Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Very good.
Go tell this to your friends in this forum that regularly excuse slaughter of children under the pretense of self-defence
As I have never heard you do so
:v:

If most Israeli want peace, they should agree to a two-state solution and retreat from the land they stole.
They have tried this when they gave back Gaza to the Arabs. The Arabs turned it into a "fortress" from where to launch suicide bombers and rockets at the Israeli civilian population, using their own innocents as human shields, and starting a campaign in schools and media to groom the Palestinian children into future terrorists. I, too, would love to see a retreat and the establishment of fair borders, and so would the moderate Israelis (who are in far larger numbers than you would think), but all they would accomplish if they did so would be to make their enemies even stronger. It wouldn't be an olive branch, it'd be appeasement.

Yes, both sides do bad things (and unlike you, I care about the people on both sides), but trying to "Palestinians just need to do this" or "all the Jews have to do is this" is just naïve.
 

Ahem

They have tried this when they gave back Gaza to the Arabs. The Arabs turned it into a "fortress" from where to launch suicide bombers and rockets at the Israeli civilian population, using their own innocents as human shields, and starting a campaign in schools and media to groom the Palestinian children into future terrorists. I, too, would love to see a retreat and the establishment of fair borders, and so would the moderate Israelis (who are in far larger numbers than you would think), but all they would accomplish if they did so would be to make their enemies even stronger. It wouldn't be an olive branch, it'd be appeasement.

Yes, both sides do bad things (and unlike you, I care about the people on both sides), but trying to "Palestinians just need to do this" or "all the Jews have to do is this" is just naïve.

And the reason for stealing land in the West Bank is?
 
Pooor Jews...they are always Victims! :v:

Do you dispute that Jews have been victims of more than two millennia of persecution and pogroms, and a holocaust in the 1940s?

Also, do you dispute the fact that the Hamas charter is rife with anti-Semitic conspiracy theories and that it glorifies the slaughter of Jews, as well as talks about the destruction of the state of Israel?

Any one-liner quips you want to answer with, or do you actually want to contribute something to the thread?
 
Someone has been releasing statements trying to finger ISIS for the murder of the three Israeli kids. Obviously stinks. Including the "Islamic name of Jerusalem" used, Bayt al-Maqdis. Which, while the common Arabic name is of course Al-Quds, according to wikipedia "is in reference to the Hebrew name for the Jewish Temple in Jerusalem, Beit Hamikdash."

I call false flag/letter/article by some ultra-orthodox nutjobs. After all ISIS is known for putting the fight against "apostates" higher than against nonbelievers/da Joooooos, which doesn't help their credibility in certain circles.
 
Last edited:
EDIT: If most Palestinians want peace, then they need to elect a government that's committed to trying for peace and not one that has the absolute destruction of Israel in their charter. Things suck for the Palestinians, but their agency in the issue cannot be denied. No I'm not saying that Israel can't do anything either, and they should change as well.

ADDED: If most Israelis want peace, then they need to elect a government that's committed to trying for peace and not one that kills children, steals land and shuns the two-state solution. Things suck for the Israelis, but their agency in the issue cannot be denied. No I'm not saying that Hamas can't do anything either, and they should change as well.

NOTE: the main culprits are the ones who steal land

We agree, then. Netanyahu does not indeed kill hundreds of children a year. Thank you for playing.

Actually, the 300 children have been killed in much less than a year
 
Last edited:
Do you dispute that Jews have been victims of more than two millennia of persecution and pogroms, and a holocaust in the 1940s?

Also, do you dispute the fact that the Hamas charter is rife with anti-Semitic conspiracy theories and that it glorifies the slaughter of Jews, as well as talks about the destruction of the state of Israel?

Any one-liner quips you want to answer with, or do you actually want to contribute something to the thread?

And there it is.

Can you please stop and think about something. Is there ANYONE on the friggin planet that can't trace a history of victimization back through history at some point?

Jews isolate themselves from other communities and so when they are targeted they stick out. But like the Jews millions of Roma, Homosexual, Christians and other types of people were also executed and persecuted under the Nazi regime.

I mean if you want to think about it, think about how Homosexuality has been treated from the get go. Now sit down and have a conversation with an Israeli and a homosexual and see who will make the argument that they have been "persecuted" the most.

Really. That's the excuse for blowing up innocent Palestinian civilians? You were victimized? Really?

That's what's really weird to me in this whole conversation. It's like meta-myopia or something. :boggled:
 
And the reason for stealing land in the West Bank is?

Um because that's how the world works. Have you ever taken a history class? You are seriously pushing the argument that during a land squabble and a war that the victor is supposed to aw shucks sorry and give it back?

Should America give the land back to the Native Americans? How about we don't give the land back to the Palestinians because they didn't do **** with it the entire time the had it and the only reason the dog wanted their bone back is because of antisemitism and some religious garbage from a stupid book that goes all the way back to Ishmael and Isaac. How about get the **** over it already and realize the train has left the station and start trying to build up what you do have instead of destroying what someone else has created because it pisses you off that they are a more successful country than you.

How about that. :D
 
Last edited:
Do you dispute that Jews have been victims of more than two millennia of persecution and pogroms, and a holocaust in the 1940s

No. I don't dispute it, but I do wonder...Why?

I don't dispute it either, but I do wonder...Why?

You two boys wonder why the Jews have been the victims of 2K years of ferocious brutality?

Because they killed Jesus and use the blood of non-Jewish children in their baked goods. Clearly.

Anything else?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom