Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
There would be an even better way to try to minimize civilian casualties in war: not steal land in first place and accept a two-state solution on the 1967 borders. Then there might be less chance for a war in first place.
But you do not like talking about land theft by the Israelis..
And we know why, as you cant blame that on Hamas :D

IMO, this has to be overcome by Hamas first:

“Hamas will not recognize Israel,” Mousa Abu Marzouk, deputy chairman of Hamas’ political bureau, told Al-Monitor in an exclusive interview.

“This is a red line that cannot be crossed,” said the 63-year-old Hamas leader who played a pivotal role in achieving the reconciliation deal with Fatah on April 23.
 
While I posted the names of 100+ fatal victims of Israeli bombardment of Gaza, nobody asked for a list of rocket attack victims in Israel, because we all know there are none. Zero. Someone at a targeted gas station was rumoured to be injured.

Here's Jen Psaki.


has anyone asked for the list of allegedly killed palestinians you post?
 
While I wouldn't mind lands being returned, and in fact believe this would be a very generous and constructive gesture on the part of Israel...

...this is certainly a very good point.
No one here, I hope, pretend the Palestinians are the only people in the world to lose land during the last century. The Finns for example lost significant land areas to the Soviet Union during the Second World War. Do you see them making a huge fuzz about that to this day, to the point that they're teaching their kids to throw rocks at soldiers and tanks, lobbing missiles at Russian neighbourhoods, or voting parties into power that promise the downfall of Russia?

...er, no. They went on with their lives a long time ago. You can reply to this with "but, but, blockade and wall and bombs!!!" if you wish, but to do so you have to remember that these things are a result of terrorist acts, not the other way around.

All of this, plus the fact that when "Palestine" (which is, remember, a fairly new invention rather than an ancient country and people) was occupied by others than Israel, no one raised an eyebrow...

And even more recent example is the situation in Cyprus. There's literally a wall down the Island and the Turks in general are total ******** who painted a huge Turkish flag on the mountainside that can only be seen in Nicosia by the Greeks. Way to instigate!

But we never hear about the constant crap of fighting and bombs etc even though it is really frustrating for the Greeks, especially the Greeks who lost houses and businesses on the other side. They just moved on a started over again with a lot of frustration.

http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/world/europe/cy-green-line.htm
 
Last edited:
I'm curious. Who here in any way expressed approval at the deaths of Palestinian civilians, or any civilians in general, in the first place? And why, exactly, are you trying to excuse the, what, 150 rockets and rejection of a ceasefire that occurred before Israel responded at all, militarily? Is there some reason that your approach to the subject is so unbalanced, regardless?


It's not my approach that's unbalanced.

Names keep adding.

102. Abdel Halim Ashra, 54, was killed in an airstrike on Wednesday in the area of Birka Deir al-Balah, but his body wasn’t discovered till Friday.
103. Saher Abu Namous, 3, was killed in an airstrike on his home in northern Gaza.
104. Hussein al-Mamlouk, 47, was killed in an airstrike on Gaza City.
105. Saber Sukkar, 80, was killed in an airstrike on Gaza City.
106. Nasser Rabih Mohammed Samamah, 49, was killed in an airstrike on Gaza City.

Saturday, July 12:

107. Rami Abu Massaad, 23, was killed in a strike on Deir al-Balah.
108. Mohammed al-Samiri, 24, was killed in the same attack.
109. Houssam Deeb al-Razayneh, 39, was killed in an attack on Jabalia
110. Anas Youssef Kandil, 17, was killed in the same bombing.
111. Abdel Rahim Saleh al-Khatib, 38, was killed in the same bombing.
112. Youssef Mohammed Kandil, 33, was killed in the same bombing.
113. Mohammed Idriss Abu Saninah, 20, was killed in the same bombing.
114. Hala Wishahi, 31, was killed in an attack on the Mabarra association for the disabled in Jabalia.
115. Suha Abu Saade, 38, was killed in the same attack.
116. Ali Nabil Basal, 32, was killed in a strike on western Gaza city.
117. Mohammed Bassem al-Halabi, 28, was killed in the same strike.
118. Mohammed al-Sowayti (Abu Askar), 20, was killed in the same attack.
119. Ibrahim Nabil Humaide, 30, was killed in a bombing in the Tufah neighborhood in eastern Gaza City.
120. Hassan Ahmed Abu Ghoush, 24, was killed in the same attack.
121. Ahmed Mazen al-Ballaoui, 26, was killed in the same attack
 
IMO, this has to be overcome by Hamas first:

Tu quoque at its finest.
We are not talking about what Hamas does wrong, but why the Israeli Government keeps stealing land (with US support).
No answer received so far

has anyone asked for the list of allegedly killed palestinians you post?

I find the list useful and on-topic.
Any problem with that?
 
Nazi body count was 10 civilians for each Nazi killed.
Jews are doing fairly better :D 121 against 3

So question, if the Israelis have better weapons that kill more people including innocent civilians and the Palestinians are so concerned about this, why don't they make sure that the terrorists don't attack Israel in the first place?

Seems to me that at times the Palestinian body count is used as a prop to help motivate even more attacks. If you KNOW that when Israel retaliates the death toll is going to be huge, wouldn't it make sense to stop attacking them?
:D:D

If Israel is in violation of agreements there are UN interventions that can be used to negotiate the situation.


The way this sounds is that your next door neighbor keeps stealing your cows. So you decide to start shooting at their house with a sling shot. You break a few windows and maybe sock one of the farmers in the eye.

They come out with an UZI and blow away five members of your family.

Sooo.....the smart thing to do is what? Keep attacking them or call the police?
 
Last edited:
So question, if the Israelis have better weapons that kill more people including innocent civilians and the Palestinians are so concerned about this, why don't they make sure that the terrorists don't attack Israel in the first place?

Never said $that Hamas is not guilty
But it is Israel who steals Palestinian land, not the Palestinians who steal Israeli land

So why all the pro-US group is evading the question: why is Israel stealing land in the West Bank?
 
Last edited:
International activists remain in Gaza hospital threatened by Israeli missiles

Israel’s army fired four ‘warning’ missiles at the roof of El-Wafa rehabilitation hospital in Gaza City, Gaza. International volunteers now staying in the hospital in solidarity, have said they, “can hear missiles falling close by”.

“The civilian population of Gaza is being bombed. We will stay with them in solidarity until the international community and our governments take action to stop Israel’s crimes against humanity.” States Swedish International Solidarity Movement (ISM) activist, Fred Ekblad.

The volunteers are citizens of USA, Spain, Sweden, Venezuela, France, UK, Australia, and New Zealand. [...]
 
You're dodging the question. So what they stole land. You think it's ok to murder people because someone stole land?

It's *********** LAND. The Palestinians have much more important social issues to consider than the stealing of land.

So in your argument it's OK to launch bombs at innocent Israelis because their screwed up government stole land. Let's just lob a bunch of bombs and if civilians get killed who cares right? They stole land!

If they stole land it means they were able to steal land. How about rounding up all the Palesitinian terrorists and gather them near the land they don't want stolen again. And when the Israeli military comes in and tries to steal the land, STOP THEM.

How does throwing bombs at Israeli people stop that? Please explain?
 
You're dodging the question. So what they stole land. You think it's ok to murder people because someone stole land?

This is not what I said

It's *********** LAND. The Palestinians have much more important social issues to consider than the stealing of land.

So it is OK to steal land as you have decided that the Palestinians should not care about their land.
What if I come to your house and take from you a part of your garden, kitchen and living room and then if you protest I call you anti-Semite and kill your wife/mother?
As this is what the Israeli are doing. With your silent support, apparently

So in your argument it's OK to launch bombs at innocent Israelis because their screwed up government stole land. Let's just lob a bunch of bombs and if civilians get killed who cares right? They stole land!

This is not what I said

If they stole land it means they were able to steal land.

HAHAHAHAHA!!
I will put this in my sign!!
:sdl: :sdl:
You are condoning a crime simply as the offender was able to commit the crime!
This is becoming ridiculous and hilarious at the utmost.

Next time someone steals you something (bike or car) and you go to the police, would you be happy if they reply to you: "If they stole your car, it means they were able to steal your car!" ??

:sdl: :sdl:
 
Last edited:
Yep, it's called reality. It's called the "real world" not a game where someone busts out th rule book and calls "No fair he's cheating" If they were able to steal the land it means the Palestinian military and government SUCKS and they aren't strong enough to win. And REALITY means that if you aren't strong enough you can't run around whining like a stupid baby and expect the world to intervene on behalf of a child.

Grow up. If you can't compete with the big dogs, stop trying to win a dog fight. You will be massacred in the process.

A crime? I'm condoning a crime? Nope, I'm saying the stupid farmer with a slingshot is an idiot for trying to fling the rocks at the farmers house. Let's say the bigger farmer has the police department in his pocket because his brother is the lead detective there.

So everytime you call the police they take the side of the farmer who stole your cow.


Only an IDIOT would think that continuing to throw slingshots at the farmers house is going to achieve anything but a childish sense of victory. "Ha Ha Ha I broke a window, did you see the look on his face!! Score!" Then the farmer comes out with his Uzi again and shoots your grandmother and three of your children.

Wow, you are brilliant there right?

If the Police force is corrupted then you need to deal with the police force. You need to worry about establishing yourself as a real player, a person of importance and someone to be taken seriously.

That's how it works in the real world.
 
Last edited:
Yep, it's called reality. It's called the "real world" not a game where someone busts out th rule book and calls "No fair he's cheating" If they were able to steal the land it means the Palestinian military and government SUCKS and they aren't strong enough to win. And REALITY means that if you aren't strong enough you can't run around whining like a stupid baby and expect the world to intervene on behalf of a child.

Exactly!!
It is called "real world", but please do not apply it only to Palestinians and Israelis.
Next time you hear about a 8-year-old girl raped, say the same please: if she was not able to defend herself then it was OK for her to be raped.
Same as you are saying with the Palestinians now :D
 
Last edited:
If you want to open a new topic on why Jews have been, in your opinion, "ferociously brutalized for thousands of years" feel free to open another thread

If you aren't interested, or don't think it's on topic here, why did you ask about it?
 
Tu quoque at its finest.
We are not talking about what Hamas does wrong, but why the Israeli Government keeps stealing land (with US support).
No answer received so far

You really need to learn what words mean, especially the logical fallacies you accuse everyone else of perpetrating while you are actually perpetrating them yourself.

In this case, it's not a tu quoque because Hamas charter and stated intent - being as they are a leading force among Palestinians - directly influences Israeli actions.
 
It's not my approach that's unbalanced.

Based on your very one-sided approach to the matter that ignores context of any kind? How many on your list, for example, are those who were directly carrying out attacks?

Tu quoque at its finest.
We are not talking about what Hamas does wrong, but why the Israeli Government keeps stealing land (with US support).
No answer received so far

Strange, "why the Israeli Government keeps stealing land (with US support)" has nothing to do with what you started the thread with, before it was merged... and has not much to do with any later discussion. One might get the impression that you're just running away from properly addressing the actual points being made, if you keep this up. To deal with this point, though, on a personal level, I've never supported Israelis breaking their agreements on who controls areas of land, nor have I personally heard any people support such here in the US. Why do and have they done it? Likely a number of reasons that most here would not find to be sufficient justification for their actions, which makes it somewhat pointless for you to try to keep bringing it up.



I find the list useful and on-topic.
Any problem with that?

The point of pointing it out was to keep one of Childlike Empress' arguments in perspective... because it is quite meaningless when kept in perspective. If it was horribly off topic, that point would have been made a number of times by now. Personally, I don't see much point in listing the names of people who I wouldn't know at all and without sufficient details to distinguish any particular reason for their deaths. I have no problem with others feeling differently, but it looks like they're just being used to garner sympathy for the Palestinians, regardless of whether any of the killings had reasonable justification or not. I do consider killing a person who is actively attacking the people a military is sworn to protect to be justified killing, though.

Nazi body count was 10 civilians for each Nazi killed.
Jews are doing fairly better :D 121 against 3

There's a distinction made in the list, now? Where might that be? All it's saying is that Palestinians have died, which, under the circumstances, is not enough information to call them civilians. Many of them may well be, but you're adding claims that are not in evidence.
 
Last edited:
Exactly!!
It is called "real world", but please do not apply it only to Palestinians and Israelis.
Next time you hear about a 8-year-old girl raped, say the same please: if she was not able to defend herself then it was OK for her to be raped.
Same as you are saying with the Palestinians now :D

You are making a straw man.

We're not talking about an 8 year old getting raped.

We're talking about a barely functioning "country" that wants the world to coddle them and treat them like a major player because they use terrorism to get what they want.

The reason they HAVE to use terrorism to get what they want is because the entire "country' is a completely disaster without a strong infrastructure, without a respected political party and without any sense of clear direction in their "country" at all because the only thing really unifying them is their hatred of the Jews.

You don't get to be a "country" that is respected and counts unless you build up a strong country to begin with.


Basically it would be like the First Nations people in the US gathering together and stating they wanted to Claim Tennessee as their own country since we stole land from them in the past. There's just no serious way it's going to happen. You'll have reservations and whatnot but no one is going to regard the Native American reservations as a country on the grand scale of things.

It would be a gesture of compromise and being "respectful" but bottom line, if Native Americans started attacking people who were encroaching on their land and building there, the entire conversation would be over.

You can't just "pretend" you are an important and powerful influence in the world when you are not. The only way it's an important and powerful influence is because of freakin' terrorism. Other than that Palestine does ABSOLUTELY NOTHING OF MERIT.
 
There's a distinction made in the list, now? Where might that be? All it's saying is that Palestinians have died, which, under the circumstances, is not enough information to call them civilians. Many of them may well be, but you're adding claims that are not in evidence.

Add to that Hamas' policy of encouraging people to remain as targets for Israeli bombs despite Israeli attempts to warn people. Hiding behind civilians like Hamas is doing is a war crime. Not that you'll see any of the antisemites accept that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom