Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
No, by all means, don't answer us.

eta
Oh, and before I forget the fair and balanced thing...

Indiscriminate rocket firing by armed groups from Gaza continues to target Israeli population centres, resulting in injuries but no fatalities to date.
...and that's it? No destruction of property? No traumatized children in need of psychosocial support? Why is this list so incomplete?
Could you at least try to take this a little bit seriously?
 
Last edited:
Hamas really does want to maximize civilian casualties on their own side:

http://www.slate.com/blogs/the_slat...tinians_to_evacuate_after_mosque_bombing.html

As the United Nations called for a cease-fire, Israel warned residents of northern Gaza that they should leave their homes “for their own safety” late on Saturday night. Gaza officials, however, told residents to ignore Israel’s warnings, saying they were part of a “psychological warfare” campaign. The sign that an escalation in Israel’s aerial campaign against Hamas and jihad fighters was imminent came on the same day as a mosque and a center for the disabled were bombed. Israel says aerial photos showed the mosque was being used to hide weapons, reports the New York Times. More than 156 Palestinians have been killed over the past five days, according to the Associated Press.

In another sign that a cease-fire is not imminent, Israel put an eight missile interceptor battery in service Saturday to try to prevent rockets being fired from Gaza from hitting Israeli cities. No Israelis have been killed by the rockets fired from Gaza, although the sheer number is much higher than Israel expected, according to Reuters.

Meanwhile, the United Nations Security Council released a statement after days of discussion on wording that would be acceptable to both Arab nations and the U.S., according to the BBC. All 15 members agreed on text that calls for “de-escalation of the situation, restoration of calm, and reinstitution of the November 2012 ceasefire” as well as “respect for international humanitarian law, including the protection of civilians.”

The situation in a nutshell.
 
Beyond the point
What I am asking you is.. Do you believe that land taken by war and by continuous settlement construction outside their borders should be given back to the people who owned it before or not?
It is a simple question that has nothing to do with Hamas
Yes or no?

So, to be clear, you've utterly failed to defend just about every point that has been disputed and just keep trying to change the subject to something you think might maybe be favorable to your cause instead of engaging in honest discussion. This is just another case of such.

Regardless, in the real world, that question isn't remotely as simple as you seem to want it to be, not least because you're trying to shove a number of distinctly different issues into the question. "Should land taken by war be given back to the people who owned it before?" is a question that does not have a single "right" answer, but rather is heavily dependent on numerous disparate issues. "By continuous settlement construction outside their borders" is also context dependent, for that matter, much as, generally speaking, violating agreements is deplorable.
 
Last edited:
Yeah!
It is the Israeli who launch the missiles who kill the children but the moral responsible is not the Israelis but Hamas as they did not do what the Israeli requested.
Good way to blame the victim here !

When the request is for them to stop engaging in acts of war which will force a military response? Yes, Hamas does bear quite a bit of the blame.
 
Last edited:
If the Palestinian was free to negotiate this would not be stealing,

At last check, they have been free to negotiate and Israel has tried. It must be convenient for you to ignore such things.

No, by all means, don't answer us.

eta
...and that's it? No destruction of property? No traumatized children in need of psychosocial support? Why is this list so incomplete?
Could you at least try to take this a little bit seriously?

I'd not knock the report too much. It is, after all, focused the needs of the only side there that really needs outside humanitarian aid to effectively handle the damage being done. As long as that's kept in perspective, it's a decent resource.
 
Last edited:
That was for Empress as much as for the report. Both Israel and Palestine have their share of traumatized children (I've read that 50% of the former's children suffer from PTSD). Using traumatized children to slam Israel with, while handwaving it when it's Israeli kids, is, to be kind, hypocrtical.
 
When the request is for them to stop engaging in acts of war which will force a military response? Yes, Hamas does bear quite a bit of the blame.

Force a military response?
Why has not Israel tried to give back the land stolen taken during the 1967 war and later on?

At last check, they have been free to negotiate and Israel has tried. It must be convenient for you to ignore such things.

I am not ignoring the negotiation
But I ask ..
Has there been any offer from Israel to recognize the existence of the Palestinian state on the 1967 borders?

So, to be clear, you've utterly failed to defend just about every point that has been disputed and just keep trying to change the subject to something you think might maybe be favorable to your cause instead of engaging in honest discussion. This is just another case of such.

I do not get it.
I ask you a question and what I get in return is a personal attack..

Regardless, in the real world, that question isn't remotely as simple as you seem to want it to be, not least because you're trying to shove a number of distinctly different issues into the question. "Should land taken by war be given back to the people who owned it before?" is a question that does not have a single "right" answer, but rather is heavily dependent on numerous disparate issues. "By continuous settlement construction outside their borders" is also context dependent, for that matter, much as, generally speaking, violating agreements is deplorable.

To me, it looks fairly simple and straightforward.
Israel has took some land outside their previous borders (1967).
And they keep build settlements outside their borders.
Shall they be able to retain that land or not regardless what Hamas does?
I do not see why I can not get a straight reply from you on this matter
 
That was for Empress as much as for the report. Both Israel and Palestine have their share of traumatized children (I've read that 50% of the former's children suffer from PTSD). Using traumatized children to slam Israel with, while handwaving it when it's Israeli kids, is, to be kind, hypocrtical.


Still the share of civilians killed by Hamas/ Israel is different with a ratio of 20 to one, or something like that.

Someone should sig this, as it pretty much sums up your cheerleading in a nutshell.

I think the Palestinians should be able to defend themselves from US/Israel terror

EDIT - the nukes would have to be used only for deterrence, of course
 
Last edited:
Israeli landgrabs in the WB, how is this happening?

I've stayed out the Israel/Palestine discussion for a while, as the it is depressing and tends to go round-and-round.

But there is an aspect of the Is/Pal conflict that I'd like to know more about: the settlements.

There is a hell of a lot of fog surrounding this issue, and most of the sources I find are partisan.

Yesterday a Muslim friend of mine posted a video of some old women basically getting kicked out of her house by Jewish settlers. With assistance of the Israeli army.

But as far is I know, the size of the settlements (which I oppose, BTW) has been fixed since the eighties. And all those building activities you hear announced are projects within existing settlements.

My question: is there still an ongoing process of dispossessing Palestinians? And are they still losing land?
 
Israeli landgrabs in the WB, how is this happening?

I've stayed out the Israel/Palestine discussion for a while, as the it is depressing and tends to go round-and-round.

But there is an aspect of the Is/Pal conflict that I'd like to know more about: the settlements.

There is a hell of a lot of fog surrounding this issue, and most of the sources I find are partisan.

Yesterday a Muslim friend of mine posted a video of some old women basically getting kicked out of her house by Jewish settlers. With assistance of the Israeli army.

But as far is I know, the size of the settlements (which I oppose, BTW) has been fixed since the eighties. And all those building activities you hear announced are projects within existing settlements.

My question: is there still an ongoing process of dispossessing Palestinians? And are they still losing land?

Yes.
As you said , there have been no new settlements since the eighties

http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/jun/05/israel-build-more-homes-settlements
 
Force a military response?
Why has not Israel tried to give back the land stolen taken during the 1967 war and later on?

For the umpteenth time: They have tried. It lead to Hamas lobbing rockets at them.

Now, if you make this argument again, it will be nothing but a lie.
 
Yes.
As you said , there have been no new settlements since the eighties

http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/jun/05/israel-build-more-homes-settlements

Those are 1500 new houses announced.
I already know that Israel builds more houses in occupied territory.

But that doesn't mean the actual geographical area of the settlements is increasing. Those houses could be within settlements, or they could claim more Palestinian land.

I oppose both, but expansion is worse IMHO as it encroaches further on Palestinian territory.

Hence my question.
 
Those are 1500 new houses announced.
I already know that Israel builds more houses in occupied territory.

But that doesn't mean the actual geographical area of the settlements is increasing. Those houses could be within settlements, or they could claim more Palestinian land.

I oppose both, but expansion is worse IMHO as it encroaches further on Palestinian territory.

Hence my question.

I would call this joking with words, if I may ..
If they are building new settlements, they are taking new areas
 
I would call this joking with words, if I may ..
If they are building new settlements, they are taking new areas

You obviously don't get it. Are they building new houses in the existing settlements or are they expanding to new territories? That was the question.
 
So let me get this straight: Israel is supposedly bombing the water pipes that carry the water that Israel is supplying to Gaza? When they could have just turned a valve to make the pipe run dry anyway?

Yeah. That sounds highly plausible.
 
But as far is I know, the size of the settlements (which I oppose, BTW) has been fixed since the eighties. And all those building activities you hear announced are projects within existing settlements.

My question: is there still an ongoing process of dispossessing Palestinians? And are they still losing land?


Well, for a start they built and are building a quite bizarre (and illegal) "barrier" partly deep inside the green line since the eighties. And yes, the land grab under different pretexts goes on. Here's a one-page UN fact sheet for a good initial overview. Here are more.
 
Last edited:
Israeli landgrabs in the WB, how is this happening?
Well... they tried to basically give pretty much all of the West Bank (and other land) to the Palestinians in a peace proposal in 2008. The Palestinians never even made a counter-offer. I agree borders should return to for example '67 lines, but... yeah.

As for videos showing Israeli brutality, there is a lot of crap out there, and settlers can be truly vile, I've heard, but you still have to take videos like that with a pinch of salt. Sounds cold, but I've learned that context/the other side's view matters tremendously in cases like that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom