Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Some of the Orthodox Jews in NYC seem to be protesting, yet again, over Israel and what's going on in Gaza.

How do you account for that, Gaetan?

Also, for your education (putting "E" into JREF here) that is "unjust" not "injust" in you last clause of the first sentence.

I don't say that all the jewishs or all the americans are wrong, but the medias wash the brain of the majority of them. You can't listen the medias, they are used by the elites to foul people, to keep them in power, to make them richer. The palestinian conflict is leading the world in kaos, the prelude to the end of the civilisation.
 
What a mess of a conflict.


You know. This might sound barbaric. But there has to be an absolute victory for this conflict to be over.
 
Israel already unilaterally withdrew from Gaza. They did not negotiate the withdrawl, they did not demand anything in return, they just... gave it back. They did exactly what you wanted them to do. And what has been the result? They have been repaid with rockets.

Not only that, and I'm running about 5 pages behind so forgive me if this has already been mentioned, the anti-Israel crowd then blamed Israel for not negotiating the withdrawal. Supposedly they were supposed to give Fatah credit to bolster Fatah in the eyes of the Palestinians. Only this was never mentioned in the months leading up to the withdrawal, only after as a way for not giving Israel credit for doing anything good ever.
 
What a mess of a conflict.


You know. This might sound barbaric. But there has to be an absolute victory for this conflict to be over.

I really hope not.

I've actually heard others who share your opinion blame Israel for the "genocide" they think is inevitable. Surreal.
 
The palestinian conflict is leading the world in kaos, the prelude to the end of the civilisation.

What?

The main operational capability of Hamas seems to be getting its own human sheilds killed. Is this some kind of prophetic knowledge?
 
You bet, i guess it is the eye for an eye law, so as they killed one israelien, they have to kill 5000 palestinians and destroy all their homes. If someone says something it is of no matter since they have the US veto.

I know right. You would think they would learn by now. The Palestinians should up the ante further, don't you think? Couldn't possibly go wrong.
 
Was it Jordan's? That's arguable. Jordan had control over it.

So if Palestinians were to take it back from Israel by force, would they be "stealing" it too?

In 1967 Israel was within the 1967 borders.
They took land with a war.
This is not acceptable as from the UN said as from any people who has a minimum of moral ground
The PLO has offered to make peace with Israel on the 1967 borders.
Israel refused
Israel keeps building settlements outside their previous borders evicting Palestinians from their homes.
Therefore, Israel is wrong on this
Since ISrael has never offered to go back to their borders, and a two-state solution based on the 1967 borders as the PLO has proposed long ago, Israel, the US and the people who support them are the ones to blame.
Hamas is to blame too, as they also do not accept a peaceful solution

So in your mind "stealing" refers to land conquered in war?

Yes.
And by forced evictions

And this is what most UN countries publicly stated, so it is not just my mind
 
Last edited:
Because 60 years of mindless violence has worked so well for them, now it's time to double-down?

For the 60 years they fought mostly with rocks
Give them tens of thousands of AK47s and bazookas and things may go very differently

So when Hamas fires rockets indiscriminately terrorizing Israeli civilians, we should call it "Collective Punishment"?

ButbutbutbutHamas

You can play these games with definitions all you want, but so can anyone else. When you honestly look at who has the power to create peace, isn't it Hamas? If they would just stop all this effort they put into smuggling and building rockets and put that effort into building up Gaza's economy, wouldn't that accomplish a lot more than all your propagandizing?

You can play these games with definitions all you want, but so can anyone else. When you honestly look at who has the power to create peace, isn't it Israel? If they would just accept the two state solution and make peace with the PLO, then Hamas would have much less reasons to sell to their people that Israel is bad
 
(words between [ and ] are mine)

This is a lie.
Israel never offered to recognize a two-state solution based on the 1967 borders.

On June 14, 2009, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu gave a speech at Bar Ilan University endorsing the establishment of a Palestinian state west of the Jordan River, a first in his career. He proposed that the state have limited to no control of its own borders, military, airspace, or foreign relations, and that no Palestinians be allowed right of return to property in Israeli territory. Netanyahu also repeatedly called on the Palestinians to recognize Israel as a Jewish state.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two-state_solution

I do agree that that specific proposal was not viable, as it was. That's generally what counter-proposals and negotiation are for, though. Either way, I read through entire linked article and did not see where "two-state solution" referred to a specific set of conditions that has not been on the negotiating table, which negates your accusation of "lie." Either way, if the point of the quoted was to try to demonstrate that Israel has not been negotiating in good faith, it just doesn't work so well in light of other bits in the article like -

The Palestinians have "shown serious interest" in a two-state solution since the mid-1970s, and its mainstream leadership has embraced the concept since the 1982 Arab Summit in Fez.[41] However, in March 2009 Mohammad Dahlan of the PLO stated that, “For the 1,000th time, I want to reaffirm that we are not asking Hamas to recognize Israel’s right to exist. Rather we are asking Hamas not to do so, because Fatah never recognized Israel’s right to exist.”[37]


What you have quoted is an article of a minor newssite that says that the 1967 borders were something to start to talk about

More evidence that you are lying

A major problem with that accusation of lying has already been noted, before considering that that was hardly the only source available. Other major problems appear when the wikipedia article is actually considered. For example,

At the Annapolis Conference in November 2007, three major parties — The PLO, Israel, and The USA — agreed on a two-state solution as the outline for negotiations.

Since entering office, Obama has halted the sale of advanced weapons to Israel while demanding that they withdraw from the entire West Bank so that a Palestinian state could be set up.[19]

On June 4, 2009, US President Barack Obama delivered a major address to the Muslim world in Cairo, Egypt. In the speech, he reiterated US support for the two-state solution:[20]

This is just one of the parts of the article that destroys multiple arguments that you've tried to make.


Referring to Israel’s disengagement from Gaza nine years ago, Lieberman said the international community repeatedly demands Israel withdraw to the 1967 borders and remove Israeli settlements from the West Bank.
“Israel did just that in Gaza and withdrew to the last millimeter and evicted 21 communities," he said. "The result of that move was rockets on all Israeli cities.”
http://www.latimes.com/world/middleeast/la-fg-israel-gaza-conflict-20140716-story.html#page=1
(in short, we are not desengeging)

More like, "we are not just going to just give land to people who will just attack us from that land," which is actually completely reasonable, from more objective views. Historically speaking, it's been the Arabs who have kept trying to attack, hurt, and destroy Israel and its people, over and over, not vice versa. Israel would be outright stupid to withdraw without assurances when all the available evidence leads to the conclusion that doing so will lead to much greater amounts of death and suffering for the Israelis, and probably for the Palestinians, as well, given that more conflicts like the one happening in the Gaza Strip are inevitable if they do.

The boundaries of a future Palestinian State, vis-a-vis Israel, are subject to ongoing negotiations in the Israel–Palestinian peace process. Israel's West Bank Wall, which encompasses almost all Israeli settlements, including all three major cities, and only a minor Palestinian population, was declared by Prime Minister Ehud Olmert as running roughly along the future borders of Israel[citation needed]. Israeli Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman proposed that the Arab-Israeli border region known as the Triangle be removed from Israeli sovereignty and transferred to the Palestinian Authority, in exchange for the border settlement blocs. The Palestinian Authority claims all of these territories (including East Jerusalem) for a future Palestinian State, and its position is supported by the Arab League in the 2002 Arab Peace Initiative which calls for the return by Israel to "the 1967 borders". While Israel has expressed desire to annex the border settlement blocs and keep East Jerusalem, its border with Gaza has largely been solidified, especially following Israel's withdrawal in 2005. Israel has not made claims to any portion Gazan territory, and offered the entire area to Palestinians as part of the 2000 Camp David Summit.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Borders_of_Israel

Yes? And? Israel's conduct there has indeed been poor, yet, as noted, exchanging the land that their settlements is on for other land that was part of Israel's territory in the pre-1967 has been put on the table, and Israel likely could do what it did with the settlements in Gaza again, much as the logistics involved makes that option quite undesirable for them.

“We call upon Israel and Palestine to resume negotiations leading to a two-State solution with a contiguous and economically viable Palestinian State existing side by side in peace with Israel, within mutually agreed and internationally recognized borders based on the 4 June 1967 lines, with East Jerusalem as its capital,” the declaration said.
http://en.itar-tass.com/world/740816

And the relevance of this is... what? It's already been demonstrated, repeatedly, that much of the world, including the US (which is only worthy of note because you keep making false statements about them on the subject), is calling for a two-state solution that will be viable for maintaining peace in the region.
 
Again, more evidence that you are lying

As expected, initial reaction was mostly negative. A statement from Netanyahu's office rejected what it called a withdrawal to the 1967 borders , calling them "indefensible" and noting it would leave major Israeli population centers in Palestinian territory. Hamas also rejected the speech.

Frankly, calling them "indefensible" is reasonable, under the circumstances.

Hamas has accepted the 1967 borders, not Israel

Border agreements tend to require accepting the legitimacy of the other party, which Hamas refuses to do, at last check, so no, Hamas hasn't really accepted such... or, more specifically, hasn't given Israel anything that remotely resembles valid reason to trust them, at all, and has given lots and lots and lots of reason to trust them to attack Israel however they can, not least being the rocket attacks and their various statements surrounding that.

Again more evidence of your lies

My lies? I've presented evidence that that particular condition and its equivalent has been put on the negotiating table in the past and said exactly that, no further. If you really want try that method of argumentation, though, I could just keep asking where the Palestinians have given any reason to believe that they won't try to hurt or destroy Israel, yet again, the moment that they think they can.

Then Hamas should not be guilty of retaliating as well :D
Do you also support Hamas` right to retaliate against Israel?

Sure, in cases when Israel starts shooting first.

Exactly.
You claimed that the Palestinians could not have a state since they do not meet the three conditions.
Now the condition number 3 is just the US vetoing their access to full membership.
So it is not Palestine who does not want to meet the criteria, it is the US stopping them

Are you ignoring what conditions would need to be met for the US to not veto? Conditions that are very likely necessary for any hope of peace without genocide in the region, regardless?

For the 60 years they fought mostly with rocks
Give them tens of thousands of AK47s and bazookas and things may go very differently

This is an excellent reason to keep those weapons and access to those weapons out of Palestinian hands.

ButbutbutbutHamas

ButbutbutbutTerrorismDoesn'tMeanAnything.

You can play these games with definitions all you want, but so can anyone else. When you honestly look at who has the power to create peace, isn't it Israel? If they would just accept the two state solution and make peace with the PLO, then Hamas would have much less reasons to sell to their people that Israel is bad

Except that a two-state solution without any good reason to believe that the Palestinians are acting in good faith is highly likely to make the situation much worse. Israel has some power, yes, but when the Palestinians have a very long history of seeking Israel's destruction and have repeatedly refused to give that up, a whole lot of the power lies in their hands. As you said, though -

For the 60 years they fought mostly with rocks
Give them tens of thousands of AK47s and bazookas and things may go very differently

Would they use those weapons to attack Israel regardless of what Israel does? Realistically speaking, yes, yes they would. Until that changes, you and they have no ground to stand upon when you and they try to divert responsibility to Israel.
 
Last edited:
Let` s hope that they find an interim agreement and a truce.

I fully agree with that, and further hope that such an agreement can somehow help lead to actual peace in the long run.

Differently from the warmongers, I do not like to see Palestinian and Israeli people killed

Which warmongers? Either way, I don't like seeing people killed on either side, as well.
 
I do agree that that specific proposal was not viable, as it was.

Aridas,
I hope we can agree that if you lie by saying that Israel offered to accept the two-state solutions based on the 1967 borders there is little room for further talk
 
Aridas,
I hope we can agree that if you lie by saying that Israel offered to accept the two-state solutions based on the 1967 borders there is little room for further talk

Except that I didn't lie by any meaningful usage of "lie," and that has been backed up repeatedly, even by sources that you brought up to try to prove that I was wrong. You, on the other hand, have repeatedly and demonstrably propagated false information about the US, what's been said, and more. There may be little room for further talk, but that has more to do with you refusing to engage in honest discussion.
 
Last edited:
Except that I didn't lie by any meaningful usage of "lie," and that has been backed up repeatedly. .

You are lying again.
There has never been any Israeli proposal to go back to the 1967 borders.

On the opposite, I have provided evidence that Nethanyahu expressely rejected that idea.
 
This is the Israel+US` view on the matter: since Hamas is bad as they do not accept the two state solution on the 1967 borders, let` s also not accept the same solution and blame it all on Hamas
Since Hamas kills civilians, let` s kill 10 times more and blame it all on Hamas
 
This is the Israel+US` view on the matter: since Hamas is bad as they do not accept the two state solution on the 1967 borders, let` s also not accept the same solution and blame it all on Hamas
Since Hamas kills civilians, let` s kill 10 times more and blame it all on Hamas

Nope. Not even close. Is there some reason why you keep resorting to trying to use demonstrably false and irrelevant propaganda, straw men and general misrepresentation of what others actually are saying, moving the goalposts, and similar tactics, when you have no honest resort other than to admit that you're wrong?
 
Last edited:
You are lying again.
There has never been any Israeli proposal to go back to the 1967 borders.

On the opposite, I have provided evidence that Nethanyahu expressely rejected that idea.

There's a significant difference between the two following statements, regardless, difficult as it might be for you to understand that, and they do not actually conflict.

"Israel offered to accept the two-state solutions based on the 1967 borders"

"There has never been any Israeli proposal to go back to the 1967 borders."

That's before touching anything else. Your accusations of lying are just as empty and invalid now as they were before, either way.
 
Last edited:
There's a significant difference between the two following statements, regardless, difficult as it might be for you to understand that, and they do not actually conflict.

"Israel offered to accept the two-state solutions based on the 1967 borders"

"There has never been any Israeli proposal to go back to the 1967 borders."

Your accusations of lying are just as invalid now as they were before, either way.

I do not see any difference between the two statements, except for the grammar.
And there has been any Israeli proposal to go back to the 1967 borders not to accept any two-state solution based on the 1967 borders
There has been a proposal to discuss the future borders based on the 1967 borders which is the article you quoted
But this another story
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom