gold bull/bear survey

Where do you think the gold price is going?


  • Total voters
    138
Sure, apologies for derailing.

ok, I wasnt aware of your previous experience of the poster and thought you were implying that a belief in the inevitable demise of this fiat ($ reserve) system was as credible and /or as likely as 911 being an inside job, and therefore to discount anyone who thinks either.

and the next 10 centuries? :)

anyone want to bet me 1 Oz of silver that it wont happen (I'm saying it will) inside of the next 10 years?
 
I disagree.

I think that it is possible to believe nonsense on one subject, and be a realist about another. Some subjects are somehow related.

I know a lady with a whole collection of books by Char (the medium), she is also one of the best investors I know.

However, in this case the lady uses Char as a bit of spiritual escapism, she doesn't call the Char hotline to ask which stock she should buy. those decisions are made on the basis of reliable data.

But in the example above one can assume that opinions about 9-11 and the fed are closely related. And come from the same mindset.
We have seen enough truthers and such on these board, to know that they often hold a set of opinions.

Usually people who think that 9-11 was a conspiracy, think that fiat currency is a conspiracy.

Not saying that this is true for the poster above, of course.

Although, the avatar referencing 'They Live' is probably also an indication of his world view.
WHAT??? I OBJECT.

"They Live" is one of the finest cult classics around, when it went on moratorium copies were selling used for close to $100. I periodically re watch it (not too often, only twice a day) between emerging from the bunker to buying boxes of sunglasses and ammo.

;)

In fact, given They Live, Delicatessan, Brazil, and Idiocracy, what other educational materials does one need?
 
Last edited:
WHAT??? I OBJECT.

"They Live" is one of the finest cult classics around, when it went on moratorium copies were selling used for close to $100. I periodically re watch it (not too often, only twice a day) between emerging from the bunker to buying boxes of sunglasses and ammo.

;)

In fact, given They Live, Delicatessan, Brazil, and Idiocracy, what other educational materials does one need?

The Matrix, of course.

Take the red pill, man.

;)
 
In the end, your comment is a red herring and misses the point entirely. Hopefully you knew that when you typed it.

It is not a red herring. People are saying "gold is money". It is not. If you can't buy something with it without going to some conversion process, then it's not money.
 
It is not a red herring. People are saying "gold is money". It is not. If you can't buy something with it without going to some conversion process, then it's not money.

Today is the fortieth anniversary of Nixon de-linking the dollar from gold, and that fiat money system is now in its death throes.

The dollar is no longer the world's favourite reserve currency. Gold is back on its throne.

:)
 
Today is the fortieth anniversary of Nixon de-linking the dollar from gold, and that fiat money system is now in its death throes.

The dollar is no longer the world's favourite reserve currency. Gold is back on its throne.

:)

I've paid for taxis and food in the UK and France with US Dollars this year (all I had in my pocket at the time) - try and do the same with gold and let me know how you get on.
 
I've paid for taxis and food in the UK and France with US Dollars this year (all I had in my pocket at the time) - try and do the same with gold and let me know how you get on.

I don't think you get it, DrDave. The question is this: Let's say I put $10,000 in a bank account, and spend another $10,000 on gold. In a year's time I sell my gold. Which pile of money will now buy me the most taxi rides?

Gold is acting as a global reserve currency. The fact that you can't use it directly to buy donuts is not relevant. Buying gold makes you your own central bank, bypassing the bankers who are making a lot of money out of you whilst your own savings lose value.
 
I've paid for taxis and food in the UK and France with US Dollars this year (all I had in my pocket at the time) - try and do the same with gold and let me know how you get on.

it would cost you $17.19 for a Big Mac meal in Zurich now, never mind 5 years time.
 
Give me a prediction for when it will die, so I can put it in my iCal and post back when you are proven wrong.

It's already very sick. That's why the US has had its credit rating downgraded. Gold has already replaced the dollar as the world's most attractive reserve currency. That is why central banks all over the planet are currently buying up gold. For me to be proven wrong, gold would have to turn around and head right back down to below $1000 per ounce.

So I don't have to make predictions about the future - only observations about the past. I will make a prediction that that the price of gold will keep rising higher and higher and higher and higher until eventually the US re-adopts the gold standard. I suspect this will happen at the point when the price has gone so high that the existing US gold reserves cover all the dollars in existence. How long will this take? I don't know. Maybe four years...
 
Almo,

You have to put this into its proper historical perspective.

At the end of WWII, the US was sitting on half the world's gold and all of the previously powerful European nations were both physically devastated and completely broke. The UK pushed for the adoption of Keynes' commodity-backed international currency ("Bancor") but the US, which at the time could dictate the course of events, insisted on a gold-backed dollar as global reserve currency.

In 1971, 40 years ago yesterday, President Nixon decided to let the US default on its commitment to cough up gold in return for dollars. This was a unilateral move which tipped the playing field even more in the direction of the US, but there was nothing anybody else could do about it. However, that system could only ever be sustained if all of the people who use it continue to believe that the US would neither default on its debts or print vast amount of money to deflate its debts away. There is nothing backing up the US dollar apart from the commitment of the US government and the US people not to default or devalue/print. And what has happened since 2008, culminating in the S&P downgrade, is that any remaining belief in this commitment has been destroyed. Nobody believes that the US can be relied on not to default/print. Therefore the existing fiat-dollar-based international monetary system is fatally compromised. It's broken. And that is the reason why the price of gold is skyrocketing, and why it will go much higher.

If you (or anybody-else) think there is something wrong with the above analysis then please do tell me what it is. :)
 
It's already very sick. That's why the US has had its credit rating downgraded. Gold has already replaced the dollar as the world's most attractive reserve currency. That is why central banks all over the planet are currently buying up gold. For me to be proven wrong, gold would have to turn around and head right back down to below $1000 per ounce.

I wouldn't say that gold has replaced the dollar. US Treasuries and the dollar remain the safe haven for the world. Gold has advanced because of that segment of investors who correctly realize that buying treasuries as a way of escaping the equity markets is like jumping out of the equity frying pan into the bond fryer.

When the bond bubble bursts is when gold will start to take off. At this point, you have to go so far out on the curve to get a real yield, what's the point? Why pay the US government to debase your fiat, when you can buy gold instead? Most investors haven't come to this realization yet, but they will, and when they do the move will be violent to the upside.

So I don't have to make predictions about the future - only observations about the past. I will make a prediction that that the price of gold will keep rising higher and higher and higher and higher until eventually the US re-adopts the gold standard. I suspect this will happen at the point when the price has gone so high that the existing US gold reserves cover all the dollars in existence. How long will this take? I don't know. Maybe four years...

Everyone has an implicit prediction of their financial future, based on exactly what they own. No need to make short term predictions on a forum, just let your money do your talking for you.
 
Last edited:
I wouldn't say that gold has replaced the dollar. US Treasuries and the dollar remain the safe haven for the world. Gold has advanced because of that segment of investors who correctly realize that buying treasuries as a way of escaping the equity markets is like jumping out of the equity frying pan into the bond fryer.

OK, so gold has replaced the dollar for one segment of investors who are ahead of the main pack in their understanding of what is actually going on in the world right now.

I do find it amazing how many people who you might expect to understand this by now, apparently still don't.
 
How long will this take? I don't know. Maybe four years...

Four years. You're on.

There is nothing backing up the US dollar apart from the commitment of the US government and the US people not to default or devalue/print. And what has happened since 2008, culminating in the S&P downgrade, is that any remaining belief in this commitment has been destroyed. Nobody believes that the US can be relied on not to default/print. Therefore the existing fiat-dollar-based international monetary system is fatally compromised. It's broken. And that is the reason why the price of gold is skyrocketing, and why it will go much higher.

If you (or anybody-else) think there is something wrong with the above analysis then please do tell me what it is. :)

I'll just point out the glaringly obvious:

1) Why are the Chinese still buying T-Bonds if "nobody believes the US can be relied on not to default/print"?
2) Why have the other two ratings agencies not downgraded the US debt if it's so bad?

Though to be honest, I'm not sure why anyone cares what the ratings agencies think after their screw-up with the CDOs.
 
Of course you do. You also believe thermite brought the twin towers down. That’s all we need to know about how you approach reality.

If you think that the implosion of the dollar is on par with a controlled demolition at the WTC in terms of viability then I'd say that's a success for truthers. A simple chart can shows you where the dollar has headed in the last decade and interest rates and the monetary policy of the Fed will tell you where it's going.

So overall I'd give your post an F-
 
It is not a red herring. People are saying "gold is money". It is not. If you can't buy something with it without going to some conversion process, then it's not money.

Ironic then that gold and silver are actually in the tertiary definition of money. Regardless, it's semantics, which is usually where the ignorant find themselves when they have nothing of value to say.

Call it whatever you want. You take your paper, and I'll take my gold. Let's see where we are in 5 years.
 
Ironic then that gold and silver are actually in the tertiary definition of money. Regardless, it's semantics, which is usually where the ignorant find themselves when they have nothing of value to say.

Call it whatever you want. You take your paper, and I'll take my gold. Let's see where we are in 5 years.

I'm not arguing semantics. I'm arguing function.
 
I'll just point out the glaringly obvious:

1) Why are the Chinese still buying T-Bonds if "nobody believes the US can be relied on not to default/print"?

Because their economy is so closely tied to ours. They think they need to prop it up to save their asses but that won't last forever. When they realize the US is a sinking ship, they'll flee.

2) Why have the other two ratings agencies not downgraded the US debt if it's so bad?

Interesting logic. Let's say another ratings agency downgrades us. Will you then say "why hasn't the last ratings agency downgraded us if it's so bad?" ?

Though to be honest, I'm not sure why anyone cares what the ratings agencies think after their screw-up with the CDOs.

The ratings simply reflect the state of the US economy. Forget the ratings. Look at the situation.

Are we as AAA as those mortgage backed securities then?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom