Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Israel doesn't have a Constitution. But in general it is accepted that Israel treats non-Jews differently from its Jewish population.

But you said that they wanted it like that. Maybe you should read up on it a bit more.
 
There are good and bad ways to defend children.
Avoid recognizing the opponent` s state and bombing their children are not the way I would define appropriate and or acceptable
But I do agree that most people in the US believe it may be OK to kill some 100+ civilians since the other side kills maybe 10 times less



Devil Kumar!!

:boxedin::boxedin:

If the Palestinians want to be recognized as a State by the other States in the world there are a few basic criteria that they have to meet:

a. Be in control of a defined territory (Gaza meets this definition, the precise location of the western border of the West Bank somewhat problematic, but this is why countries talk about these things and come to agreements);
b. Abide by international laws (ie. lobbing rockets into neighbouring nations is considered to be a social faux pas amongst nation states that results in being shunned at parties, air strikes, counter bombardment and other unpleasantness. Abiding by the laws of war is part of this, so if you do decide to lob rockets at your neighbour, it is again bad form to place said rockets in schools, housing developments, places of worship - if only because the allowable retaliation is then allowed to target these areas that are generally to be left alone); and
c. Recognized as a State by other States - if a significant number of other Recognized States say that you are a State, then you are.

At the moment, the Palestinian Authority seems to only meet a. There is strong pressure to recognize Palestine as a State, but the resolution that would do so is likely unacceptable to Hamas, as it requires them to resume negotiations with Israel. Given that in April the head of state said that they would not recognize Israel, negotiations just aren't going to happen. There is some light though, as at least one senior official is asking that the Palestinian government revisit this position.
 
You want me to ask Hamas if they want to destroy Israel? You want me to ask them, when I can see by their action that they are acting upon the desire to destroy Israel?

Ye shall know them by their fruits. Do men gather grapes of thorns, or figs of thistles?
 
Ye shall know them by their fruits. Do men gather grapes of thorns, or figs of thistles?

It doesn't matter, because if Magellan doesn't have an inside track with the Hamas leadership, he's just blowing smoke. They still want to destroy Israel, just like their charter says. I base this knowledge on public appearances by Hamas leadership during the last decade.
 
I think he's pointing out that just becuse something is written down somewhere, doesn't mean it's followed. Which is a worthwhile point in general, I suppose, but in HAMAS' case, the more... genocidal parts of the charter are definitely followed. Listen to their speeches, look at their actions, read their documents. Their stated goal is to destroy Israel and kill the Jews.
 
If the Palestinians want to be recognized as a State by the other States in the world there are a few basic criteria that they have to meet:

a. Be in control of a defined territory (Gaza meets this definition, the precise location of the western border of the West Bank somewhat problematic, but this is why countries talk about these things and come to agreements);
b. Abide by international laws (ie. lobbing rockets into neighbouring nations is considered to be a social faux pas amongst nation states that results in being shunned at parties, air strikes, counter bombardment and other unpleasantness. Abiding by the laws of war is part of this, so if you do decide to lob rockets at your neighbour, it is again bad form to place said rockets in schools, housing developments, places of worship - if only because the allowable retaliation is then allowed to target these areas that are generally to be left alone); and
c. Recognized as a State by other States - if a significant number of other Recognized States say that you are a State, then you are.

At the moment, the Palestinian Authority seems to only meet a. There is strong pressure to recognize Palestine as a State, but the resolution that would do so is likely unacceptable to Hamas, as it requires them to resume negotiations with Israel. Given that in April the head of state said that they would not recognize Israel, negotiations just aren't going to happen. There is some light though, as at least one senior official is asking that the Palestinian government revisit this position.

b. Why is Israel abiding to international laws by launching rockets to Gaza and the PLO is not?

c. Not true.
You become a full member of the UN by a decision of the UNSC but the US is vetoing Palestinian bid for a member state at the USNC
Palestine is already a state at the UN
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_of_Palestine

And please please stop talking about Hamas!
 
Last edited:
I think he's pointing out that just becuse something is written down somewhere, doesn't mean it's followed. Which is a worthwhile point in general, I suppose, but in HAMAS' case, the more... genocidal parts of the charter are definitely followed. Listen to their speeches, look at their actions, read their documents. Their stated goal is to destroy Israel and kill the Jews.

How can Israel complain about this since Israel is also not recognizing the two-state solution (same as Hamas) on the 1967 borders and killing by far more Palestinians than Hamas is killing Jews?
Where is Israel supposed to be different than Hamas?
As they claim they are really sorry for killing children?
 
Last edited:
I never tried to put "all the blame on one side".
I clearly stated multiple times that Hamas is wrong.

By your choice of words and arguments, you have been doing your best to demonize Israel and the US. Further, you've repeatedly tried to remove any and all responsibility from the Palestinians for why Israel has done or not done much what it's done or not done in your statements and questions. In short, to modify what I said to something slightly more accurate, you've done your best to keep all the blame, or at least as much of it as possible, away from the Palestinians.

What I am saying that, if Hamas is wrong, the US and Israel are at least as wrong as Hamas
:D:D

And your basis is... what? That Israel is willing to employ military force to stop direct military attacks on them, after going out of their way to seek a diplomatic solution? You may as well condemn all countries, then. That Israel has built upon land that they gained from hostile powers during war? You seem to also ignore that they've either removed such settlements or offered to give up land of equal value elsewhere in exchange during negotiations and either returned, given, or offered to give the land they gained in numerous attempts to obtain actual peace. For your presented case regarding the US being just as bad because it maintains its status as Israel's ally, it's so bad that it's nonsensical, to put it nicely.
 
By your choice of words and arguments, you have been doing your best to demonize Israel and the US. Further, you've repeatedly tried to remove any and all responsibility from the Palestinians for why Israel has done or not done much what it's done or not done in your statements and questions. In short, to modify what I said to something slightly more accurate, you've done your best to keep all the blame, or at least as much of it as possible, away from the Palestinians.

I have said that Israel and the US are guilty of war crimes (same as Hamas) for not accepting the two state solution regarding the 1967 borders and for killing many civilians in Gaza.
I do not know if this is demonizing anyone, but it is true.
Again, Hamas is also guilty of their part of crimes

And your basis is... what? That Israel is willing to employ military force to stop direct military attacks on them, after going out of their way to seek a diplomatic solution?

If they were serious in looking for a diplomatic solutions, why not accepting the offer made in 1988 to have a two-state solution based on 1967 borders?
The PLO offered.
Israel refused

You may as well condemn all countries, then. That Israel has built upon land that they gained from hostile powers during war? You seem to also ignore that they've either removed such settlements or offered to give up land of equal value elsewhere in exchange during negotiations and either returned, given, or offered to give the land they gained in numerous attempts to obtain actual peace.

Given land in equal value elsewhere?
Offered to give back the land of the settlements?

This is not true

For your presented case regarding the US being just as bad because it maintains its status as Israel's ally, it's so bad that it's nonsensical, to put it nicely.

Well, if you support your ally when doing war crimes, I believe you are guilty of war crimes too
 
I do not know how you want to call them, but UN resolutions should be followed.
Israel is not doing that.

Therefore, they are on the wrong side

Like I said to you before Welcome to reality. I mean seriously you want to paint the whole story from the onset of it being " A country is breaking the rules" welcome to *********** reality and the real world.

For whatever excuse Israel is giving, they aren't following the rules set by the UN. My god, it's shocker isn't it. We've NEVER heard of that happening before ever! :rolleyes:

One of the reasons they aren't following the rules is that the UN is a god damned joke. It's one of the reasons we pulled out of the Persian Gulf war and left tons of people to get "massacred" because you're not supposed to get involved in a civil war. And one of the reasons we didn't get involved in Rwanda because "we're not supposed to get involved in a civil war."

It really shocks you that a country might decide to violate an agreement because their country is being threatened daily?

This has been an enlightening discussion. I always thought there were stronger arguments about the debate. But this is really nonsensical. :boggled::boggled:

You want to "stop talking about Hamas" when HAMAS is the problem! TOOOO funny.
 
Last edited:
False.
Israel wants to grab land
If Israel were sincere in looking for peace, they would have offered to accept the two-state solution based on 1967 borders, but they did not.
This is the proof that Israel does not want peace

...This again? I gave evidence previously of multiple occasions when exactly that was offered, which is exactly what you're claiming never happened. It was not accepted, because negotiations broke down for other reasons. Frankly, points like, say, accepting Israel as having a legitimate claim in the first place have long been in dispute. That the PLO may have officially removed certain bits that made negotiations nearly impossible from its charter in no way means that the issues were dropped or that they intend to hold to them any more softly, for example.

And on this we agree.
What me and you disagree on is that I consider Israeli behaviour at least as much not acceptable as Hamas, while you did not condemn them, you condemned only Hamas

As I noted previously, there are reasons for that. Official policy and official reactions can be condemned quite easily, and there's a lot that Hamas has as official policy that's reprehensible, in my opinion. There's much, much less that's reprehensible in Israel's official policy and official reactions, on the other hand, and Israel has repeatedly acted in ways that negate much of the criticisms that you keep trying to level against them. Furthermore, once again, by striking at Israel first militarily and refusing negotiations, the Palestinians forced Israel into taking military action to end their military attacks against Israel. After that, Israel's officially employed multiple methods to reduce the Palestinian body count, on top of that, when the Palestinian leaders are most definitely not. By just about all used objective measures of policy and morality, Israel's behavior been overwhelmingly better than Hamas' behavior. Yes, Israel's certainly racked up a much, much higher body count and amount of damage than Hamas' forces. It would have been much easier and safer for them to have racked up overwhelmingly more dead and horribly suffering Palestinians than they have been, though, which actually does show that they're trying to follow the one of the least reprehensible courses of action that they can reasonably follow, given the situation.

In short, Israel is very much not "just as bad" as Hamas, by the evidence at hand, and there's fairly little in the generalities that is reasonable to condemn with regards to Israel and much to condemn with regards to Hamas, when the whole picture is taken into account. Hence why I have no problem with condemning Hamas' actions, despite being sympathetic to them in some ways, and don't condemn the general course of action taken by Israel. There will fairly certainly be a number of more specific things to condemn Israel for with regards to the current conflict... as more specific details become available, and I will and do have no problem with condemning Israel for those.


Israel had their borders in 1967.
They expanded their borders by war.
This is not acceptable.
Since then they kept taking land away from the Palestinians.
This is not acceptable either

As I recall, they expanded their borders by war, yes, in a situation where the countries that they took land from either were about to attack them or were just saying and posturing that they were about to attack (Egypt), or did attack them first (everyone else). They've largely kept land away from the Palestinians, in part, because their attempts to give the land to the Palestinians keep ending with the Palestinians attacking Israel on larger scales. Still, besides that, that second part is openly false. They "took" the land from the countries that formerly controlled it, not "kept taking," and that the Palestinians control any land areas, such as the Gaza Strip, is proof that the trend is in the opposite direction as what you're claiming with your chosen wording.
 
Last edited:
And in the US constitution there are several paragraphs on how slavery is to be regulated. They never changed that.

That's not all that relevant when Hamas' leaders are still calling for it to happen, whereas the leaders in the US are not calling for slavery to happen.

I think that any opposition in Israel against a two-state solution derives from the fact that ceding territory has had adverse effects for Israel in the past.

I highly doubt that, myself. As I recall, though, resistance to the two-state solution has frequently taken the form of desiring co-existence as equals in the same land, as well as a fairly expectable amount of racism, religious conflicts, and the like.
 
...This again? I gave evidence previously of multiple occasions when exactly that was offered [to accept the two-state solution based on 1967 borders], which is exactly what you're claiming never happened.

(words between [ and ] are mine)

This is a lie.
Israel never offered to recognize a two-state solution based on the 1967 borders.

On June 14, 2009, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu gave a speech at Bar Ilan University endorsing the establishment of a Palestinian state west of the Jordan River, a first in his career. He proposed that the state have limited to no control of its own borders, military, airspace, or foreign relations, and that no Palestinians be allowed right of return to property in Israeli territory. Netanyahu also repeatedly called on the Palestinians to recognize Israel as a Jewish state.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two-state_solution

What you have quoted is an article of a minor newssite that says that the 1967 borders were something to start to talk about

More evidence that you are lying

Referring to Israel’s disengagement from Gaza nine years ago, Lieberman said the international community repeatedly demands Israel withdraw to the 1967 borders and remove Israeli settlements from the West Bank.
“Israel did just that in Gaza and withdrew to the last millimeter and evicted 21 communities," he said. "The result of that move was rockets on all Israeli cities.”
http://www.latimes.com/world/middleeast/la-fg-israel-gaza-conflict-20140716-story.html#page=1
(in short, we are not desengeging)

The boundaries of a future Palestinian State, vis-a-vis Israel, are subject to ongoing negotiations in the Israel–Palestinian peace process. Israel's West Bank Wall, which encompasses almost all Israeli settlements, including all three major cities, and only a minor Palestinian population, was declared by Prime Minister Ehud Olmert as running roughly along the future borders of Israel[citation needed]. Israeli Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman proposed that the Arab-Israeli border region known as the Triangle be removed from Israeli sovereignty and transferred to the Palestinian Authority, in exchange for the border settlement blocs. The Palestinian Authority claims all of these territories (including East Jerusalem) for a future Palestinian State, and its position is supported by the Arab League in the 2002 Arab Peace Initiative which calls for the return by Israel to "the 1967 borders". While Israel has expressed desire to annex the border settlement blocs and keep East Jerusalem, its border with Gaza has largely been solidified, especially following Israel's withdrawal in 2005. Israel has not made claims to any portion Gazan territory, and offered the entire area to Palestinians as part of the 2000 Camp David Summit.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Borders_of_Israel

“We call upon Israel and Palestine to resume negotiations leading to a two-State solution with a contiguous and economically viable Palestinian State existing side by side in peace with Israel, within mutually agreed and internationally recognized borders based on the 4 June 1967 lines, with East Jerusalem as its capital,” the declaration said.
http://en.itar-tass.com/world/740816
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom