gold bull/bear survey

Where do you think the gold price is going?


  • Total voters
    138
Gold is not necessarily money. Take a bar of gold to a car dealer and see if they let you buy a car with it.

Gold coins can be useful as money, but gold in general not. It's just a shiny metal.

Paper is not necessarily money <<Loop: repeat prior statements insert paper<--gold>>

:)
 
Gold is now trading as if it was another currency/money.

It couldn't trade as money during Bretton-Woods (1946-1971) because there was a fixed exchange rate between gold and the US dollar. And it didn't trade as money during the last three decades of the 20th century because the central banks still had large stockpiles which they were selling off at a pre-agreed rate, keeping the price steady. Only when the central banks started to become net buyers in the last few years did gold start going back to being a currency/money, and that process has just been accelerated by the US credit rating downgrade.

The US has already defaulted on its commitments to the rest of the world once, when Nixon reneged on the promise to turn over gold for dollars. It is now going to default a second time, if you include deliberate devaluation-by-money-printing as an effective default. The rest of the world does not have to put up with this, and isn't going to. In the past month gold has unofficially replaced the US dollar as the world's favourite reserve currency. Nobody wants dollars anymore. They want gold.
 
Gold is now trading as if it was another currency/money.

It couldn't trade as money during Bretton-Woods (1946-1971) because there was a fixed exchange rate between gold and the US dollar. And it didn't trade as money during the last three decades of the 20th century because the central banks still had large stockpiles which they were selling off at a pre-agreed rate, keeping the price steady. Only when the central banks started to become net buyers in the last few years did gold start going back to being a currency/money, and that process has just been accelerated by the US credit rating downgrade.

The US has already defaulted on its commitments to the rest of the world once, when Nixon reneged on the promise to turn over gold for dollars. It is now going to default a second time, if you include deliberate devaluation-by-money-printing as an effective default. The rest of the world does not have to put up with this, and isn't going to. In the past month gold has unofficially replaced the US dollar as the world's favourite reserve currency. Nobody wants dollars anymore. They want gold.

In Russia, banks do sell gold. I've seen pictures of the display counters at the banks.
 
Paper is not necessarily money <<Loop: repeat prior statements insert paper<--gold>>

:)

But I know for a fact I can walk into a car dealer with the correct amount of paper money and walk out with a car. Bring in the right amount of money in gold bars, and they will laugh at you.

The willful ignorance in this thread is stunning.
 
Megabull and minor bear are not mutually exclusive. The price of any asset can fall but in the long term move up in price.
 
But I know for a fact I can walk into a car dealer with the correct amount of paper money and walk out with a car. Bring in the right amount of money in gold bars, and they will laugh at you.

The willful ignorance in this thread is stunning.

Yet in the past 10 years, the price of gold has increased 6X in dollar terms. So while you may not be able to walk into a car dealership and make a purchase with gold, if you had held gold as opposed to dollars you would be able to buy several cars rather than just one.

In the end, your comment is a red herring and misses the point entirely. Hopefully you knew that when you typed it.
 
Yet in the past 10 years, the price of gold has increased 6X in dollar terms. So while you may not be able to walk into a car dealership and make a purchase with gold, if you had held gold as opposed to dollars you would be able to buy several cars rather than just one.

In the end, your comment is a red herring and misses the point entirely. Hopefully you knew that when you typed it.

I understand what you're saying. But the goldbugs are telling us to keep on buying gold as though that performance is replicable over the next ten years or so. That means a projected price of over $10,000 USD/oz in 2021. And $60,000 USD/oz in 2031.

At what price are any of them planning to sell? At what price will they stop buying?
 
I understand what you're saying. But the goldbugs are telling us to keep on buying gold as though that performance is replicable over the next ten years or so. That means a projected price of over $10,000 USD/oz in 2021. And $60,000 USD/oz in 2031.

At what price are any of them planning to sell? At what price will they stop buying?

I'm not sure you understand what we are saying. It is not a case of "at what price do you sell?", because (most of us at least) believe that the fiat money system is collapsing. So long as the leading western nations are still drowning in debt and printing money then there will be no "top" - gold will just keep going up when priced in fiat currencies. Only when it has been acknowledged that the old system is broken and a new form of currency is brought into existence which can't be abused like the old ones will it be time to sell.

So the answer is not a figure. I don't have a price target. I'll make future decisions about both buying more gold and trading it in for the new money or for land/property based on the global political-economic situation. The critical moment is when the defenders of the dollar capitulate - when they admit that the fiat US dollar (and presumably Sterling, the Yen and whatever is left of the Euro) is effectively dead. Exactly when this happens depends on (amongst other things) internal US politics, and I'm not in the game of predicting that.

Regardless of how many people keep telling me it is completely impossible, I think we are going to end up with metal-backed currencies again. If/when that happens then there would no longer be any point in owning the physical metal.
 
Last edited:
But I know for a fact I can walk into a car dealer with the correct amount of paper money and walk out with a car. Bring in the right amount of money in gold bars, and they will laugh at you.

The willful ignorance in this thread is stunning.

currently this is the case, things can change.

would you be willing to bet you could use the same money to buy the car in 5 or 10 years time?

that the same amount buys the same car?

and even that the $USD will exist in its current form by then?

I am not suggesting that the whole world goes back to going around giving each other actual lumps of gold for things, my best guess is that it will be a new primarily digital gold-backed currency.

there are several working versions of this already, and more coming into the market shortly.
 
I understand what you're saying. But the goldbugs are telling us to keep on buying gold as though that performance is replicable over the next ten years or so. That means a projected price of over $10,000 USD/oz in 2021. And $60,000 USD/oz in 2031. ....
That is not claimed to represent INCREASES IN wealth, but the preservation of wealth in the face of declining values of paper currency.

Gold must continue to rise in paper dollar value until whatever "normalization" of the US dollar occurs, some sort of theft of partial value 2014-2016 maybe. That'll probably fail, then gold will continue to rise.

But maybe it will work, who knows.
 
I understand what you're saying. But the goldbugs are telling us to keep on buying gold as though that performance is replicable over the next ten years or so. That means a projected price of over $10,000 USD/oz in 2021. And $60,000 USD/oz in 2031.

At what price are any of them planning to sell? At what price will they stop buying?

I, as many do, believe that the currency is imploding. This means that if the currency did collapse, gold would function as an interim medium of value exchange. The nominal value of gold is irrelevant in the end. $10k per oz sounds like a lot but it really just has to do with the value of the dollar. It may get that high; it may not. It may get higher than that, but the point is that gold will retain its value through what many believe is a coming depression.

I ask you this: what is going to change in the near future that knocks the gold price down significantly? Interest rates are at zero. The Fed has communicated it has no plans of letting the market crash to the bottom. They'll just keep printing more money, and as long as they do, gold will go up and the dollar will go down.
 
I'm not sure you understand what we are saying. It is not a case of "at what price do you sell?", because (most of us at least) believe that the fiat money system is collapsing. So long as the leading western nations are still drowning in debt and printing money then there will be no "top" - gold will just keep going up when priced in fiat currencies. Only when it has been acknowledged that the old system is broken and a new form of currency is brought into existence which can't be abused like the old ones will it be time to sell.

So the answer is not a figure. I don't have a price target. I'll make future decisions about both buying more gold and trading it in for the new money or for land/property based on the global political-economic situation. The critical moment is when the defenders of the dollar capitulate - when they admit that the fiat US dollar (and presumably Sterling, the Yen and whatever is left of the Euro) is effectively dead. Exactly when this happens depends on (amongst other things) internal US politics, and I'm not in the game of predicting that.

Regardless of how many people keep telling me it is completely impossible, I think we are going to end up with metal-backed currencies again. If/when that happens then there would no longer be any point in owning the physical metal.

I agree. This shouldn't necessarily be seen as a typical trade for profit. It's about wealth preservation during a depression. Paper is in trouble.
 
Of course you do. You also believe thermite brought the twin towers down. That’s all we need to know about how you approach reality.

And you have just revealed to the board how you approach public debate. This is a thread about gold prices in the section of the board dedicated to business and finance. What tempesta29 believes about the WTC attacks is completely irrelevant. In the context of this thread, your post is little more than a personal attack.

I post on another board (Powerswitch) which is home to a believer (Ludwig) in 9-11 conspiracy theories. I don't happen to agree with him on this particular topic, but on almost every other subject discusses, his are amongst the most insightful and illuminating posts on the board.
 
Of course you do. You also believe thermite brought the twin towers down. That’s all we need to know about how you approach reality.

er, he's hardly the only one? a lot of intelligent well informed people think this version of the fiat system is nearing it's end, changing the thread tack to off-topic 911 slurs and insults just indicates a lack of any other arguments on the subject to me.
 
er, he's hardly the only one? a lot of intelligent well informed people think this version of the fiat system is nearing it's end, changing the thread tack to off-topic 911 slurs and insults just indicates a lack of any other arguments on the subject to me.

I disagree.

I think that it is possible to believe nonsense on one subject, and be a realist about another. Some subjects are somehow related.

I know a lady with a whole collection of books by Char (the medium), she is also one of the best investors I know.

However, in this case the lady uses Char as a bit of spiritual escapism, she doesn't call the Char hotline to ask which stock she should buy. those decisions are made on the basis of reliable data.

But in the example above one can assume that opinions about 9-11 and the fed are closely related. And come from the same mindset.
We have seen enough truthers and such on these board, to know that they often hold a set of opinions.

Usually people who think that 9-11 was a conspiracy, think that fiat currency is a conspiracy.

Not saying that this is true for the poster above, of course.

Although, the avatar referencing 'They Live' is probably also an indication of his world view.
 
And you have just revealed to the board how you approach public debate. This is a thread about gold prices in the section of the board dedicated to business and finance. What tempesta29 believes about the WTC attacks is completely irrelevant. In the context of this thread, your post is little more than a personal attack.

Oh, no doubt. I wasn't pretending otherwise. tempesta29 has long ago worn out his welcome re considered debate. While I obviously don't doubt the possibility of the end of the "fiat empire" at some time in the next 10 centuries, I was merely observing the fact that such fantastical "thinkers" are irresistably drawn to such scenarios. Even if the world's economies were rather stable, people like him would still be attracted to Doomsday. I know this because these people fit that pattern 9 times out of 10. (And FYI I think while there is market turmoil gold will remain rather bullish.)

I post on another board (Powerswitch) which is home to a believer (Ludwig) in 9-11 conspiracy theories. I don't happen to agree with him on this particular topic, but on almost every other subject discusses, his are amongst the most insightful and illuminating posts on the board.

Well, he's definitely a rare sort. Most people that believe that kind of nonsense are prone to indulging in many, many others. And I discovered this half a decade before I registered on JREF.
 
Well, he's definitely a rare sort. Most people that believe that kind of nonsense are prone to indulging in many, many others. And I discovered this half a decade before I registered on JREF.

A lot of people believe nonsense about one subject or another. Even the Dawkinses and Randis of this world aren't immune.

Can we stick to talking about economics and monetary systems now please?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom