Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
I have long thought that a strategy of nonviolent resistance would have produced much better results for the Palestinians by now.

It would have, if they wanted what you think it's reasonable for them to want (peace, land of their own, economic prosperity, etc). But they don't (or at least, the ones with power don't), and it's a mirror fallacy to believe they do. They want to kill Jews and destroy Israel, and it follows from those goals that nonviolent resistance cannot succeed.
 
Have the Palestinians in the West Bank agreed to end hostilities and recognize Israel's existence as legitimate? Have they even allowed the option onto the negotiating table in a meaningful manner?

In 1988, however, the PLO officially endorsed a two-state solution, contingent on terms such as making East Jerusalem capital of the Palestinian state and giving Palestinians the right of return to land occupied by Palestinians prior to 1948, as well as the right to continue armed struggle until the end of "The Zionist Entity."[16] In 1996, the PLO nullified the articles of the PLO's Charter, or parts of it, which called for the destruction of Israel and for armed resistance.[17]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palestine_Liberation_Organization
 
In 1988, however, the PLO officially endorsed a two-state solution, contingent on terms such as making East Jerusalem capital of the Palestinian state and giving Palestinians the right of return to land occupied by Palestinians prior to 1948, as well as the right to continue armed struggle until the end of "The Zionist Entity."[16] In 1996, the PLO nullified the articles of the PLO's Charter, or parts of it, which called for the destruction of Israel and for armed resistance.[17]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palestine_Liberation_Organization

Nullifying those was a start, yes. Allowing provisions on the negotiating table that could reasonably end official hostilities is a step beyond that, though. Given the long and unpleasant history on both sides, provisions to that effect are likely to be both necessary and unpopular.
 
As I was assuming, still no answer ..
I have to say that somehow I am not surprised .. :rolleyes: :rolleyes:

Happy birthday, by the way..

You've received answers to your "1967 borders" question several times.

At this point, given the refusal of Hamas to even come to the table, why should Israel cede any part of the lands that were surrendered to Israel in the wake of the 6 day war that have not already been returned? Egypt negotiated in good faith, and lo, the Sinai was returned. Jordan negoitiated in good faith and was able to divest itself of the albatross known as the west bank. Syria hasn't and has essentially lost the Golan Heights.
 
You've received answers to your "1967 borders" question several times.

At this point, given the refusal of Hamas to even come to the table, why should Israel cede any part of the lands that were surrendered to Israel in the wake of the 6 day war that have not already been returned? Egypt negotiated in good faith, and lo, the Sinai was returned. Jordan negoitiated in good faith and was able to divest itself of the albatross known as the west bank. Syria hasn't and has essentially lost the Golan Heights.

I think this is the blind spot KumarS has on this issue.

KumarS read your signature over and over again until it clicks. When the land was divided those who fought against the division LOST. Then the land borders were reset. Egypt is a good example. They got their land back and settled into a compromise of peace.

This isn't kindergarten where the teacher comes over and makes Johnny give the crayons back. If you start a war and you freakin' LOSE then you don't get to call the shots anymore. You either make peace or you get squashed under the more powerful military and country.

I agree it's not "fair" but then perhaps Palestine should invest its energies in developing their country and become more powerful. Not keep trying to "win a war" through Mafiaesque intimidation and terrorism.

It's not working.
 
If you start a war and you freakin' LOSE then you don't get to call the shots anymore. You either make peace or you get squashed under the more powerful military and country.

What you are saying is against the UN Charter and therefore you are supporting a violation of the UN Charter that says that the land can not be taken by war.
However, I have to appreciate your honesty, at least you are someone replying to questions (which I assume the reply is :no)
 
Well..
While Hamas does have their responsibilities, I think a good part of the responsibility is still on Israeli, US and their supporters` shoulders since Israel has not yet agreed to a Palestinian state based on the 1967 borders

Last I heard Hamas has not yet agreed to an Israeli state based on the 1967 borders either.

Let's see, this is what I could find:
Hamas accepts 1967 borders, but will never recognize Israel, top official says

Hamas would be willing to accept a Palestinian state within 1967 borders, a leader of the militant group, Mahmoud Zahar, told the Palestinian news agency Ma'an on Wednesday, adding, however, that Hamas would never recognize Israel since such a move would counter the group's aim to "liberate" all of Palestine.

Zahar's comments come amid Palestinian efforts to form a unity government that would include former rivals Fatah and Hamas, following a reconciliation agreement the two factions signed last week in Cairo.

Speaking to Ma'an on Wednesday, Zahar, hinting at the possible political line of a future Palestinian unity cabinet, said that recognizing Israel would "preclude the right of the next generations to liberate the lands," wondering: "What will be the fate of the five million Palestinians in the diaspora?"
 
What you are saying is against the UN Charter and therefore you are supporting a violation of the UN Charter that says that the land can not be taken by war.
However, I have to appreciate your honesty, at least you are someone replying to questions (which I assume the reply is :no)

The settlements are wrong but the entire situation started with the "Palestinians" fighting against the borders set in 1947. You can't rewrite history and pretend that "the fighting started when Israel stole the land."

It didn't happen that way. They started fighting when they were given the land and they lost. Instead of building up the country they did have (or state) they decided to keep fighting. Why? They LOST. Game over.

Build your country. Stop continuing a lost cause. The infrastructure in Palestine is a freakin' disaster because they've spent the last 50 years fighting a lost cause. It's really stupid to be honest.
 
As I suspected ..
ButbutbutbutHamas!!

Why do you keep doing this? Hamas are not petty actors who have zero influence on anything or operate from within a vacuum in Gaza. They won a large number of seats in the PLC in 2006 showing that they have massive representation in the West Bank, which we are discussing.
 
Why do you keep doing this? Hamas are not petty actors who have zero influence on anything or operate from within a vacuum in Gaza. They won a large number of seats in the PLC in 2006 showing that they have massive representation in the West Bank, which we are discussing.

You mean that Hamas has a seat in the Knesset and they are one who are deciding whether Israel should retreat from the settlements?
Wow..
I thought Hamas was powerful, but not that powerful :)
 
You mean that Hamas has a seat in the Knesset and they are one who are deciding whether Israel should retreat from the settlements?
Wow..
I thought Hamas was powerful, but not that powerful :)

So you do not deny that Hamas has large amounts of influence in the West Bank, which you want Israel to unconditionally disengage from, even though when Israel unconditionally disengaged from Gaza, which Hamas had massive influence in, they were attacked as a thank you.
 
I'm asking you a direct question. If you are saying that Israel is illegally in the settlements I don't think anyone here is disagreeing with you. So why is this your "butbutbutsettlements"

That's not what CAUSED the situation right now. Or are we going to just play ping pong with agreed upon obviousness?

Seriously? LMAO
 
What you are saying is against the UN Charter and therefore you are supporting a violation of the UN Charter that says that the land can not be taken by war.
However, I have to appreciate your honesty, at least you are someone replying to questions (which I assume the reply is :no)

Which article of the UN Charter is that?
 
Which article of the UN Charter is that?

Part II. Cod&ration of the provisiona of Article 2 of the Charter

At the 1483rd meeting on 1 July 1969, the repre-
sentative of the United Arab Republic* stated that
Israel disregarded the will of the United Nations and
the principles of the Charter by persisting in its illegal
mcasurcs of annexation and the systematic obliteration
of all that was Arab in Jerusalem in spite of General
Assembly resolutions 2253 (ESV) and 2254 (ES-V)
as well as Security Council resolution 252 (1968) that
had invalidated Israeli measures and reaffirmed the
inadmissibility of acquisition of territories by war and
called upon Israel to rescind and d

http://www.un.org/en/sc/repertoire/69-71/69-71_12.pdf

I add.
I am not 100% sure it is the UN Charter or the UNSC.
Whatever it is, it is international law.
 
Do you have any evidence that they were attacked because they desengaged?

When Israel left, Hamas and Fatah went at eachother's throats, with Hamas coming out on top. After Hamas took full control, they re initiated hostilities towards Israel, which lead up to Cast Lead.
 
When Israel left, Hamas and Fatah went at eachother's throats, with Hamas coming out on top. After Hamas took full control, they re initiated hostilities towards Israel, which lead up to Cast Lead.

Is there any evidence that Hamas attacked Israel because they (Israel) desengaged?
 
Part II. Cod&ration of the provisiona of Article 2 of the Charter

At the 1483rd meeting on 1 July 1969, the repre-
sentative of the United Arab Republic* stated that
Israel disregarded the will of the United Nations and
the principles of the Charter by persisting in its illegal
mcasurcs of annexation and the systematic obliteration
of all that was Arab in Jerusalem in spite of General
Assembly resolutions 2253 (ESV) and 2254 (ES-V)
as well as Security Council resolution 252 (1968) that
had invalidated Israeli measures and reaffirmed the
inadmissibility of acquisition of territories by war and
called upon Israel to rescind and d

http://www.un.org/en/sc/repertoire/69-71/69-71_12.pdf

I add.
I am not 100% sure it is the UN Charter or the UNSC.
Whatever it is, it is international law.

First, what you are quoting above is a summary of many resolutions of the UN General Assembly - such resolutions are NOT international law.

Second, This is Article 2.

Sub Para 4 is relevant - "All Members shall refrain in their international relations from the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of any state, or in any other manner inconsistent with the Purposes of the United Nations."

To the issue of the Israeli occupation of the territories claimed after Egypt, Syria and Jordan LOST the 6 Days War. the argument there is whether or not the 6 Days War was a one of a defensive nature (ie. was there an imminent threat from the nations attacked against the nation doing the attacking) has an effect on whether or not the war was one that was contrary to the UN Charter (which IS international law, being a treaty to which Israel is signatory), Israel occupied those territories until the nation states entered into negotiations with Israel for their return - this didn't happen until after those same states LOST the Yom Kippur War and Egypt and Jordan, seeing that continued wars with Israel weren't likely to accomplish anything of benefit to them, entered into negotiations with Israel.

Israel returned the Sinai to Egypt, and Egypt gave up it's claim to Gaza.

Jordan gave up the claims to the West Bank

Technically, with the countries who orginally had control of these territories ceding control to the occupying power, those territories were gained by Israel and if another group wants them, they have two options:

a. Win a war with Israel and claim them;
b. Negotiate with Israel for them.

Hamas appears to be incapable of the first, and unwilling to do the second.
 
First, what you are quoting above is a summary of many resolutions of the UN General Assembly - such resolutions are NOT international law.

I do not know how you want to call them, but UN resolutions should be followed.
Israel is not doing that.

Therefore, they are on the wrong side
 
I do not know how you want to call them, but UN resolutions should be followed.

UN General Assembly resolutions are not binding. The general assembly has no power or authority to enforce any of its resolutions. All those resolutions amount to is a popularity contest, and given that the general assembly is largely a club of dictators, it's a feature, not a bug, that the resolutions mean nothing.

Israel is not doing that.

Therefore, they are on the wrong side

Argument ad populum is a fallacy.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom