Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
I do not know how you want to call them, but UN resolutions should be followed.
Israel is not doing that.

Therefore, they are on the wrong side

I would call them UN General Assembly (UNGA) Resolutions.

Since UNGA resolutions are not law and do not have to be followed, they are international equivalent of your local homebrewers' association declaring that "Bob Smith is to be censured for taking more than his share of the barrell aged barleywine. Oh and Frank and Joe should consider maybe stopping trying to break Bob's containers on bottling day."

Many nation states do not adhere to UNGA Resolutions - why should Israel be singled out for non-compliance?
 
Is there any evidence that Hamas attacked Israel because they (Israel) desengaged?

:boggled:

The point we are trying to show you is that Israel's withdrawal from the Gaza strip did nothing to abate Hamas' desire for war.
 
:boggled:

The point we are trying to show you is that Israel's withdrawal from the Gaza strip did nothing to abate Hamas' desire for war.

Well...yeah! I mean, Gaza is nothing but one big Open-Air Concentration Camp!

I don't think the Palestinians are happy about living in a Concentration Camp!
 
Well...yeah! I mean, Gaza is nothing but one big Open-Air Concentration Camp!

I don't think the Palestinians are happy about living in a Concentration Camp!

???

But isn't the line you guys are trying to push that once Israel withdraws from Gaza and the West Bank the Palestinians will stop shooting? Are you now saying that the Palestinians want more than that?
 
193.

169. Saddam Moussa Moamar, 23, was killed in Khan Younis.
170. Mousa Shehade Moamar, 60, was killed in Khan Younis.
171. Hanadi Hamadi Moamar, 27, was killed in Khan Younis.
172. Adham Mohammed Abed el-Fatah Abed el-Al, was killed in Gaza.

Monday, July 14:

173. Qassem Tallal Hamdan, 23, was killed in Beit Hanoun.
174. Hamid Suleiman Abu al-Araj Deir al-Balah, 60.
175. Abdullah Mahmoud Barakah, 24, was killed in Khan Younis.
176. Tamer Salem Kodeih, 37, was killed in Khan Younis.
177. Ziad Maher al-Najjar, 17, was killed in Khan Younis.
178. Ziad Salem al-Shawi, 25, was killed in Rafah.
179. Mohammed Yasser Hamdan, 24, was killed in Gaza.
180. Mohammed Shakib al-Agha, 22, was killed in Khan Younis.
181. Mohammed Younis Abu Youssif, 25, was killed in Khan Younis.
182. Sara Omar Sheikh al-Eid, 4, was killed in Rafah.
183. Omar Ahmad Sheikh al-Eid, 24, was killed in Rafah.
184. Jihad Ahmad Sheikh al-Eid, 48, was killed in Rafah.
185. Kamal Ated Youssif Abu Taha, 16, was killed in Khan Younis.
186. Ismail Nabil Ahmad Abu Hatab, 21, was killed in Khan Younis.

Tuesday, July 15:

187. Ahmad Younis Abu Youssif, 28, was killed in Khan Younis.
188. Bushra Khalil Zoarob, 53, was killed in Rafah.
189. Atwa Amira al-Maamour, 63, was killed in Khan Younis.
190. Ismail Salim al-Najjar, 46, was killed in Khan Younis.
191. Mohammed Ahmad Ibrahim al-Najjar, 49, was killed in Khan Younis.
192. Suleiman Abu Louli, 33, was killed in Khan Younis.
193. Sobhi Abed el-Hamid Moussa, 77, was killed in Khan Younis.


Number 110:
 

Attachments

  • no110.jpg
    no110.jpg
    53.5 KB · Views: 4
BTW, here's an article about the current Gaza invasion. Actually, it was written 2 years ago, but it does demonstrate how predictable this violence has become for the article is perfect for today, also.

http://pando.com/2014/07/12/lessons...-military-is-way-less-than-it-seems-on-paper/

That article is kind of stupid. It says that Israel has lost the war. That is, the war that is claiming lots of casualties on the Hamas side, and very few on the Israeli side.

The article says that the winners of this war will be the Gazans - that is, the people who are living clustered up in a war zone, their houses destroyed, their basic necessities shattered.

No, the writer of that article doesn't really know what "winning" means if his prediction is a win for the people of Gaza. After all, the only way Hamas keeps getting any press is that they are putting the people of Gaza in the line of fire.
 
Last edited:
I have long thought that a strategy of nonviolent resistance would have produced much better results for the Palestinians by now.
That, and actually accepting the offers that have been given by Israel to return land.

There was no PALESTINE before 1947. There was no "country" that land was stolen from.
Surprisingly many do not know this. A lot of people seem to think that because the area of land is called Palestine, there must also be a historical nation bearing this name or an ethnic group called the Palestinians. This is a modern invention, in part pushed by Arafat during his regime.
 
Well...yeah! I mean, Gaza is nothing but one big Open-Air Concentration Camp!

I don't think the Palestinians are happy about living in a Concentration Camp!
What makes it an "open-air concentration camp", Jules, and how did these things come to be? Be honest with yourself.
 
I'm asking you a direct question. If you are saying that Israel is illegally in the settlements I don't think anyone here is disagreeing with you.

????????????????????????

You are the first one (or maybe second one) who said this.
After one week I am stalking all the people in this thread to give me a reply about this question

and given that the general assembly is largely a club of dictators,

OK
Since Ziggurat said so, let` s close the UN :rolleyes: :rolleyes:

I would call them UN General Assembly (UNGA) Resolutions.

Since UNGA resolutions are not law and do not have to be followed, they are international equivalent of your local homebrewers' association declaring that "Bob Smith is to be censured for taking more than his share of the barrell aged barleywine. Oh and Frank and Joe should consider maybe stopping trying to break Bob's containers on bottling day."

Many nation states do not adhere to UNGA Resolutions - why should Israel be singled out for non-compliance?

But they have an enormous importance from a moral point of view as they show what the world thinks about Israel
and there are tons of resolutions condemning Israel for the matter
All systems and Empire based on fear and killings at the end collapse.
Nazi Germany, the Soviet Union they all collapsed
The American Empire and their Zionists friends will collapse as well

:boggled:

The point we are trying to show you is that Israel's withdrawal from the Gaza strip did nothing to abate Hamas' desire for war.

As I pointed out many times, Israel should have done the right thing independently from Hamas
The fact that they did not, and the fact that they kill by far more people thnan Hamas, means that the real terrorists is them and their protector US.
But this regime will not last long
All regimes based on fear and persecution are bound to fail at the end
 
As I pointed out many times, Israel should have done the right thing independently from Hamas

First, it's not the right thing and second, why should they?

The fact that they did not, and the fact that they kill by far more people thnan Hamas, means that the real terrorists is them and their protector US.

That's not how you define terrorism.

But this regime will not last long
All regimes based on fear and persecution are bound to fail at the end

Keep dreaming, antisemites of the world.
 
????????????????????????

You are the first one (or maybe second one) who said this.
After one week I am stalking all the people in this thread to give me a reply about this question

You should lurk more, or read the threads.

As I pointed out many times, Israel should have done the right thing independently from Hamas

Your opinion has been noted on several occasions.
 
Well...yeah! I mean, Gaza is nothing but one big Open-Air Concentration Camp!

I don't think the Palestinians are happy about living in a Concentration Camp!

I wonder if I can buy a lampshade made from Gazan skin or if I can get my company to use Gazan Slave Labour.


@KumarS

I think I hear Alexander, Cyrus, Genghis Khan, Atilla the Hun, Tamerlane, Mehmed II, Sulemain, Cortez, Napoleon, Victoria and Hitler roaring in laughter at the idea that America is somehow an "Empire".
 
Last edited:
I wonder if I can buy a lampshade made from Gazan skin or if I can get my company to use Gazan Slave Labour.

No...but I hear more and more from the anti-semite whackos on the web that the Jews will be happy to sell you the blood of Gentile Children for your Passover Matzo Crackers. In fact, you can read all kind of crazy and slanderous stories about the Israelis on the Web....and the Occupation is probably making it worse.

I mean, people of Israel surely don't think the latest fighting in Gaza has done anything for their image, and I think they are right: http://www.timesofisrael.com/deaths-in-gaza-attacks-on-israel-spell-rising-popularity-for-hamas/

And while the impact of Israel's actions are limited to the Arab world in the Article above, I would bet that the rest of the world doesn't view with great favor what Israel is doing, either.

It's a War of Propaganda...to see who can become the biggest Victim.
 
No...but I hear more and more from the anti-semite whackos on the web that the Jews will be happy to sell you the blood of Gentile Children for your Passover Matzo Crackers. In fact, you can read all kind of crazy and slanderous stories about the Israelis on the Web....and the Occupation is probably making it worse.

I mean, people of Israel surely don't think the latest fighting in Gaza has done anything for their image, and I think they are right: http://www.timesofisrael.com/deaths-in-gaza-attacks-on-israel-spell-rising-popularity-for-hamas/

And while the impact of Israel's actions are limited to the Arab world in the Article above, I would bet that the rest of the world doesn't view with great favor what Israel is doing, either.

It's a War of Propaganda...to see who can become the biggest Victim.

Nobody should care what antisemites think. About who's the biggest victim, that "honor" belongs to the people of Gaza. They are the victims of having a psychopathic leadership that uses them as human shields while poking at a hornet's nest.

That said, they did elect the psychos.
 
I wonder if I can buy a lampshade made from Gazan skin or if I can get my company to use Gazan Slave Labour.


@KumarS

I think I hear Alexander, Cyrus, Genghis Khan, Atilla the Hun, Tamerlane, Mehmed II, Sulemain, Cortez, Napoleon, Victoria and Hitler roaring in laughter at the idea that America is somehow an "Empire".

I find very amusing that you consider Alexander, Cyrus, Genghis Khan, Atilla the Hun, Tamerlane, Mehmed II, Sulemain, Cortez, Napoleon, Victoria and Hitler as legitimate moral compasses
 
And while the impact of Israel's actions are limited to the Arab world in the Article above, I would bet that the rest of the world doesn't view with great favor what Israel is doing, either.

I think that the only country protecting them is now the US
Too bad (for them) the US is losing ground economically, militarly and politically at blazing speed
When the US will have no Empire, waht the Zionists will do? Ahem.
 
I find very amusing that you consider Alexander, Cyrus, Genghis Khan, Atilla the Hun, Tamerlane, Mehmed II, Sulemain, Cortez, Napoleon, Victoria and Hitler as legitimate moral compasses

He doesn't. Your reading comprehension fails yet again.
 
I think that the only country protecting them is now the US
Too bad (for them) the US is losing ground economically, militarly and politically at blazing speed
When the US will have no Empire, waht the Zionists will do? Ahem.

That's always been the case. That said, plenty of people around the world view what the Israelis are doing now as self defense while still retaining the ability to criticize Israeli excessive force.

A few people are so utterly blinded by their hatred of Jews that they aren't able to understand how someone can view the situation in shades of grey as opposed to purely black and white.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom