Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
I have said that Israel and the US are guilty of war crimes (same as Hamas) for not accepting the two state solution regarding the 1967 borders and for killing many civilians in Gaza.
I do not know if this is demonizing anyone, but it is true.
Again, Hamas is also guilty of their part of crimes

Much of the demonizing has been in how you've said it and the completely false statements that you've employed to try to prop up your opinion. As it happens, the US is still not able to accept the two state solution because they're not one of the parties that even can accept it. Furthermore, I've already given evidence that the US has actively tried to help the Israelis and Palestinians make the two state solution on the pre-1967 borders a reality. Next, what civilians in Gaza have US forces killed? Exactly 0, at last check. Your accusations against the US here are inexcusably false, before even getting to the next issue.

Regarding Israel's actions, you really, really need to take a step back and learn what constitutes a war crime. Not accepting a two state solution is not a war crime, regardless of how valid the claim is. End of story. Given that the military attacks on Israel are being based in civilian areas, the Palestinians just don't get a free pass to say that Israel is committing war crimes by attacking targets in civilian areas. On further investigation, it may be found that some of these attacks can be reasonably be called war crimes, yes, but we don't have sufficient information to reasonably determine whether many do yet, at last check.



If they were serious in looking for a diplomatic solutions, why not accepting the offer made in 1988 to have a two-state solution based on 1967 borders?
The PLO offered.
Israel refused

What else was on the negotiating table?



Given land in equal value elsewhere?
Offered to give back the land of the settlements?

This is not true

For the former, I encountered that presented as part of proposed negotatiations. For the later, what, exactly, do you think happened when Israel removed their settlements from the Gaza Strip? Unless, of course, you were again having yet another failure in your reading comprehension of -

You seem to also ignore that they've either removed such settlements or offered to give up land of equal value elsewhere in exchange during negotiations

and missing the point. The point being that Israel has acted in good faith on those points, which makes the objections that you were actually making pretty bad.


Well, if you support your ally when doing war crimes, I believe you are guilty of war crimes too

Except you've been claiming that things that are demonstrably not war crimes somehow are, as the first huge hurdle that you would need to overcome to support your point. A second huge hurdle would be that you demonstrate that you're not trying to conflate a usage of "support" that could validly qualify with the ones that do not. The ones that do not seem to be valid look like the relevant ones here.
 
Last edited:
Again, more evidence that you are lying

As expected, initial reaction was mostly negative. A statement from Netanyahu's office rejected what it called a withdrawal to the 1967 borders , calling them "indefensible" and noting it would leave major Israeli population centers in Palestinian territory. Hamas also rejected the speech.

Hamas has accepted the 1967 borders, not Israel

For us Palestinians, the reconciliation agreement concluded between Fatah and Hamas in Gaza two weeks ago was a necessary condition for moving on from the past. The agreement brings our main political players to the same side, namely to the side of a historic agreement with Israel. The terms of agreement includes recognition of the 1967 borders. Hamas's political leaders, moreover, are willing to back the Arab peace initiative of 2002, which is the clearest sign I know that their readiness to sign off on the 1967 border is not a mere tactical move but reflects deeper strategic calculations.

The real question is how the Netanyahu government will respond.
http://www.haaretz.com/opinion/1.589343
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
Israel won't withdraw to 1967 borders: Netanyahu
http://www.cbc.ca/news/world/israel-won-t-withdraw-to-1967-borders-netanyahu-1.1078602

Sex, lies.. and Nethanyahu !!

:D:D:D:D:D

Seriously, this is pretty damned stupid. Evidence has been delivered. You lost the argument. Now move on.

For people who are actually interested in reading the truth, as opposed to Kumar's weird version of reality, here are the times the Israelis accepted a two-state solution (from the wiki link above):

Partition was again proposed by the 1947 UN Partition plan for the division of Palestine. It proposed a three-way division, again with Jerusalem held separately, under international control. The partition plan was accepted by the Jewish leadership. However, the plan was rejected by the leadership of Arab nations and the Palestinian leadership at the time, which opposed any partition of Palestine and any Jewish presence in the area. The 1948 Arab-Israeli War for control of the disputed land broke out soon afterwards.

At the Annapolis Conference in November 2007, three major parties — The PLO, Israel, and The USA — agreed on a two-state solution as the outline for negotiations.


This quote is also noteworthy as it indicates that Palestinians are becoming less interested in a two-state solution:

In a 2007 poll in the Gaza Strip and the West Bank by the Jerusalem Media & Communication Centre, 46.7% of respondents favored a two-state solution, followed by 26.5% for a binational state.[17] However support is lower among younger Palestinians; U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice noted: "Increasingly, the Palestinians who talk about a two-state solution are my age."[18]
 
Last edited:
b. Why is Israel abiding to international laws by launching rockets to Gaza and the PLO is not?

They are retaliating, which is allowable.

c. Not true.
You become a full member of the UN by a decision of the UNSC but the US is vetoing Palestinian bid for a member state at the USNC
Palestine is already a state at the UN
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_of_Palestine

No, the State of Palestine is a not a voting member of the UN, it is an observer.

Membership at the UN is based on a vote of the General Assembly, after approval by the UNSC. The US is vetoing it at the SC and will continue to do so until the Palestinians agree that Israel has a right to exist, since they won't, the US is vetoing. Even if the US wasn't using its veto, more than 1/3 of the GA have indicated that they would vote against full membership until the Palestinian Authority agrees to accept that Israel has a right to exist.

And please please stop talking about Hamas!


Why? They are the de jure government of Gaza.
 
What do you mean, "exist"? It's still written down, nobody went back with an eraser, but it no longer has any legal significance because of the 13th amendment. It's been nullified, so in the only sense in which it ever mattered, it HAS been changed. That it "exists" is irrelevant.

exactly like the hamas charter, a 30 year old battle cry.
 
exactly like the hamas charter, a 30 year old battle cry.

Except that they still abide by it, as evidenced by what they say and what they do. The slavery portions of the US constitution have been amended by the 13th amendment.

Now, are you done with this idiotic side track?
 
They are retaliating, which is allowable.

Then Hamas should not be guilty of retaliating as well :D
Do you also support Hamas` right to retaliate against Israel?

No, the State of Palestine is a not a voting member of the UN, it is an observer.

Membership at the UN is based on a vote of the General Assembly, after approval by the UNSC. The US is vetoing it at the SC and will continue to do so until the Palestinians agree that Israel has a right to exist, since they won't, the US is vetoing. Even if the US wasn't using its veto, more than 1/3 of the GA have indicated that they would vote against full membership until the Palestinian Authority agrees to accept that Israel has a right to exist.

Exactly.
You claimed that the Palestinians could not have a state since they do not meet the three conditions.
Now the condition number 3 is just the US vetoing their access to full membership.
So it is not Palestine who does not want to meet the criteria, it is the US stopping them

Why? They are the de jure government of Gaza.

But not the de jure government of Tel Aviv
 
Then Hamas should not be guilty of retaliating as well :D
Do you also support Hamas` right to retaliate against Israel?

They aren't retaliating. They started shooting. When they stop shooting, Israel will stop retaliating.


But not the de jure government of Tel Aviv

Maybe you are suffering from selective blindness, but the topic of the thread is General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2, so Hamas is very much on topic.
 
exactly like the hamas charter, a 30 year old battle cry.

No, exactly not like that. Hamas never revoked that charter, they never changed that charter, their rhetoric is still in line with that part of their charter, and they continue to act like they want to destroy Israel. Age has nothing to do with this either. The 1st amendment is still in force, but the much more recent eighteenth amendment (prohibition) is not.

Your continued excuses for the genocidal aspirations of antisemitic primitive barbarians are getting more and more pathetic.
 
We see that the US government support Israel in the destruction of Gaza to make rich US jewishs happy, don't you see something injust and wrong? And what about the jewish colonies in the palestinians territories?
Some of the Orthodox Jews in NYC seem to be protesting, yet again, over Israel and what's going on in Gaza.

How do you account for that, Gaetan?

Also, for your education (putting "E" into JREF here) that is "unjust" not "injust" in you last clause of the first sentence.
 
They aren't retaliating. They started shooting. When they stop shooting, Israel will stop retaliating.
I always find it funny when people call terrorism against civilians "retaliation" or "self-defence". Even if HAMAS did have grounds to retaliate, retaliation involves attacking the enemy's armed forces, not civilian targets.

And spare me any of the worn-out ******** about "all they have to fight with" or "just defending their country" or "butbutisrael". I've heard it a thousand times before and it's as sick and hearing it over and over doesn't make it less nauseating.
 
Was it Jordan` s when Israel took it?
If yes, then it would be stealing as all land in the world was no man land 20000000 years ago.

Was it Jordan's? That's arguable. Jordan had control over it.

So if Palestinians were to take it back from Israel by force, would they be "stealing" it too?

If the Palestinian was free to negotiate this would not be stealing, but what has this to do with the land conquered during the war?

So in your mind "stealing" refers to land conquered in war?
 
Last edited:

So when a Palestinian kills the child of an Israeli living in the West Bank, we should call it "sippenhaft"?


Collective PunishmentWP

So when Hamas fires rockets indiscriminately terrorizing Israeli civilians, we should call it "Collective Punishment"?

You can play these games with definitions all you want, but so can anyone else. When you honestly look at who has the power to create peace, isn't it Hamas? If they would just stop all this effort they put into smuggling and building rockets and put that effort into building up Gaza's economy, wouldn't that accomplish a lot more than all your propagandizing?
 
Sad but true..
I start to suspect that the only hope for the Palestinians is to get some better military equipment and maybe a couple of nukes from Iran or Pakistan..

Because 60 years of mindless violence has worked so well for them, now it's time to double-down?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom