Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Tu quoque at its finest.
We are not talking about what Hamas does wrong, but why the Israeli Government keeps stealing land (with US support).
No answer received so far



I find the list useful and on-topic.
Any problem with that?

You keep using words wrong. If you want to employ a term, understand its definition first.

It very much has bearing on negotiations if the other party insists you have no right to exist. Does Israel, within its non-Palestinian Authority boundaries, have a right to exist, or not?

Leave out the question of the settlements, because I consider them wrong. I am by no means a diehard sympathizer of Israel. You do realize shades of gray exist, do you not?
 

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fisking

A fisking is characteristically an incisive and fierce point-by-point rebuttal, and the aim is generally to weaken the target's credibility rather than seek common ground. The British newspaper The Observer defined fisking as "the practice of savaging an argument and scattering the tattered remnants to the four corners of the internet (named after Robert Fisk of the Independent, whose columns are considered soft targets.)"[3]
 
First, I'll say that the murder of the Palestinian boy was disgusting. There is no justification for that. It was an evil action, and the perpetrators need to be punished. They need to be punished for both moral and political reasons. The moral reasons are obvious. The political reason is that Israel needs to send a strong message to the extremists among their own population that actions like those should not be tolerated.

I'll say further that among the Jewish people that I know, nobody celebrates the death of that Palestinian boy. The reactions I see reflect sadness and frustration. The murder is just a murder. It doesn't help anyone except the anti-Israel propagandists, and even that's a disgusting way to use a tragedy.

Although I kept trying to point out that I am aware of the horrors and the unbalanced hatred that many Palestinians have towards Israel and Jews, I kept noticing that the people in the discussion refused to stay on the topic of the Palestinian boy. Instead they kept trying to shift the discussion back to a sort of "Palestinians have no one but themselves to blame because they started it" type of mentality.

The more I asked them why they kept shifting back to that direction, the more angry and defensive they got. I mean super duper angry.

I can't speak for your friends, but I'm going to guess it's because their thoughts about the Palestinian boy took about as many paragraphs as I took above. If you want them to say more, you will need to do more than point out that they haven't spoken about it. You will probably need to introduce other lines of thinking, such as the attitudes among radical Israelis that allow tragedies like this to happen, but do it without being accusatory.

A. Why is it, that whatever the Israeli's do is always rationalized away as a "response" and never an open act of aggression when it's really clear that sometimes Israelis are just as bad. I pointed this out as being a tu quoque argument and was accused of ad hominen attack.

I won't try to speak for every situation, but it's hard to see this event as anything but a response when it comes so soon after the murder of the Israeli boys, and is so similar. It's a response that's awful and deeply wrong, but still a response.

B. Why is it that if you don't agree 100% agree with the Israeli POV you are immediately deemed "antisemitic" or a "Jew Hater"


I seriously am baffled by this behavior.

Just looking through this thread I see many responses from people who don't agree with Israeli government actions, who might have harsh criticisms for Israel, who nobody calls anti-Semitic. Angrysoba, Puppycow, DC, twinstead, tyr_13...I could go on.

Those who may have been called anti-Semitic are those who have done a lot more than criticize the Israeli government. They've mocked Jewish suffering during the Holocaust, they've all but openly cheered Hamas and/or Hezbollah, and seem to revel in the possibility of Pakistani or Iranian nukes being used against Israel. If you really think everyone gets called an anti-Semite, I really invite you to take a closer look.

Honest replies only please I'm exhausted from the angry drama.

I hope my reply is drama free. :)
 
Your claims are wrong

Then demonstrate that.

and show that you don't want people to see the information I provide. Tough luck.

Hardly. I simply don't see much point to the list that you keep continuing to update and pointed out a little bit of why. I have no problem with people seeing it at all, but don't see much point in a list that only really adds "these are some people who have died" to the table. Yes, we already know that there are a bunch of people dying. That list simply adds irrelevant information. I honestly don't care what their names are. I do care about why they died, which isn't even hinted at by the list. I will and do condemn Israel for the deaths of innocents that they've caused, but I have no interest in simply excusing those who forced them to use violence, regardless of side. Quite frankly, I am a proponent of Israel compensating the Palestinians for each and every mistake that they have, are, and will make in this conflict, intentional and unintentional, as well as the Palestinian government fixing the damage that their people have caused and taking responsibility for their people's actions in general.
 
Last edited:
First, I'll say that the murder of the Palestinian boy was disgusting. There is no justification for that. It was an evil action, and the perpetrators need to be punished. They need to be punished for both moral and political reasons. The moral reasons are obvious. The political reason is that Israel needs to send a strong message to the extremists among their own population that actions like those should not be tolerated.

Except for the disgusting part, I do fully agree with this, for the record, but that has more to do with my lack of disgust in general. Reprehensible would be a bit more accurate when it comes to my position on the matter.
 
Quite frankly, Aridas, I don't care one bit about what you care about or not, and advise you to stop your futile attempt to stop me from posting exactly in the way I see fit.
 
Quite frankly, Aridas, I don't care one bit about what you care about or not, and advise you to stop your futile attempt to stop me from posting exactly in the way I see fit.

Alright. If you want to just keep posting things that are of little to no value, go right on doing it. If you happen to want to post things that are more meaningful, please do.
 
You are making a straw man.

This is what you wrote
"If they stole land it means they were able to steal land."

This means it is OK to commit a crime if you are powerful enough to get away with it. And this is applies to all crimes.

Strange, "why the Israeli Government keeps stealing land (with US support)" has nothing to do with what you started the thread with, before it was merged...

Ahem..
This thread is about Israel and Palestine and the question of the land theft is central to this issue.
May I know why some people feel uneasy to talk about the land theft by the Israeli against the Palestinians?
Or maybe you think that stealing land belonging to another people is perfectly fine?

There's a distinction made in the list, now? Where might that be? All it's saying is that Palestinians have died, which, under the circumstances, is not enough information to call them civilians. Many of them may well be, but you're adding claims that are not in evidence.

Yeah..
Maybe they were terrorists.
3 year old terrorists
 
May I know why some people feel uneasy to talk about the land theft by the Israeli against the Palestinians?
Or maybe you think that stealing land belonging to another people is perfectly fine?

The problem is that it's not true. Kind of a big problem. Simply calling something theft doesn't make it true, it just makes it propaganda.
 
First, I'll say that the murder of the Palestinian boy was disgusting. There is no justification for that. It was an evil action, and the perpetrators need to be punished. They need to be punished for both moral and political reasons. The moral reasons are obvious. The political reason is that Israel needs to send a strong message to the extremists among their own population that actions like those should not be tolerated.

When 3 Jewish boys are kidnapped and murdered..
HAMAS - Praise and encouragement. No attempt to find kidnap/murderers
ISRAEL - Condemnation

When 1 Palestinian boy is murdered...
HAMAS - Outrage and condemnation.
ISRAEL - Outrage and condemnation. Finds and arrests the people involved.
 
Yeah..
Maybe they were terrorists.
3 year old terrorists

So we can remove everyone on the list that are 16 and over then?

ETA: I believe Kumar has stopped answering me. Guess it's not easy for him to have absolutely no coherent argument.
 
Last edited:
When 3 Jewish boys are kidnapped and murdered..
HAMAS - Praise and encouragement. No attempt to find kidnap/murderers
ISRAEL - Condemnation

When 1 Palestinian boy is murdered...
HAMAS - Outrage and condemnation.
ISRAEL - Outrage and condemnation. Finds and arrests the people involved.

When 120+ civilians killed in Gaza
Outrage and condemnation

Err. no
Praising the people killing the civilians? Yes, that is the IDF
Praising the people who ordered the massacre? Yes, this is the Isreali Government

The problem is that it's not true. Kind of a big problem. Simply calling something theft doesn't make it true, it just makes it propaganda.

So how do we call when land is *ahem* "taken" during a war and not given back after?
You know..
Something called taking something that is not yours..
Same if someone took your bike and then did not give you back..
 
Last edited:
When 120+ civilians killed in Gaza
Outrage and condemnation

Err. no

Quite a bit of outrage actually. A lot of false outrage from antisemites as well.


So how do we call when land is *ahem* "taken" during a war and not given back after?
You know..
That thing called building settlements outside the 1967 borders..

You mean the way virtually all countries established their modern borders - by conquering or being conquered?

Gee, there's an awful lot of land-thieves around.
 
You mean like happened in 2005?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israeli_disengagement_from_Gaza



Yeah, no it's really not.

Also, have you read up on the history of antisemitism? Are you planning to ask why Jews have been persecuted for 2000 years again, or are you good?

Israel should also exit the land they are stealing in the West Bank, too.

The only reason Israel was willing to give up the Gaza strip was:

1. It's worthless
2. It's not part of, and never was part of, Biblical Egypt (so it's not a Zionist objective)
3. The act convinces mushy-headed sympathizers that Israel is just a wonderful state.

When Israel wants Peace, then they'll start demanding Peace - and they'll back up their words with actions.
 
Last edited:
Israel should also exit the land they are stealing in the West Bank, too.

The only reason Israel was willing to give up the Gaza strip was:

1. It's worthless
2. It's not part of, and never was part of, Biblical Egypt (so it's not a Zionist objective)
3. The act convinces mushy-headed sympathizers that Israel is just a wonderful state.

So let me get this straight. The last time Israel voluntarily withdrew it's armed forces and evicted all settlers, Hamas took over the area and continued lobbing rockets at Israel. That is, the same Hamas that has the complete destruction of Israel in it's charter. Your idea is now for Israel to do it again, because it worked so well the last time?

Really?
 
When 120+ civilians killed in Gaza
Outrage and condemnation

You of course are being dishonest here. Have you bothered investigating why the deaths in Gaza are always so high before blaming the Jews?

Hamas uses civilians as human shields despite this being the biggest humans rights violation there is. They intentionally store weapons, launch attacks, and carry out military operations in civilian buildings and within civilian areas. They do this knowing that any retaliation will have a greater chance of civilian casualties which can then be used to get people such as yourself who have already decided what they want to believe to blame the Jews.

When Israel launches an attack, they use the most suficsticated technology to minimize collateral damage as much as possible. When possible they call off strikes for fear of too much collateral damage. You have to understand that a common Hamas tactic is to launch rockets from within schools and to store weapons within schools.

Israel drops leaflets, makes phone calls, and sends text messages to residents beforehand in order to give them a chance to evacuate before a strike. Before a strike they will knock on a roof which means to drop a small mortar which will create smoke and noise, giving civilians an opportunity to flee before the actual strike.

Unfortunately when they do this, Hamas gets civilians to surround these buildings in order to claim higher death tolls and to get people such as yourself to blame the Jews for their actions.

So they have two choices. Allow rockets to rein down on their civilians, or strike those weapon supplies and operations within civilian areas using the best technology to minimize deaths as much as possible. While Hamas uses crude weapons to indiscriminately attack any civilians possible. They even openly encourage the killing of civilians when speaking in public on TV. They also encourage civilians on their side to die in these operations. They do everything they can to increase civilian casualties on both sides, while the IDF tries to minimize it.


Err. no
Praising the people killing the civilians? Yes, that is the IDF
Praising the people who ordered the massacre? Yes, this is the Isreali Government

No, this is a fabrication on your part and it 100% untrue. Shame on you.



So how do we call when land is *ahem* "taken" during a war and not given back after?
You know..
Something called taking something that is not yours..
Same if someone took your bike and then did not give you back..

No one took land that is not theirs. The problem is that you are starting with a lie. If you could only be bothered to learn the history there you might understand. But clearly you have no intent on doing so.
 
Nicely constructed blanket statement there. Does it keep you warm?

Would you give some land back to your neighbor if he said you did not have a right to be on your land at all, the very land you live on? If so, why should you?


So...you are saying Israel has an excuse to steal land?
 
So...you are saying Israel has an excuse to steal land?

He's saying they didn't steal land. No more so than any other country.

He's also saying that the people you are asking Israel to give back land to are not happy unless they get everything.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom