Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
He's saying they didn't steal land. No more so than any other country.

He's also saying that the people you are asking Israel to give back land to are not happy unless they get everything.

So...you are saying that because other countries have stolen land, then it's OK for Israel to steal land too?
 
So...you are saying that because other countries have stolen land, then it's OK for Israel to steal land too?

I'm saying that it's hypocritical to hold Israel to a higher standard than any other country.

Now, about that plan of yours for Israel to withdraw completely from the West Bank with the knowledge that when they did so from the Gaza strip, Hamas got stronger, took over and continued lobbing rockets on them...

Have you identified the problem with your plan?
 
I'm saying that it's hypocritical to hold Israel to a higher standard than any other country.

Now, about that plan of yours for Israel to withdraw completely from the West Bank with the knowledge that when they did so from the Gaza strip, Hamas got stronger, took over and continued lobbing rockets on them...

Have you identified the problem with your plan?

As long as Israel is sucking the American taxpayer's teat...I'll hold them to any standard I God-Damned well see fit. Now...if Israel wants me to shut up, then maybe they should unwrap their collective lips from the American Money Teat. If they do it, then I'll be glad to shut up.

Until then, every time Israel Steals Land, it not only reflects bad on Israel, but it makes the American taxpayer look bad as well.
 
As long as Israel is sucking the American taxpayer's teat...I'll hold them to any standard I God-Damned see as right. Now...if Israel wants me to shut up, then maybe they should unwrap their collective lips from the American Money Teat. If they do it, then I'll be glad to shut up.

So you are confessing to being hypocritical about Israel then?

Until then, every time Israel Steals Land, it not only reflects bad on Israel, but it makes the American taxpayer look bad as well.

Doesn't the fact that you are living on stolen land make you look bad?
 
So...you are saying Israel has an excuse to steal land?

No, I am not excusing anyone's behavior. For what it's worth, Israel should not have held onto the land it took from Jordan and Egypt after the six day war, but that was a long time ago. Settlements just aggravate the situation.

I am seeing from my POV where the roadblocks to peace are. Does Israel have a right to exist?
 
n't the fact that you are living on stolen land make you look bad?

Actually, I live on land once owned by the Krankawe...who died out as a result of disease brought over by the Spanish. As a result, the land was empty when it was settled.

Now...go find me a Krankawe, and I'll be glad to help him get what he deserves from the political system.
 
Actually, I live on land once owned by the Krankawe...who died out as a result of disease brought over by the Spanish. As a result, the land was empty when it was settled.

Now...go find me a Krankawe, and I'll be glad to help him get what he deserves from the political system.

Still, the land you live on was stolen by Westerners who waged a war of extinction against the native population. What about all the other still existing native American tribes? Shouldn't they get their territory back?

What about Germany and Poland, who ceded territory to the USSR after World War 2. Shouldn't they get their land back? What about South Vietnam which was invaded and conquered by North Vietnam?
 
Last edited:
I am seeing from my POV where the roadblocks to peace are. Does Israel have a right to exist?

It doesn't matter what Hamas thinks. Israel should give the land back that they stole.

Afterwards...if Hamas keeps attacking...then utterly destroy them.
 
You of course are being dishonest here. Have you bothered investigating why the deaths in Gaza are always so high before blaming the Jews?

Hamas uses civilians as human shields despite this being the biggest humans rights violation there is. They intentionally store weapons, launch attacks, and carry out military operations in civilian buildings and within civilian areas. They do this knowing that any retaliation will have a greater chance of civilian casualties which can then be used to get people such as yourself who have already decided what they want to believe to blame the Jews.

This is the Israeli narrative of course.
They launch the attack, they kill the people as missiles are from Israel and not from Hamas and then they blame Hamas for the victims.
Even if (for the sake of argument as I do not believe this is true) Hamas uses civilians as human shields, why then still Israel steals land?
What is stealing land have to do with protecting from Hamas?

When Israel launches an attack, they use the most suficsticated technology to minimize collateral damage as much as possible. When possible they call off strikes for fear of too much collateral damage. You have to understand that a common Hamas tactic is to launch rockets from within schools and to store weapons within schools.

Israel drops leaflets, makes phone calls, and sends text messages to residents beforehand in order to give them a chance to evacuate before a strike. Before a strike they will knock on a roof which means to drop a small mortar which will create smoke and noise, giving civilians an opportunity to flee before the actual strike.

Beyond the point.
Israel knows before launching an attack that there will be lots of civilian victims.
So they should avoid this as much as possible whatever the behaviour of Hamas

Unfortunately when they do this, Hamas gets civilians to surround these buildings in order to claim higher death tolls and to get people such as yourself to blame the Jews for their actions.

This is of course Israeli narrative

So they have two choices. Allow rockets to rein down on their civilians, or strike those weapon supplies and operations within civilian areas using the best technology to minimize deaths as much as possible.

What about the third choice?
Go back to their legitimate borders and accept the two-state solution on the 1967 borders?

While Hamas uses crude weapons to indiscriminately attack any civilians possible. They even openly encourage the killing of civilians when speaking in public on TV. They also encourage civilians on their side to die in these operations. They do everything they can to increase civilian casualties on both sides, while the IDF tries to minimize it.

Tu quoque argument.
We are speaking about why Israel does what they do, and you keep yelling
But but but Hmas!!

No, this is a fabrication on your part and it 100% untrue. Shame on you.

You mean that it is not the IDF that sends the missiles?
Or you mean that it is not the Israeli government that orders this?

No one took land that is not theirs. The problem is that you are starting with a lie. If you could only be bothered to learn the history there you might understand. But clearly you have no intent on doing so.

Which lie, exactly?
That before the 1967 war Israel was not on much smaller borders?
Or that Israel keeps building outside the 1967 borders?
Which lie did I say?
 
Last edited:
It doesn't matter what Hamas thinks. Israel should give the land back that they stole.

Afterwards...if Hamas keeps attacking...then utterly destroy them.

They did keep attacking after they were given land back. Since this seems difficult for you to accept, I'll repeat it: The Hamas charter calls for the utter destruction of Israel.
 
So...you are saying Israel has an excuse to steal land?

Some people say it is OK to steal other people property and then bomb them if they protest too much

If they stole land it means they were able to steal land.

It doesn't matter what Hamas thinks. Israel should give the land back that they stole.

Afterwards...if Hamas keeps attacking...then utterly destroy them.

Agreed for the first part.
Do not agree with the "utterly destroy them"
 
They did keep attacking after they were given land back. Since this seems difficult for you to accept, I'll repeat it: The Hamas charter calls for the utter destruction of Israel.

Israel kept Stealing Land from the West Bank.

But...don't worry about Hamas...Israel won't dare destroy Hamas. To Israel, Hamas is precious...Hamas is an Israeli national Treasure.

See...Hamas is just dumb enough to fight Israel, but so dumb that they always choose the wrong way to fight. As a result, Hamas keeps giving Israel an excuse to Steal more-and-more Land.

Israel + Hamas = A Nest of Lovers
 
This is the Israeli narrative of course.

It is. It is also the narrative of independent human rights organizations.

Beyond the point.
Israel knows before launching an attack that there will be lots of civilian victims.
So they should avoid this as much as possible whatever the behaviour of Hamas

They do avoid it as much as possible. They could go into Gaza with full force. They don't.


This is of course Israeli narrative

As I said, it is also the narrative of independent human rights organizations.

What about the third choice?
Go back to their legitimate borders and accept the two-state solution on the 1967 borders?

Why are those the legitimate borders? Why not 1948? Why not 1776?

Tu quoque argument.
We are speaking about why Israel does what they do, and you keep yelling
But but but Hmas!!

Not a tu quoque, as already explain. Learn what words mean.


You mean that it is not the IDF that sends the missiles?
Or you mean that it is not the Israeli government that orders this?

Are you being intentionally obtuse? What is 100% untrue is that anyone here is praising the IDF or the Israeli government. Why do you feel the need to lie so much?


Which lie, exactly?
That before the 1967 war Israel was not on much smaller borders?
Or that Israel keeps building outside the 1967 borders?
Which lie did I say?

Well, considering the fact that most of your posts contain lies, it's kind of hard to just pick one, but in this specific case he is talking about the lie that the story of Israel started in 1967, or 1948 for that matter. You don't know, because you are uneducated. You should rectify that.
 
Israel kept Stealing Land from the West Bank.

They withdrew from parts of the West Bank as well. Why should they withdraw more when withdrawing strengthened their enemies and caused more violence?

But...don't worry about Hamas...Israel won't dare destroy Hamas. To Israel, Hamas is precious...Hamas is an Israeli national Treasure.

See...Hamas is just dumb enough to fight Israel, but so dumb that they always choose the wrong way to fight. As a result, Hamas keeps giving Israel an excuse to Steal more-and-more Land.

Israel + Hamas = A Nest of Lovers

This is quite possibly the stupidest thing you've posted yet, and that's really saying something.
 
It doesn't matter what Hamas thinks. Israel should give the land back that they stole.

Afterwards...if Hamas keeps attacking...then utterly destroy them.

I didn't say it matters what Hamas thinks. I asked what you think.

As far as Hamas, what they Say and DO matters. This is a land dispute. It can be resolved by force, or by negotiation. Negotiation is the better way, no? Unilateral moves to give up land have no guarantee and will be avoided by any nation with a position of strength.
 
I didn't say it matters what Hamas thinks. I asked what you think.

As far as Hamas, what they Say and DO matters. This is a land dispute. It can be resolved by force, or by negotiation. Negotiation is the better way, no? Unilateral moves to give up land have no guarantee and will be avoided by any nation with a position of strength.

Hamas are a bunch of psychotic retards. Until Hamas gives up the dream of destroying Israel, then no one should really care what Hamas thinks. And...while it would be nice to see Israel negotiate with a reformed Hamas, I don't think Israel should wait around for that to happen. In the mean time, it's never too early to do the right thing. Israel should give back what they stole.

Of course, Israel isn't going to be able to vacate everything they took...but they can compensate the Palestinians some how. Israel can negotiate this with the reasonable Palestinians.

Israel has the Strength to do this. But...will they? Can they? Or are they so locked-in to an all-conquering Zionist Vision that they have blinded themselves forever?
 
Hamas are a bunch of psychotic retards. Until Hamas gives up the dream of destroying Israel, then no one should really care what Hamas thinks. And...while it would be nice to see Israel negotiate with a reformed Hamas, I don't think Israel should wait around for that to happen. In the mean time, it's never too early to do the right thing. Israel should give back what they stole.

Of course, Israel isn't going to be able to vacate everything they took...but they can compensate the Palestinians some how. Israel can negotiate this with the reasonable Palestinians.

Israel has the Strength to do this. But...will they? Can they? Or are they so locked-in to an all-conquering Zionist Vision that they have blinded themselves forever?

It's a hard sell to the Israeli public that they should give land to terrorists that have their destruction in mind in the vain hope that they'd stop lobbing rockets at them. The "reasonable" Palestinians lost in the internal Palestinian power struggle between Fatah and Hamas.

That said, this is one out of two options I can see that would have any chance of moving the situation forward. The other option is a full Israeli invasion of the West Bank and Gaza, followed by a military crackdown. The second option is worse, but also has it's advantages.

However, there can be no negotiation as long as Hamas has any political influence.

ETA: For the record, Hamas were elected by the Palestinian people to lead them. If they are a bunch of psychotic retards - something I agree with, possibly minus the "retard" part - they are elected psychotic retards leading the Palestinians.
 
Last edited:
This is the Israeli narrative of course.
They launch the attack, they kill the people as missiles are from Israel and not from Hamas and then they blame Hamas for the victims.
Even if (for the sake of argument as I do not believe this is true) Hamas uses civilians as human shields, why then still Israel steals land?
What is stealing land have to do with protecting from Hamas?

No, it’s not a narrative. You can watch the TV clips of Hamas leaders making these claims. You can watch the video footage of the strikes to see the techniques used. You can watch the interviews with Palestinians talking about the phone calls and texts coming in.

You don’t have to believe Hamas uses human shields, but it’s a claim that Hamas touts. It’s part of their documented procedure that they promote and fully endorse publicly.

Israel did NOT steal any land what so ever. Part of the problem is this fictitious claim. And for some reason people such as yourself who clearly have no understanding of the situation keep blindly repeating because someone told you and you just assumed it was true. This notion that Arabs lived in a land and one day some Jews came and took it away is complete fiction. No such thing ever happened. You have two groups of people who have been living in the same area for centuries who don’t get along. Now they are in a land dispute over the borders. Neither can agree where those borders should be and neither was there first.



Beyond the point.
Israel knows before launching an attack that there will be lots of civilian victims.
So they should avoid this as much as possible whatever the behaviour of Hamas

Are you suggesting that Israel should just sit by and allow its civilians to be killed? That they should not be allowed to retaliate against a group that is launching missiles into their civilian population? Why don’t you hold Hamas to this same standard? Why don’t you complain about Hamas firing rockets into Israel and say they shouldn’t do it? You claim they are somehow defending themselves (laughable). But when Israel rather than blindly attacking civilians takes every possible course of action known to man to strike only military targets you seem to apply a double standard.

So why the double standards? Because that’s pure bigotry.



This is of course Israeli narrative

No, documented events and policy publicly stated by Hamas


What about the third choice?
Go back to their legitimate borders and accept the two-state solution on the 1967 borders?

Because they ARE at their legitimate borders. You seem to have no understanding of history and simply parrot Hamas propaganda. Israel accepted those older borders originally and the Arabs rejected it. In response, all Arab surrounding countries waged war on the Jews. In 1967 when all surrounding countries waged war, Israel held them back. Those countries lost some land in the process which is what happens in war. That land was used as buffer zones to prevent future attacks and to prevent those countries from having easy striking range to big Israeli cities which those countries made very clear they intended to attack.

The current borders give Israel a strategic advantage over attacking countries and without which they would be wiped out. To change those borders now would be suicide for Israel. You need that kind of tactical advantage when all surrounding countries are hostile towards you.

Gaza is a perfect example. Israel build infrastructure there which kind of defeated the point of having a buffer zone. It offered little strategic advantage. So they gave it to the Palestinian refugees. It belonged originally to Egypt, not ‘Palestine’, but in an attempt to work towards peace they handed it over. Now it has become a staging ground for attacks on Israel. It now gives the Arabs the ability to target Israeli cities they previously could not hit with missiles.

So you have two sides only one of which has conceded land while the other has not. The one that refuses to concede any land continues to launch attacks even after getting more land. And you think that all they want is land when they continue to attack? You might have a point if the attacks diminished after conceding land. But just the opposite happened.

Both groups are going to have to give up land. Not just Israel. But they will first both have to agree one which land goes to who, not your fictions narrative that all land is Palestinian.



Tu quoque argument.
We are speaking about why Israel does what they do, and you keep yelling
But but but Hmas!!

That’s not a quote, that’s you not wanting to listen to anyone and therefore making straw man arguments since you cannot defend your position.


You mean that it is not the IDF that sends the missiles?
Or you mean that it is not the Israeli government that orders this?

The missiles targeting Hamas missile launching sites, weapons storage, and military members who staged attacks? Yes it is. And unfortunately Hamas uses civilian locations to carry out such things which is a clear cut humans right violation. That’s what using human shields is.

If someone is shooting at your child while hiding behind their own child, is it wrong to stop them from killing your child because it risks killing their child?



Which lie, exactly?
That before the 1967 war Israel was not on much smaller borders?
Or that Israel keeps building outside the 1967 borders?
Which lie did I say?

The lie was that that land belongs to the Palestinians. The lie was that Israel was at fault for those surrounding countries attacking it. You don’t seem to mind at all when Jews are killed, only Arabs. Isn’t that interesting? That land was originally Jordan and Egypt and Syria before those countries declared war on Israel, lined up all their troops on the border and said they would drive the Jews into the Sea. Perhaps if they had been interested in peace instead of genocide those borders would still be in place. But so long as they remain hostile, those borders are not going to change and they have no right to them. But of course you blame the people defending themselves. I wonder why that is…
 
No, it’s not a narrative. You can watch the TV clips of Hamas leaders making these claims. You can watch the video footage of the strikes to see the techniques used. You can watch the interviews with Palestinians talking about the phone calls and texts coming in.

I'll be damned. Hamas posts their twitter accounts. Who would have thought?

Hamas: You killed my Child!

IDF: I gave you warning...Didn't you get my Tweet?

Hamas: No...my smartphone's battery was uncharged.

This notion that Arabs lived in a land and one day some Jews came and took it away is complete fiction.

Except...all those times when some Jews came along one day and took the Arabs land.

The current borders give Israel a strategic advantage over attacking countries and without which they would be wiped out.

And...those 200 Nuclear Israeli Weapons are quite an Insurance Policy, too...don't ya' think?

So you have two sides only one of which has conceded land while the other has not. The one that refuses to concede any land continues to launch attacks even after getting more land. And you think that all they want is land when they continue to attack? You might have a point if the attacks diminished after conceding land. But just the opposite happened.

So...giving back Land that you stole is all noble and stuff?

The missiles targeting Hamas missile launching sites, weapons storage, and military members who staged attacks? Yes it is. And unfortunately Hamas uses civilian locations to carry out such things which is a clear cut humans right violation. That’s what using human shields is.

Maybe if Hamas had more Land, they could move those missiles away from the kids?

If someone is shooting at your child while hiding behind their own child, is it wrong to stop them from killing your child because it risks killing their child?

Why would some jerk be shooting at my Child? What...does he think I tried to steal his land, burn down his house, and kill his kids...or something?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom