Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
I guess this ******** has something to do with the propaganda from your medias you hear in your country.

Which claim do you not believe? That Hamas uses human shields? They did during the Second Intifada, where gunmen would surround themselves with children while shooting at Israeli military. Hamas puts it's military actions and officials around civilians. It's not western media that's a primary source for that.

Hamas still does shoot rockets targeting Israeli civilians. They still do this from sites next to or even on civilian centers. They still want the absolute destruction of Israel, they refuse to recognize Israel's right to exist , will not follow cease fires, and will not negotiate even after unilateral concessions from Israel. Which of these things to you not believe, and which do you need cites for?
 
Last edited:
I dont` think recognition of the Palestinian State` s right to exist is an unreasonable request either



Still, both were outside Israel control



It is difficult to negotiate with a gun pointed to your head.
Only free men can negotiate.
As an external, I do not find the Palestinians` requests of a state based on the 1967 unreasonable.
Israel however does not seems interested to stop their settlements, let alone go back to what were their borders in 1967
And this, in my opinion and in the opinion of many countries who voted condemning Israel, puts Israel and the US among the coutnries committing war crimes

Now you bet that someone will come out shouting butbutbutbutHamas!!

Is there any particular reason why you keep trying to put all the blame on one side with your words, to the point where keeping things in perspective and providing accurate criticism of Israel and the US, rather than the indefensible propaganda you keep trying to push, is anathema to you?

While Israel wants the Palestinian State destroyed.
Well, not even created..

Only if one ignores a number of their official stated positions on the matter. What Israel definitely wants is to not be continually attacked and they, like any country, tend to be willing to use force to achieve that goal. By the looks of it, they're employing a fair bit of restraint, in comparison to numerous other countries' approaches. Even with that said, they do have a fair bit that they will need to answer for or have really good justification for, such as that last incident cited by Childlike Empress.

There are good and bad ways to defend children.
Avoid recognizing the opponent` s state and bombing their children are not the way I would define appropriate and or acceptable

What about avoiding recognizing the opponent's state and either using or encouraging your children to suicide bomb them or put themselves in the line of fire as human shields? I consider that quite unacceptable, myself.

To address the "avoid recognizing the opponent's state" bit, though...repeatedly offering to recognize an opponent's state and give the opponent quite a bit of land that they did not control in the first place, for, in essence, the reasonable price of the opponent recognizing the legitimacy of their state and not going out of their way to attack and destroy it is, in fact, a really, really good deal for the opponent.
 
Last edited:
Is there any particular reason why you keep trying to put all the blame on one side with your words,

I never tried to put "all the blame on one side".
I clearly stated multiple times that Hamas is wrong.
What I am saying that, if Hamas is wrong, the US and Israel are at least as wrong as Hamas
:D:D
 
And Hamas is wrong here.
Lucky enough, the US and Israel are much better than Hamas as they do recognize he Palestinian State right to exist on the 1967 borders..
Oh, wait..

There was no Palestinian state in 1967.
 
And Hamas is wrong here.
Lucky enough, the US and Israel are much better than Hamas as they do recognize he Palestinian State right to exist on the 1967 borders..
Oh, wait..

What Palestinian state's 1967 borders? There was no Palestinian state. The creation of one would be done with the good will of Israel on lands currently administered by Israel. The Palestinians get nothing until they stop attacking the only ones that can grant them their state.
 
Only if one ignores a number of their official stated positions on the matter. What Israel definitely wants is to not be continually attacked and they, like any country, tend to be willing to use force to achieve that goal.

False.
Israel wants to grab land
If Israel were sincere in looking for peace, they would have offered to accept the two-state solution based on 1967 borders, but they did not.
This is the proof that Israel does not want peace


What about avoiding recognizing the opponent's state and either using or encouraging your children to suicide bomb them or put themselves in the line of fire as human shields? I consider that quite unacceptable, myself.

And on this we agree.
What me and you disagree on is that I consider Israeli behaviour at least as much not acceptable as Hamas, while you did not condemn them, you condemned only Hamas

To address the "avoid recognizing the opponent's state" bit, though...repeatedly offering to recognize an opponent's state and give the opponent quite a bit of land that they did not control in the first place, for, in essence, the reasonable price of the opponent recognizing the legitimacy of their state and not going out of their way to attack and destroy it is, in fact, a really, really good deal for the opponent.

Israel had their borders in 1967.
They expanded their borders by war.
This is not acceptable.
Since then they kept taking land away from the Palestinians.
This is not acceptable either
 
Last edited:
False.
Israel wants to grab land
If Israel were sincere in looking for peace, they would have offered to accept the two-state solution, but they did not.
This is the proof that Israel does not want peace

They have offered to accept it multiple times. You are simply lying here.

Israel had their borders in 1967.
They expanded their borders by war.
This is not acceptable.

Untrue. They expanded their borders through a defensive war. That makes it fine.

Since then they kept taking land away from the Palestinians.
This is not acceptable either

They have done no such thing. They have allowed the Palestinians to live on Israeli land.
 
Which claim do you not believe? That Hamas uses human shields? They did during the Second Intifada, where gunmen would surround themselves with children while shooting at Israeli military. Hamas puts it's military actions and officials around civilians. It's not western media that's a primary source for that.

Hamas still does shoot rockets targeting Israeli civilians. They still do this from sites next to or even on civilian centers. They still want the absolute destruction of Israel, they refuse to recognize Israel's right to exist , will not follow cease fires, and will not negotiate even after unilateral concessions from Israel. Which of these things to you not believe, and which do you need cites for?

That's what you hear in the US medias, if the palestinians leave their house they'll just blow it, if they don't they'll blow it as well because they'll say we advise you.
 
Neither of which Hamas recognizes.



In other words, your objection really is just semantic. Pathetic.



Are you aware of how many countries are islamic states? You really don't have a legitimate point here.

You are missing the point.
Those states don't claim to have a right to exist as islamic states. If the people of Iran write a new constitution (acting according to their right of self determination) and reconstitute as a secular democracy, that's their good right.

But if Israel has a right to exist as a jewish state, if secular jews and israeli arabs wanted to change that, they could not, without first giving up that imaginary right. So why do they need it in the first place?
Look at it this way: Not having a right to exist did not harm the state of Israel in any significant way in the past 66 years. Nor any other.
 
You are missing the point.
Those states don't claim to have a right to exist as islamic states. If the people of Iran write a new constitution (acting according to their right of self determination) and reconstitute as a secular democracy, that's their good right.

But if Israel has a right to exist as a jewish state, if secular jews and israeli arabs wanted to change that, they could not, without first giving up that imaginary right. So why do they need it in the first place?

I don't presume to speak for the Israelis, but I'd say that they would settle for being recognized as a state. I'm not sure where you got this "Jewish state" nonsense from. The problem is that Israel's enemies don't even recognize Israel as a state, and some of them have sworn to destroy Israel as an entity.

Look at it this way: Not having a right to exist did not harm the state of Israel in any significant way in the past 66 years. Nor any other.

You mean except for being attacked three times by all it's neighbors, and having to put up with constant harassment from terrorists. Recognition as a state is step one in international diplomacy. Without it, normal relations between two states cannot exist.
 
Last edited:
They have done no such thing. They have allowed the Palestinians to live on Israeli land.

Well, Israel wants to maintain a Jewish state, meaning non-Jews will not be allowed to live as full fledged citizens of their State.

Both Gaza and West Bank are supposed to have autonomy for displaced non-Jewish people of old Palestine region, but there has been resistance for 2-state solution on both sides, since the "Palestinians" feel that they were driven from their homes to create the Jewish State of Israel.

I do think that some in power in Israel also oppose the 2-state solution, because then West Bank could be made essentially off-limits to Jewish people, or at very least face the same issues non-Jews have in Israel.
 
Last edited:
Drop the semantic ****. Hamas wants Israel destroyed. It doesn't recognize them as a state, nor do they intend to let any Jews remain if they should win. That's all in black and white in their charter.

And in the US constitution there are several paragraphs on how slavery is to be regulated. They never changed that.
 
Well, Israel wants to maintain a Jewish state, meaning non-Jews will not be allowed to live as full fledged citizens of their State.

Please cite the relevant passage from Israel's constitution.

Both Gaza and West Bank are supposed to have autonomy for displaced non-Jewish people of old Palestine region, but there has been resistance for 2-state solution on both sides, since the "Palestinians" feel that they were driven from their homes to create the Jewish State of Israel.

I do think that some in power in Israel also oppose the 2-state solution, because then West Bank could be made essentially off-limits to Jewish people, or even face the same issues non-Jews have in Israel.

I think that any opposition in Israel against a two-state solution derives from the fact that ceding territory has had adverse effects for Israel in the past.
 
And in the US constitution there are several paragraphs on how slavery is to be regulated. They never changed that.

Are you saying that Hamas has changed and added in an amendment in their charter that contradicts the passages about the destruction of Israel, similar to the 13th amendment of the US constitution?

No?

Then what the hell are you talking about?
 
You are missing the point.
Those states don't claim to have a right to exist as islamic states.

Yes they do. They just don't talk about it all the time, because nobody contests that right. Israel is not unique in claiming a right to exist, it's only unique in having so many other countries refuse to recognize that right.

If the people of Iran write a new constitution (acting according to their right of self determination) and reconstitute as a secular democracy, that's their good right.

And? Israel's current status as a jewish state no more prevents them from doing so than Iran's status as an islamic state.

But if Israel has a right to exist as a jewish state, if secular jews and israeli arabs wanted to change that, they could not, without first giving up that imaginary right.

Since semantics are all you have as the basis for your argument, I'll just point out that having a right and exercising it are not the same, so no, they wouldn't have to give up any right.

Look at it this way: Not having a right to exist did not harm the state of Israel in any significant way in the past 66 years. Nor any other.

Still wrong. The fact that Israel's neighbors didn't recognize Israel's right to exist led to multiple wars, which did considerable harm to Israel.

tl;dr version: you're still completely wrong.
 
Are you saying that Hamas has changed and added in an amendment in their charter that contradicts the passages about the destruction of Israel, similar to the 13th amendment of the US constitution?

No?

Then what the hell are you talking about?

Not as formaly as that, but then again they never accepted it as their founding document as formaly.
But yes. They don't consider themselves bound by it, and prefer their election program. Ask them.
 
Not as formaly as that, but then again they never accepted it as their founding document as formaly.
But yes. They don't consider themselves bound by it, and prefer their election program. Ask them.

You want me to ask Hamas if they want to destroy Israel? You want me to ask them, when I can see by their action that they are acting upon the desire to destroy Israel? You want me to ask them when I can read their charter and see that they desire the destruction of Israel?

Get back to me when you want to start being serious.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom