Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
So they are not for defense purposes (only)
Agreed

They are as far as the state is concerned. They are not as far at the settlers are concerned. Is this confusing to you?


How is Hamas` s behaviour in Gaza relevant to the decision by Israel to retreat or not from the land taken in the West Bank?

Because as long as Israel has no guarantee that Hamas will accept Israel's right to continued existence and keep lobbing rockets, Israel has no incentive whatsoever to withdraw from the West Bank, and it would in fact hurt their security situation.

Now, this has been explained to you many times. It would take someone utterly stupid or seriously dishonest to misunderstand this by now.
 
I do not think that Israel has ever completely retreated, or offered to completely retreat, from the lands taken after the 1967 war.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israeli_disengagement_from_Gaza

Those Israeli citizens who refused to accept government compensation packages and voluntarily vacate their homes prior to the August 15, 2005 deadline, were evicted by Israeli security forces over a period of several days.[1] The eviction of all residents, demolition of the residential buildings and evacuation of associated security personnel from the Gaza Strip was completed by September 12, 2005.[2] The eviction and dismantlement of the four settlements in the northern West Bank was completed ten days later.
 
If I remember correctly, the lands claimed as a result of the 6 Day War were the Sinai (returned to Egypt in 1978 or 79), Gaza (not returned to Egypt, but also ceded by Egypt to Israel, who in 2005 gave it to the Palestinian Authority), the West Bank (ceded to the PA in 2005), Jerusalem (not returned and essentially absorbed by Israel) and the Golan Heights (not returned to Syria). There is or were no significant populations in the Golan, and the Israelis are holding it as a buffer zone to delay any incursion from Syria.
 
If I remember correctly, the lands claimed as a result of the 6 Day War were the Sinai (returned to Egypt in 1978 or 79), Gaza (not returned to Egypt, but also ceded by Egypt to Israel, who in 2005 gave it to the Palestinian Authority), the West Bank (ceded to the PA in 2005), Jerusalem (not returned and essentially absorbed by Israel) and the Golan Heights (not returned to Syria). There is or were no significant populations in the Golan, and the Israelis are holding it as a buffer zone to delay any incursion from Syria.

Actually, there was a significant population in Golan until Israel drive them out.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golan_Heights

As far as the Sinai is concerned, Israel read the "Writing on the wall" as a result of the 1973 War and decided that peace with Egypt was more desirable that war. So they gave up the Sinai to Egypt.

Israel takes from the weak. But Israel can be forced to give back to the strong.
 
I have read the link and can not find where Israel is OK with the two-state solution based on 1967 borders

I'll ask again. Why would this particular speech THAT YOU CHOSE be reasonable to expect to find specific details in the first place? Why should anyone believe that you're not choosing it specifically because it doesn't include all the specific details that Israel would be willing to accept, regardless of how much it destroys your poor attempts at arguments in general. Beyond that, why would that speech even matter when it's already been separately demonstrated that Israel has repeated been willing to go to the negotiating table prepared to turn over land on the lines that you're fixated upon, which was exactly the thing that you were trying to claim hasn't happened, before you repeatedly moved the goalposts.
 
ButbutbutbutHamas!!
Who is in charge to odering (or not ordering) the removal of the settlements outside the 1967 borders?

As usual, you're just running away, unable to actually defend your position. Instead, you've resorted to strawmen and playing dumb, yet again. How's that working out for you?

the question, already asked a few days ago, is still here:

Israel took land outside their previous borders (1967) and they keep build settlements.
Shall they be able to retain that land or not regardless what Hamas does?

And it's as nonsensical when reality is considered now as it was then, given that the actions of the Palestinian government are directly relevant to any reasonable answer. That you keep trying to ignore this is openly dishonest behavior. Why, exactly, are you repeatedly trying to tell us that the Israelis should just let themselves be attacked continually and not respond for the sake of what you think should happen? As was noted in the very speech you linked, Israel has tried, repeatedly, to withdraw, with and without agreements in place, partially and nearly fully... and every time they do, the attacks on them intensify, which tends to force their hand for the sake of their people.
 
Israel’s Security Cabinet Accepts Egyptian Cease-fire Proposal

JERUSALEM — Israel has accepted Egypt’s proposal for a cessation of hostilities with the Gaza Strip, the prime minister’s office announced at 9 a.m. Tuesday, the appointed hour in the proposal made by Cairo on Monday night.

The announcement came via text message and without comment after Israel’s top ministers, known as its security cabinet, met early Tuesday. It followed a relatively quiet night, with fewer Israeli airstrikes and Gaza rocket attacks than has been typical of the intense fighting, which began last Monday.

It was unclear whether Hamas, the Palestinian militant faction that dominates Gaza and led the aerial battle with Israel, would also accept the Egyptian plan, which won backing from the Arab League and the Palestinian Authority.

“The responses of resistance will continue until the demands of our people are achieved,” Sami Abu Zuhri, a Hamas spokesman in Gaza, wrote on his Facebook page. “Any unilateral Israeli cessation has no value in the light of the large crimes and the disastrous humanitarian situation.”

Although several top Israeli ministers had criticized the idea of a cease-fire, saying that not enough damage had yet been inflicted on Hamas’s infrastructure and weapons cache, analysts saw little downside for Israel in accepting the Egyptian outline. The cease-fire will either lead to a genuine calm that benefits both sides or, if Hamas rejects the terms, provide Israel with more international legitimacy to continue the conflict.
 
Let` s hope that this stupid war will finish soon

Yeah, let's hope that now the evil Israelis have finally accepted a truce, the war will end. The only thing that could possibly go wrong is...

Hamas's armed wing, the al-Qassam Brigades, rejected the reported text of the truce deal, saying: "Our battle with the enemy continues and will increase in ferocity and intensity."

http://uk.reuters.com/article/2014/07/15/uk-palestinians-israel-idUKKBN0FI04D20140715

Oh bottom!

So, why would Hamas's "armed wing" reject the truce?
 
Happy birthday, Aridas :) !

As was noted in the very speech you linked, Israel has tried, repeatedly, to withdraw, with and without agreements in place, partially and nearly fully... and every time they do, the attacks on them intensify, which tends to force their hand for the sake of their people.
There have been other kinds of gestures as well. For example, both Israeli moderates and the international community rightfully criticises the expansion of settlements, so the Israeli government tries freezing said settlement construction.

HAMAS' response is always the same: nothing. The same hateful rhetoric, the same number of rockets, the same hatred. There simply can't be a mutal peace, or any kind of Israeli seccessions, as long as the Palestinian rulers use "resistance" as a transparent excuse to commit terorist acts and simply do not want peace.
 
I have long thought that a strategy of nonviolent resistance would have produced much better results for the Palestinians by now. Maybe the results of this latest conflict would give them a hint (although I'm not going to hold my breath). It worked for Gandhi, it worked for Mandela. Every act of terror only hardens Israeli public opinion against making any concessions, and moves it further to the hard-line position. Once, Likud was a right-wing party. Now they are like the moderates, and other parties even further to the right than Likud are growing, while the old left Labour party is shrinking.
 
I have long thought that a strategy of nonviolent resistance would have produced much better results for the Palestinians by now.

The Palestinians in the West Bank have been quite peaceful

I have seen that this has fostered good results and the Israeli have withdrawn from the West Bank

Hamas has a Facebook page? What's next, Breivik creating a Twitter account?

Or Nethanyahu and Obama having a Google + page ..
 
Change the subject ?
It is about one week that I keep asking the same quetsion: why the Israeli do not accept the two-state solution based on the 1967 borders?



Err..
Let alone that this site does not appear to me extremely authoritative, there is just written that the Israeli government uses the pre-1967 borders as a "baseline" for the future status.
Which does not mean the Israeli government has agreed that they would go back to the pre-1967 borders

It is the Palestinians that are OK with the pre-1967 borders
The Palestinian Declaration of Independence of 15 November 1988, which referenced the UN Partition Plan of 1947 and "UN resolutions since 1947" in general, was interpreted as an indirect recognition of the State of Israel, and support for a two-state solution. The Partition Plan was invoked to provide legitimacy to Palestinian statehood. Subsequent clarifications were taken to amount to the first explicit Palestinian recognition of Israel
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two-state_solution

Security Council resolutions dating back to June 1976 supporting the two-state solution based on the pre-1967 lines were vetoed by the United States,[10] which argued that the borders must be negotiated directly by the parties. The idea has had overwhelming support in the UN General Assembly since the mid-1970s

Here is the full speech of Nethanyahu speech in 2009
http://www.haaretz.com/news/full-text-of-netanyahu-s-foreign-policy-speech-at-bar-ilan-1.277922

Please tell me where he accepts the two-state solution based on 1967 borders



But your position, as mine, is irrelevant.
The position of the US Government is what matters.
The point is: why the US government is still giving military aid to Israel despite the settlements?



And here we go..
Butbutbutbut Hamas!


Couple of questions. Why did they push into the land in the first place?

You make it sound like the situation is this

Two states living peacefully next to each other and then Israel crept in and stole the land. Then Hamas lost it's **** and decided to retaliate.

What fantasy History book did you get this idea from?

There was no PALESTINE before 1947. There was no "country" that land was stolen from. Only after Israel was reestablished with new land issues did the Palestinians start squawking about their country. Then they wanted the Israelis out and so they started to attack and attack and tried to push them out.

They couldn't do it. But they were quite successful in causing massive violence and destruction in their efforts to do so. In the end there really wasn't ever going to be a peaceful resolution because Hamas (yes Hamas) continually attacked.

Some of the issues with the "land" were about creating a buffer zone to prevent constant lobbing of bombs etc. In other words they needed a protection. And that's really what the push into the "stolen lands" is mostly about. It's definitely been taken advantage of.

But you are rewriting history here to make it seem like the reason the Palestinians started attacking the Israelis is because they 'stole the land."

It just isn't true at all.
 
The Palestinians in the West Bank have been quite peaceful

I have seen that this has fostered good results and the Israeli have withdrawn from the West Bank

Have the Palestinians in the West Bank agreed to end hostilities and recognize Israel's existence as legitimate? Have they even allowed the option onto the negotiating table in a meaningful manner?
 
Last edited:
They couldn't do it. But they were quite successful in causing massive violence and destruction in their efforts to do so. In the end there really wasn't ever going to be a peaceful resolution because Hamas (yes Hamas) continually attacked.

Incidentally, Hamas was formed in 1987. You could try to claim that Hamas' precursors continually attacked, but not Hamas, specifically. As another important date to keep in mind, Hamas gained control of the Gaza Strip's government in 2006. Blaming the actions of the Palestinian government on them before 2006 would require justification, not that the quoted specifically deals with the government.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom