First, I'll say that the murder of the Palestinian boy was disgusting. There is no justification for that. It was an evil action, and the perpetrators need to be punished. They need to be punished for both moral and political reasons. The moral reasons are obvious. The political reason is that Israel needs to send a strong message to the extremists among their own population that actions like those should not be tolerated.
I'll say further that among the Jewish people that I know, nobody celebrates the death of that Palestinian boy. The reactions I see reflect sadness and frustration. The murder is just a murder. It doesn't help anyone except the anti-Israel propagandists, and even that's a disgusting way to use a tragedy.
Although I kept trying to point out that I am aware of the horrors and the unbalanced hatred that many Palestinians have towards Israel and Jews, I kept noticing that the people in the discussion refused to stay on the topic of the Palestinian boy. Instead they kept trying to shift the discussion back to a sort of "Palestinians have no one but themselves to blame because they started it" type of mentality.
The more I asked them why they kept shifting back to that direction, the more angry and defensive they got. I mean super duper angry.
I can't speak for your friends, but I'm going to guess it's because their thoughts about the Palestinian boy took about as many paragraphs as I took above. If you want them to say more, you will need to do more than point out that they haven't spoken about it. You will probably need to introduce other lines of thinking, such as the attitudes among radical Israelis that allow tragedies like this to happen, but do it without being accusatory.
A. Why is it, that whatever the Israeli's do is always rationalized away as a "response" and never an open act of aggression when it's really clear that sometimes Israelis are just as bad. I pointed this out as being a tu quoque argument and was accused of ad hominen attack.
I won't try to speak for every situation, but it's hard to see this event as anything but a response when it comes so soon after the murder of the Israeli boys, and is so similar. It's a response that's awful and deeply wrong, but still a response.
B. Why is it that if you don't agree 100% agree with the Israeli POV you are immediately deemed "antisemitic" or a "Jew Hater"
I seriously am baffled by this behavior.
Just looking through this thread I see many responses from people who don't agree with Israeli government actions, who might have harsh criticisms for Israel, who nobody calls anti-Semitic. Angrysoba, Puppycow, DC, twinstead, tyr_13...I could go on.
Those who may have been called anti-Semitic are those who have done a lot more than criticize the Israeli government. They've mocked Jewish suffering during the Holocaust, they've all but openly cheered Hamas and/or Hezbollah, and seem to revel in the possibility of Pakistani or Iranian nukes being used against Israel. If you really think everyone gets called an anti-Semite, I really invite you to take a closer look.
Honest replies only please I'm exhausted from the angry drama.
I hope my reply is drama free.
