offering deep discounts for scrap and selling to bullion dealers. That requires capital unavailable to casual investors like us.

On the flip side, many of the bulls are late in their predictions and sometimes by as much as two decades:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=6729507&postcount=479

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=6729541&postcount=480

Nobody really wants to defend their position when they risk being wrong. Tippit has readily admitted that his crystal ball is outdated or at least unfalsifiable and most of the bulls here are saying the same thing. That kind of uncertainty from strong gold promoters is at least puzzling.
 
I think that given the global fundamentals behind this bull run are way worse than last time, there's a long way to go yet.

if it fizzled out now it would be a rather lame bull run compared to the last one, and compared to other asset classes bull markets too.



IMO this is what's behind the bull, add another $2.4 trillion to the Y axis here and extrapolate the new price.

 
I think that given the global fundamentals behind this bull run are way worse than last time, there's a long way to go yet.

if it fizzled out now it would be a rather lame bull run compared to the last one, and compared to other asset classes bull markets too.

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_178524e450fd59d269.gif[/qimg]

IMO this is what's behind the bull, add another $2.4 trillion to the Y axis here and extrapolate the new price.

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_178524e450f82b5875.jpg[/qimg]

My sentiments exactly. The essence of a bull run is displayed here. We KNOW that there is a lag time between the effect of increasing M3 on the dollar's value, and thus there is a "buying time" for gold at a lower price in dollars, before it reaches the "correct", or equilibrated, price.

In other words, as long as you are buying on the upcurve, you can't go wrong. The upcurve is based on the continued frenzied printing of money. The assumption is that gold really does not change one fraction in value.

But this is based on fundamentals, not some wacko reading of the chart.

brief review of the statistics on this issue is here.

http://dollardeathspiral.blogspot.com/2010/04/us-debt-vs-gold-price-linear-regression.html
 
Last edited:
by "wacko reading of" do you mean chart technicals? if so Im in full agreement.

My sentiments exactly. The essence of a bull run is displayed here. We KNOW that there is a lag time between the effect of increasing M3 on the dollar's value, and thus there is a "buying time" for gold at a lower price in dollars, before it reaches the "correct", or equilibrated, price.

In other words, as long as you are buying on the upcurve, you can't go wrong.

But this is based on fundamentals, not some wacko reading of the chart.
 
by "wacko reading of" do you mean chart technicals? if so Im in full agreement.
Yes, as the terms are typically used.

I think a lot of the people who are skeptical about gold think of it in terms of chart technicals, and not as investing on fundamentals. This is not a complex subject in business practice, but it is complex when human pyschology gets involved.

For example. The same McDonalds manager who would never predict a continued 5% per month rise in his volume sales will believe based on "reading the chart" that his favorite stock pick (or precious metal) will go up 5% per month by way of his "reading the chart".

But I'm not seeing anyone here labeled as "goldbug" who has fallen prey to the chart technicals mythologies.
 
But I'm not seeing anyone here labeled as "goldbug" who has fallen prey to the chart technicals mythologies.

Agreed. Goldbugs, usually at least, are people who are in it for the long game and who make decisions based on wide-scale, macroscopic observations of where human civilisation as we know it is heading. They aren't interested in chart technicals. They are for day-traders and month-traders....
 
please define: goldbug ? - and presumably then, you are a paperbug?

Did you read what he said?

Right now, gold is a one-way bet. It can only go up. The only question is how far, and how fast.

This kind of attitude can only be described as that of someone who assumed nothing could possibly go wrong with a gold investment. This is clearly a deluded attitude, hence the attachment of the label "goldbug".
 
Did you read what he said?



This kind of attitude can only be described as that of someone who assumed nothing could possibly go wrong with a gold investment. This is clearly a deluded attitude, hence the attachment of the label "goldbug".

Ahhh...no, see my post #189.
 
Last edited:
This kind of attitude can only be described as that of someone who assumed nothing could possibly go wrong with a gold investment. This is clearly a deluded attitude, hence the attachment of the label "goldbug".

First, I don't believe swapping fiat (soon-to-be-toilet-)paper fiat money for gold to be an "investment". Gold isn't an investment; it is money.

Second, I don't believe nothing could go wrong. There's always some degree of security issue, and there's always a possibility that the government will confiscate everybodys bullion during some future phase of this monetary crisis. The only certainty I have is that the US, along with much of the rest of the western world, is drowning under a massive pile of debt at the same time that peak oil is killing off the prospects of long-term economic growth. There aren't many possible responses to this situation, and all those responses I can think of would cause the price of gold to go up over the longer-term.

What we have at the moment is a situation where all "normal" investments look risky, because the monetary system itself is not stable.
 
What is lacking in such economic conditions is a stable "measure of value". In numerous cases of hyperinflation or other styles of collapse historically, the local currency collapsed but the measure of stability remained the USD. Here and now, forget that. It's not likely another currency takes this position, but instead we'll have a big continually changing mix of them...all with somewhat unknown futures and values.

Why? Because that's what "THEY" want. That makes the uncertainties hard or impossible to compute, and thus, "their" currency retains value and usage.

To understand this, consider that a flight to gold, commodities, or bitcoins is an end run around the world monetary systems. All of these "flights to safety" are greatly simplified due to the internet. All of these are enemies of the monetary systems. None of the many plausible "flights to safety" available with the internet are at this time clearly understood, and many have not yet arisen.

Why is that, you ask?

Inflation, the great destroyer of money's value, has two components (A) amount of money printed or ratio between that existing in the past and the future (B) the velocity of circulation of the currency. One striking component of a hyperinflation is the acceleration of velocity, because people hold money only for short times. They get their paycheck, rush to cash it and transfer the value into hard goods.

Any of the anti-monetary systems mentioned above, or any other things serving such a purpose, including alternative currencies, dramatically increase velocity in the currency being considered at the moment. Thus, the net of consumer actions to preserve wealth can destroy the value of currency. And arguably should, in many circumstances.

Ultimately, then the enemy of organized monetary systems is the individual consumer. The WWW reshaped the planet, and shifted the balance of power between nations and individuals. Yet to come, but inevitable, is a "WWW of money", in which the value of the individual is not subject to arbitrary spending of a local government.

In the meantime we....
 
Last edited:
....If you do pull down those books, I'd be interested in hearing what you find.

.
One of the best, and long, long, long out of print, books on the Weimer Republic economy is available on the web.

Fascinating reading, does have info on how bond prices tracked during the incipent hyperinflation. The few old copies that have shown up on Amazon or Ebay went for $300-700 each.

"Dying of Money".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom