Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
If Israel gave all that land back, would it bring peace?

No, it would not.

So why should Israel do so?

I do not grasp it.
Assuming that giving back the land was the right thing to do, why not just do it instead of blame it on the other.
Going back to the 1967 is a decision involving Israel only, as it is Israel outside the 1967 borders, not Hamas
 
I do not grasp it.

We've all noticed.

Assuming that giving back the land was the right thing to do

Why should we assume that?

why not just do it instead of blame it on the other.

Because it would weaken their security. There is no benefit to them to doing so, only cost. And no matter how much you say that they should do it because it's the right thing to do, it's simply delusional to expect Israel, alone of all nations, to act purely selflessly.

Going back to the 1967 is a decision involving Israel only, as it is Israel outside the 1967 borders, not Hamas

Israel already unilaterally withdrew from Gaza. They did not negotiate the withdrawl, they did not demand anything in return, they just... gave it back. They did exactly what you wanted them to do. And what has been the result? They have been repaid with rockets.

Why would they repeat that with the West Bank?
 
Change the subject ?
It is about one week that I keep asking the same quetsion: why the Israeli do not accept the two-state solution based on the 1967 borders?

In fair part because that's not the only issue in play. Your overly simplistic approach tries to ignore this.

Err..
Let alone that this site does not appear to me extremely authoritative, there is just written that the Israeli government uses the pre-1967 borders as a "baseline" for the future status.
Which does not mean the Israeli government has agreed that they would go back to the pre-1967 borders

It's far from the only source available. Look it up yourself, though, because your demand has been met... and you're immediately moving the goal posts. No, the Israeli government has not agreed to do such. As has been pointed out in this thread, when the other party or parties as the case may be 1) don't agree and don't even come up with a counter-proposal or 2) is explicitly against not getting everything they want, solely blaming Israel for not agreeing is idiotic.

Please tell me where he accepts the two-state solution based on 1967 borders

Amusing. You didn't even try to read it, did you? From that link,

But, friends, we must state the whole truth here. The truth is that in the area of our homeland, in the heart of our Jewish Homeland, now lives a large population of Palestinians. We do not want to rule over them. We do not want to run their lives. We do not want to force our flag and our culture on them. In my vision of peace, there are two free peoples living side by side in this small land, with good neighborly relations and mutual respect, each with its flag, anthem and government, with neither one threatening its neighbor's security and existence.

This looks like exactly what you seem to think doesn't exist. Unless, of course, you're making the totally unreasonable demand to find all the specifics in a speech where it would not have been appropriate to put all the details in in the first place... years before the negotiations in question took place. Furthermore, an earlier bit completely counters most of the arguments that you've tried to make.

Whoever thinks that the continued hostility to Israel is a result of our forces in Judea, Samaria and Gaza is confusing cause and effect. The attacks on us began in the 1920s, became an overall attack in 1948 when the state was declared, continued in the 1950s with the fedaayyin attacks, and reached their climax in 1967 on the eve of the Six-Day War, with the attempt to strangle Israel. All this happened nearly 50 years before a single Israeli soldier went into Judea and Samaria.

To our joy, Egypt and Jordan left this circle of hostility. They signed peace agreements with us which ended their hostility to Israel. It brought about peace.

To our deep regret, this is not happening with the Palestinians. The closer we get to a peace agreement with them, the more they are distancing themselves from peace. They raise new demands. They are not showing us that they want to end the conflict.

A great many people are telling us that withdrawal is the key to peace with the Palestinians. But the fact is that all our withdrawals were met by huge waves of suicide bombers.

We tried withdrawal by agreement, withdrawal without an agreement, we tried partial withdrawal and full withdrawal. In 2000, and once again last year, the government of Israel, based on good will, tried a nearly complete withdrawal, in exchange for the end of the conflict, and were twice refused.

We withdrew from the Gaza Strip to the last centimeter, we uprooted dozens of settlements and turned thousands of Israelis out of their homes. In exchange, what we received were missiles raining down on our cities, our towns and our children. The argument that withdrawal would bring peace closer did not stand up to the test of reality.





But your position, as mine, is irrelevant.

Nice try to equivocate and misrepresent the nature of this.

The position of the US Government is what matters.

Why would the US Government matter when the Israelis and the Palestinians are the parties that actually have a direct say in how they will relate to each other? Yet again, you try to change the subject. Again, you demonstrate that you are completely unable to defend your position.

The point is: why the US government is still giving military aid to Israel despite the settlements?

You're really bad at understanding politics, in short.

And here we go..
Butbutbutbut Hamas!

And here we go again with your failure to comprehend even the basics. Keep playing dumb and everyone will think you actually are.
 
Last edited:
Amusing. You didn't even try to read it, did you? From that link,



This looks like exactly what you seem to think doesn't exist. Unless, of course, you're making the totally unreasonable demand to find all the specifics in a speech where it would not have been appropriate to put all the details in in the first place... years before the negotiations in question took place. Furthermore, an earlier bit completely counters most of the arguments that you've tried to make.

Where exactly in the quoted part of the speech Mr. Nethanyahu is agreeing to go back to the pre-1967 borders?

Why would the US Government matter when the Israelis and the Palestinians are the parties that actually have a direct say in how they will relate to each other?

As they are the ones providing military aid to Israel + using their veto power to help them
 
Because it would weaken their security.

They could put some military outposts there, why is building settlements outside the pre-1967 borders improving the security?

So, in short, some people here say that going back to the pre-1967 borders is the right thing to do.
Do you think this is the case or not?

In my opinion the should give back that land (WB) apart from some bits where it is more practical/advantageous for both parties to do land-swaps.
 
So, in short, some people here say that going back to the pre-1967 borders is the right thing to do.

Get Hamas et al to agree that the 1967 borders are legit and will end the conflict, then I will sign on.
 
Where exactly in the quoted part of the speech Mr. Nethanyahu is agreeing to go back to the pre-1967 borders?

Go back a few steps. Why would this speech THAT YOU CHOSE have those details in the first place? Why are you moving the goalposts from 1967 borders to pre-1967 borders?

Are you ever going to stop using completely dishonest tactics?



As they are the ones providing military aid to Israel + using their veto power to help them

Which is totally irrelevant, really, despite your repeated fallacious attempts to treat the US and Israel as the same entity.


ETA: Actually, I have a direct question for you KumarS. With all the many valid criticisms that can be made regarding Israel and it's actions, why do you keep using such pathetically invalid criticisms and employing such dishonest tactics to try to make your fallacious points? Are you trying to use reverse psychology to make those here favor Israel more? Are you trolling? Are you just that ignorant and biased?
 
Last edited:
Get Hamas et al to agree that the 1967 borders are legit and will end the conflict, then I will sign on.

As part of that, get them to officially agree that Israel is a legitimate entity in the first place and many, many problems would be likely to lose their edge.
 
They could put some military outposts there, why is building settlements outside the pre-1967 borders improving the security?

An outpost without control of the territory behind that outpost is a vulnerability, not an asset. Since Israel has an interest in controlling that territory, why not place settlements there?

If conditions were ever favorable to peace, the settlements could always be removed. That's what Israel did with Gaza. But conditions aren't favorable to peace, because of the Palestinians, so Israel has nothing to gain by removing them now.

So, in short, some people here say that going back to the pre-1967 borders is the right thing to do.
Do you think this is the case or not?

I think it's an arbitrary fixation on those borders. Why those, and not the pre-1948 borders? Why not some other borders?

Both Egypt and Jordan have renounced their territorial claims to Gaza and the West Bank (ponder that injustice for a while: entire populations have been abandoned to the mercy of the enemy). Israel controls that land by right of conquest. How much they give up (not return, since Egypt and Jordan will not take it back) should be determined by what will produce the most stable peace. And right now, that percentage is... 0%. Perhaps in the future it will be 100%, but perhaps it will only be, say, 80%. That ultimately depends quite a bit on the Palestinians. And I am no prophet, so I cannot tell you what it will eventually be, if peace is ever reached.
 
Get Hamas et al to agree that the 1967 borders are legit and will end the conflict, then I will sign on.

BUTBUTBUTBUTHAMAS!
Hamas is not the one who has to take the decision to go back or not to the 1967 borders in the West bank

Go back a few steps. Why would this speech THAT YOU CHOSE have those details in the first place? Why are you moving the goalposts from 1967 borders to pre-1967 borders?

I use the terms "1967 borders" and "pre-1967 borders" meaning the same thing.
That is, the borders before the 1967 war.

I wrote : Please tell me where he accepts the two-state solution based on 1967 borders
You replied: Amusing. You didn't even try to read it, did you? From that link,

I have read the link and can not find where Israel is OK with the two-state solution based on 1967 borders
 
An outpost without control of the territory behind that outpost is a vulnerability, not an asset. Since Israel has an interest in controlling that territory, why not place settlements there?

You mean that settlements are placed outside the 1967 for purely defensive reasons?

As part of that, get them to officially agree that Israel is a legitimate entity in the first place and many, many problems would be likely to lose their edge.

ButbutbutbutHamas!!
Who is in charge to odering (or not ordering) the removal of the settlements outside the 1967 borders?
 
Change the subject ?
It is about one week that I keep asking the same quetsion: why the Israeli do not accept the two-state solution based on the 1967 borders?

And I keep telling you that the Israelis have done so from the start. The Palestinians didn't.
 
You mean that settlements are placed outside the 1967 for purely defensive reasons?



ButbutbutbutHamas!!
Who is in charge to odering (or not ordering) the removal of the settlements outside the 1967 borders?

You really don't understand what we're talking about at all, do you? Why are you even participating in this conversation if you aren't going to even make an effort to understand the basics?
 
You mean that settlements are placed outside the 1967 for purely defensive reasons?

No, I do not mean that, and I did not say that.

ButbutbutbutHamas!!

ButButButIsrael!!

Address the question, Kumar.

Who is in charge to odering (or not ordering) the removal of the settlements outside the 1967 borders?

Again, absent any serious prospects for peace, why should Israel remove the settlements?

You want them to do something which will not help them in any way, which will instead cost them, all to benefit people who want to kill them. Why should they do that? Why would they do that?
 
No, I do not mean that, and I did not say that.

So why are the settlements there?

ButButButIsrael!!

Address the question, Kumar.

the question, already asked a few days ago, is still here:

Israel took land outside their previous borders (1967) and they keep build settlements.
Shall they be able to retain that land or not regardless what Hamas does?

Israel took land outside their previous borders (1967) and they keep build settlements.
Shall they be able to retain that land or not regardless what Hamas does?

To me, it looks fairly simple and straightforward.
Israel has took some land outside their previous borders (1967).
And they keep build settlements outside their borders.
Shall they be able to retain that land or not regardless what Hamas does?
I do not see why I can not get a straight reply from you on this matter

So far..
The only person replying to this question has been EddieDane
 
Last edited:
Israel took land outside their previous borders (1967) and they keep build settlements.
Shall they be able to retain that land or not regardless what Hamas does?

Israel can do whatever they want. In order to get a peaceful solution with the Palestinians they should probably think about ceding some of that land to a Palestinian authority that accepts the right of Israel to exist. That authority is not Hamas, and as long as Hamas is a major player in Palestinian matters, Israel shouldn't give up anything.

Now you can answer the many questions you lamely dodged or falsely accused of being logical fallacies.
 
the question, already asked a few days ago, is still here:

What you are not understanding is that unconditionally disengaging from areas obtained during the 6 day war has not stopped the violence towards Israel. When people say "Hamas..." in response to your question, they're not saying "BUTHAMAS", they're showing you an example of how respected Israel's actions are when they make a legitimate attempt at peace. One way to encourage Israel to get out of the West Bank would be to get people like Hamas (and others...) to finally say "Yes, that will be enough to get peace."

Why do you object to that?
 
So why are the settlements there?

Because there are Israelis who want to live there.

Israel took land outside their previous borders (1967) and they keep build settlements.
Shall they be able to retain that land or not regardless what Hamas does?

Long-term status of that land is very dependent upon Hamas's behavior. You can't meaningfully ask "regardless of what Hamas does", because what Hamas does is directly relevant.
 
What you are not understanding is that unconditionally disengaging from areas obtained during the 6 day war has not stopped the violence towards Israel.

I do not think that Israel has ever completely retreated, or offered to completely retreat, from the lands taken after the 1967 war.
 
Because there are Israelis who want to live there.

So they are not for defense purposes (only)
Agreed

Long-term status of that land is very dependent upon Hamas's behavior. You can't meaningfully ask "regardless of what Hamas does", because what Hamas does is directly relevant.

How is Hamas` s behaviour in Gaza relevant to the decision by Israel to retreat or not from the land taken in the West Bank?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom