Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh.. There are others..

[qimg]http://m.c.lnkd.licdn.com/mpr/mpr/p/5/005/067/3b6/379aa17.jpg[/qimg]



As
1) I do not think people hate all Jews, just the ones who murder
2) As I do not have Mr. Fisk` e email address :)

Why do you hate all Jews?

I mean, you clearly do. You crack wise about the holocaust, joke about how the Nazis wanted to see how long a Jew could breathe in poison gas, want nothing more than to see Israel be destroyed by murderous Palestinians. You also support terror organizations that have the murder of Jews and the destruction of Israel in their charter, alongside numerous antisemitic conspiracy theories.

So, the question again is why. Why do you hate Jews?
 
As
1) I do not think people hate all Jews, just the ones who murder
2) As I do not have Mr. Fisk` e email address :)

So your answer as to why Jews as an ethnic group have been ferociously brutalized for thousands of years is that they actually haven't...just the murdering ones?

Interesting.
 
I do not think they huddle together in ghettos anymore...

You questioned why the Jews have been the victims of such enmity for so long by so many people. During most of that time they did huddle together in Ghettos.

Perhaps it's because they have beady eyes and tails.
 
You questioned why the Jews have been the victims of such enmity for so long by so many people. During most of that time they did huddle together in Ghettos.

Perhaps it's because they have beady eyes and tails.

But so did a lot of other people. A lot of other people have been tortured and abused and attacked and victimized throughout history.

They just don't whinge on about to death. I mean seriously, people roll their eyes when African Americans bring up slavery because it was "Ancient History" even though racism is a huge around the world even today.

Look at what's going on in Africa as we speak. So why is it that we're supposed to regard the Jews as if they've been the only people in the world who have been victimized this way?

LOTS AND LOTS of groups have been victimized in the same way. :confused:
 
Are you were justifying the crimes the Israeli are doing.
Now I am asking you: what is the justification for stealing land?
Again you seem to be jumping to conclusions as to what other people support. Remember when I had to point out to you that not everyone here supports Operation Iraqi Freedom, or illegal NSA surveillance? Yeah. Now you're doing it again.
 
Here's a video of one of the much-written about "warnings" the IDF gives when they occasionally feel like it. "Knocking on the roof". Don't be a coward, there's no gore seen anywhere. Just make sure you're wearing your empathy cap while watching. You've likely read the casualties' names on the list already.

 
Last edited:
Look at what's going on in Africa as we speak. So why is it that we're supposed to regard the Jews as if they've been the only people in the world who have been victimized this way?

LOTS AND LOTS of groups have been victimized in the same way. :confused:
I, for one, certainly don't pretend so. I have sympathy for the Roma as much as the Jews, possibly more as the Roma still don't have their own country and possibly never will, especially since they are often nomadic by nature.
 
But so did a lot of other people. A lot of other people have been tortured and abused and attacked and victimized throughout history.

They just don't whinge on about to death. I mean seriously, people roll their eyes when African Americans bring up slavery because it was "Ancient History" even though racism is a huge around the world even today.

Look at what's going on in Africa as we speak. So why is it that we're supposed to regard the Jews as if they've been the only people in the world who have been victimized this way?

LOTS AND LOTS of groups have been victimized in the same way. :confused:

I think if you read through the relevant back and forth posts in this thread carefully, you'll realize what you've typed has nothing to do with what what I've typed.
 
Um because that's how the world works. Have you ever taken a history class? You are seriously pushing the argument that during a land squabble and a war that the victor is supposed to aw shucks sorry and give it back?

Should America give the land back to the Native Americans? How about we don't give the land back to the Palestinians because they didn't do **** with it the entire time the had it and the only reason the dog wanted their bone back is because of antisemitism and some religious garbage from a stupid book that goes all the way back to Ishmael and Isaac. How about get the **** over it already and realize the train has left the station and start trying to build up what you do have instead of destroying what someone else has created because it pisses you off that they are a more successful country than you.

How about that. :D
While I wouldn't mind lands being returned, and in fact believe this would be a very generous and constructive gesture on the part of Israel...

...this is certainly a very good point.
No one here, I hope, pretend the Palestinians are the only people in the world to lose land during the last century. The Finns for example lost significant land areas to the Soviet Union during the Second World War. Do you see them making a huge fuzz about that to this day, to the point that they're teaching their kids to throw rocks at soldiers and tanks, lobbing missiles at Russian neighbourhoods, or voting parties into power that promise the downfall of Russia?

...er, no. They went on with their lives a long time ago. You can reply to this with "but, but, blockade and wall and bombs!!!" if you wish, but to do so you have to remember that these things are a result of terrorist acts, not the other way around.

All of this, plus the fact that when "Palestine" (which is, remember, a fairly new invention rather than an ancient country and people) was occupied by others than Israel, no one raised an eyebrow...
 
While I posted the names of 100+ fatal victims of Israeli bombardment of Gaza, nobody asked for a list of rocket attack victims in Israel, because we all know there are none. Zero. Someone at a targeted gas station was rumoured to be injured.

Here's Jen Psaki.

 
Last edited:
Here's a video of one of the much-written about "warnings" the IDF gives when they occasionally feel like it. "Knocking on the roof". Don't be a coward, there's no gore seen anywhere. Just make sure you're wearing your empathy cap while watching. You've likely read the casualties' names on the list already.

While I posted the names of 100+ fatal victims of Israeli bombardment of Gaza, nobody asked for a list of rocket attack victims in Israel, because we all know there are none. Zero. Someone at a targeted gas station was rumoured to be injured.

I'm curious. Who here in any way expressed approval at the deaths of Palestinian civilians, or any civilians in general, in the first place? And why, exactly, are you trying to excuse the, what, 150 rockets and rejection of a ceasefire that occurred before Israel responded at all, militarily? Is there some reason that your approach to the subject is so unbalanced, regardless?
 
Last edited:
I'm curious. Who here in any way expressed approval at the deaths of Palestinian civilians, or any civilians in general, in the first place? And why, exactly, are you trying to excuse the, what, 150 rockets and rejection of a ceasefire that occurred before Israel responded at all, militarily? Is there some reason that your approach to the subject is so unbalanced, regardless?

When you have half the posters on ignore, I guess you just make up what you think their opinions are.
 
So your answer as to why Jews as an ethnic group have been ferociously brutalized for thousands of years is that they actually haven't...just the murdering ones?

Interesting.

If you want to open a new topic on why Jews have been, in your opinion, "ferociously brutalized for thousands of years" feel free to open another thread

You questioned why the Jews have been the victims of such enmity for so long by so many people. During most of that time they did huddle together in Ghettos.

Perhaps it's because they have beady eyes and tails.

People think Hitler and Stalin were brutal dictators.
They both had mustachos
Maybe the fact that they had mustachos may be the reason why they were brutal dictators.
Ahem.

LOTS AND LOTS of groups have been victimized in the same way. :confused:

And they do not go around killing people in revenge

Again you seem to be jumping to conclusions as to what other people support.

I do not jump to any conclusion.
I state fact and ask questions
Again
You were justifying the crimes the Israeli are doing.
Now I am asking you: what is the justification for stealing land?

I, for one, certainly don't pretend so. I have sympathy for the Roma as much as the Jews, possibly more as the Roma still don't have their own country and possibly never will, especially since they are often nomadic by nature.

What about the Palestinians?
Do you have any sympathy for them?
They had their land taken for the last tens of years.
Any sympathy for the victims of this theft?

Uh, no? Has anyone here said that:confused:?

"We"?

You have muttered not one single word of condemnation for the systematic killing of civilians that we are seen in the news right now.
Is there any reason for your silence?
Just explain please

While I wouldn't mind lands being returned, and in fact believe this would be a very generous and constructive gesture on the part of Israel...

Well, returning something that you have stolen is not exactly "a very generous and constructive gesture" but rather a duty

I'm curious. Who here in any way expressed approval at the deaths of Palestinian civilians, or any civilians in general, in the first place?

Ahem..
This thread is quite long and some guys have muttered just excuses why Israel kills civilians and did not say a word of condemnation against the crime.
I guess this stands as "approval at the deaths of Palestinian civilians"
 
Last edited:
Ahem..
This thread is quite long and some guys have muttered just excuses why Israel kills civilians and did not say a word of condemnation against the crime.
I guess this stands as "approval at the deaths of Palestinian civilians"

It doesn't stand as such particularly well, though, when it's being treated as an very undesirable side-effect of a conflict that 1) certain Palestinians forced in the first place, even after being given ample opportunity to end it before reprisal, 2) those Palestinians are *putting* noncombatants, their own and others, directly in harms way, 3) those Palestinians have also been indoctrinating their population with the idea that military and terroristic actions are feasible and desirable courses of action to accomplish their goals. Quite frankly, there's lots and lots to criticize on the Israeli side, but they don't even remotely bear all the blame for the situation, contrary to the way that you've kept trying to portray things. Keeping things accurate and in perspective is not the same as giving "approval."

Of course, if you actually want to try to dispute the point, you could admit that you approve of the killing of Israeli civilians, as a number of your posts predict will happen, seemingly a little gleefully.
 
Last edited:
Aridas, thank you for your post.

If you want to open a new topic on why Jews have been, in your opinion, "ferociously brutalized for thousands of years" feel free to open another thread

People think Hitler and Stalin were brutal dictators.
They both had mustachos
Maybe the fact that they had mustachos may be the reason why they were brutal dictators.
Ahem.
I give up. Have fun.
 
Last edited:
While I posted the names of 100+ fatal victims of Israeli bombardment of Gaza, nobody asked for a list of rocket attack victims in Israel, because we all know there are none. Zero.
Entirely incorrect, and of course it's not only about deaths. But you know that of course.

Want to know the real reason, though, when you're done building strawmen? The real reason we don't reply is that well, we have nothing to add, nothing to dispute. Civilians die in wars, no matter how justified. This is a tragic fact, no matter how much we wish it were not so, and I believe I'm speaking for every pro-Israeli here when I say Israel should do its utmost to minimize civilian casualties and prosecute whoever in their ranks violate sensible rules of war -- and we have the maturity to just say so.
 
Entirely incorrect, and of course it's not only about deaths. But you know that of course.

Want to know the real reason, though, when you're done building strawmen? The real reason we don't reply is that well, we have nothing to add, nothing to dispute. Civilians die in wars, no matter how justified. This is a tragic fact, no matter how much we wish it were not so, and I believe I'm speaking for every pro-Israeli here when I say Israel should do its utmost to minimize civilian casualties and prosecute whoever in their ranks violate sensible rules of war -- and we have the maturity to just say so.

There would be an even better way to try to minimize civilian casualties in war: not steal land in first place and accept a two-state solution on the 1967 borders. Then there might be less chance for a war in first place.
But you do not like talking about land theft by the Israelis..
And we know why, as you cant blame that on Hamas :D
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom