Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
The current conflict isn't in the West Bank. It's in Gaza. Israel gave Gaza back to the Palestinians. That's where Hamas is in control. That's where they're launching rockets from.

Regardless of what you think the end result should look like, regardless of what you think is fair, the fact of the matter is that when Israel did what you wanted them to do (give land back to the Palestinians), the violence simply got worse. Palestinians didn't take that opportunity to try to reconcile with Israel, show them that land-for-peace can work, they used it as a chance to launch more missiles. Given that, why on earth should the Israelis give back any land in the West Bank? Because you think that it's the right thing to do? That simply isn't a good enough reason, much as you might wish it to be.

If Israel wanted to stop Hamas from launching rockets, then they could stop them. In fact, Israel could pretty-much make Hamas "Disappear". Israel has overwhelming power.

However, without Hamas and their Chihuahua-like Barking and shooting those silly rockets, Israel would lose all pretext for their Apartheid State...for their Land Stealing...for their generally treating Arabs like Animals.

Make no mistake about it...Hamas exists because Israel lets it exists. Hamas shoots rockets because Israel lets it shoot Rockets. Hamas is a wholly-owned subsidiary of "Zionism Incorporated" and will remain so as long as it is useful for Israel to let it remain so.
 
If Israel wanted to stop Hamas from launching rockets, then they could stop them. In fact, Israel could pretty-much make Hamas "Disappear". Israel has overwhelming power.

However, without Hamas and their Chihuahua-like Barking and shooting those silly rockets, Israel would lose all pretext for their Apartheid State...for their Land Stealing...for their generally treating Arabs like Animals.

Make no mistake about it...Hamas exists because Israel lets it exists. Hamas shoots rockets because Israel lets it shoot Rockets. Hamas is a wholly-owned subsidiary of "Zionism Incorporated" and will remain so as long as it is useful for Israel to let it remain so.

Hamas is the duly elected government of the Palestinians. To make them 'disappear' with the mechanism available to Israel would mean the deaths of a large chunk of the Palestinians. Because of the human shield policies of Hamas this would include a HUGE number of children and civilians.

A large portion of Israel does actually care about the deaths of Palestinian children and civilians. It's not actually an option for Israel to simply take out Hamas right now. Besides the fact that Israel doesn't actually want to do that to the Palestinians, there are other complications such as what Israel's allies would accept, international sanctions, and of course what actions other countries would take if Israel supplied them with such political ammunition.


Currently the only group with true agency to act on that are the Palestinian people. Israel can (and I think should!) do things to encourage this, but even then it's really not their choice to make.
 
Blah...Blah...Blah...Hamas Bad...Blah.

What? You don't think most of the world knows that Hamas are nothing but a bunch of Psychotic Retards?

Nevertheless, just because Hamas is "BAAAAAD" does not give Israel an excuse to steal land on the West Bank and practice apartheid.

I am assuming that Hamas can't be reasoned with...but perhaps Israel can. Or...am I wrong? Has Israel sank its teeth into the Zionist Over-man Dream so deeply that they have turned into a bunch of Psychotic Retards, too? I hope not.

1) Hamas is the elected leaders of the Palestinians in Gaza. That means that they are the psychos in charge. That means Israel must deal with them, because there's nobody else.

2) No land was stolen, either on the West Bank or in Gaza. Both territories were annexed after Israel fought a defensive war against it's neighbors who had set out to utterly destroy them. The territories now serve as a buffer-zone against further attacks from those countries. Neither territory ever belonged to the Palestinians.
 
If Israel wanted to stop Hamas from launching rockets, then they could stop them. In fact, Israel could pretty-much make Hamas "Disappear". Israel has overwhelming power.

This is true. The problem is that Hamas hides behind civilians, and to destroy Hamas, Israel would have to destroy the people of Gaza. I wonder what the outrage would be from you if they did that.

However, without Hamas and their Chihuahua-like Barking and shooting those silly rockets, Israel would lose all pretext for their Apartheid State...for their Land Stealing...for their generally treating Arabs like Animals.

Make no mistake about it...Hamas exists because Israel lets it exists. Hamas shoots rockets because Israel lets it shoot Rockets. Hamas is a wholly-owned subsidiary of "Zionism Incorporated" and will remain so as long as it is useful for Israel to let it remain so.

And this is just as stupid as the first time you wrote it.
 
Jules Galen

Last I checked, if Israel was half as evil as you make it out to be, they'd have:

Given free condoms out to the IDF and told them "loot and rape all you want!"

Taken Palestinians out of their homes, planted a minefield, forced them to march across it and shoot them all if an Israeli Officer stepped on a mine

Taken Prisoners and flayed them alive in public before making lampshades from their skin

Taken every tenth Palestinian and Impaled them Vlad style on the outskirts of Tel Aviv.

Rounded Palestinians up into barns and burned them alive

Beheaded everyone in a town and made a pyramid of their heads

Burned down every gazan town to rubble, crushed the rubble and sowed the fields with salt.

Taken the children of towns out to a plain and ordered a tank column to drive through.

Taken 20% of their population and have their hearts ripped out in public

hanged dozens of Palestinians per hour with Piano Wire

Had prisoners eaten alive by dogs

Shot prisoners while burying them in Pig fat/hides.

Had Palestinians strapped to tank barrels before firing
 
Hamas is the duly elected government of the Palestinians. To make them 'disappear' with the mechanism available to Israel would mean the deaths of a large chunk of the Palestinians. Because of the human shield policies of Hamas this would include a HUGE number of children and civilians.

A large portion of Israel does actually care about the deaths of Palestinian children and civilians. It's not actually an option for Israel to simply take out Hamas right now. Besides the fact that Israel doesn't actually want to do that to the Palestinians, there are other complications such as what Israel's allies would accept, international sanctions, and of course what actions other countries would take if Israel supplied them with such political ammunition.


Currently the only group with true agency to act on that are the Palestinian people. Israel can (and I think should!) do things to encourage this, but even then it's really not their choice to make.

What? Are you saying that Hamas is the elected reps of ALL Pakestinians? Even those in the West Bank?

Also, Israel has once again sent soldiers into Gaza. No doubt they will claim a glorius victory when it is all over...but Hamas will remain. Israel dare not wipe out Hamas! Like Oceana needed Eastasia/Eurasia in 1984, Israel needs Hamas: the Eternal Enemy. In fact. I'm surprised Israel does not Telecast a photo of Yasser Arafat at least once a day for a daily "2-minutes Hate".

Anyways...Israel has Hamas: the guys who always make the wrong choice at the right time - ALWAYS. Hamas is batting a 1000 here of the course of a decade - and it ain't no coincidence. I mean, what a perfect time to start a war on Hamas for Netenyahu - just after he threw a fit about Fatah and Hamas reconciling. It is so convenient - and it will teach those Palestinians what happens when they try to make peace amongst themselves. because Israel must keep the Palestinians fighting amongst themselves - ALWAYS - so Stealing Land is made that much easier.
 
What? Are you saying that Hamas is the elected reps of ALL Pakestinians? Even those in the West Bank?

Also, Israel has once again sent soldiers into Gaza. No doubt they will claim a glorius victory when it is all over...but Hamas will remain. Israel dare not wipe out Hamas! Like Oceana needed Eastasia/Eurasia in 1984, Israel needs Hamas: the Eternal Enemy. In fact. I'm surprised Israel does not Telecast a photo of Yasser Arafat at least once a day for a daily "2-minutes Hate".

Anyways...Israel has Hamas: the guys who always make the wrong choice at the right time - ALWAYS. Hamas is batting a 1000 here of the course of a decade - and it ain't no coincidence. I mean, what a perfect time to start a war on Hamas for Netenyahu - just after he threw a fit about Fatah and Hamas reconciling. It is so convenient - and it will teach those Palestinians what happens when they try to make peace amongst themselves. because Israel must keep the Palestinians fighting amongst themselves - ALWAYS - so Stealing Land is made that much easier.

I think every historical conqueror from Atilla to Tamerlane to Hitler is laughing at the idea that Israel is "Stealing land". If Israel really wanted to, they could leave a mound of Palestinian Skulls where Gaza once stood while having crucified and impaled bodies on the outskirts of Jerusalem.
 
What? Are you saying that Hamas is the elected reps of ALL Pakestinians? Even those in the West Bank?

No, they are the duly elected representatives of the Palestinians on the Gaza strip. You know, the same Gaza strip that Israel withdrew from, leading to a Hamas takeover and an escalation of violence.

Also, Israel has once again sent soldiers into Gaza. No doubt they will claim a glorius victory when it is all over...but Hamas will remain. Israel dare not wipe out Hamas! Like Oceana needed Eastasia/Eurasia in 1984, Israel needs Hamas: the Eternal Enemy. In fact. I'm surprised Israel does not Telecast a photo of Yasser Arafat at least once a day for a daily "2-minutes Hate".

Anyways...Israel has Hamas: the guys who always make the wrong choice at the right time - ALWAYS. Hamas is batting a 1000 here of the course of a decade - and it ain't no coincidence. I mean, what a perfect time to start a war on Hamas for Netenyahu - just after he threw a fit about Fatah and Hamas reconciling. It is so convenient - and it will teach those Palestinians what happens when they try to make peace amongst themselves. because Israel must keep the Palestinians fighting amongst themselves - ALWAYS - so Stealing Land is made that much easier.

Seriously, you might as well stop it with these moronic rants. They are utter failures.
 
I think every historical conqueror from Atilla to Tamerlane to Hitler is laughing at the idea that Israel is "Stealing land". If Israel really wanted to, they could leave a mound of Palestinian Skulls where Gaza once stood while having crucified and impaled bodies on the outskirts of Jerusalem.

Yes, but you see, Jules has created a brain dead conspiracy theory to explain away all that, wherein Israel somehow needs Hamas in order to steal land they didn't steal.

Everything to avoid having to admit that Israel doesn't want to kill civilian Palestinians.
 
I think every historical conqueror from Atilla to Tamerlane to Hitler is laughing at the idea that Israel is "Stealing land". If Israel really wanted to, they could leave a mound of Palestinian Skulls where Gaza once stood while having crucified and impaled bodies on the outskirts of Jerusalem.

Yeah...except that Palestians and others have Weapons that could easily counter such a scenario - or make it suicidal for Israel to implement.

Canon - Nikon - Sony: these people and their like make the most powerful weapons on earth, and they are available at Wal-mart!

What good is an F-16 when it drops a bomb on a child...and a photo is taken of the gnarly remains and distributed around the world in minutes? Likewise, could you even begin to imagine the backlash that images of a mass crucifixion would generate? You are dreaming...and your comments show you know precious little about warfare.
 
Yeah...except that Palestians and others have Weapons that could easily counter such a scenario - or make it suicidal for Israel to implement.

Canon - Nikon - Sony: these people and their like make the most powerful weapons on earth, and they are available at Wal-mart!

What good is an F-16 when it drops a bomb on a child...and a photo is taken of the gnarly remains and distributed around the world in minutes? Likewise, could you even begin to imagine the backlash that images of a mass crucifixion would generate? You are dreaming...and your comments show you know precious little about warfare.

I'm just saying what Israel would do if they really wanted to get rid of Palestinians. Anything less would have the Conquistadors, Timurids and Mongols laughing at them.
 
If Israel wanted to stop Hamas from launching rockets, then they could stop them. In fact, Israel could pretty-much make Hamas "Disappear". Israel has overwhelming power.

And how exactly do you think they can accomplish this?

However, without Hamas and their Chihuahua-like Barking and shooting those silly rockets, Israel would lose all pretext for their Apartheid State...for their Land Stealing...for their generally treating Arabs like Animals.

So now we're in Grand Conspiracy of the Jews to Start Wars and Steal Things land. Got it.

Nope, nothing antisemitic about that AT ALL.

Make no mistake about it...Hamas exists because Israel lets it exists.

Sure, Hamas exists because Israel lets it: because Israel chooses not to level Gaza in its entirety. Short of that, Israel is actually quite constrained in what it can do to eliminate Hamas.

But of course, if Israel were to do that, then that too would just prove how evil and murderous those land-steeling Jews really are. Those conniving Jews are so sneaky that everything they could possibly do is part of their plot! No, I swear I'm not paranoid!
 
I'm just saying what Israel would do if they really wanted to get rid of Palestinians. Anything less would have the Conquistadors, Timurids and Mongols laughing at them.

Perhaps...but the Mongols never had to deal with Photojournalists, either.

Here's a funny quote from Gary Brecher (aka...The War Nerd) about the PIRA (Provisional Irish Republican Army) and the overwhelming power of images:

Even after they focused on London, it took the IRA 20 years to perfect a way of attacking London without drawing too much bad publicity. Because that's what the IRA's war was about: publicity, "hearts 'n minds," not real military advantage. In their first London campaigns, they used Khadafy's semtex to attack military targets. Some of the results were pretty funny, like when they killed seven cavalry horses bombing a military parade in Hyde Park in 1982.

It was a successful attack, with eight soldiers killed -- but killing those horses drove the British papers into a frenzy. The Limeys are more horse-crazy than a sexually frustrated 14-year-old girl. They were ready to hang anybody with red hair or freckles after the pictures of dying horses hit the front page. You can slaughter all the people you want, but touch a pony and those English ladies will pull your spleen out and squeeze it to pulp right before your eyes.

So the PIRA went back to the drawing board, with a note-2-self: "No more dead animals, lads."
 
What? Are you saying that Hamas is the elected reps of ALL Pakestinians? Even those in the West Bank?

No, in Gaza.

Also, Israel has once again sent soldiers into Gaza. No doubt they will claim a glorius victory when it is all over...but Hamas will remain. Israel dare not wipe out Hamas! Like Oceana needed Eastasia/Eurasia in 1984, Israel needs Hamas: the Eternal Enemy. In fact. I'm surprised Israel does not Telecast a photo of Yasser Arafat at least once a day for a daily "2-minutes Hate".

Anyways...Israel has Hamas: the guys who always make the wrong choice at the right time - ALWAYS. Hamas is batting a 1000 here of the course of a decade - and it ain't no coincidence. I mean, what a perfect time to start a war on Hamas for Netenyahu - just after he threw a fit about Fatah and Hamas reconciling. It is so convenient - and it will teach those Palestinians what happens when they try to make peace amongst themselves. because Israel must keep the Palestinians fighting amongst themselves - ALWAYS - so Stealing Land is made that much easier.


None of this addresses any of the issues with 'Israel can destroy Hamas' that I raised. Israel does not need Hamas, and your assertions of conspiracy that they do is unsupported.
 
None of this addresses any of the issues with 'Israel can destroy Hamas' that I raised. Israel does not need Hamas, and your assertions of conspiracy that they do is unsupported.

Who said it was a conspiracy? What...do you think I am suggesting that the IDF and Hamas have joint discussions on how to wage war against each other and against their peoples?

No...what I am suggesting is that if Hamas were soooooo Baaaad, then Israel would have gotten rid of them already. It wouldn't be that difficult. I remember that Israel had no problem slam-dunking Yasser Arafat and the PLO when they were no longer useful. You remember the PLO don't ya'?

But...why get rid of Hamas when they are such useful idiots? When Israeli leadership can always depend on Hamas to do the wrong thing at the right time? I mean, these Hamas idiots are a god-send to the Zionists! And as long as Hamas remains useful, they won't become history like the PLO.
 
I think every historical conqueror from Atilla to Tamerlane to Hitler is laughing at the idea that Israel is "Stealing land". If Israel really wanted to, they could leave a mound of Palestinian Skulls where Gaza once stood while having crucified and impaled bodies on the outskirts of Jerusalem.
^^This. Exactly this. Shouldn't be difficult to understand, but apparently to many it is.

Had Israel's goal been conquest, Palestine wouldn't exist today. Plain and simple.
 
Last edited:
Who said it was a conspiracy?

You did, when you outlined a conspiracy theory.

What...do you think I am suggesting that the IDF and Hamas have joint discussions on how to wage war against each other and against their peoples?

No...what I am suggesting is that if Hamas were soooooo Baaaad, then Israel would have gotten rid of them already. It wouldn't be that difficult. I remember that Israel had no problem slam-dunking Yasser Arafat and the PLO when they were no longer useful. You remember the PLO don't ya'?

But...why get rid of Hamas when they are such useful idiots? When Israeli leadership can always depend on Hamas to do the wrong thing at the right time? I mean, these Hamas idiots are a god-send to the Zionists! And as long as Hamas remains useful, they won't become history like the PLO.

Please explain how the IDF could easily destroy Hamas without incurring unacceptable losses of civilians in Gaza. I'm sure the Israeli government is interested in your knowledge.
 
Last edited:
The way I see it, the regimes in the Palestinian areas are like the regime in North Korea. I'm sure most of us would love to see them gone so that those areas could prosper, and we could easily defeat them military...

...but.
 
Perhaps...but the Mongols never had to deal with Photojournalists, either.

Here's a funny quote from Gary Brecher (aka...The War Nerd) about the PIRA (Provisional Irish Republican Army) and the overwhelming power of images:

No, but Genghis Khan/Tamerlane/Conquistadors LOVED attention! Made future conquests more likely to submit than perish needlessly.

Oh, and the War Nerd is the idiot who thought missiles rendered aircraft carriers obsolete.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom