Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Good, so explain why the conversation about this Palestinian boy got me responses like this

You are right. Not all Palestinian Muslims are fanatics who want to murder Jews. According a 2013 Pew Research report, only 62% of them thought suicide bombings against Jews were justified. And only 80% of them support Hamas. So you are right, it's only the majority that is extremist. And when a Palestinian moderate or Arab who genuinely wants peace does speak out, he's murdered by the extremists. How's that been working out for you?


And by the way, in case you are interested in knowing what has "caused" the long history of Arab terrorist brutality against Jews and Israelis, I will tell you--- it's the very existence of Israel itself. Yes, folks, had Israel not existed, all those Jewish lives snuffed out by Arabs would have been spared. Maybe we should start thinking about extinguishing Israel, eh? Lots of blood would be spared.


It's like she literally could not just stay on the topic of the Palestinian boys murder. She had to keep bringing it bad to how Jews are victims and Palestinians started it.


I am seriously asking people who are so outspoken on this topic to try to take a second and see how it's completely tu quoque.

IMO this feeds the anger in the region. So let's just sweep the innocent civilians who were killed during bombings under the rug and say it doesn't matter because Palestinians do the same thing.

Um no fanatical, jihadist, terrorists do the same thing. Most Palestinians want peace. But as long as we treat the Palestinians like the Zombies outside the prison in the Walking Dead, we can rationalize killing them. So that's why the conversation can never fully pause on the things the Israeli military is doing wrong. It's always shifted back to Jews as victims.
 
Now you (or DC) just have to show us the official Hamas statement praising the death of those three teenagers and you might have some point.

I guess we'll just have to find the transcript of Khaled Mashaal's interview Al-Jazeera on June 23. I'm sure it can't be hard.

“Blessed be the hands that captured them”
 
I have to agree with truethat in the case of the Palestinian boy who was horribly murdered.

It is ridiculous to treat the murder of the Palestinian boy frivolously on the basis of his ethnic background.

A lot of people here were quick to agree with the narrative of him being killed by other Palestinians because he was gay, and yet, now that it turns out that it was based on ethnic hatred it should be condemned in the same manner as Palestinian murders of Jewish Israelis, not qualified with assertions that at least murders by Israelis are not glorified.
 
I guess we'll just have to find the transcript of Khaled Mashaal's interview Al-Jazeera on June 23. I'm sure it can't be hard.

“Blessed be the hands that captured them”


Not hard, but you prefer to not do it as it would show that he thought they were soldiers and, as your quote hints at already, "captured", not killed.
 
I have to agree with truethat in the case of the Palestinian boy who was horribly murdered.

It is ridiculous to treat the murder of the Palestinian boy frivolously on the basis of his ethnic background.

A lot of people here were quick to agree with the narrative of him being killed by other Palestinians because he was gay, and yet, now that it turns out that it was based on ethnic hatred it should be condemned in the same manner as Palestinian murders of Jewish Israelis, not qualified with assertions that at least murders by Israelis are not glorified.


What's with his cousin who was detained and viciously beaten up by the Israeli police? He has an American passport - hope that caused at least some cognitive dissonance in those nauseating commentators.
 
What's with his cousin who was detained and viciously beaten up by the Israeli police? He has an American passport - hope that caused at least some cognitive dissonance in those nauseating commentators.

I posted a video of his beating earlier in the thread. I haven't seen any other commentary on that here since then.
 
Not hard, but you prefer to not do it as it would show that he thought they were soldiers and, as your quote hints at already, "captured", not killed.

I'm not taking sides in this issue. In my opinion, for some reason neither Palestine nor Israel seem to be interested in peace, and they are loosing an entire generation of young people that they've made pawns in their struggle.

I will say that I find Mahmoud Abbas' reaction to the kidnappings and subsequent murders was far more reasonable than Khaled Mashal's.
 
Last edited:
Good, so explain why the conversation about this Palestinian boy got me responses like this







It's like she literally could not just stay on the topic of the Palestinian boys murder. She had to keep bringing it bad to how Jews are victims and Palestinians started it.


I am seriously asking people who are so outspoken on this topic to try to take a second and see how it's completely tu quoque.

IMO this feeds the anger in the region. So let's just sweep the innocent civilians who were killed during bombings under the rug and say it doesn't matter because Palestinians do the same thing.

Um no fanatical, jihadist, terrorists do the same thing. Most Palestinians want peace. But as long as we treat the Palestinians like the Zombies outside the prison in the Walking Dead, we can rationalize killing them. So that's why the conversation can never fully pause on the things the Israeli military is doing wrong. It's always shifted back to Jews as victims.


It's a reflexive defense mechanism from people who are used to everything being used as a bludgeon against them. I'm not saying it's right, but let me as this; What do you want to talk about with the murder of this boy? Here is the conversation I'd have. 'This was horrible, as murder is bad enough but to do so for ethnic reasons does not mitigate it at all. These murderers should be shunned and punished to the full extent of the law. Who disagrees?' And no one disagrees. The problem comes when someone believes that the murder of this boy will be used as a weapon against Israel or Israelis in general and react super defensively. Well, the other problem is that people are using this as a weapon against Israel. That's where you get the comparison between child killers being lauded on one side and condemned or whatnot.

So what aspect of this tragedy did you want to discuss that you think isn't being discussed?

EDIT: If most Palestinians want peace, then they need to elect a government that's committed to trying for peace and not one that has the absolute destruction of Israel in their charter. Things suck for the Palestinians, but their agency in the issue cannot be denied. No I'm not saying that Israel can't do anything either, and they should change as well.
 
Last edited:
Even more names.

87. Sami Adnan Shaldan, 25, was killed in a bombing in Gaza City.
88. Jamah Atieh Shalouf, 25, was killed in a bombing in Rafah.
89. Bassem Abdelrahman Khattab, 6, was killed in a bombing in Deir al-Balah.
90. Abdullah Mustafa Abu Mahrouk, 22, was killed in a bombing in Deir al-Balah.

Friday, July 11:

91. Anas Rizk Abu al-Kas, 33, was killed in a bombing in Gaza City.
92. Nour Marwan al-Najdi, 10, was killed in a bombing in Rafah.
93. Mohammed Mounir Ashour, 25, was killed in a bombing on the al-Ghanam family home in Rafah.
94. Ghalia Deeb Jabr al-Ghanam, 7, was killed in the same bombing.
95. Wasim Abd al-Rizk Hassan al-Ghanam, 23, was killed in the same bombing.
96. Mahmoud Abd al-Rizk Hassan al-Ghanam, 26, was killed in the same bombing.
97. Kifah Shahada Deeb al-Ghanam, 20, was killed in the same bombing.
98. Ra’ed Hani Abu Hani, 31, was killed in a bombing in Rafah.
99. Shahraman Ismail Abu al-Kas, 42, was killed in a bombing in a refugee camp in central Gaza.
100. Mazen Mustafa Aslan, 63, was killed in the same bombing.
101. Mohammed Rabih Abu Humeidan, 65, was killed in shelling that struck northern Gaza.
 
This was posted in the Ukraine-thread, and I thought it would fit very well in here:

No, it's what happens when you hide irregular combatants among civilians (a war crime, obviously). If Nazi volunteers were sent in, the numbers would be an order of magnitude higher.

McHrozni

This is, of course, what completely ruins the argument for the pro-Palestinian side. Israel takes (some) care to avoid civilian casualties. They certainly take more care to do so than any other modern power has to date. Nevertheless, civilians die, because the Palestinian terror groups hide among civilians, and encourage civilians to not heed the Israeli warnings and remain as willing targets. The Palestinians, on the other hand, specifically aim for civilian casualties. I know who I consider more moral in this situation.
 
It's a reflexive defense mechanism from people who are used to everything being used as a bludgeon against them. I'm not saying it's right, but let me as this; What do you want to talk about with the murder of this boy? Here is the conversation I'd have. 'This was horrible, as murder is bad enough but to do so for ethnic reasons does not mitigate it at all. These murderers should be shunned and punished to the full extent of the law. Who disagrees?' And no one disagrees. The problem comes when someone believes that the murder of this boy will be used as a weapon against Israel or Israelis in general and react super defensively. Well, the other problem is that people are using this as a weapon against Israel. That's where you get the comparison between child killers being lauded on one side and condemned or whatnot.

So what aspect of this tragedy did you want to discuss that you think isn't being discussed?

EDIT: If most Palestinians want peace, then they need to elect a government that's committed to trying for peace and not one that has the absolute destruction of Israel in their charter. Things suck for the Palestinians, but their agency in the issue cannot be denied. No I'm not saying that Israel can't do anything either, and they should change as well.


This is a great commentary. Do you mind if I share it! :cool:
 
The problem, truethat, I think is we read so much more into what people say than they really intend. Which goes a long way to explain all the weird replies we constantly get here on JREF and other places when discussing things like Israel and Palestine, for example all the "butbut'merica" posts.

Which supports the old saying, "don't write so to be understood, write so that you can't be misunderstod".

Edit: I also echo what tyr said above ;).
Edit 2: it's also about how we constantly assign a "side" to people. If you show up in a thread and say something about Palestine, you're labelled "pro-Israeli" and responded to accordingly. If you show up in a CT thread and ask about something you don't understand about 9/11, you risk being labelled a CT-er. It's something we all do, I suppose.
 
Last edited:
Nay!
Do not be so harsh on poor Nethanyahu.
He manages to kill several hundreds of children per year, more or less .. Only the US in Vietnam and few others did better
Too bad his window of opportunity for killing children is closing

Do you have any actual, credible support for this babbling nonsense? Or did you just make it up?
 
So 300+ children is NOT "hundreds of children", I assume.
We agree, then. Netanyahu does not indeed kill hundreds of children a year. Thank you for playing.

Yeah.. The side I appear to side with ..

:rolleyes::rolleyes:
I don't like jumping to conclusions, thus qualifiers like "appear to". If this bothers you, I can throw it out and just blindly assume in your case, just for you?
 
The problem, truethat, I think is we read so much more into what people say than they really intend. Which goes a long way to explain all the weird replies we constantly get here on JREF and other places when discussing things like Israel and Palestine, for example all the "butbut'merica" posts.

Which supports the old saying, "don't write so to be understood, write so that you can't be misunderstod".

Edit: I also echo what tyr said above ;).
Edit 2: it's also about how we constantly assign a "side" to people. If you show up in a thread and say something about Palestine, you're labelled "pro-Israeli" and responded to accordingly. If you show up in a CT thread and ask about something you don't understand about 9/11, you risk being labelled a CT-er. It's something we all do, I suppose.


Yes this is my pet peeve on this site. When I first showed up on here I was asking questions about evolution. And I was immediately deemed a YEC. Then when I would discuss things in religion I was called a "Closet Christian" Never mind that I really am an aggressive atheist who gets annoyed when Evolution is referred to as a belief.

The women in the threads flipping out on me assume two things.

A. I am pro Palestine etc.
B. I have no idea what Muslim fanaticism really looks like

and then if I take the Israeli side I'm a Muslim hater.

I have two Arab Muslim sons who are 20 and 18 years old. I lived in a house for years with Israeli Jews (and no it's not the old canard of "some of my best friends....) I watched the dinner discussions between my then Egyptian boyfriend and my Israeli roomies dissolve into a chaos far too often not to get a good understanding of what it looks like.

I also think that many Americans are completely blind to how psychotic the discussion among Muslims is about Israel. I remember years ago my husbands brother chiding me about the Rodney King riots and the white guy getting pulled out the truck and attacked. He tisked tisked tisked until I said "Seriously create the same scenario with an Israeli Jew being dropped into the middle of a small Palestinian village.....um yeah. He replied that it would be different because you have to kill the Jews.

It's senseless. But here's the other thing that annoys the living crap out of me. The only issues in the news that my Jewish friends ever post about are Jewish issues. Granted she is an Orthodox Jew but every friend, every dinner party, every picture even her entire job is all Jews ALL THE TIME. So it's just non stop focus ONLY on issues that matter to Jews.

And after a while it feels like you only give a **** about stuff that matters to Jews. You really don't care about anyone else in the world. You've become myopic. Don't post on my facebook wall the Muslim Arabs are vicious monsters knowing full well that my kids are Arab Muslims and then wonder why it pisses me off.

When I point out that these are racist ideas I'm attacked for being "antisemitic" And it's draining after a while. I seriously sometimes feeling like if the only thing that Jews care about are things that matter to the Jews, then why in the hell do you expect non Jews to be in your corner all the time?
 
Last edited:
The US is officially on the side of Israel

My mother told me never to trust somebody who thinks they "have it all figured out" and sees the world in black and white. <SNIP>

Edited by Locknar: 
SNIPed, breach of rule 0, rule 12.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
This was posted in the Ukraine-thread, and I thought it would fit very well in here:



This is, of course, what completely ruins the argument for the pro-Palestinian side. Israel takes (some) care to avoid civilian casualties. They certainly take more care to do so than any other modern power has to date. Nevertheless, civilians die, because the Palestinian terror groups hide among civilians, and encourage civilians to not heed the Israeli warnings and remain as willing targets. The Palestinians, on the other hand, specifically aim for civilian casualties. I know who I consider more moral in this situation.

Exactly.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom