Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well...it looks like people all over the world are protesting Israel and it's invasion of Palestine.
This is about as useless as an argument as Childlike's lists of names. I think all of us here know Irael is unpopular. It also receives a level of attention that is not proportional to what is actually happening there. So yes, there are going to be protests. No, the fact that there are protests doesn't mean that what Israel's current operation is wrong.
 
While I posted the names of 100+ fatal victims of Israeli bombardment of Gaza, nobody asked for a list of rocket attack victims in Israel, because we all know there are none. Zero. Someone at a targeted gas station was rumoured to be injured.

No, that's not why. Rational people understand it doesn't matter.

If I throw a punch at someone and he ducks, responding with several solid punches to my face that break my nose, crack my eye-socket and knock out several teeth, I don't have the right to claim "disproportionate response". It doesn't matter that he wasn't hurt. I tried to hurt him. His reaction is still self-defense.

I'm sure you think when you post those lists you think you're confronting people with how awful Israel is in killing all those people. When I see those lists I think, "Wow, these are real people who have suffered and died due to Hamas's intransigence. Why can't Palestinians be more like the Kurds, who are working towards independence by building the infrastructure of government and services, who refuse to engage in terrorism, and who only use violence in self-defense?"

The people who are directly responsible for the safety of Gazan people are not Israel, but Hamas. Hamas was democratically elected to be their government. Hamas are the ones who are putting Gazans in harms way by engaging in armed conflict with Israel, and when Gazans die as a result of it, the blood is on the hands of Hamas.

And the latest sickening outrage from Hamas? Deliberately trying to boost civilian casualties:

Hamas tells Palestinian civilians to stay in homes in face of Israeli warnings
 
Talking about Crazy...here's an article from a Israeli Newspaper entitled, "Hamas Editor Links Teen's Murder with 'Matzah Blood Libel'"

http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/182499#.U8LbvlNqirM

Instead of dismissing the Hamas Editor who wrote the article as a "Whack Job", the Israeli article goes through great pains to document and refute the libel. Gawd knows why.

Because there are people who believe it. That might well include Israeli Arabs.

Now, about how Fatah could take out Hamas with Israeli air and artillery strikes? We're all waiting for your explanation. Until you provide one, your credibility here is zero.
 
While I posted the names of 100+ fatal victims of Israeli bombardment of Gaza, nobody asked for a list of rocket attack victims in Israel, because we all know there are none. Zero. Someone at a targeted gas station was rumoured to be injured.

Of course. "Rumored" to be injured. Of course, it's not actually a rumor but a fact, nor is that the only victim (a woman in Haifa died), but such phrasing allows you to downplay the seriousness of the situation. You get to deploy your own ignorance as a rhetorical weapon.

But Mycroft is also right, aside from your lies of omission, the more fundamental lie is that this is the relevant metric to begin with. According to your moral calculus, the situation would be improved if more Israelis were dying. Maybe Israel should just shut down Iron Dome, would that make you happier?

Actually, I bet it would.
 
No, that's not why. Rational people understand it doesn't matter.

If I throw a punch at someone and he ducks, responding with several solid punches to my face that break my nose, crack my eye-socket and knock out several teeth, I don't have the right to claim "disproportionate response". It doesn't matter that he wasn't hurt. I tried to hurt him. His reaction is still self-defense.

[/URL]

No. What the other guy did is not self-defense...it is fighting. Self Defense when using violence is doing just enough to stop the immediate danger...and no more.

Every year, lots of guys who trained for Self-Defense at some local McDojo go all KungFooy on some obnoxious drunk in a bar and wonder why they have been arrested and thrown in jail when all they were doing was "Self Defense". The lawyers make a ton of money on these guys.
 
No. What the other guy did is not self-defense...it is fighting. Self Defense when using violence is doing just enough to stop the immediate danger...and no more.

Every year, lots of guys who trained for Self-Defense at some local McDojo go all KungFooy on some obnoxious drunk in a bar and wonder why they have been arrested and thrown in jail when all they were doing was "Self Defense". The lawyers make a ton of money on these guys.

Who's the arbiter of what's too much violence? You?

Also... you still haven't answer the question about Fatah taking on Hamas. Just letting you know that your credibility is still zero.
 
Instead of dismissing the Hamas Editor who wrote the article as a "Whack Job", the Israeli article goes through great pains to document and refute the libel. Gawd knows why.
You're honestly unable to understand why someone would respond to something in a serious, mature manner rather than by poisoning the well? Really? Because to me this seems like the mature and adult thing to do. Not sure why it baffles you so.
 
No. What the other guy did is not self-defense...it is fighting. Self Defense when using violence is doing just enough to stop the immediate danger...and no more.

And if that's what it took to stop the immediate danger? You make an assumption that isn't warranted, and avoid the central point that the injuries to the two parties are not indicative of which party is to blame.
 
I have never understood the whole deal with "disproportionate response", to be honest. If you commit an act of war, no matter how justified you believe it to be, you have no one to blame but yourself if a war does indeed ensue, and you that more casualties than the enemy. Especially if said act of war is targetted at the enemy's civilian population rather than their armed forces.

This whole "proportionate response" thing seems to be another one of those arguments that is applied only to the Israel-Palestine conflict.
 
You couldn't find a less objective source? Because, see, context and the other side's perspective are incredibly important when things like this happens.
 
Now it is being reported that Israel has bombed the Handicapped.

http://www.opednews.com/articles/Is...on_Israel_Israel-Attacks-Gaza-140713-987.html

Wow....explain THAT to the folks back home!

I sincerely hope Israel can show evidence that there was a legitimate target there, or at least admit to making a terrible mistake. A military official has said that it is under investigation. That said, this kind of thing is absolutely not acceptable. In the sources about this incident we can read about the steps the IDF takes in order to prevent civilian casualties.

Now. About how Fatah could take out Hamas, Jules? You still haven't replied. Are you running from your failed argument?
 
Last edited:
Now it is being reported that Israel has bombed the Handicapped.

http://www.opednews.com/articles/Is...on_Israel_Israel-Attacks-Gaza-140713-987.html

Wow....explain THAT to the folks back home!

Huh. Sources seem... conflicted about the details.

http://www.nytimes.com/2014/07/13/world/middleeast/israel-gaza-strip.html

"Neighbors like Yasir Abu Shoodq, 32, stared up at the sky through the holes the missile cut through the roof and each floor before making a crater in the ground. Children picked up the chunks of sharp steel from the crater and made off with them."

http://wallwritings.me/2014/07/12/israel-destroys-gaza-home-for-handicapped/

"The lower picture of the destroyed Mabaret home, with men in the basement where the bomb exploded is from AP. It was taken by Khalil Hamra."

You will notice in the picture that there are no holes in the roof or floors above through which anyone could be looking up at the sky, because the entire building is collapsed. This isn't adding up.

From the NYT link, again:

"At the site, neighbors picked through the rubble of modest medical equipment and scattered children’s books, from the small neighborhood children’s library Ms. Elaiwa ran. There was a seared copy of “Jane Eyre,” condensed, in English with Arabic translation, and an English-language copy of “Ali Baba and the Forty Thieves.”"

Who the **** cares about the titles of the books left after the bombing? That has all the stink of "details" that people give because they think it will make a lie more plausible.

In other words, unless there's some much better information about what exactly happened, I don't believe a word of the story so far. I've been lied to too many times about supposed Israeli crimes which turned out to never have happened.
 
Huh. Sources seem... conflicted about the details.

http://www.nytimes.com/2014/07/13/world/middleeast/israel-gaza-strip.html

"Neighbors like Yasir Abu Shoodq, 32, stared up at the sky through the holes the missile cut through the roof and each floor before making a crater in the ground. Children picked up the chunks of sharp steel from the crater and made off with them."

http://wallwritings.me/2014/07/12/israel-destroys-gaza-home-for-handicapped/

"The lower picture of the destroyed Mabaret home, with men in the basement where the bomb exploded is from AP. It was taken by Khalil Hamra."

You will notice in the picture that there are no holes in the roof or floors above through which anyone could be looking up at the sky, because the entire building is collapsed. This isn't adding up.

From the NYT link, again:

"At the site, neighbors picked through the rubble of modest medical equipment and scattered children’s books, from the small neighborhood children’s library Ms. Elaiwa ran. There was a seared copy of “Jane Eyre,” condensed, in English with Arabic translation, and an English-language copy of “Ali Baba and the Forty Thieves.”"

Who the **** cares about the titles of the books left after the bombing? That has all the stink of "details" that people give because they think it will make a lie more plausible.

In other words, unless there's some much better information about what exactly happened, I don't believe a word of the story so far. I've been lied to too many times about supposed Israeli crimes which turned out to never have happened.

Wow! You sure hate the Handicapped...especially if they are Arab!

Here's some more info on the deaths:

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/...-death-toll-tops-125/articleshow/38273492.cms

Also...here's a video of some IDF Soldiers abusing a mentally-handicapped Palestinian. I don't know why they would do this, but they sure did:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4NZ1X_mVYj8

But...at least they are going to make the soldiers who did this pay for their crime.
 
Last edited:
No...what I am suggesting is that if Hamas were soooooo Baaaad, then Israel would have gotten rid of them already. It wouldn't be that difficult. I remember that Israel had no problem slam-dunking Yasser Arafat and the PLO when they were no longer useful. You remember the PLO don't ya'?

It's still around. Now it's called the "Palestinian National Authority".

But...why get rid of Hamas when they are such useful idiots? When Israeli leadership can always depend on Hamas to do the wrong thing at the right time? I mean, these Hamas idiots are a god-send to the Zionists! And as long as Hamas remains useful, they won't become history like the PLO.

If that's truly your belief, why not try to convince people to pressure Hamas to stop falling for the scam?
 

Ah, the ISM. Purposefully putting American and European kids in harms way, so their deaths can be used for Palestinian propaganda.

Israel should also exit the land they are stealing in the West Bank, too.

The only reason Israel was willing to give up the Gaza strip was:

1. It's worthless.

50 miles of prime beach-front property on the Mediterranean is worthless?

2. It's not part of, and never was part of, Biblical Egypt (so it's not a Zionist objective)

Jeebus, you think Zionists want biblical Egypt?

3. The act convinces mushy-headed sympathizers that Israel is just a wonderful state.

When Israel wants Peace, then they'll start demanding Peace - and they'll back up their words with actions.

Take a look at those two statements. On one hand you state that when Israel does something for peace, it's a ploy to convince "mushy-headed sympathizers" how wonderful they are, then in the very next breath you state they don't back up their words with actions. Clearly when Israel does take action for peace, you interpret it as a propaganda ploy.


Make no mistake about it...Hamas exists because Israel lets it exists. Hamas shoots rockets because Israel lets it shoot Rockets. Hamas is a wholly-owned subsidiary of "Zionism Incorporated" and will remain so as long as it is useful for Israel to let it remain so.

You know this sounds like conspiracy woo, don't you?
 
And yet...Israel keeps Stealing land. there is always an excuse to Steal Land.

Let's talk about "stealing land".

For starters, were you aware that for the first 60 years of Zionism, Zionists purchased the land they settled? Did you know that Zionists continue to purchase Arab land, and that selling land to Jews has been made a crime carrying the death penalty by the PNA?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom