Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
[...] We heard it again today. What if the people of London were being rocketed like the people of Israel? Wouldn’t they strike back? Well yes, but
"Yes, but let me change the subject really quick. What about those refugee camps?"
 
I'd like to ask a few questions here because I'm seriously hitting a wall in trying to dialogue with friends.

As I mentioned before one of my friends posted the link about how Israel "will not call them heroes!" About the six Jewish men who burned a 16 year old Palestinian boy to death.

Although I kept trying to point out that I am aware of the horrors and the unbalanced hatred that many Palestinians have towards Israel and Jews, I kept noticing that the people in the discussion refused to stay on the topic of the Palestinian boy. Instead they kept trying to shift the discussion back to a sort of "Palestinians have no one but themselves to blame because they started it" type of mentality.

The more I asked them why they kept shifting back to that direction, the more angry and defensive they got. I mean super duper angry.

Finally the discussion was Godwined with this question:

So, by your logic, because Germans were ultimately killed in Allied bombings, we can't blame the Nazis for starting World War

And I kept trying to explain that the boy who was killed was innocent and a victim.

This rallied the anger even more. And I was seriously gobsmacked at how they absolutely refused to stay on the topic of the boy.

So I wrote this in frustration:

As to the blaming the Nazis for starting WW2 first of all we're talking about Six men who burned a teenaged boy alive. Not who started a war/ Those men are sick human beings and the idea that we have to be told not to refer to them as "heroes" is sickening.

If while the Nazis were dropping bombs on England, Six English men went out and kidnapped a 16 year old German girl and raped her and set her on fire, they are EVIL SADISTIC VIOLENT MEN.

Only an equally sick, sadistic and vicious person would say, "Well she was German, I mean come on, the Germans were the ones dropping the bombs in England, you can hardly blame a few Englishmen if they burned her alive, the Germans started it."


This didn't make a dent in the discussion. The two questions I'd like to ask those on here who are so forceful in their opinions about the situation is this.


A. Why is it, that whatever the Israeli's do is always rationalized away as a "response" and never an open act of aggression when it's really clear that sometimes Israelis are just as bad. I pointed this out as being a tu quoque argument and was accused of ad hominen attack.

But again Why do zealots about Israel always rationalize the acts done to the Palestinians as "retaliatory!" "they started it." Never an acknowledgement that they have done some pretty ****** things as well?


B. Why is it that if you don't agree 100% agree with the Israeli POV you are immediately deemed "antisemitic" or a "Jew Hater"


I seriously am baffled by this behavior.

Honest replies only please I'm exhausted from the angry drama.

TYIA
 
B. Why is it that if you don't agree 100% agree with the Israeli POV you are immediately deemed "antisemitic" or a "Jew Hater"


I seriously am baffled by this behavior.

I am not baffled. Israel seems to play up the "Victim Narrative" as much as possible so that they can justify whatever it is they do. The Israel Victim Narrative is of a people who have been unjustly harrassed for thousands of years and are trying to free themselves - so when they spy on allies and steal land and bomb civilians, we're supposed to ignore that.

The Palestinians have also tried to embrace the "Victim Narrative" but with a lot less success. Mainly because the Palestinians seem to revel at killing innocents....and this always backfires on them. The Palestinians would be wise if they hired a good PR Firm.

In the Israel-Palestinian War, it's Victim vs Victim. For whom will the world cry more?
 
In the Israel-Palestinian War, it's Victim vs Victim. For whom will the world cry more?

Ahem..
At the moment, the first "victim" has had zero civilians killed in the "war", while the second "victim" had many.
As for the world, the world could not care less..
But as we saw already last century, things can change rather quick and the oppressor may become the victim (I mean, real victim) pretty soon..
 
Last edited:
Ahem..
At the moment, the first "victim" has had zero civilians killed in the "war", while the second "victim" had many.
As for the world, the world could not care less..
But as we saw already last century, things can change rather quick and the oppressor may become the victim (I mean, real victim) pretty soon..

The death toll is certainly quite uneven, but your claim is simply indefensible, unless you're also claiming that no Israeli is a civilian in the first place, which is itself indefensible, without caveat, or limiting the scope of the "war" to rather specific events, which would more accurately to be considered "battles."

For a more balanced, much more factual take on the subject than what you've been presenting, you might trying reading things like http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/jul/09/israel-renewed-hamas-attack-bbc-balance-palestinian. For what is somewhat closer to the other side of the coin, with valid and rational points made in the first place, http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/frame_game/2014/07/gaza_civilian_casualties_while_hamas_targets_innocent_people_israel_tries.html is worth a look.
 
Last edited:
Ahem..
At the moment, the first "victim" has had zero civilians killed in the "war", while the second "victim" had many.
As for the world, the world could not care less..
But as we saw already last century, things can change rather quick and the oppressor may become the victim (I mean, real victim) pretty soon..

Naftali Fraenkel, Gilad Shaer and Eyal Yifrah were not civilians?
why do you need to lie?
 
Naftali Fraenkel, Gilad Shaer and Eyal Yifrah were not civilians?
why do you need to lie?

Let alone that it would still be three against one hundred killed by the side you support, the three were actually killed before the war
 
Let alone that it would still be three against one hundred killed by the side you support, the three were actually killed before the war

well had Hamas arrested the murderers of those kids instead of praising them, they could have prevented a "war" ?
 
I am not baffled. Israel seems to play up the "Victim Narrative" as much as possible so that they can justify whatever it is they do. The Israel Victim Narrative is of a people who have been unjustly harrassed for thousands of years and are trying to free themselves - so when they spy on allies and steal land and bomb civilians, we're supposed to ignore that.

The Palestinians have also tried to embrace the "Victim Narrative" but with a lot less success. Mainly because the Palestinians seem to revel at killing innocents....and this always backfires on them. The Palestinians would be wise if they hired a good PR Firm.

In the Israel-Palestinian War, it's Victim vs Victim. For whom will the world cry more?



Hmmm this is interesting I'll share this with my friend if you don't mind. I think she might appreciate it.
 
well had Hamas arrested the murderers of those kids instead of praising them, they could have prevented a "war" ?

Let` s play a game: it is called "blame it on the others".
When our side kills a child (or ten, or twenty), we have to blame it on the other side
Little bit as the Nazis did: when they were rounding up and shooting civilians they still blame it on the other side
 
Let` s play a game: it is called "blame it on the others".
When our side kills a child (or ten, or twenty), we have to blame it on the other side
Little bit as the Nazis did: when they were rounding up and shooting civilians they still blame it on the other side

:confused: I did not blame the other side. some Palestinians killed 3 Israeli kids, Hamas praised the murderers and have no intentions of bringing the murderers to justice.
 
No it doesn't but in the same vein just because three Jewish kids were killed and the killers not brought to justice doesn't "equal out' the fact that six adult Jewish men murdered a Palestinian boy. So why are you bringing up the Jewish boys when we're discussing the Palestinian kid?

That's tu quoque.
 
Could you imagine the outrage if the Israeli government would have praised the murderers of the 16 year old Palestinian boy as "heroes"?
 
Last edited:
doesn't change the fact that 3 kids have been murdered and the murderers were praised instead of arrested.

Exactly the same thing that you guys are doing with the 20+ children killed in the last few days.
Oops!
:D :D :D :D

Could you imagine the outrage if the Israeli government would have praised the murderers of the 16 year old Palestinian boy as a "hero"?

Actually, they have called the politicians that ordered the murder of 300+ children during Cast Lead as "heroes".
Wow!!
 
Last edited:
Could you imagine the outrage if the Israeli government would have praised the murderers of the 16 year old Palestinian boy as a "hero"?

Well that's what started the conversation on facebook. I posted the article before

http://www.foxnews.com/politics/201...alestinian-teen-will-not-be-hailed-as-heroes/


Can you imagine a group of white men lynching a black man. Then our president goes on the news and says "They will not be hailed as heroes"

It's absolutely mind boggling that this statement even had to be made. And frankly YES many Jews consider it tit for tat and do consider them "heroes"
 
No it doesn't but in the same vein just because three Jewish kids were killed and the killers not brought to justice doesn't "equal out' the fact that six adult Jewish men murdered a Palestinian boy. So why are you bringing up the Jewish boys when we're discussing the Palestinian kid?

That's tu quoque.

No it is not.
"Tu quoque" works only when you criticize Israel for killing 100 Palestinians, NOT when you criticize Hamas for killing 10 Israeli
:D
 
No it doesn't but in the same vein just because three Jewish kids were killed and the killers not brought to justice doesn't "equal out' the fact that six adult Jewish men murdered a Palestinian boy. So why are you bringing up the Jewish boys when we're discussing the Palestinian kid?

That's tu quoque.

never claimed it does. murdering children is disgusting no matter who is doing the murdering.
 
Exactly the same thing that you guys are doing with the 20+ children killed in the last few days.
Oops!
:D :D :D :D

I never did. Israel's bombing is just as disgusting and totally out of proportion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom