Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
No, the writer of that article doesn't really know what "winning" means if his prediction is a win for the people of Gaza. After all, the only way Hamas keeps getting any press is that they are putting the people of Gaza in the line of fire.

Moreover, even on its own terms it's now outdated. He talks about how willing Palestinians are to accept higher casualties than the Israelis. And it's true that in many modern conflicts, the winning side may have higher casualties than the losing side because one side is more willing to accept casualties than the other.

But the Israeli side has had almost no casualties. Iron Dome has been a game changer, just like the security fence in the west bank. There's a limit to how lopsided a conflict even the Palestinians are willing to accept. Hamas is losing, they have nothing to show for their efforts except dead Palestinians. They aren't even generating the international outrage that they hoped for. Sure, there's a few anti-Israel protests, and the people who already hate Jews are being a little more vocal. But none of that translates into any actual gains. The actual decision-makers aren't backing Hamas in this. The governments which matter are either staying out of it or voicing support for Israel.

Nobody will come to Hamas's rescue here. And because of Iron Dome, Israel can bide its time, retaliate at whatever pace and to whatever degree they want to. They aren't under a time pressure to stop the rocket attacks by any means necessary, so they aren't stuck between trying to push a military response too fast and trying to find a negotiated settlement. They have the strategic initiative now.
 
I think that the only country protecting them is now the US
Too bad (for them) the US is losing ground economically, militarly and politically at blazing speed
When the US will have no Empire, waht the Zionists will do? Ahem.

Who is the US losing ground to? The Arab states? Hells no, the Arab states are economic backwaters completely dependent on oil exports which are likely to decrease in the future while our own oil production grows. We're losing ground to China right now (though there are reasons to think that won't continue indefinitely), but China is on good terms with Israel. And if you think the US future looks grim, Russia's is even worse, with demographic decline already knocking on its door. To the extent that US protection of Israel may weaken over time, it will also be true that US protection of Israel will become less necessary over time. The threat from Arab states isn't growing, it's shrinking. They've got far bigger internal problems than Israel. So who, exactly, poses an existential threat to Israel? Unless Iran gets nukes and decides to use them, (which would also result in the destruction of Iran) then nobody does. The Palestinians sure as hell don't. They can't find their own ass with a flashlight and a map.
 
Today was one of those ever more frequent days when the BBC gets harassed by the some people who pay for it I have no idea who they actually are and think they can demand "the truth" in return... :nope:

FTFY. Although you were right to put quotes around "the truth".
 
Today was one of those ever more frequent days when the BBC gets harassed by the people who pay for it and think they can demand "the truth" in return... :nope:


looks like its a small minority of people that pay for BBC that are protesting there.
 
The support of israel by US government

We see that the US government support Israel in the destruction of Gaza to make rich US jewishs happy, don't you see something injust and wrong? And what about the jewish colonies in the palestinians territories?
 
I wonder if I can buy a lampshade made from Gazan skin or if I can get my company to use Gazan Slave Labour.

The skin-lampshade thing was actually a myth.

As much as the comparisons to Gaza as concentration camps are hyperbolic, so too is this:

@KumarS

I think I hear Alexander, Cyrus, Genghis Khan, Atilla the Hun, Tamerlane, Mehmed II, Sulemain, Cortez, Napoleon, Victoria and Hitler roaring in laughter at the idea that America is somehow an "Empire".

If you can hear those people laughing you ought to see a doctor.

And you don't have to ramp every argument you make up to 11 every time to make a point. Doing so only undermines any serious arguments you may have.
 
We see that the US government support Israel in the destruction of Gaza to make rich US jewishs happy, don't you see something injust and wrong?
Absolutely. What about making poor US jewishs happy? What has the US government done for them?

And what about the jewish colonies in the palestinians territories?
As long as the rich US jewishs are happy, I don't see the problem.
 
The thread on Israeli-Palestinian conflict in the Non-US and General Politics section would probably be a better place to discuss this.

As far as US support for Israel, I am high skeptical of the idea that making rich US Jews happy is a primary or even substantial motivator. While I have many issues with various actions of Israel and some of the specifics of US support thereof, I don't think that US support of Israel is unjust or wrong.

Israel gave land in Gaza to the Palestinians. They reacted by electing Hamas and continuing to lob rockets at Israel. The groups with agency to stop the destruction of Gaza right now are Hamas and the Palestinian voters. If those groups stopped attacking then I could condemn the attacking of Gaza, but right now I'd call it just and right.

I reserve the right to criticize and condemn any given specific action by Israel or Israelis in the current attacks though.
 
There was a lady in the radio this morning from Human Rights Watch.

She wanted to call attention to the fact that Israel is 'committing warcrimes'.
They had identified three incidents where Israel had apparently 'targeted civilians'.

I truly cannot believe how warped reporting is on this issue.

They have no choice to take military action because there are literally thousands of incidents of their civilians being targeted, gave a 48-hour warning to stop the attacks before starting their campaign, unilaterally accepted the Egyptian cease-fire proposal and ceased hostilities for six hours, give warnings before bombing by text message, dropping leaflets and 'roof knocking'.

Interviewer: 'Isn't Hamas committing war-crimes?'
HRW twunt: 'possibly'
 
We see that the US government support Israel in the destruction of Gaza to make rich US jewishs happy, don't you see something injust and wrong? And what about the jewish colonies in the palestinians territories?

I expect it is the work of Satan.

After all, it was that sneaky Satan guy who provided Moses with a bogus set of commandments, therefore it was that same sneaky Satan guy who started up this war.
 
I expect it is the work of Satan.

After all, it was that sneaky Satan guy who provided Moses with a bogus set of commandments, therefore it was that same sneaky Satan guy who started up this war.

I had no Idea Miroslav Satan was so nefarious.
 
I think that killing hundreds of civilians without having been sincere in offering a way out to the counter part (i.e. offering to end the blockade and accept the two-state solution in exchange of the end of violence) is what can be called a "war crime"

Israel does not accept a Palestinian State on the 1967 borders, same as Hamas. But it is only Hamas the bad guys
Israel kills 10x more children than Hamas, but it is only Hamas the terror state.

Go figure out how brainwashed people in the West are..

The only good outcome of the war is that Israel has been exposed to the world (I mean, except maybe the Americans that would support Israel no-matter-what) as a war crime state
Were I an Israeli citizen, I would be worried of the consequences
 
Last edited:
I think that killing hundreds of civilians without having been sincere in offering a way out to the counter part (i.e. offering to end the blockade and accept the two-state solution in exchange of the end of violence) is what can be called a "war crime"

Israel does not accept a Palestinian State on the 1967 borders, same as Hamas. But it is only Hamas the bad guys
Israel kills 10x more children than Hamas, but it is only Hamas the terror state.

Go figure out how brainwashed people in the West are..

The only good outcome of the war is that Israel has been exposed to the world (I mean, except maybe the Americans that would support Israel no-matter-what) as a war crime state
Were I an Israeli citizen, I would be worried of the consequences

There is a problem with your assessment here - there was no Palestinian State based on the 1967 borders - Gaza was part of Egypt and the West Bank was Jordanian.

Israel has offered to negotiate with the PA over the exact locations of borders, etc, in return for recognition of its right to exist and a cessation of hostilities - and what has happened is more rocket attacks and other acts of terrorism rather than talks. Why should Israel make further unilateral concessions when previous ones have not yielded positive results?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom