Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Instead of dismissing the Hamas Editor who wrote the article as a "Whack Job", the Israeli article goes through great pains to document and refute the libel. Gawd knows why.

Because lots of people on your side of the argument take that kind of nonsense seriously.
 
No. What the other guy did is not self-defense...it is fighting. Self Defense when using violence is doing just enough to stop the immediate danger...and no more.

So by your logic, Israel should use a lot more force against Gaza to stop the immediate danger?

Clearly the force they're using is not enough.
 
And do they have any reason whatsoever to believe that such a course of action even could lead to the attacks stopping when the Palestinian government has been acting the way it is?

Beyond the point
What I am asking you is.. Do you believe that land taken by war and by continuous settlement construction outside their borders should be given back to the people who owned it before or not?
It is a simple question that has nothing to do with Hamas
Yes or no?

If you call what Israel is getting up to "stealing land", Hernan "i had unruly natives fed to dogs" Cortez would sell you a bridge to Tenochtitlan.

Agree that phrases like "stealing land" don't really help the discussion any, as they ignore both historicla context and relevant laws. This case, too, is far less black-and-white than it initially seems.

Just a quick and straightforward question.
Before the 1967 war Israel was within their 1967 borders.
After the 1967 war they took land outside their previous borders.
Now they keep building new settlements outside their borders.
Is this behaviour acceptable or not regardless what Hamas is doing since taking this land has nothing to do with Hamas??
 
The people who are directly responsible for the safety of Gazan people are not Israel, but Hamas. Hamas was democratically elected to be their government. Hamas are the ones who are putting Gazans in harms way by engaging in armed conflict with Israel, and when Gazans die as a result of it, the blood is on the hands of Hamas.

Yeah!
It is the Israeli who launch the missiles who kill the children but the moral responsible is not the Israelis but Hamas as they did not do what the Israeli requested.
Good way to blame the victim here !
 
So by your logic, Israel should use a lot more force against Gaza to stop the immediate danger?
Yup. More accidental support of Israeli military action. This is getting good:D.

Clearly the force they're using is not enough.[/quote]It is enough to make them lay low and lick their wounds for a time, for then to resume hostilities.
 
Beyond the point
What I am asking you is.. Do you believe that land taken by war and by continuous settlement construction outside their borders should be given back to the people who owned it before or not?
It is a simple question that has nothing to do with Hamas
Yes or no?

It's not directed at me, but I'll answer anyway.

I think whatever political entity gets sovereignty over any square meter of land should be decided by negotiations between a Palestinian government that recognizes Israel's right to exist, and an Israeli government that wants to finalize a two-state solution.

I think that whatever individual ends up owning any particular square meter of land depends on who legally purchased it, and that wherever it can be shown that someone is holding some land, Israeli or Arab, that should belong to someone else, then that someone else should either have the property returned or be compensated, and that these matters should be decided in a legal forum after peace has been achieved between these peoples.
 
Yeah!
It is the Israeli who launch the missiles who kill the children but the moral responsible is not the Israelis but Hamas as they did not do what the Israeli requested.
Good way to blame the victim here !

Not many people would describe Hamas as a "victim". You're making a pretty bold claim there.
 
It's not directed at me, but I'll answer anyway.

Thank you but this is not an answer to my question
You keep repeating what the Arabs should do
My question is different
My question is: leaving aside what Hamas and the Arabs does or does not, should Israel give back the land that has taken during the 1967 war + settlements?
It is a simple question
 
The latest batch. The 17 al-Batash's are guilty of having been family of the Gaza police chief. Who was injured.

122. Ratib Sabahi al-Sifi, 22, was killed in a bombing in Gaza City along with five others.
123. Azmi Mahmoud Abid, 51, was killed in the same attack.
124. Nidal Mahmoud Abu al-Malish, 22, was killed in the same attack.
125. Suleiman Said Abid, 56, was killed in the same attack.
126. Ghassan Ahmad al-Masri, 25, was killed in the same attack.
127. Mustafa Mohammed Anaieh, 58, was killed in the same attack.
128. Rafa’at Youssef Amer, 36, succumbed to wounds sustained in a bombing in Gaza City.
129. Ghazi Mustafa Areef, 62, died when his home in Gaza City was bombed. His son sustained serious injuries.
130. Mohammed Adriss Abu Sulim, 20, was killed in a bombing in Jabaliya.
131. Fadi Yaqub Sakr, 25, was killed in a bombing in Gaza City.
132. Qassem Jaber Adwan Awdeh, 16, was killed in a bombing in Khan Younis.
133. Mohammed Ahmad Bassal, 19, was killed in a bombing in Gaza City.
134. Muhannad Youssef Dhahir, 23, was killed in a bombing in Rafah.
135. Mahmoud Abdallah Shratiha, 53, was killed in a bombing in north Gaza.
136. Shadi Mohammed Zarb, 21, was killed in a bombing in Rafah that wounded three others.
137. Imad Bassam Zarb, 21, was killed in the same bombing.
138. Nahid Ta’im al-Batash, 41, was killed in a bombing in Gaza City along with 16 family members. Dozens more were wounded in the same attack.
139. Baha Majid al-Batash, 28, was killed in the same bombing.
140. Qassi Isam al-Batash, 12, was killed in the same bombing.
141. Aziza Youssef al-Batash, 59 was killed in the same bombing.
142. Mohammed Isam al-Batash, 17 was killed in the same bombing.
143. Ahmad Naman al-Batash, 27 was killed in the same bombing.
144. Yahya Alaa al-Batash, 18 was killed in the same bombing.
145. Jalal Majid al-Batash, 26 was killed in the same bombing.
146. Mahmoud Majid al-Batash, 22 was killed in the same bombing.
147. Marwa Majid al-Batash, 25 was killed in the same bombing.
148. Majid Subhi al-Batash was killed in the same bombing.
149. Khalid Majid al-Batash, 20 was killed in the same bombing.
150. Ibrahim Majid al-Batash, 18 was killed in the same bombing.
151. Manar Majid al-Batash, 14 was killed in the same bombing.
152. Amal Hassan al-Batash, 49 was killed in the same bombing.
153. Anas Alaa al-Batash, 10 was killed in the same bombing.
154. Qassi Alaa al-Batash was killed in the same bombing.

Sunday, July 13:

155. Rami Abu Shanab, 25, succumbed to wounds sustained several days ago in Deir al-Balah.
156. Khawla al-Hawajri, 25, was killed in a bombing in Nusseirat.
157. Mohammed Ghazi Areef, 35, was killed in a bombing in Gaza City.
158. Ahmad Youssef Daloul, 47, was killed in a bombing in Gaza City.
159. Hijaziyah Hamid al-Helou, 80, succumbed to wounds sustained in the bombing of her home in Gaza City on Saturday night.
160. Fawzia Abdela’el, 73, was killed in a bombing in Gaza City.
161. Haitham Ashraf Zarb, 21, succumbed to wounds sustained during an attack on Rafah on Saturday that killed two other members of the Zarb family.
162. Leila Hassan al-Awdat, 41, was killed in an attack on Meghazi that wounded four others.
163. Hussam Ibrahim al-Najjar, 14, was killed in a bombing in north Gaza. His remains were taken to Beit Hanoun Hospital.
164. Rawidah Abu Harb al-Zwaida, 31, was killed.
165. Samer Tallal Hamdan was killed in a bombing in Beit Hanoun.
166. Hussein Abd al-Qadir Muheisen, 19, succumbed to wounds sustained in Gaza City.
167. Maher Thabit Abu Mar, 24, was killed in a bombing in Rafah.
168. Mohammed Salim Abu Bureis, 65, was killed in a bombing in Deir al-Balah.
 
Thank you but this is not an answer to my question
You keep repeating what the Arabs should do

No, my response was directed at all parties, not just the Arabs.


My question is different
My question is: leaving aside what Hamas and the Arabs does or does not, should Israel give back the land that has taken during the 1967 war + settlements?
It is a simple question

Your question carries assumptions that are either false or so ill-defined as to be useless. Clarify a few things for me:

If Israel captures land from Jordan that was not Jordan's when Jordan captured it, would that be "stealing", "liberating", or something else?

If an Israeli buys land in East Jerusalem from a Palestinian land owner and then builds some apartment buildings there, is that considered "stealing" even though he paid for it?
 
If Israel captures land from Jordan that was not Jordan's when Jordan captured it, would that be "stealing", "liberating", or something else?

Was it Jordan` s when Israel took it?
If yes, then it would be stealing as all land in the world was no man land 20000000 years ago.

If an Israeli buys land in East Jerusalem from a Palestinian land owner and then builds some apartment buildings there, is that considered "stealing" even though he paid for it?

If the Palestinian was free to negotiate this would not be stealing, but what has this to do with the land conquered during the war?
 
Last edited:
The resort to brute military force is accompanied, as always, by the shrill rhetoric of victimhood and a farrago of self-pity overlaid with self-righteousness. In Hebrew this is known as the syndrome of bokhim ve-yorim, "crying and shooting".
- Avi Shlaim, 7 January 2009

How Israel brought Gaza to the brink of humanitarian catastrophe

Oxford professor of international relations Avi Shlaim served in the Israeli army and has never questioned the state's legitimacy. But its merciless assault on Gaza has led him to devastating conclusions
 
SippenhaftWP

wikipedia said:
Sippenhaft or Sippenhaftung (English: "kin liability") refers to the principle of families sharing the responsibility for a crime committed by one of its members. It is a form of collective punishment. A relative of the perpetrator could thus be punished in place or in addition to the perpetrator, depending on the circumstances. This legal principle is derived from Germanic law in the middle ages. It has been practised in some countries until the modern age as well as in communist East Germany and on a larger scale in Nazi Germany towards the end of the World War II. The term "Haft" does not necessarily imply a prison sentence, but can refer to any form of punishment. The same principle is also found in many non-western cultures, including in Japan until the mid 19th century, North Korea currently.


Collective PunishmentWP

wikipedia said:
Collective punishment is the punishment of a group of people as a result of the behavior of one or more other individuals or groups. The punished group may often have no direct association with the other individuals or groups, or direct control over their actions. In times of war and armed conflict, collective punishment has resulted in atrocities, and is a violation of the laws of war and the Geneva Conventions. Historically, occupying powers have used collective punishment to retaliate against and deter attacks on their forces by resistance movements (e.g. destroying entire towns and villages where such attacks have occurred).
 
Last edited:
Sad but true..
I start to suspect that the only hope for the Palestinians is to get some better military equipment and maybe a couple of nukes from Iran or Pakistan..

Someone should sig this, as it pretty much sums up your cheerleading in a nutshell.
 
Childlike Empress: so you've gone from posting lists of casualties (of one side:rolleyes:) to dictionary definitions. What's next, cake recipes or kitten pictures? Or do you plan to start posting some actual arguments any time soon?
 
UN report, 13 July: Thanks to the al-Batash sacrifice, the killers managed to raise their civilian rate to at least 80% (133 of 168 dead).

In the most serious incident overnight, an Israeli airstrike targeted a house east of Gaza city. According to initial information, 18 persons including six children and three women, one of them pregnant, were killed, and 16 others injured including the Director General of the Gaza police, reportedly the intended target who was visiting his relatives at the time.

... 1,140 Palestinians injured, of whom 296 are children and 233 women ...

... 25,300 Children in need of psychosocial support ...

... Leaflets were dropped on northern Gaza by the Israeli air force warning residents to evacuate by noon Sunday, ahead of anticipated attacks on rocket launchers in the area. Approximately 16,000 people are now taking shelter in UNRWA schools in the northern Gaza area. ...

... 66 Schools damaged by shelling (29 government schools and 37 UNRWA schools) ...

... 32 fishing boats have been burned, destroyed or partially damaged ...


Oh, and before I forget the fair and balanced thing...

Indiscriminate rocket firing by armed groups from Gaza continues to target Israeli population centres, resulting in injuries but no fatalities to date.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom