Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
I expect it is the work of Satan.

After all, it was that sneaky Satan guy who provided Moses with a bogus set of commandments, therefore it was that same sneaky Satan guy who started up this war.

You bet, i guess it is the eye for an eye law, so as they killed one israelien, they have to kill 5000 palestinians and destroy all their homes. If someone says something it is of no matter since they have the US veto.
 
You bet, i guess it is the eye for an eye law, so as they killed one israelien, they have to kill 5000 palestinians and destroy all their homes. If someone says something it is of no matter since they have the US veto.

Wow! How terribly correct you are.
 
You bet, i guess it is the eye for an eye law, so as they killed one israelien, they have to kill 5000 palestinians and destroy all their homes. If someone says something it is of no matter since they have the US veto.


The attacks are because of continued rocket attacks. The Palestinian casualties are high for many reasons, most of them having to do with Hamas policies of using civilian shields (a war crime), not allowing residents to leave targets even though Israel gives 48 hour notice through text message, pamphlet drops, and other means, and of course the refusal of Hamas to stop launching rockets.
 
I don't think recognition of Israel's right to exist is an unreasonable request

I dont` think recognition of the Palestinian State` s right to exist is an unreasonable request either

There is a problem with your assessment here - there was no Palestinian State based on the 1967 borders - Gaza was part of Egypt and the West Bank was Jordanian.

Still, both were outside Israel control

Israel has offered to negotiate with the PA over the exact locations of borders, etc, in return for recognition of its right to exist and a cessation of hostilities - and what has happened is more rocket attacks and other acts of terrorism rather than talks. Why should Israel make further unilateral concessions when previous ones have not yielded positive results?

It is difficult to negotiate with a gun pointed to your head.
Only free men can negotiate.
As an external, I do not find the Palestinians` requests of a state based on the 1967 unreasonable.
Israel however does not seems interested to stop their settlements, let alone go back to what were their borders in 1967
And this, in my opinion and in the opinion of many countries who voted condemning Israel, puts Israel and the US among the coutnries committing war crimes

Now you bet that someone will come out shouting butbutbutbutHamas!!
 
Last edited:
Israel uses their weapons to defend their children. Hamas uses their children to defend their weapons.

Kumar is on Hamas's side. He has chosen evil, and no appeal to rationality or morality will sway him.
 
I think it is. No other state claims that it has a "right" to exist, and such a right is not recognized in international law.

Wrong on both counts. And foolish to boot: you're trying to make a semantic argument when the problem is not a semantic one. Hamas wants Israel destroyed. Agreeing to borders is meaningless when their objective remains Israel's destruction.
 
Israel uses their weapons to defend their children. Hamas uses their children to defend their weapons.

There are good and bad ways to defend children.
Avoid recognizing the opponent` s state and bombing their children are not the way I would define appropriate and or acceptable
But I do agree that most people in the US believe it may be OK to kill some 100+ civilians since the other side kills maybe 10 times less

IKumar is on Hamas's side. He has chosen evil, and no appeal to rationality or morality will sway him.

Devil Kumar!!

:boxedin::boxedin:
 
Wrong on both counts. And foolish to boot: you're trying to make a semantic argument when the problem is not a semantic one. Hamas wants Israel destroyed. Agreeing to borders is meaningless when their objective remains Israel's destruction.

While Israel wants the Palestinian State destroyed.
Well, not even created..
 
Wrong on both counts. And foolish to boot: you're trying to make a semantic argument when the problem is not a semantic one. Hamas wants Israel destroyed. Agreeing to borders is meaningless when their objective remains Israel's destruction.

That's covered by territorial integrity and right to self determination. You do not need a new "right to exist" for that, a right no other nation demands or enjoys. (And in case you didn't notice: Israel demands not only a right to exist, but a right to exist as a jewish state.)
 
The attacks are because of continued rocket attacks. The Palestinian casualties are high for many reasons, most of them having to do with Hamas policies of using civilian shields (a war crime), not allowing residents to leave targets even though Israel gives 48 hour notice through text message, pamphlet drops, and other means, and of course the refusal of Hamas to stop launching rockets.

I guess this ******** has something to do with the propaganda from your medias you hear in your country.
 
I guess this ******** has something to do with the propaganda from your medias you hear in your country.

Indeed!

The media is controlled by Satan since he wants people to go to hell. After all, he sure snookered Moses, so he is trying to snooker the people of the USA as well.
 
Now they're blowing up children in front of journalists...

Peter Beaumont said:
The retaining wall of Gaza's harbour sticks out into the Mediterranean about 100 metres from the terrace of al-Deira hotel, base to many of the journalists covering the conflict in Gaza. The first of the artillery shells came in a little after 4pm on Wednesday as I was writing on the hotel's terrace.

There is a deafening explosion as it hits a structure on the pier, a place we have seen hit before, where fishermen usually store their nets. Behind the smoke, I see four figures running, silhouettes whose legs are pumping raggedly. They clear the smoke. From their size it is clear they are a man and three young boys.

Where the harbour wall ends and the beach starts, there are a few brightly coloured tents and chairs for beach users in more peaceful times. The four figures jump on to the beach and begin running towards us and the safety of the hotel.

Only afterwards do we discover there are four others who are dead, all children, lying on the wall. I am shown a picture of one of the dead boys, his skin scorched and bruised. Their names are released later: Ahed Bakr, aged 10; Zakaria, 10; and two other boys from the Bakr family, both named Mohammad, aged 11 and nine.

The second shell catches the survivors as they reach the brightly coloured tents. As it explodes, my colleagues, now standing by the terrace wall, shout at unseen Israeli gunners who can't hear them: "They are only children." [...]
 
That's covered by territorial integrity and right to self determination. You do not need a new "right to exist" for that, a right no other nation demands or enjoys. (And in case you didn't notice: Israel demands not only a right to exist, but a right to exist as a jewish state.)

Drop the semantic ****. Hamas wants Israel destroyed. It doesn't recognize them as a state, nor do they intend to let any Jews remain if they should win. That's all in black and white in their charter.
 
I thought this was rather enlightening:



According to the video description, this is the Palestinian envoy to the UNHRC being interviewed on Palestinian TV. I do not know how accurate the translation is, but the guy admits that the Hamas rockets are crimes against humanity, while the Israeli response isn't. He claims that other Israeli activities - occupation, arrests, what he calls "Judaization" (I suppose this refers to the settlements) - are crimes against humanity, but that the Palestinians have a weakness when their plead their case, and that weakness is their rocket attacks.
 
I guess this ******** has something to do with the propaganda from your medias you hear in your country.

First you throw out stuff about rich jews. Now you add mass media conspiracy.

Only sources that agree with my preformed and factually inaccurate beliefs are true. All other sources are BS propaganda/conspiracy.
 
That's covered by territorial integrity and right to self determination.

Neither of which Hamas recognizes.

You do not need a new "right to exist" for that, a right no other nation demands or enjoys.

In other words, your objection really is just semantic. Pathetic.

(And in case you didn't notice: Israel demands not only a right to exist, but a right to exist as a jewish state.)

Are you aware of how many countries are islamic states? You really don't have a legitimate point here.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom