Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
You did, when you outlined a conspiracy theory.

Please explain how the IDF could easily destroy Hamas without incurring unacceptable losses of civilians in Gaza. I'm sure the Israeli government is interested in your knowledge.

Silly man! Who says the Israelis got to get rid of Hamas by using their own soldiers as bait? I'm sure Fatah could be hired to do the job.
 
Silly man! Who says the Israelis got to get rid of Hamas by using their own soldiers as bait? I'm sure Fatah could be hired to do the job.

So your advice to the Israeli government is to hire Fatah - who lost the internal power struggle against Hamas after the withdrawal of Israel from the Gaza strip - to destroy Hamas?

How do you propose Fatah would go about doing this?
 
So your advice to the Israeli government is to hire Fatah - who lost the internal power struggle against Hamas after the withdrawal of Israel from the Gaza strip - to destroy Hamas?

How do you propose Fatah would go about doing this?

That would be the same Fatah who could call-in Israeli Air-and-Artillary Strikes for support.

See how easy? It would be just like when the Northern Alliance defeated Al Qaeda.
 
That would be the same Fatah who could call-in Israeli Air-and-Artillary Strikes for support.

See how easy? It would be just like when the Northern Alliance defeated Al Qaeda.

Ok, so Fatah would call in Israeli airstrikes and artillery strikes. How would that help avoid civilian casualties when Hamas hides in civilian areas? Please advice.
 
Who said it was a conspiracy? What...do you think I am suggesting that the IDF and Hamas have joint discussions on how to wage war against each other and against their peoples?

No. You're saying that Israel conspires to keep Hamas around so that Israel can steal land.

No...what I am suggesting is that if Hamas were soooooo Baaaad, then Israel would have gotten rid of them already. It wouldn't be that difficult. I remember that Israel had no problem slam-dunking Yasser Arafat and the PLO when they were no longer useful. You remember the PLO don't ya'?

But...why get rid of Hamas when they are such useful idiots? When Israeli leadership can always depend on Hamas to do the wrong thing at the right time? I mean, these Hamas idiots are a god-send to the Zionists! And as long as Hamas remains useful, they won't become history like the PLO.


I do remember the PLO, and of course the Palestinian Authority, and the the Fatah-Hamas civil war. They lost control of Gaza because of legislative losses to Hamas. Hamas was elected by the Palestinians there, and then Hamas and the PA couldn't reconcile. Israel, Britain, and the US actually did some things to support the PA against Hamas. Israel didn't get rid of them. In fact they are still around.

Have you done any research on this?
 
Of course I do extensive research. I read FrontPage Magazine every morning and memorize Davis Horowitz's talking points. Afterwards...I know what to think.

Could you then elaborate on how Fatah while calling in Israeli airstrikes and artillery are going to avoid civilian casualties while destroying Hamas?
 
Could you then elaborate on how Fatah while calling in Israeli airstrikes and artillery are going to avoid civilian casualties while destroying Hamas?

I don't know. Who is John Galt? Why do so many people hate the Jews?
 
I don't know. Who is John Galt? Why do so many people hate the Jews?

You said Israel could easily destroy Hamas. When asked how, you said they should hire Fatah and have them call in Israeli air strikes and artillery. Are you now saying it's not that easy? Where does that leave your conspiracy theory about Israel not destroying Hamas even though it would be easy because they want to grab land?
 
Please advice.

<pedantry>
"advice" is a noun, and the "c" is pronounced like an "s".

"advise" is a verb, and the "s" is pronounced like a "z".

You want "advise" not "advice".
</pedantry>

Yeah, English is messed up That's what you get when you try to create a bastard offspring between French and German. :o
 
You said Israel could easily destroy Hamas. When asked how, you said they should hire Fatah and have them call in Israeli air strikes and artillery. Are you now saying it's not that easy? Where does that leave your conspiracy theory about Israel not destroying Hamas even though it would be easy because they want to grab land?

And yet...Israel keeps Stealing land. there is always an excuse to Steal Land.

Pardon me...I didn't mean "Steal" Land, I meant Lawfully Annex Territory. Territory that is empty of Palestinians (for if they didn't get out, then they would have been shot). territory where the Palestinians had no Land Claim (for the Israelis refuse to recognize titles deriving from Ottoman and local rule as being legitimate). palestinians do not get titles to Land.

Israel needs the Land for a Buffer Zone so the bad Palestinians won't attack them, but then Israelis move into the Buffer Zone and settle it, then a new Buffer Zone is needed...and once again this Buffer Zone is settled. And for some reason the Palestinians just won't accept this...FACT. The fact that Israelis need the Land.

I mean, don't the Palestinians realize that the Jews of Israel have always been victimized so they have a right to the land - especially after the Holocaust? I mean, after the Holocaust and what is written in the Bible...who can rightfully say that the Jews do not have a right to all the land as a means of Self Defense - and they need Nuclear and Biological Weapons, too? The Jews are the Victims here!

Despite their F-15s, Tanks, Killer Helicopters, Nuclear Weapons, AWACS Planes, Ships, and all that money from the USA - the Jews are being victimized by the Palestinians. The Jews are the Victims..despite all the military firepower and dead Palestinians! Ignore the Palestinians...they are just "Beasts" according to Israeli Prime Minister Netenyahu!

I think I see it now.
 
And yet...Israel keeps Stealing land. there is always an excuse to Steal Land.

Pardon me...I didn't mean "Steal" Land, I meant Lawfully Annex Territory. Territory that is empty of Palestinians (for if they didn't get out, then they would have been shot). territory where the Palestinians had no Land Claim (for the Israelis refuse to recognize titles deriving from Ottoman and local rule as being legitimate). palestinians do not get titles to Land.

Israel needs the Land for a Buffer Zone so the bad Palestinians won't attack them, but then Israelis move into the Buffer Zone and settle it, then a new Buffer Zone is needed...and once again this Buffer Zone is settled. And for some reason the Palestinians just won't accept this...FACT. The fact that Israelis need the Land.

I mean, don't the Palestinians realize that the Jews of Israel have always been victimized so they have a right to the land - especially after the Holocaust? I mean, after the Holocaust and what is written in the Bible...who can rightfully say that the Jews do not have a right to all the land as a means of Self Defense - and they need Nuclear and Biological Weapons, too? The Jews are the Victims here!

Despite their F-15s, Tanks, Killer Helicopters, Nuclear Weapons, AWACS Planes, Ships, and all that money from the USA - the Jews are being victimized by the Palestinians. The Jews are the Victims..despite all the military firepower and dead Palestinians! Ignore the Palestinians...they are just "Beasts" according to Israeli Prime Minister Netenyahu!

I think I see it now.

So this big heap of sarcasm is designed to attempt to conceal the fact that you've painted your argument into a corner? That dog don't hunt, son.

Again, how would Fatah go about destroying Hamas using Israeli air and artillery strikes without incurring unacceptable civilian losses?
 
If you call what Israel is getting up to "stealing land", Hernan "i had unruly natives fed to dogs" Cortez would sell you a bridge to Tenochtitlan.
 
If you call what Israel is getting up to "stealing land", Hernan "i had unruly natives fed to dogs" Cortez would sell you a bridge to Tenochtitlan.

Please, let's not confuse Jules with more issues. Let him consider how his theory about Israel hiring Fatah to take out Hamas would play out.
 
Nevertheless, just because Hamas is "BAAAAAD" does not give Israel an excuse to steal land on the West Bank and practice apartheid.

Technically, it does give them an excuse. It's just a really bad excuse, much as "stealing" really is of questionable accuracy. Regardless, I have yet to contend that those actions of Israel are anything but wrong, and have, in fact, repeatedly said that that those actions of Israel should be condemned, had you been paying attention. Well, not apartheid, technically, because that's the first time that it's come up in this discussion. I'm not a huge fan of it, either way, much as I'm unsurprised by it.

Even if true, and I do not think it is, this matters nothing for the victims

Which is completely irrelevant to the claim that you were making.


If Israel were interested in end the attacks on Israeli property and the people on Israeli property they would first need to give back what they have stolen

And do they have any reason whatsoever to believe that such a course of action even could lead to the attacks stopping when the Palestinian government has been acting the way it is?

As I said, you have no reason to assume that Israel is interested in a fair peace until they do not give back what they have stolen

Honestly, at the moment, I'd be surprised if they were particularly interested in what you would consider a "fair peace" after all the bad blood that's been there for how long? "Fair peace" tends to come when populations aren't actively antagonistic and indoctrinating their kids to keep the antagonism going.

Who initiated the violence is a chicken-and-egg problem since violence has been around since 1948, probably earlier

Again, irrelevant to who initiated this particular conflict. So far, you're doing a terrible job of making your case.

False.
They never tried to return waht they have stolen, in first place

In short, you are unable to make a valid argument against the point, if that's still your argument.

??
I have asked you: Did Isreal offer to give back what they stole and accept a Palestinian State? When?

It's somewhat sad that you think that that in any way counters or even validly addresses the point that I made. The Palestinians could have prevented the entire recent death toll and bombings easily and refused to do it, instead knowingly choosing a path that was certain to lead to many Palestinian civilian causalities and deaths, fairly little damage to Israel... and encouraged their civilians to put themselves in harm's way on top of that. Despite that, you're still trying to throw up that red herring?


How does Hamas behaviour prevent Israel to give up what they have stolen and accept the two state solution?
Please explain in detail


Tu quoque argument.
I will ask you once again: How does Hamas behaviour prevent Israel to give up what they have stolen and accept the two state solution?
Please explain in detail

In short, you have no idea what tu quoque means. You made a claim, I pointed out why it didn't work. You've utterly failed to defend your point and tried to hide behind your smokescreen. With that said, is there any country that you can think of that would willingly give up land to a vastly weaker group that is actively promoting terrorism against them, after they've already demonstrated that it's not a viable solution to reducing the violence?

??
We are not talkin about Hamas here. I do not dispute that Hamas does bad things. What you dispute is that Israel does steal land and does not accept the two state solution!

In short, your reading comprehension is abominable. Feel free to reread what I've actually said and try again.


??
We were talking that the US has used its veto power to prevent Israel being sanctioned at the US
The evidence I have provided support this claim

In short, your reading comprehension AND memory are abominable. Feel free to reread what has actually been said, though, and try again.
 
Last edited:
Agree that phrases like "stealing land" don't really help the discussion any, as they ignore both historicla context and relevant laws. This case, too, is far less black-and-white than it initially seems.

And yet...Israel keeps Stealing land.
Funny how you state this right after we established that Israel recently pulled out of Gaza. Then there was Olmert's peace proposal in 2008, where Israel tried to initiate negotiations by offering to give up significant aras of land.

But sure, Israel Just Keeps Stealing Land. Repeat it over and over and it will at least sound true.
 
Well...it looks like people all over the world are protesting Israel and it's invasion of Palestine. Seems like people all over the world "Get it".

https://www.google.com/search?hl=en...thuser=0&gl=us&hl=en&q=israel+protest&tbm=nws

Have you figured out how Fatah could take out Hamas with Israeli air and artillery strikes without incurring unacceptable civilian losses yet?

Or have you fled from your failed argument without even the common decency to admit that you were wrong?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom