Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
I do not see any difference between the two statements, except for the grammar.

English lesson of the day, then.

In the former, when used in the context that it was, "based on" generally counts as naming an origin, one that should be at least loosely held as a base. By the information given, it looked like exactly that was cited to have occurred, with proposals for roughly equivalent amounts of land shifted from each side to the other side, using the borders in question as a base, which would make the results of an agreement much easier to implement, overall. There's a fair bit of wiggle room in the exact implementation for it to be true. The latter statement deals with a very specific condition, on the other hand. Either it is the case or is not the case.

In short, in general usage, that something is based on X does not mean that it actually is X, merely that it is inspired by or derived from X.
 
Last edited:
English lesson of the day, then.

In the former, when used in the context that it was, "based on" generally counts as naming an origin, one that should be at least loosely held as a base. By the information given, it looked like exactly that was cited to have occurred, with proposals for roughly equivalent amounts of land shifted from each side to the other side, using the borders in question as a base, which would make the results of an agreement much easier to implement, overall. There's a fair bit of wiggle room in the exact implementation for it to be true. The latter statement deals with a very specific condition, on the other hand. Either it is the case or is not the case.

I consider what you are writing here an acceptable solution (without considering the right of return and Jerusalem as capital and without considering how much "wiggle" is "wiggle") but this is not the position of the Israeli Government
The is the offer that the PLO made to the Israeli in 198 and was refused by the Israeli
 
I don't say that all the jewishs or all the americans are wrong, but the medias wash the brain of the majority of them. You can't listen the medias, they are used by the elites to foul people, to keep them in power, to make them richer. The palestinian conflict is leading the world in kaos, the prelude to the end of the civilisation.

Kaos? From Get Smart? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KAOS_(Get_Smart)#KAOS

BTW: The word media is plural, you don't have to add an 's'.
 
I consider what you are writing here an acceptable solution (without considering the right of return and Jerusalem as capital and without considering how much "wiggle" is "wiggle") but this is not the position of the Israeli Government
The is the offer that the PLO made to the Israeli in 198 and was refused by the Israeli

Again, it was also not the full extent of what was on the negotiating table. Of what you just noted, "the right of return" and "Jerusalem as capital" are two separate issues that were also involved in the negotiations. I rather doubt that Israel was as flexible with those as with the specific borders, which would likely make them stronger points for you, were you trying to make the still rather fallacious argument that Israel's been unwilling to negotiate. They are not, in fact, requirements for a two-state solution based on the 1967 border and should not be referred to as such. Incidentally, refusing the "right of return" would be quite understandable and a fairly expected move of Israel's, given the general weakness of Israel's claims on land in the area in the first place, security concerns, and a few other things, despite that, at best, it could be seen from the outside as a necessary evil to prevent even more unpleasant challenges to their continued residence in the area.

Again, though, one of the most basic requirements for successful negotiations in attempts to reach peace is for the measures that are taken to be even likely to result in actual peace. As long as Israel has every reason to believe that Palestinians will attack them or try to destroy them the moment Israel gives them an opening to do so, peace negotiations are largely doomed from the start.
 
Last edited:
Notice how quick Israel stopped bombing Gaza after that photo of the Palestinian child killed on the beach made front pages all over the world? This clearly demonstrates that the Gaza attacks are not a result of some "existential" threat to Israel, but are actually a product Israel's goal of marginalizing the Palestinians.

The video of the massacre was quite poignant. After the first shell struck, you can see three children running like mad down the beach....and ya' just know they are not going to make it. Meanwhile, the Israelis took careful aim and finished them off.

Let that be a lesson.
 
Last edited:
Oh the Israelis would have loved something like this if they were as evil as you think they were. They'd have impaled the dead bodies and flaunted the corpses.
 
Oh the Israelis would have loved something like this if they were as evil as you think they were. They'd have impaled the dead bodies and flaunted the corpses.

Well, as a result of that morbid massacre, the world is now safe from those four Palestinian Children. Perhaps the guys that did the strike should get a Medal for their Heroism in delivering all that firepower? I'm thinking, we could give them, "The Congressional Medal of Ugly" - for Displaying Degeneracy Above and Beyond the Call of Duty.

And for Hamas...it was their fault for not supplying those kids better running shoes. I mean, how is some poor Palestinian kid going to dodge Israeli bombs running on nothing but bare feet?

And ya' know what? Had that massacre not been so well documented, the Israelis would have claimed the Hamas were using those children as Human Shields. You can bet on it.
 
Last edited:
Netanyahoo's spokesperson made mincemeat of on British Channel 4:


Mincemeat, that is if you reject the laughable butButBUTHamas "arguments" this guy uses and hands down to the hasbara parrots to justify the mass-murder of civilians.
 
Last edited:
Yes, Israel behaves like the Wehrmacht on the Eastern Front and it recently flayed Palestinians alive in order to make lampshades while making a thousand people march over a minefield and shooting them all if an Israeli officer stepped on a mine before rounding up every Palestinian and shooting one tenth of them at random.
 
Yes, Israel behaves like the Wehrmacht on the Eastern Front and it recently flayed Palestinians alive in order to make lampshades while making a thousand people march over a minefield and shooting them all if an Israeli officer stepped on a mine before rounding up every Palestinian and shooting one tenth of them at random.

Why don't you discuss what the Israelis really do?

1. They Steal Land.

2. They Practice Apartheid.

3. They Sabotage any Peace Process.



The long longer the Israelis can keep this fight going, the more Land they can Steal.
 
Why don't you discuss what the Israelis really do?

1. They Steal Land.

2. They Practice Apartheid.

3. They Sabotage any Peace Process.



The long longer the Israelis can keep this fight going, the more Land they can Steal.

Then they're doing a piss-poor job of it. Wake me when Israel has conquered Jordan and is going full Generalplan Ost after it has left a pyramid of skulls where Gaza used to be, and is responding to rocket attacks by taking people at random and having them fed to Mastiffs on live tv.
 
What?

The main operational capability of Hamas seems to be getting its own human sheilds killed. Is this some kind of prophetic knowledge?

9-11, wars in Afganistan, Irak, trouble with Iran, religious fundamentalism have one point of origin, the Israelian and palestinian conflict.

It is not the palestinians who are responsible for the massacre of Jews by Hitler, this is not the people who should pay for that. Israelians don't want peace because they would have to go back to their position of their constitution and allowed the palestinians to return in their country, instead of that they construct more and more colonnies in the palestinians territory. The US support to Israel by his veto is unjust toward the palestinians and continue and perpetuate injustice toward them. Don't listen the medias, they won't say that, they all say that palestinians persecute jews by throwing rokets on israel, those attacts are symbolic compared with the attacts of Israel. The purpose of medias is not to be a guard for democratie but to manipulate and to foul people for the benifit of rich, their purpose is to elect Satan at the head of the country to make rich richer, don't listen the medias.
 
Last edited:
Then they're doing a piss-poor job of it. Wake me when Israel has conquered Jordan and is going full Generalplan Ost after it has left a pyramid of skulls where Gaza used to be, and is responding to rocket attacks by taking people at random and having them fed to Mastiffs on live tv.

Your Hyperbolic Rhetoric is a smokescreen...or so you think.

Despite all the Propaganda, the world knows what Israel is doing to the Palestinians - and they know it is unjust.
 
Why don't you discuss what the Israelis really do?

1. They Steal Land.

Nope.

2. They Practice Apartheid.

Nope.

3. They Sabotage any Peace Process.

They accepted Egypt's cease-fire proposal. Hamas rejected it. How is that Israel sabotaging the peace process?

The long longer the Israelis can keep this fight going, the more Land they can Steal.

They gave back Gaza. If all they were interested in was stealing land, then why would they have given it back? And why would they be fighting to take back what they already gave up? That's irrational paranoia.

It has become clear that you cannot think about this issue logically. Your criticisms have become downright delusional.
 
Your Hyperbolic Rhetoric is a smokescreen...or so you think.

Despite all the Propaganda, the world knows what Israel is doing to the Palestinians - and they know it is unjust.

I'm sorry, it's NOTHING compared to what's going on in Chechnya or North Korea or the horror next door in Iraq. Once the conflict in Gaza dies down, people will drop the 13yo Anarchist "Zionazi Gazauschwitz" rhetoric and focus on other things in the world.
 
Your Hyperbolic Rhetoric is a smokescreen...or so you think.

Despite all the Propaganda, the world knows what Israel is doing to the Palestinians - and they know it is unjust.

Despite all the Propaganda, the world knows that Hamas started this fight, Hamas is keeping it from ending, and Hamas does nothing to protect its own civilians. How inhumane, how unjust, how cruel is that?
 
Netanyahoo's spokesperson made mincemeat of on British Channel 4:


Mincemeat, that is if you reject the laughable butButBUTHamas "arguments" this guy uses and hands down to the hasbara parrots to justify the mass-murder of civilians.

Jeez...

It was physically impossible for Ned Stark's bastard to condemn Hamas when he had the chance to do so - if he did he'd lose his leverage to berate that sap, which would lose ratings. For the sake of journalistic integrity I wonder when he'll have a Hamas spokesman on to grill them about committing obvious war crimes by using Hospitals and civilians centers as launching sites for their weapons. I'm guessing he won't reach out to them.

And the fighting continues with no end in sight, but plenty of entertainment for people with axes to grind.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom