gold bull/bear survey

Where do you think the gold price is going?


  • Total voters
    138
This is without doubt the most idiotic thing that has been posted in this thread. I'm not buying gold itself? Funny that....I could have sworn I actually own some gold...

They aren't taking any risk because they are gold retailers. They make their money by selling people gold for more than they pay for it. If they did not make any money in this manner, what would be the point in them being gold retailers?

You do understand the difference between a retailer and a speculator, right?

You are desperately trying to convince me I'm being ripped off, but the fact of the matter is that if I were to sell the gold I've bought it would be at a handsome profit already, and the value is going up daily and shows no signs of stopping. Had I left that money in a bank account or invested it in the stock market, it would have lost value.

What a foolish person I have been!

Right now, gold is a one-way bet. It can only go up. The only question is how far, and how fast.

Nobody is trying to convince you of anything. In fact, you were trying to convince me that people buying gold they didn't sell to you at a premium and with a guaranteed penalty for buying it back were scammers. You don't have a smelter in your basement so you're stuck with a couple of options and neither of them work to your advantage. Calling one retailer who purchases any gold in any form a scammer while posting another business that will only ever buy back whatever you bought from them as a legitimate gold retailer is dishonest.

Each merchant is running a business. One is built on your being a net seller of gold (the deep discounter) and the other is built on your being a net buyer of gold (the premium merchant). Each of these business models works regardless of the spot price.

If you the customer are a net purchaser, as you've said you are, then you can only profit if the price rises. If you the customer are a net vendor then you can profit regardless of the size of the discount or the source of your supply.

A problem only ever arises for a net purchaser if the price of gold falls. That won't affect a net vendor because they're not stuck with a buyback arrangement as you are. You won't be able to resell your stock of gold to anyone except the merchant you bought from unless you're willing to take a deep discount too.

Keep in mind that you don't realise a profit until the day you sell. You don't earn anything from having it hidden in your back yard. The net sellers don't carry the risk that you do because they are realising their gains right now.
 
So what? There's a six month waiting period for the Honda Unicorn and an indeterminate waiting period for the Nissan Leaf. And those are items that at least have some kind of utility.

Yes, but they aren't likely to be worth 20% more in three months time than they are right now.

The problem with ordering gold and expecting to wait 3 months for it (in the current situation) is that you've got no guarantee that it will ever be delivered. You may just get your cash back.
 
Nobody is trying to convince you of anything. In fact, you were trying to convince me that people buying gold they didn't sell to you at a premium and with a guaranteed penalty for buying it back were scammers. You don't have a smelter in your basement so you're stuck with a couple of options and neither of them work to your advantage. Calling one retailer who purchases any gold in any form a scammer while posting another business that will only ever buy back whatever you bought from them as a legitimate gold retailer is dishonest.

No it isn't. The bullion dealer will offer me something close to spot price. The scammers will offer me nowhere near the spot price, even though they advertise "best prices paid." THAT is dishonest.

Each merchant is running a business. One is built on your being a net seller of gold (the deep discounter) and the other is built on your being a net buyer of gold (the premium merchant). Each of these business models works regardless of the spot price.

Yes, but the bullion dealer is running a business which does not depend on hoodwinking its clients. The truth is this: if the people selling their gold to these people knew what they could get for it from an honest dealer, then they wouldn't be selling it to the scammers.

If you the customer are a net purchaser, as you've said you are, then you can only profit if the price rises. If you the customer are a net vendor then you can profit regardless of the size of the discount or the source of your supply.

A problem only ever arises for a net purchaser if the price of gold falls. That won't affect a net vendor because they're not stuck with a buyback arrangement as you are.

I am not stuck with a buyback arrangement. Gold has just returned to its rightful place as the world's primary reserve currency. Why on Earth would I be restricted to selling it back to the dealer I bought it from?

You won't be able to resell your stock of gold to anyone except the merchant you bought from unless you're willing to take a deep discount too.

Where did you get that idea from? Why are you scaremongering people??

Keep in mind that you don't realise a profit until the day you sell. You don't earn anything from having it hidden in your back yard. The net sellers don't carry the risk that you do because they are realising their gains right now.

If you believed that gold is going to be as valuable in the coming years as I do, then you wouldn't be saying any of these things.

Gold is not a commodity, and certainly not a commodity which can only be sold back to the person I bought it from. It is money.
 
Yes, but they aren't likely to be worth 20% more in three months time than they are right now.

indeed, so the smart thing to do is store the money you are going to be paying for it with in Gold, and it's gotten 20% cheaper by the time you buy it :)

I nearly bought a boat at the tail end of last summer, was only a cheap old speedboaty type thing (2500) but on the morning of the test the guy texted to say he'd blown the engine up and then stopped answering his phone.

it was pretty obvious he'd either sold it to someone else (because for a blown engine it seemed to be moored in different berths a bit too often to be rowing it about) or was waiting until Spring to ask a higher price.

so I was curious when another "For sale" went up on it this year, and called the number, different guy, who had indeed bought it out from under me, and who had now put the price up (3000) - however the amount of gold I needed to sell to pay that, was still 10% less than I needed to sell at the end of last summer.

so even with a higher nominal price, it's still cheaper when priced in Gold.

deflation in full view.
 
Last edited:
Where did you get that idea from? Why are you scaremongering people??

If you believed that gold is going to be as valuable in the coming years as I do, then you wouldn't be saying any of these things.

Gold is not a commodity, and certainly not a commodity which can only be sold back to the person I bought it from. It is money.

careful, I got a stundie nomination for saying that in another thread :D

apparently, it is not, so said several "financial experts" on here, and The Bernank agrees with them, so what do I know? :boxedin:

edit.. although Matthew McClennan from First Eagle (with $31 billion under management, and who outperformed 93% of their peers over the last 5 years) just said on Bloomberg TV:

"We think of gold as nature's money, you can't print it" :)
 
Last edited:
I think it is a bubble.

But it is a bubble driven by very real concern of which there is no end in sight.
So for me the question is: how far will the bubble go?

If France and Germany cannot cough up the green to save Italy and Spain we could see gold go to 2200.

All guesstimations, of course.

France cant, they're most likely getting downgraded too now, at which point the EFSF (being AAA only) will have only one contributor left Germany, and will be requiring 56% of their GDP to fund it.

http://www.zerohedge.com/article/fa...bailout-82-million-soon-be-very-angry-germans

obviously not happening.

edit, lol @ the link abreviation, the title of the post is definitely not "fat angry germans" :)
 
Last edited:
careful, I got a stundie nomination for saying that in another thread :D

apparently, it is not, so said several "financial experts" on here, and The Bernank agrees with them, so what do I know? :boxedin:

edit.. although Matthew McClennan from First Eagle (with $31 billion under management, and who outperformed 93% of their peers over the last 5 years) just said on Bloomberg TV:

"We think of gold as nature's money, you can't print it" :)

If gold is a commodity, then why did it go sharply up in value over the last few days at the same time as every commodity apart from gold was going sharply down?

As for Ben Bernanke...

http://www.theonion.com/articles/drunken-ben-bernanke-tells-everyone-at-neighborhoo,21059/

"Then he puked all over the sink and the mirror," Kampman added.

Customers at the bar told reporters the "*********" and disruptive Bernanke refused to pay for his drinks with U.S. currency, claiming it was "worthless." Witnesses also confirmed that near the end of the evening, Bernanke put money into the jukebox and selected Dire Straits' "Money For Nothing" to play five times in a row.

"This is what it's all about," said Bernanke, who reportedly danced alone in the middle of the dark tavern. "******* love this song.
 
If gold is a commodity, then why did it go sharply up in value over the last few days at the same time as every commodity apart from gold was going sharply down?

I'm curious... What do you think was different in 2008 when gold managed to lose ~30% and how can you rule out something like that happening again?


.
 
quoting The Onion, for Ed´s sake...

one might say that you have done the same by not checking out the link.

either that or your operating system is missing the humor module.
 
I'm curious... What do you think was different in 2008 when gold managed to lose ~30% and how can you rule out something like that happening again?


.
Taking a look at five years of performance

http://www.google.com/finance?client=ob&q=NYSE:GLD

check the box to overlay the stock index on top. I used RJI and the "Dow JOnes".

I don't even see the 30% loss you mention, unless perhaps you have a starting point at the beginning of 2008. But the end of this chart shows a dramatic change from the priors

Generally speaking, no matter what time frame we average within this five year window, and whatever presumptions are applied to the data elements, gold shows a clear upward divergence from either grouped commodities, or the stock indexes.

So the question regarding the last 30 days is relevant, because it is outside the bounds of normal behavior for these data streams.
 
I'm curious... What do you think was different in 2008 when gold managed to lose ~30% and how can you rule out something like that happening again?

What happened in 2008 was that the rules of the game were changed big-time (zero interest rates, massive bailouts, money-printing gone mad) and the people whose job it is to look after a lot of other people's money decided (correctly) that the most of the newly-printed money was going to end up in the stock market.

I don't completely rule out something like that happening again as an initial response to any QE3. What I think has changed is the general perception of how serious the debt/currency problems have become, especially amongst ordinary members of the public both in the west and places like China and India. If gold does dip sharply in response to more money-printing, a lot of people are waiting to pile in this time. The market for precious metals just got a whole load bigger. How many people are there out there who could easily spend £100,000 on gold tomorrow, don't currently own any because they haven't being paying attention, and are just now waking up to what is going on?
 
Last edited:
Okay, you have finally destroyed whatever vestigial credibility you still had... quoting The Onion, for Ed´s sake...:rolleyes:

http://www.thedailymash.co.uk/news/business/bad-money-thing-make-new-scary-time-201108054163/

BAD money thing make world have big new scary time, clever men say now.

Noisy room where shirty men swap zeroes have frowny day as lazy bones in sunny places say no money now and be sad.

And wide place with shouty fat people also have no money and all say nice brown man in big house is rubbish now.

Clever men say new scary time not that new, just new bit of spend-money-no-have big-scary-bad-thing.

But very big scary thing is clever men say not know how to make nice happy money time.

Fancy clever man with big proper job say: "Not know. Oh dear. Not know. You know? Tell please."

He say only six people have happy money time now and you and me be poor stinkies who live in dirty box near choo-choo house.

Fancy clever man then go back to bed and pull blanket over frowny face.

But stupid nobody man who no have fancy proper job say all must make good shiny thing.

He say: "Swap shiny thing for happy money to buy more good shiny thing.

"All happy smile when every place make good shiny thing. Even shouty fats and lazy bones.

"Then every day be happy money swap time. Hurray! Hurray!

"Right now ********** though."
 
Taking a look at five years of performance

http://www.google.com/finance?client=ob&q=NYSE:GLD

check the box to overlay the stock index on top. I used RJI and the "Dow JOnes".

I don't even see the 30% loss you mention, unless perhaps you have a starting point at the beginning of 2008. But the end of this chart shows a dramatic change from the priors

Generally speaking, no matter what time frame we average within this five year window, and whatever presumptions are applied to the data elements, gold shows a clear upward divergence from either grouped commodities, or the stock indexes.

So the question regarding the last 30 days is relevant, because it is outside the bounds of normal behavior for these data streams.

I have real time quotes and data.

Gold fell roughly (depending on what you use -- futures, continuous contracts, cash market, etc) from almost $1100 to almost $700 in 2008.

I'm not sure how what your saying here addresses my rather simple question to UE.


.
 
What happened in 2008 was that the rules of the game were changed big-time (zero interest rates, massive bailouts, money-printing gone mad) and the people whose job it is to look after a lot of other people's money decided (correctly) that the most of the newly-printed money was going to end up in the stock market.

I don't completely rule out something like that happening again as an initial response to any QE3. What I think has changed is the general perception of how serious the debt/currency problems have become, especially amongst ordinary members of the public both in the west and places like China and India. If gold does dip sharply in response to more money-printing, a lot of people are waiting to pile in this time. The market for precious metals just got a whole load bigger. How many people are there out there who could easily spend £100,000 on gold tomorrow, don't currently own any because they haven't being paying attention, and are just now waking up to what is going on?

Thanks for the explanation. So you don't completely rule out something like 2008 happening again.

I'm just trying to understand where you are coming from because of other comments you've made like this:

Right now, gold is a one-way bet. It can only go up. The only question is how far, and how fast.


.
 
I'm just trying to understand where you are coming from because of other comments you've made like this:

UndercoverElephant said:
Right now, gold is a one-way bet. It can only go up. The only question is how far, and how fast.


Over the vast majority of time horizons he's correct, it only goes up. Even people that bought gold in early 2008 are happy now. They've been happy for years. For short-term gambler time horizons.. Gamblers are always at risk of losing money.
 
Thanks for the explanation. So you don't completely rule out something like 2008 happening again.

I'm just trying to understand where you are coming from because of other comments you've made like this:
.

OK, I can see the reasons for possible confusion. I'm not interested in short-term trading positions. I'm only interested in big pictures and longer timescales, where "long" means the next 18 months to two years. After that, my crystal ball doesn't seem to be functioning very well.
 
Over the vast majority of time horizons he's correct, it only goes up. Even people that bought gold in early 2008 are happy now. They've been happy for years. For short-term gambler time horizons.. Gamblers are always at risk of losing money.

I've been invested in metals for over 10 years, so I'm not knocking making money in anything over any time horizon.

But your statement would have been true in 1980 (ie; even people who bought in 1977 were happy in 1980).



.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom